AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
[Per : URMILA JOSHI-PHALKE, J.]
Heard learned counsel for the respective parties. Alleging cruelty and desertion against the wife, the appellant husband approached this Court by filing an appeal against the judgment and decree passed in petition No.A-870/2020 by the Family Court No.3, Nagpur, dismissing the petition, which was filed for seeking divorce, dated 17.05.2023.
The facts giving rise to the dispute are as follows: The appellant and the respondent are husband and wife. Their marriage was solemnized on 10.05.2007 at Village Allawalpur, Faizabad as per the Hindu rites and rituals. The appellant and the respondent are blessed with two sons aged about 12 and 8 years. As per the allegation of the appellant, the distance between the parental place of the respondent of village Allawalpur and the native place of the appellant village Periyawa is approximately 60 k.m. Prior to the marriage, the appellant was not having any acquaintance with the respondent and they have not seen each other. Without his consent, the marriage was fixed. Prior to two years from the date of solemnization, the ritual of gauna was took place on 10.05.2007. When the respondent first time resumed for cohabitation, it was revealed to the appellant that she is blind by one eye and suffering from mental disorder. Thus, he was cheated by the parents of the respondent and, therefore, appellant was not willing to continue with the said marriage, but due to the pressure of his family, he has accepted the respondent as his wife.
It is further alleged by the appellant that respondent was cruel, rude since beginning of her marriage and was in habit of picking up the quarrels with the appellant and his family members. Because of her rude behaviour, the appellant was unable to communicate with her and, therefore, he wanted to dissolve the marriage, but the brother and parents of the respondent threatened him and, therefore, he continued with the same. The appellant was unemployed at the time of marriage. After three months of marriage, he went to Delhi in search of employment. When he started residing at Delhi, respondent wife has also joined him in the year 2008, however, there was no change in the behaviour of respondent. In the meantime, she gave birth to elder son in the year 2008. Due to the behaviour of the respondent, the appellant could not visit his native place. Thus, as per his contention, there was continuous cruelty, he faced at the hands of the respondent, due to her quarrelsome nature, therefore appellant shifted to Nagpur. At Nagpur also, he was subjected for the harassment by the respondent by picking up the unnecessary quarrels. In the year 2018, respondent left his company and went to her parental house and thereafter never returned back. Due to the conduct of the respondent and as she was not having any emotional attachment, there is no purpose in continuing with the said marriage and, therefore, he approached the Family Court for seeking dissolution of marriage on the ground of cruelty.
In response to the notice of the said petition, the respondent appeared and filed her written statement and denied all the contentions. As per her contention, it was the appellant who was having extramarital relationship with one lady namely Deepmala and he was intending to marry her and, therefore, he subjected the respondent with cruelty and, therefore, respondent was constrained to leave matrimonial house and started residing at her parents' house. She denied all the allegations against her regarding the cruelty and prayed for dismissal of the petition.
In support of the contention, the appellant examined himself as well as the respondent also examined herself and the father of the appellant. After appreciating the evidence, the learned Family Court held that as the appellant was desiring to marry with another girl and, therefore, there used to be quarrels between them and the appellant was taking advantage of his own wrong. The Family Court held that the appellant could not prove the cruelty at the hands of the respondent and dismissed the petition.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the same, the present appeal is preferred.
Heard learned counsel Mr. Dable, who submitted that without reasonable cause the appellant was subjected for desertion by the wife. Considering the allegation against the respondent, which was substantiated by the appellant through his evidence that continuously since marriage due to the quarrelsome nature of the respondent, he was subjected for the continuous harassment and thus, he is a victim of mental cruelty. However, the learned Family Court has not considered the same. Now, there is no chance of reunion and no purpose would to be served by compelling the appellants and respondent to stay together. It is irretrievable marriage and, therefore, requires to be dissolved.
Learned counsel Mr. Mandpe, for the respondent supported the judgment of the Family Court and submitted that the appellant could not prove a desertion or cruelty. On the contrary, the evidence of the father of the appellant, which was adduced by the respondent itself sufficient to show that it was the appellant who neglected the respondent as he was desiring to marry another lady and, therefore, respondent constrained to leave the matrimonial house. In view of that, the appeal being devoid of merits and liable to be dismissed.
After hearing both sides, the following points arise for our consideration and we answer the same accordingly:
Whether the petition for dissolution of marriage is liable to be allowed on the ground of cruelty and desertion as pleaded in the petition?
Whether the desertion at the hands of the respondent wife is proved by the appellant?
As both point Nos.1 and 2 are interlinked, they are answered together.
