AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
HARPREET SINGH BRAR J. (Oral)
Prayer in this writ petition filed under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India, is for issuance of a writ in the nature of certiorari, for quashing the impugned letter dated 27.6.2024 (Annexure P-6) and order at Sr. No.2 of table of letter dated 28.03.2025 (Annexure P-8) issued by respondent No.3, whereby the petitioner's claim for reimbursement of chronic disease medical expenses amounting to Rs.2,76,700/- for treatment taken at BLK Hospital, New Delhi between 12.12.2023 and 19.05.2024 has been declined. Further a writ of mandamus has been sought, directing the respondents to make the payment of medical bills claim submitted by the petitioner along with interest @ 18% on the total bill amount from the date of submission of respective bills.
The petitioner, who is appearing in person, inter alia, contends that he is entitled to medical reimbursement as his wife was taking treatment from BLK Hospital, New Delhi since the year 2016 onwards. He submits that earlier the said hospital was an empanelled hospital, however, it was de-empanelled by the Government of Haryana on 05.11.2023. Being unaware of the said fact, the petitioner’s wife continued to take treatment from the said hospital from 12.12.2023 to 19.05.2024, and during the said period, he has incurred Rs.2,76,700/- on critical and life-saving treatment of his wife, as is evident from Annexure P-4. He further submits that he had submitted a part of the above-said reimbursement claim of Rs.2,09,669/- to respondent/authorities on 23.04.2024 for the period from 12.12.2023 to 11.04.2024 (Annexure P-5) but the same was returned by respondent No.3 vide letter dated 27.06.2024 (Annexure P-6) solely on the ground that BLK Hospital, was no longer on the empanelled list of the government. He again made a request to respondent No.1 vide letter dated 08.01.2025 for post-facto sanction of Rs.2,76,700/- for the treatment of his wife. The petitioner further refers to Chronic Disease Certificate of his wife issued by the Civil Surgeon, Panchkula, dated 11.08.2021 (Annexure P-2) and submits that his wife is suffering from kidney ailments. In support of the arguments, he places reliance upon the judgment rendered by this Court in CWP-13494-2016, titled as Manoj Jain vs State of Haryana and others, decided on 03.12.2018, reported as 2019(1) PLR 585, which was upheld before the Division Bench of this Court in LPA-174-2022, titled as State of Haryana and another vs. Manoj Jain and others, decided on 27.01.2025. Lastly, the petitioner submits that the action of the respondents in denying medical reimbursement is arbitrary and illegal.
Per contra, learned State counsel opposes the prayer made by the petitioner on the ground that the medical reimbursement is to be extended only in terms of the applicable policy for the treatment taken in an approved hospital. He submits that the wife of the petitioner has not taken the treatment from an empanelled hospital and as such, the claim of the petitioner was rightly rejected. However, he could not controvert the fact that prior to 05.11.2023, the BLK Hospital was an empanelled hospital.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record with their able assistance.
The core issue before this Court is whether the respondents were justified in denying medical reimbursement claim on the technical grounds that the hospital was unapproved, despite the life-saving nature of the procedure and the chronic disease suffered by the petitioner's wife.
The claim for medical reimbursement ought not to be dismissed merely because the patient or claimant underwent treatment in a non-empanelled. In such cases, the test of essentiality and emergency comes into play, which dictates that if the medical procedure was undergone by the claimant in an emergency, on the advice of a doctor based on his medical record, in order to save his or her life, the reimbursement for the same must be made. Not only is the preservation of human life instinctive, but it also forms a part of Article 21 of the Constitution of India, and therefore, it shall always retain the highest priority.
