AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
The present Revision Petition has been filed by the petitioner/ opposite party (OP) against the order dated 12.02.2024 in First Appeal No. 03 of 2018 passed by the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Delhi whereby the Appeal filed by the Opposite Party was dismissed with cost of Rs.50,000/-.
Case of the Complainant/Respondent is that he booked plot No.C-81, Ganga Vihar Village Sadullabad, Ghaziabad, UP on 24.08.1987 for a total consideration of Rs.20,000 by paying an advance of Rs.15,000 vide receipt No.704 dated 24.08.1987 and paid the balance amount of Rs.5,000 as full and final payment vide Receipt No.719 dated 26.08.1987. The plot booked by him was a 3-side open plot and the OP ensured that the possession will be handed over very soon. On 21.09.1987 and 23.06.1990 the OP issued letter to him to deposit more money. On 04.05.1989 and 25.06.1990 the Complainant wrote letters to OP which were not responded to and on telephone OP asked him to deposit further Rs.4,918 for E.E. charges, failing which the plot would be cancelled. The complainant paid Rs.4,918 on 18.3.1993 vide Receipt No.6270 and requested OP to execute the sale deed. It was not done. The OP again asked him to deposit further Rs.5,000 as registration fee and Rs.6,700 for non-judicial stamp papers for registration, which was also deposited by the Complainant with the OP in the Court. Again OP asked the Complainant to deposit Rs.5,000 for some other charges, which was also deposited on 12.04.1998 vide receipt No. 9846. Even then the OP did not execute the sale deed. Thus, he filed a complaint in the office of Lt Governor on 27.06.1998. The police called both the parties on 25.10.1998 and at the request of the OP he handed over original payment receipts to him. The OP marked all receipts as cancelled and kept them in his bag. It is alleged that the colony map has changed but OP did not provide the copy of the changed map. Over 50% of the plots were developed and the residents were residing there but OP did not hand over possession of the plot. Alleging deficiency in service and unfair trade practice, the Complainant filed CC No.378/2015 before the District Forum.
On notice, the complaint was contested by the OP by filing the written version stating that the plot in question was booked by the Complainant with M/s Choudhary Properties, a partnership firm, the payment was also made to the said firm and there was no privity of contract between the Complainant and OP. The sale deed of the plot was executed on 24.04.1998 and symbolic possession was also given. The dispute required oral and documentary evidence which is under the jurisdiction of the Civil Court and the Complaint before the District Forum is not maintainable. The plot in question was a two side open and not three side open as alleged by the Complainant. The Complainant is filed on false and frivolous ground and the same deserves to be dismissed.
The District Forum after hearing the learned counsel for the parties and appreciating the evidence on record, held the OP to be guilty of deficiency in service and directed it as follows: -
“i)To hand over to the complainant the possession of plot No.C-81, Ganga Vihar, in the Village Sadullabad, Ghaziabad (U.P.) within 15 days after receiving legal dues as per letter dated 18.09.2013 and the Registry charges from the complainant.
ii) To adjust the amount of Rs.9,918/- in the account of the complainant.
iii) To pay to the complainant an amount of Rs.1,00,000/- as compensation for harassment and mental agony suffered and includes litigation cost.
iv) The above amount of compensation shall be paid by the OP to the complainant within 30 days from the date of receiving of this order failing which OP shall be liable to pay interest on the entire awarded amount @ 10% per annum from the date of receiving of this order till the date of payment. If OP fails to comply with the order within 30 days from the date of receiving of this order, the complainant may approach this Forum u/s 25 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986."
Aggrieved by the order of the District Forum, the OP filed FA/03/2018 before the State Commission and the State Commission vide impugned order dated 12.02.2024 dismissed the appeal with cost of Rs.50,000/-.
Thus, the present Revision Petition has been filed by the OP.
Heard learned counsel for both the parties in detail and carefully perused the records. The learned counsel for the Petitioner argued that the plot in question was booked by the Complainant with M/s Choudhary Properties through H.S. Choudhary, the erstwhile partner of the said firm. The Complaint was filed against the petitioner in the individual capacity, which was not maintainable. The District Forum as well as the State Commission failed to appreciate this aspect of the matter. After booking, a dispute arose relating to the cost of the plot. However, it was resolved and the sale deed was registered on 24.04.1998. Original copy of the sale deed was also handed over to the Complainant on 25.10.1998. Thereafter, on 20.08.2009 the respondent approached the petitioner for possession which was followed by him vide letters dated 24.12.2009 and 23.06.2010. The respondent raised the dispute of 2-sdie open/3-side open for the first time vide letter dated 07.06.2011 i.e. after expiry of 13 years of the execution of the sale deed. The Complaint was barred by limitation. The District Forum overlooked all these important aspects of the case and committed illegality and irregularity in allowing the Complaint. It is also argued that the District Forum order was challenged by the Petitioner and the Complainant has not filed any cross appeal. However, the State Commission awarded additional compensation of Rs.50,000 the Complainant. he, therefore sought that the Revision Petition deserves to be allowed.
The learned counsel for Respondent/Complainant argued that the Complainant is a senior citizen of about 80 years old and the Petitioner is misusing the process of law in order to avoid the execution of the order of the District Forum as confirmed by the State Commission. The District Forum passed the impugned order after examining the entire record and then held the Petitioner guilty for deficiency in service. There are concurrent findings of the District Forum as well as the State Commission and the National Commission cannot re-evaluate the facts in the revisional jurisdiction in view of the judgments of Hon'be Supreme Court in the case of Amit Kapoor vs. Ramesh Chander AIRONLINE 2012 SC 668 and Vinay Tyagi vs. Irshad Ali, (2013) 5 SCC 762. The Revision Petition has no merit and deserves to be dismissed.
After hearing learned counsel for the parties, we find that there are two main disputes involved in the Revision Petition, one whether the plot in question is a 2-side open or 3-side open. The State Commission observed that in the payment receipt No.719 dated 26.08.1987 it is clearly mentioned that the plot is a 3-side open plot. The petitioner has not produced any record contrary to the same. On this count, the District Forum and the State Commission correctly held the OP guilty of deficiency in service. The Petitioner alleged that the sale deed was already executed on 24.04.1998. The State Commission in paragraph 22 of the impugned order has held that the alleged sale deed was a forged document because it was not bearing the signature of the respondent/complainant. The Petitioner chose to avoid filing a copy of the said sale deed. Thus, the State Commission was justified in imposing the cost of Rs.50,000/- upon the Petitioner.
It is undisputed position that the Complainant had paid the entire consideration to OP with respect to the plot as on 24.08.1987 itself. Till date the possession has not been handed over by OP. It is stated before us that the Petitioner has no objection if the Complainant occupies the plot and takes possession. He also states on instructions that the Petitioner will handover possession to the Complainant on 16.09.2026 and file an affidavit of compliance before this Commission within two weeks.
With due regard to the undertaking of the OP to handover the plot in question and file an affidavit of compliance, we are restraining from imposing further costs. The OP is also directed to execute registration of the sale deed, if necessary, at its own cost within six weeks.
With these directions, the Revision Petition is disposed of.