It is always said that the marriages are settled in heaven. The parties to marriage tying knot are supposed to bring about the union of souls. It creates a new relationship of love and affection, concern between the husband and wife. According to Hindu Vedic it is ‘Sanskar.’ The two human being pledged themselves. Despite the pledge and promises, sometimes said relationship becomes complex.
Present case is one more example of complex relationship between husband and wife. Undisputedly, the said matrimonial relationship is still in existence.
The appellant husband had filed a petition for seeking dissolution of marriage mainly on the ground of cruelty under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. The petition for dissolution of marriage is preferred mainly on the allegation that respondent wife had treated him with cruelty after marriage. As per the allegation of the appellant husband, the marriage was settled without his consent. He as well as respondent both have not seen each other prior to the marriage. The respondent wife to whom he has seen first time after the marriage and it was found that she was blind by one eye and also suffering from mental disorder. As per the allegation, the respondent wife used to raise the quarrel with him as well as with his family members. Though the marriage was settled against his consent, he continued with the marriage, however, it was the respondent wife who was frequently raising the quarrels with him and, therefore, it was difficult for him to stay with her. Moreover, he was jobless at the relevant time. Therefore, in search of a job, he went at Delhi. In the year 2008, their elder son was born. After the birth of the elder son also, there was no change in her behaviour. He brought her at Delhi, but her nature of raising quarrel with him never changed. Thereafter, he shifted to Nagpur, wherein also he faced the cruelty at the hands of the respondent, therefore, he was desiring to break the said marriage. However, he was threatened by the parents of the respondent as well as her brothers.
In support of his contention, he examined himself by filing affidavit of his evidence and reiterated the entire allegations. His cross-examination shows that there was no evidence to show that respondent was suffering from mental disorder. His cross-examination further shows that their marriage took place with the consent of both the families and his family has forced him for his marriage. His further cross-examination shows that at Delhi, they have co-operated as husband and wife and they stayed there for six months. He further admits that no maid was appointed at Delhi. He denied the allegation that he wants to marry with the said Deepmala. He even denied that he is having any acquaintance with the said Deepmala. Admittedly, as to the incidence of the cruelty, the appellant has not narrated any specific instances of cruelty at the hands of the respondent. Except the averment in the petition there is no evidence that he was subjected for the cruelty. Neither the nature nor the specific instances of the cruelty are narrated by the appellant.
The respondent has denied all these allegations and stepped into the witness box by filing an affidavit of her evidence and reiterated her contention that since the date of marriage, she performed her duty as a house wife and also towards the role of mother towards her both sons. She has also taken care of her in-laws. It was the appellant who was not willing to cohabit with her as he wants to marry with one lady namely Deepmala and, therefore, she left the matrimonial house as she was ill-treated physically and mentally by the appellant. She also narrated the incident of slapping to her sons by the said Deepmala. Her evidence shows that she made an attempt to convince the appellant to keep distance from the said Deepmala, but he has not paid any heed towards it and dropped her at her parent’s house in the year 2018. Since then, she is residing there. Despite her cross-examination, nothing incriminating is brought on record. The attempt was made to show that she has subjected him for the cruelty, but she denied the allegations. The attempt was also made to show that the respondent was having a defect in her eyesight which was also denied by her. She admitted that there was a fight between the appellant and his neighbours on account of agricultural land and, therefore, he was sent in jail. It has specifically came in the evidence that the fight for which the appellant was prosecuted has no concern with the matrimonial dispute between her and the appellant. Her evidence further shows that at the time of naming ceremony, the appellant was present at the matrimonial home for about 10 days. She also stayed along with the appellant at Delhi. Thus, these admissions falsify the version of the appellant that since the date of marriage, there was no cordial relationship between him and the respondent.
The respondent further examined the father of the appellant namely Premnath Bhubneshwar Pandey, who testified that the appellant was intending to marry with a lady at Nagpur, however, he opposed for the same and requested him to keep the relations with the respondent only. The father of the appellant further deposed that since the date of entering of the respondent in their family, there was no complaint against her. She was carrying her duties not only towards her son but also towards in-laws. Despite the cross-examination, nothing incriminating is brought on record to falsify the version of the witness.
On the basis of the evidence, it is to be ascertained whether the appellant has established that he was subjected for the cruelty. In relation to matrimonial matters, it is contemplated that a conduct of such type which endangers the living of the other amounts to cruelty. Cruelty consists of acts which are dangerous to life, limb or health. Cruelty may be physical or mental. Mental cruelty is the conduct of other spouse which causes mental suffering or fear to the matrimonial life of other. Cruelty however, has to be distinguished from the ordinary wear and tear of the family life. The question whether the act complained was a cruel act is to be determined from the whole facts and the matrimonial relationship between the parties.
