AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Harkesh Manuja, J.
By way of the present appeal filed under Section 23 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 (for short, ‘the 1987 Act’), challenge has been laid to the award dated 12.01.2022 passed by the Railway Claims Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, Chandigarh (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Tribunal’), whereby the claim application preferred by the appellant under Section 16 of the 1987 Act, seeking compensation of Rs.8,00,000/- along with interest at the rate of 12% per annum on account of amputation of his left leg in an alleged untoward incident dated 27.12.2019, was dismissed.
Briefly stating, the case set up by the appellant, Rajesh Paswan, is that on 27.12.2019, he purchased an unreserved journey ticket at Phillaur Railway Station and boarded Train No.13050, Howrah Express, bound for Kiul. While boarding the train, owing to heavy rush, his foot slipped and he fell into the gap between the platform and the train, resulting in crush injuries to his left leg. He was immediately removed by Ambulance No.108 to Civil Hospital, Phillaur, from where he was referred to Dayanand Medical College and Hospital, Ludhiana (for short, ‘DMC’). His left leg was ultimately amputated. He remained admitted at DMC from 27.12.2019 to 02.01.2020 and thereafter continued to remain confined to bed. According to the appellant, he could not return to Punjab owing to the nationwide lockdown imposed on account of the COVID-19 pandemic. Upon his return in July 2020, he handed over his unreserved journey ticket bearing No.UAD-06205915 to the police, whereupon his statement was recorded.
The respondent-Union of India contested the claim application, denying the occurrence of any untoward incident. It was pleaded that, as per the appellant's own version, he sustained injuries while attempting to board a moving train and that the incident was attributable to his own negligence. It was further contended that no journey ticket was recovered from the appellant or produced before the police on 27.12.2019 or 28.12.2019, and that the ticket subsequently produced after about seven months was suspicious. The respondent also relied upon the absence of any eyewitness and the statements of the Guard and the Loco Pilot of the train, besides the report of the Divisional Railway Manager (for short, ‘the DRM’).
On the basis of the pleadings, the Tribunal framed four issues, inter alia, regarding the appellant's status as a bona fide passenger, the occurrence of an untoward incident, the nature of the injuries sustained and the relief to which he was entitled.
The learned Tribunal decided the first issue against the appellant primarily on the ground that the journey ticket was not produced when his statement was allegedly recorded at DMC on 28.12.2019. The subsequent production of the ticket was considered suspicious, and the Tribunal inferred that the same was procured later. The explanation furnished by the appellant regarding his medical condition and the intervening lockdown was not accepted. The second issue was also decided against him on the ground that there was no eyewitness to the occurrence, that certain discrepancies existed in his statements regarding whether the train was moving or stationary, and that the Guard and the Loco Pilot did not report any untoward incident. The Tribunal further doubted the possibility of the injuries having been sustained in the manner alleged by the appellant. Consequently, the remaining issues were treated as redundant or consequential, resulting in dismissal of the claim application.
Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the findings recorded by the Tribunal were contrary to the evidence available on record and based on conjectures and surmises. It was contended that the appellant appeared as AW-1 and supported his case on affidavit, whereas the journey ticket produced by him was subsequently verified by the respondent's own authorities. The contemporaneous police record, the injury report, the DRM inquiry report and the medical documents corroborate the occurrence of an incident at Phillaur Railway Station on the relevant date. It was further submitted that the absence of an eyewitness or the failure of the Guard and the Loco Pilot to notice the incident cannot, by itself, discredit the claim. Reliance was placed upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India v. Rina Devi, (2019) 3 SCC 572, to contend that negligence on the part of a passenger was not a ground to deny compensation for an untoward incident. Learned counsel also submitted that the learned Tribunal failed to adjudicate upon the nature of the injuries despite the undisputed fact that the appellant suffered amputation of his left leg.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent supported the impugned award, submitted that the appellant's own statement indicates that he was attempting to board a moving train. It was argued that the belated production of the unreserved ticket casts serious doubt upon his status as a bona fide passenger and that the findings recorded by the Tribunal were based upon an appreciation of evidence, warranting no interference by this Court.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the paper-book.
