AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Impugned order of 10th November, 2015 sets aside the order of 30th May, 2012 of the concerned Collector and thereby restores the order of 3rd
February, 1982 of the Revenue Assistant.
It is matter of record that the Revenue Assistant’s order was ex parte and even the order of the concerned Collector was ex parte. The
Financial Commissioner in the impugned order has taken note of delay of more than 24 years in filing of the appeal by petitioner herein. Strangely, the concerned Collector does not deal with the delay aspect and maintains that the delay is presumed to be condoned. To say the least, such a course is not open as inordinate delay needs to be cogently explained.
Otherwise, it leads to injustice.
After having heard both the sides at length, it has now transpired that respondents’ application was for correction of Khasra/Girdawari and not
for correction of the mutation. It is no longer res integra that Khasra/Girdawaridoes not confer a title.
Learned counsel for respondents submits that an application for correction of mutation was infact filed as the concerned Revenue Collector has
directed expunging of name of petitioner’s predecessor-ininterest from the revenue record. It is also matter of record that the aspect of
respondents’ application being one for correction of Khasra/Girdawari was never an issue before the authorities below.
In the considered opinion of this Court, injustice cannot be allowed to perpetuate on a mere technicality. Substantial justice is required to be done.
Since the parties have all along treated the application for correction of Khasra/Girdawari as the one relating to title i.e. of correction of mutation,
therefore, respondents cannot be non-suited on this mere technicality. What stares in the face is the delay aspect. In the instant case, there is an unexplained delay of about 24 years to which the concerned Collector has closed its eyes on a lame plea that the delay is presumed to be condoned. It cannot be so. The Financial Commissioner has drawn adverse inference against the concerned Collector on this account and rightly so. On merits, the
Financial Commissioner had perused the record and had found that petitioner’s predecessor-in-interest, i.e. Bal Kishan, had refused to accept the
Notice sent by the concerned Revenue Assistant and Madan Mohan, who was also a predecessor-ininterest of petitioner, had appeared before the
Revenue Assistant on 16th September, 1981 and the order-sheet of the next date i.e. 30th September, 1981, records that above-said Madan Mohan was present on the last date of hearing, but had absented himself and so, proceeded ex parte.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel for petitioner has asserted that the records need to be requisitioned to find out as to whether Madan
Mohan, predecessor-in-interest of petitioner, had signed the ordersheet or not.Such an exercise is uncalled for as there is no basis to dispute the records so produced before the Financial Commissioner. Otherwise also, in the instant case, inordinate and unexplained delay assumes importance.
After more than two decades, old record cannot possibly be traced. It is no longer res integra that the law assists those, who are vigilant and not those,
who are indolent.
Consequentially, I find that the impugned order of 10th November, 2015 does not suffer from any illegality or infirmity. Hence, this petition and the
pending application are dismissed while leaving the parties to bear their own cost.
