AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
A.N. Jindal, J.—Rajinder Kumar-petitioner/defendant (hereinafter referred to as the defendant) has challenged the order dated 7.11.2008 (Annexure P/3 and the order dated 25.5.2009 (Annexure P/4) passed by the Additional District Judge, Gurgaon, whereby both the courts declined to set aside the ex-parte decree dated 31.7.2002 passed in Civil Suit No. 635 titled Om Parkash Versus Rajinder Kumar and others. The factual background of the case is that in the aforesaid suit filed by Om Parkash on 23.11.1994, Rajinder Kumar was arrayed as defendant No.1. Upon notice, he appeared, filed the written statement and he also filed counter-claim in the said suit. Another suit with regard to the same property was filed by Chandgi against Ratni Devi titled as Chandgi Ram versus Ratni Devi, wherein Rajinder Kumar was arrayed as defendant No.2. Suit titled as Om Parkash Vs. Rajinder Kumar was consolidated with the suit titled as Chandgi Vs. Ratni Devi. Later on, the suit titled as Chandgi Vs. Ratni Devi was detached from the suit Om Parkash Versus Rajinder Kumar and was dismissed in default on 11.1.2000. It has been further pleaded by the defendant/petitioner that, as advised by his counsel, he did not appear in the court to contest the suit filed by Om Parkash. However, on 5.2.2003 when a bailiff reached his house with the warrant of possession, he came to know that an ex-parte decree for possession has been passed against him and he was proceeded against ex-parte on 11.1.2000. It is also averred that on account of impression that both the suits were dismissed on 11.1.2000, he did not attend the court. Resultantly, decree dated 31.7.2000 was passed against him. Thus, he applied for setting aside ex-parte decree on 6.2.2003. The said application was contested by the plaintiff/respondent Om Parkash. On the pleadings of the parties, the following issues were framed:-
Whether judgment and decree dated 31.7.2002 are liable to be set aside or not? OPA
Whether the application is not maintainable? OPR
Relief.
Both the courts below have held that the defendant was in knowledge of the pendency of the suit, so much so even he had also filed the counter-claim, but he did not prefer to contest the same and he was not prevented by any sufficient cause from appearing in the court. The petitioner has admitted that Shri Ram Avtar Gupta was his advocate. He denied if he had engaged Shri O.P. Yadav, as his counsel but his statement goes contrary to the power of attorney Ex. R6, which, interalia, indicates that he had engaged Shri O.P. Yadav, as his counsel in the suit titled as Chandgi Ram Versus Ratni Dev etc. and the file of the suit titled as Om Parkash Versus Rajinder Kumar also reveals that he had engaged Shri O.P. Yadav, as his counsel. Thus, the story put forward by the petitioner that he had engaged Shri Ram Avtar Gupta, as his counsel, who had guided him stands falsified. The petitioner appears to have appointed Shri Badri Parshad Gupta, Shri Ram Avtar Gupta and Shri Neeraj Gupta, as his counsel, vide power of attorney Ex. R7 dated 30.9.2005, but that is of no consequences. The story with regard to his unintentional non-appearance in the court also does not help him. Rajinder Kumar-petitioner, while appearing as AW1, has stated that having instituted the above suits in 1994, his mother had died on 25.6.1995 and thereafter he was told by his brother that they had stopped pursuing the suit and as such he also stopped pursuing the two suits. This version also goes contrary to the plea taken by him in the application as well as the affidavit Ex. AW2/1, wherein he had stated that only on 11.1.2000 he was informed by his counsel that suit titled Chandgi Ram Versus Ratni Devi was dismissed in default. It is pertinent to mention here that when he was informed by his counsel about the fate of the suit titled Chandgi Ram Versus Ratni Devi, then he must have inquired about another suit titled as Om Parkash Versus Rajinder Kumar etc. or about his counter claim at least. The petitioner has made a very funny statement that he did not know if the suit titled Chandgi Ram Versus Ratni Devi was dismissed on 11.1.2000 and whether the two suits were separated on 3.3.2001. As such, a litigant who himself is negligent cannot seek protection of law because the law always help those who are vigilant about their rights. While deciding the application for setting aside the ex-parte decree, both the courts below have taken concurrent view with regard to the fact that the petitioner had full knowledge of the proceedings and he intentionally did not appear to contest the same. Having examined the concurrent findings, I do not find any ground to differ with the same. No ground to interfere. Dismissed.