The first question which arises for consideration is whether the appellant established that he was a bona fide passenger on the relevant date. Section 2(29) of the Act defines a ‘passenger’ as a person travelling with a valid pass or ticket. In Rina Devi (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the initial burden upon a claimant to establish his status as a bona fide passenger can be discharged by filing an affidavit to that effect, whereafter the burden shifts to the Railways to rebut the same. It was further held that mere non-recovery of a ticket from the injured passenger or the deceased is not, by itself, sufficient to reject a claim. In the present case, the appellant entered the witness box as AW-1 and supported his claim regarding the purchase of the journey ticket and the circumstances in which the incident occurred. The unreserved ticket bearing No.UAD-06205915 also forms part of the police record. Significantly, the inquiry report prepared by the railway authorities records that the ticket was verified through the Chief Booking Supervisor, Phillaur, and the concerned UTS authorities at New Delhi. The verification confirmed that the ticket was issued from Phillaur to Bhagalpur for one adult passenger on 27.12.2019 at 18:39 hours. The aforesaid verification assumes significance inasmuch as the appellant stated that he purchased the ticket between 6:30 p.m. and 7:00 p.m. on the date of the incident. The ticket was thus issued from the very station where the incident occurred and well before the arrival of Train No.13050 at Phillaur. The ticket was subsequently taken into possession by the GRP, Phillaur, on 27.07.2020, vide the memo of production, along with the statement of the appellant. The respondent did not produce any material to establish that the ticket was fabricated or that it was procured subsequently by the appellant.
The mere fact that the ticket was an unreserved one cannot be a sufficient ground to discard it, particularly when its issuance was independently verified by the respondent's own authorities. The observation in the inquiry report that an unreserved ticket does not, by itself, establish the identity of its holder does not displace the appellant's sworn testimony, especially when the surrounding circumstances lend corroboration to his version. The inference drawn by the Tribunal that the ticket was ‘managed and procured later on’ is not supported by any cogent evidence and rests merely upon suspicion. Further, the delay in production of the ticket has also been explained by the appellant. The record establishes that he suffered grievous injuries on 27.12.2019, remained hospitalised till 02.01.2020 and underwent amputation of his left leg. He was thereafter confined to bed. The appellant was a migrant from outside Punjab, and the nationwide lockdown imposed in March 2020 further restricted his movement. In these circumstances, the failure to produce the ticket immediately was not to be treated as sufficient to discredit his claim. The Tribunal failed to appreciate the appellant's physical condition and the surrounding circumstances in their proper perspective.
Another material aspect which escaped the notice of the Tribunal is that its finding regarding the appellant having an opportunity to produce the ticket when his statement was recorded at DMC on 28.12.2019 is not borne out by the contemporaneous police record. The daily diary maintained at the RPF Post, Ludhiana, records that the statement of the injured could not be recorded and that no eyewitness could be traced. On the other hand, the statement of the appellant before the GRP, Phillaur, as well as the memo recording production of the ticket, bears the date 27.07.2020. Thus, the available record indicates that the ticket was produced when the appellant's statement was recorded by the GRP upon his return. The discrepancies noticed by the Tribunal regarding the appellant whether conscious or unconscious when he was initially approached by the police do not go to the root of the matter. These are collateral aspects of the testimony of an injured person who suffered a traumatic injury and underwent amputation. The material evidence, including the ticket verification report and the contemporaneous police record, lends sufficient support to his version. In view of the above, the finding recorded by the Tribunal that the appellant was not a bona fide passenger is based on an erroneous appreciation of the evidence and cannot be sustained. The first issue is, accordingly, decided in favour of the appellant.
The next question is whether the injuries sustained by the appellant fall within the ambit of an untoward incident as defined under Section 123(c)(2) read with Section 124-A of the Act. Section 123(c)(2) includes the accidental falling of a passenger from a train carrying passengers within the expression ‘untoward incident’. Section 124-A provides for compensation in respect of such incidents, subject to the exceptions specifically enumerated in the proviso thereto. In Rina Devi (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court reiterated that the provisions relating to compensation for untoward incidents are beneficial in nature and are required to be interpreted accordingly. The Court also held that an injury sustained while boarding or de-boarding a train may fall within the scope of an untoward incident. Further, negligence on the part of the passenger, by itself, does not constitute an exception to the statutory liability of the Railways under Section 124-A of the Act.
