High CourtsSingle Bench(2026) 11 BOM CK 1066

Rajesh vs Mohammad Siddique

Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench · Decided on 2 November 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
Nandesh S. Deshpande, J
RESULT
Disposed Of
CASE NUMBER
Writ Petition No.2116 of 2024

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

20 paragraphs · 1,022 words
1.

Heard. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard finally with the consent of learned counsel appearing for the parties.

2.

The present petition challenges the order below Exhibit-5 passed on 7th February, 2024 by the District Judge-14, Nagpur in Regular Civil Appeal No. 196 of 2023. The said appeal arised out of judgment and decree dated 07.06.2023 passed in Regular Civil Suit No. 51 of 2016.

3.

As can be seen from the record, the said suit was filed by the original respondent claiming a decree of eviction against the present petitioner on the ground of he requiring the premises in question on bona fide need, as also on the ground of arrears of rent. The said suit was decreed, as stated supra, vide judgment and decree dated 07.06.2023.

4.

Being aggrieved, the petitioner i.e. the tenant herein challenged the said decree by filing a Regular Civil Appeal No.196 of 2023. In the said appeal, an application was filed under the provisions of Order XLI Rule 5 of the CPC seeking stay to the effect and operation of the impugned judgment and decree. The appellate court, after hearing the parties, was pleased to allow the application filed by the appellant/petitioner herein, but on certain conditions. One of such conditions was a direction to the appellant to deposit the decretal amount of Rs. 1,63,770/- towards arrears of rent from November 2010 to October 2015 and Rs.10,000/- towards notice charges. By a further direction, it was directed that an amount of Rs. 14,025/- be deposited as a monthly compensation from the date of decree i.e. 07.06.2023 till date and thereafter continue to deposit the said monthly compensation. It is this clause or direction to pay monthly compensation at the rate of 14,025/- by which the present petitioner is aggrieved.

5.

I have heard Mr. S.B. Mohta Mehta, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. R.S. Akbani, learned counsel for the respondent.

6.

Mr. S.B. Mohta, learned counsel draws my attention to the judgment of this Court in Writ Petition No.5573 of 2017 (Anil Kumar Khare v. Pragati Printers). In the said judgment, this Court, after relying on the celebrated judgment of State of Maharashtra and another v. Super Max International Private Limited and others reported in (2009) 9 SCC 59, has recorded a finding that even though in the said judgment the Hon’ble Apex Court quantified the compensation on the basis of 6% return on the value of the property in cities like Nagpur that cannot be done so. This Court thereafter quantified the rate at the rate of 4% of the return on the property. However, in the said judgment this Court has made it categorically clear that there cannot be a mathematical formula to be applied.

7.

In that view of the matter, it is the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the amount of Rs.14,025/-comes about 10.75%. He therefore submits that the amount as quantified is in excess and therefore ought to have been done at the rate of 4%.

8.

Per contra, Mr. R.S. Akbani, learned counsel for the respondent points me out an earlier order of the trial Court during the pendency of the suit. The order is dated 13th October, 2022 passed below Exhibit-47. By way of said order, the trial Court, i.e. the Judge, Small Causes Court, Nagpur, directed the defendant i.e. the petitioner herein to pay arrears of rent amounting to Rs.3,88,514/- within two months from the date of the order. He was also directed to pay regular rent of Rs.4,322/- per month on or before 15th day of every month from March 2020 till the disposal of the suit. It is the submission of Mr. Akbani that the said order has not been complied with inasmuch as the said deposit has not been made. He would also concede to the fact that, unfortunately, this order was not brought to the notice of the Appellate Court while deciding the stay application.

9.

On being confronted, Mr. Mohta, on instructions, would submit that as far as the amount as directed in clause (b) of the impugned order, the same would be deposited within 30 days from today. He would also submit that even though the decision of Super Max International Private Limited (supra) was cited, the same has not been considered and the impugned order mechanically arrives at an amount of Rs.14,025/- only on the say of the present respondent.

10.

Having gone through the impugned order, I am of the considered opinion that there is some substance in the contentions raised by Mr. Mohta, the learned counsel for the petitioner. The authoritative pronouncement of the Hon’ble Apex Court, which seems to be followed, even though on facts by this Court, is not been considered. In that view of the matter, and on a statement made by Mr. Mohta that direction in clause (b) would be complied, I am of the considered opinion that the order needs a re-look by the District Judge.

11.

In that view of the matter, following order is passed:

O R D E R

(i)

The Writ Petition is allowed.

(ii)

The impugned order dated 07.02.2024, passed below Exhibit-5, in Regular Civil Appeal No.196 of 2023 is quashed and set aside.

(iii)

The matter is relegated to the District Judge-14, Nagpur for deciding the application at Exhibit-5 afresh after granting the parties an opportunity of hearing.

(iv)

The opportunity of hearing will only be granted if the compliance of the statement made before this Court regarding the deposit of monthly compensation at the rate of Rs.14,025/-from the date of decree i.e. 07.06.2023 till date is made and the Appellate Court is informed accordingly.

(v)

Needless to mention that both the parties are at liberty to put on record some additional material in support of their respective contentions.

(vi)

With these directions and observation, the petition is disposed of.

(vii)

Needless to mention that this Court has not commented on the merits of the matter or the stay application and it is for the Appellate Court to decide the same.

(viii)

Rule is made absolute in above terms. No costs.