In Samar Ghosh vs. Jaya Ghosh reported in (2007) 4 SCC 511, the Hon'ble Apex Court given certain illustrative examples wherefrom inference of mental cruelty can be drawn. The Hon'ble Apex Court reproduced some of the illustrations:
“(i)On consideration of complete matrimonial life of the parties, acute mental pain, agony and suffering as would not make possible for the parties to live with each other could come within the broad parameters of mental cruelty.
(ii)On comprehensive appraisal of the entire matrimonial life of the parties, it becomes abundantly clear that situation is such that the wronged party cannot reasonably be asked to put up with such conduct and continue to live with other party.
xxx xxx xxx
(iv)Mental cruelty is a state of mind. The feeling of deep anguish, disappointment, frustration in one spouse caused by the conduct of other for a long time may lead to mental cruelty.
xxx xxx xxx
(vii)Sustained reprehensible conduct, studied neglect, indifference or total departure from the normal standard of conjugal kindness causing injury to mental health or deriving sadistic pleasure can also amount to mental cruelty.
xxx xxx xxx
(x)The married life should be reviewed as a whole and a few isolated instances over a period of years will not amount to cruelty. The ill conduct must be persistent for a fairly lengthy period, where the relationship has deteriorated to an extent that because of the acts and behaviour of a spouse, the wronged party finds it extremely difficult to live with the other party any longer, may amount to mental cruelty.”
The allegations of cruelty cannot be considered on trivial issues. The allegation should have the origin with reference to time, place and manner of cruelty. General allegations of cruelty do not constitute cruelty in the eyes of law so as to grant decree of dissolution of marriage on that premise. Mere annoyance or irritation may not constitute cruelty, rather it is a spontaneous change in human behaviour which restricts the other side to live with the spouse under the fear of endangering life or bodily injuries. Though, the word, ‘cruelty’ has not been defined strictly, but it has to be gathered from attending circumstances of each case. The allegation should be specific with regard to time, place and manner of committing such cruelty. The cruelty should be such in which it is not reasonably expected to live together. It is observed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Gurbux Singh vs. Harminder Kaur reported in AIR 2011 SC 114 that the aggrieved party has to make a specific case that the conduct of which exception is taken amounts to cruelty. It is true that even a single act of violence which is of grievous and inexcusable nature satisfies the test of cruelty. The marital life should be access as a whole and few isolated instances over a certain period will not amounts to cruelty.
After adverting the material on record, it is not in dispute that the matrimonial relationship between the appellant and respondent, according to the appellant was not cordial since the date of marriage. However, the evidence shows contrary, it appears that there was a cordial relationship between them as they have begotten two sons and were residing at Delhi as well as at Nagpur. It is clear from the evidence of the appellant and the respondent that the marriage of the appellant was performed against his desire. Except his words, there is no evidence on record to support or to substantiate the contention that he was treated with cruelty by the respondent. On the contrary, the evidence of father of the appellant shows that the respondent has rendered not only as a mother of the children but also as a daughter-in-law of the house. His evidence shows that it was the respondent who was managing all the household chores, therefore, there is a substance in the submission of the learned counsel for the respondent as the appellant was desiring to perform marriage with another lady and that was the reason to have rift between the relationship.
Thus, after giving thoughtful consideration to the controversy, it reveals that it was present appellant who was not willing to stay along with his wife. To constitute cruelty it is enough the conduct of one party is so abnormal and below the accepted norm that the other spouse could not reasonably be expected to put up with it. Cruelty was made a ground for divorce and the words that reasonable apprehension in the mind of the petitioner that it may be harmful or injurious for the petitioner to live with other party which are now omitted from Section 10. The word cruelty has not been defined in the Hindu Marriage Act. It has been used in Section (1) (i-a) of the Act in the context of human conduct or behaviour in relation to or in respect of matrimonial duties or obligations. It is a course of conduct of one which is adversely affecting the others. Thus, the appellant must have specific pleadings with reference to the instances of cruelty meted out by the respondent and those have to establish by the cogent and reliable evidence.
This aspect is also considered by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of V. Bhagat vs. Mrs. D. Bhagat reported in AIR 1994 SC 710, wherein it is held that mental cruelty in Section 13(1)(ia) can broadly be defined as that conduct which inflicts upon the other party such mental pain and suffering as would make it not possible for that party to live with the other. In other words, mental cruelty must be of such a nature that the parties cannot reasonably be expected to live together. The situation must be such that the wronged party cannot reasonably be asked to put up with such conduct and continue to live.