In the present case, the contemporaneous record lends substantial support to the appellant's version. The Station Master issued a memo at about 20:30 hours on 27.12.2019 regarding an injured person lying on Platform No.1 at Phillaur Railway Station. The record of Ambulance No.108 indicates that the injured was taken from the same platform to Civil Hospital, Phillaur, at about the same time. The statements of Constable Subhash Chand and Head Constable Gurmukh Singh, along with the relevant daily diary entries, also refer to the presence of blood marks on the platform and the removal of the injured to the hospital. More importantly, the injury report prepared by the GRP, Phillaur, records that the appellant sustained injuries while boarding Train No.13050 on 27.12.2019. The injury report and the subsequent police inquiry also refer to the slipping of his foot while boarding the train. The DRM inquiry report prepared by the respondent's own authorities records that the appellant fell while attempting to board the moving train at Phillaur at about 20:30 hours. The medical record prepared at DMC describes the injury as a ‘rail road injury’ and records the crush injury and subsequent amputation of the left leg. The aforesaid material, when read collectively, establishes a consistent chain of circumstances connecting the appellant's injuries with an occurrence at Phillaur Railway Station on the relevant date. The place of occurrence, the approximate time, the removal of the injured by ambulance, the nature of the injuries and the contents of the DRM report substantially corroborate the appellant's version. Further, the Tribunal placed considerable reliance upon the statements of the Guard and the Loco Pilot of Train No.13050. However, a perusal of their statements reveals that they merely stated that no information regarding any untoward incident was communicated to them and that there was no chain pulling at Phillaur. Neither of them claimed to have witnessed the entire platform or specifically stated that the appellant did not fall while boarding the train. The train halted at Phillaur for approximately two minutes, and the incident was alleged to have occurred amid heavy rush. In such circumstances, the failure of the Guard or the Loco Pilot to notice the incident cannot, by itself, disprove its occurrence. The absence of an eyewitness is also not decisive in the facts of the present case. The relevant question is whether, on a preponderance of probabilities, the appellant sustained the injuries in an untoward incident. The contemporaneous police record and the respondent's own inquiry report provide sufficient corroboration in this regard. The finding of the Tribunal that no untoward incident occurred is, therefore, not supported by the material available on record.
The learned Tribunal further observed that the crush injuries sustained by the appellant did not appear to be possible as a result of a fall from the train and proceeded to speculate that he probably became entangled with a fast-moving object while loitering near the railway track. Such an inference is purely conjectural. No medical opinion or other evidence was produced by the respondent to substantiate this alternative theory. On the contrary, the medical documents record a comminuted displaced fracture of the left tibia and fibula, followed by a crush injury and amputation. The nature of the injuries, read with the contemporaneous record, does not justify the alternative inference drawn by the Tribunal. The discrepancy regarding whether the train was moving or stationary at the time of the incident also does not discredit the appellant's case. The consistent thread running through his statements is that, while boarding Train No.13050 at Platform No.1, Phillaur, his foot slipped owing to heavy rush and his left leg was crushed. The difference in the description of the train's movement is not sufficient to displace the otherwise corroborated version of the occurrence. Even assuming that the appellant was attempting to board a train that commenced moving, such conduct may amount to negligence, but negligence simpliciter is not one of the exceptions enumerated in the proviso to Section 124-A of the Act. The statutory liability under Section 124-A is not dependent upon proof of negligence or wrongful conduct on the part of the Railways. The relevant consideration is whether the injury resulted from an untoward incident and whether any of the statutory exceptions applies. No material has been brought on record to establish that the appellant's case falls within any of the exceptions contemplated under the proviso to Section 124-A. In these circumstances, the finding recorded by the Tribunal on the second issue is also unsustainable. The appellant has established, on a preponderance of probabilities, that he sustained injuries in an untoward incident while boarding Train No.13050 at Phillaur Railway Station on 27.12.2019. The second issue is accordingly decided in his favour.
The medical record establishes that the appellant suffered a crush injury to his left lower limb, resulting in amputation above the knee. The discharge summary of Dayanand Medical College and Hospital, Ludhiana, records the amputation, while the disability certificate dated 17.02.2020 records permanent disability to the extent of 75% of the left lower limb. In view of the nature of the injury sustained by the appellant, compensation is required to be determined in accordance with the Schedule to the Railway Accidents and Untoward Incidents (Compensation) Rules, 1990, as amended with effect from 01.01.2017. Under Part III, Item 19 of the amended Schedule, compensation of Rs.4,80,000/- is prescribed for amputation below the middle thigh to 4½ inches below the knee.
Keeping in view the nature of the injuries suffered by the appellant, he is held entitled to compensation in accordance with the applicable entry of the amended Schedule. Since the untoward incident occurred on 27.12.2019, the amended Schedule, which already came into force on 01.01.2017, governs the claim. Accordingly, subject to the precise level of amputation falling within Part III, Item 19, the appellant shall be entitled to compensation of Rs.4,80,000/- along with interest @ of 9% per annum from the date of filing of the claim application till actual realisation. The respondent-Union of India is directed to deposit the aforesaid amount along with accrued interest with the learned Tribunal within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment. In the event of default, the appellant shall be entitled to further interest @ 12% per annum on the amount remaining unpaid, from the expiry of the aforesaid period till actual payment.
Pending misc. application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