Section 13(1)(i-a) uses the word "treated the petitioner with cruelty". The word "cruelty" has not been defined. Indeed it could not have been defined. It has been used in relation to human conduct or human behaviour. It is the conduct in relation to or in respect of matrimonial duties and obligations. It is a course of conduct of one which is adversely affecting the other. The cruelty may be mental or physical, intentional or unintentional. If it is physical the court will have no problem to determine it. It is a question of fact and degree. If it is mental, the problem presents difficulty. First, the inquiry must begin as to the nature of the cruel treatment. Second, the impact of such treatment on the mind of the spouse. Whether it caused reasonable apprehension that it would be harmful or injurious to live with the other. Ultimately, it is a matter of inference to be drawn by taking into account the nature of the conduct and its effect on the complaining spouse. There may, however, be cases where the conduct complained of itself is bad enough and per se unlawful or illegal. Then the impact or the injurious effect on the other spouse need not be enquired into or considered.
It will be necessary to bear in mind that there has been marked change in the life around us. In matrimonial duties and responsibilities in particular, we find a change. They are of varying degrees from house to house or person to person. Therefore, when a spouse makes complaint about the treatment of cruelty by the partner in life or relations, the Court should not search for standard in life. A set of facts showing cruelty in one case may not be in another case. The cruelty alleged may largely depend upon the type of life the parties are leading or their economic and social conditions. It may also depend upon their culture and human values to which they attach importance.
In the light of above principles if the facts of the present case are examined and the evidence adduced is appreciated it reveals that the appellant failed to establish the cruelty by narrating either a specific instances or the nature of the cruelty. Therefore, as far as the ground of cruelty is concerned, the appellant failed to establish the said ground.
Another ground raised by the appellant that there was a desertion at the hands of the respondent. ‘Desertion’ means the intentional, permanent forsaking and abandonment of one spouse by the other without the other's consent and without reasonable cause. Desertion means withdrawing from the matrimonial obligations. To constitute desertion two essential conditions must be established: (1) The factum of separation, and (2) the intention to bring cohabitation permanently to an end (animus deserendi). For holding desertion as proved the inference may be drawn from sudden circumstances. It is held in Darshan Gupta vs. Radhika Gupta (2013) 9 SCC 1 that merely because husband and wife are staying separately, an inference regarding desertion on the wife's part cannot be drawn. The law laid down in the case of Lachman Utamchand Kirpalani vs Meena Alias Mota 1964 SCR (4) 331 which has been consistently followed in several decisions of the Hon'ble Apex Court. The law laid down in the above decision is that desertion means the intentional permanent forsaking and abandonment of one spouse by the other without the consent of the other and without reasonable cause. The deserted spouse must prove that there is a factum of separation and there is an intention on the part of deserting spouse to bring cohabitation to permanent end. In other words, there should be animus deserendi on the part of the deserted spouse and the conduct of the deserted spouse should not give a reasonable cause to deserting spouse to leave matrimonial house.
Here in the present case, admittedly, no evidence is adduced to prove the cruelty and desertion at the hands of the respondent. On the contrary, the evidence on record shows that it was the appellant who was not willing to reside with the respondent and, therefore, he dropped the respondent at her matrimonial house. Thus, there is no evidence to show that respondent wife was desiring to end the relationship permanently. Even the evidence of the father of the appellant substantiates the contention of the respondent that it was the appellant, who was not desiring to stay along with the respondent and it was the appellant due to whose behaviour the respondent was constrained to leave separately. Therefore, the contention of the appellant husband that the respondent left the matrimonial house and she subjected to him for cruelty as well as for the desertion, is not sustainable.
After giving thoughtful consideration to the controversy, we are of the view that the appellant husband failed to prove the ground of cruelty to obtain a decree of dissolution of marriage. The manner in which the appellant husband faced cruelty is not proved. Mere annoyance or irritation or normal wear or tear differences does not constitute cruelty. Here in the present case, even there are no instances narrated as to the annoyance or irritation or normal wear or tear differences. The cruelty should be such in which it is not reasonably expected to live together. The appellant husband has not proved the desertion at the hands of the respondent wife. Merely because the respondent wife staying separately an inference of desertion cannot be drawn. In fact, the evidence shows that it was the appellant who has dropped the respondent at her matrimonial house and, therefore, she is residing there. The marriage between the parties cannot be dissolved on the averments made by one of the parties that the marriage between them has broken down. The irretrievable breakdown of the marriage is not a ground by itself to dissolve it. As regards the allegation made by the appellant husband are not believable.
In the light of the above discussion, we are unable to accept the contention of the appellant husband and hence no ground is made out to interfere with the findings of the Family Court. Accordingly, point Nos. (1) and (2) answered in negative. We accept the conclusion derived by the trial Court. Therefore, the appeal fails and dismissed. There is no order as to the costs.
Appeal is disposed of.