Moreover, the State bears an obligation to ensure the availability of timely medical care to those in need. As such, it cannot expect the citizens to refrain from availing timely care, merely for the reason of non-empanelment of the hospital. Such conduct on the part of the State does not satisfy the criteria of fairness and reasonableness and therefore, amounts to a violation of the fundamental rights enshrined in Article 21 of the Constitution of India. Reliance in this regard can be placed on the judgments rendered by a two Judge bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Surjit Singh vs. State of Punjab and others(1996) 2 SCC 336, whereby, speaking through Justice M.M. Punchhi, the following was opined:
“8.The policy, providing recognition for treatment of open heart surgery in the Escorts, specifically came to be examined by a Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court at Chandigarh in C.W.P. No. 13493 of 1992 titled as Sadhu R. Pall v. State of Punjab through Secretary, Health and Family Welfare Punjab, Civil Secretariat, Chandigarh and others, 1994(1) SCT 552 (P&H). decided on 6.10.1993, wherein the claim of the then writ petitioner to medical reimbursement was accepted when in order to save his life he had got himself operated upon in the Escorts, and the plea of the State that he could be paid rates as prevalent in the AIIMS was rejected. Special Leave Petition No. 22024 of 1995 against the said decision was dismissed by this Court on 2.2.1994. The other judgments of the High Court following the decision in Sadhu R. Pall's case are :
(1)C.W.P. No. 18562 of 1992 decided on 10.5.95 titled K.L. Kohli v. State of Punjab and others, 1995(4) SCT 280 (P&H);
(2)C.W.P. No. 260 of 1995, decided on 30.5.1995 titled Ravi Mohan Duggal v. State of Punjab and others (DB)
(3)C.W.P. No. 5669 of 1994 decided on 4.9.94 titled Prem Singh Gill v. State of Punjab and others;
(4)1995(4) SCT 816 (P&H) : 1995 (III) Punjab Law Report 529 titled Tarlok Chander v. State of Punjab etc. (SB); and
(5)1996(2) SCT 148 (P&H) : 1995 (III), Punjab Law Reporter 682 titled Mrs. Surya Pandit v. State of Punjab and others (SB) xxx xxx xxx
10.It is otherwise important to bear in mind that self preservation of one's life is the necessary concomitant of the right to life enshrined in Article 21 of the Constitution of India , fundamental in nature, sacred, precious and inviolable. The importance and validity of the duty and right to self-preservation has a species in the right of self defence in criminal law…
11.The appellant therefore had the right to take steps in self preservation. He did not have to stand in queue before the Medical Board, the manning and assembling of which, bare-facedly, makes its meetings difficult to happen. The appellant also did not have to stand in queue in the Government hospital of AIIMS and could go elsewhere to an alternate hospital as per policy. When the State itself has brought the Escorts on the recognised list, it is futile for it to contend that the appellant could in no event have gone to the Escorts and his claim cannot on that basis be allowed, on suppositions. We think to the contrary…”
The denial of medical reimbursement merely on the ground that the hospital was no longer empanelled, despite the petitioner’s wife suffering from a chronic and life-threatening condition such as Chronic Kidney Disease (CKD), cannot be sustained as it defeats the very object of the medical reimbursement scheme, which is intended to safeguard the right to life and health guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
Moreover, the legal position on this matter is now well-settled. The Division Bench of this Court in Manoj Jain’s case (supra), while dealing with an identical issue concerning CKD treatment taken in OPD from an unapproved hospital, upheld the allowance of the claim. The Division Bench of this Court unequivocally rejected the argument that reimbursement could be denied solely on the ground of OPD treatment for a chronic condition. For clarity and precedent, Paragraph 12 of the said judgment is reproduced hereunder:
"12.'Chronic' means a condition that does not get completely better and lasts over a long time. A patient with CKD is also at an increased risk of other ailments like heart attack or stroke. It is not disputed by the appellants that the wife of respondent No.1-writ petitioner had taken treatment from the aforesaid hospitals. As the wife of respondent No.1-writ petitioner was suffering from CKD, the treatment given by the concerned Doctor(s) in the OPD, was totally dependent upon the expertise of the said Doctor(s) and therefore, the denial of the claim of the medical reimbursement of the wife of respondent No.1-writ petitioner on the ground that it was taken in OPD, is not based on a reasonable classification. We further find that the disease being chronic in nature, the treatment even if taken in OPD, cannot be termed to be not falling in category of 'emergency treatment', particularly when the disease relating to renal requires a continuous treatment. The judgments of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Ram Lubhaya Bagga and Mahesh Kumar (supra) is of no help to the appellant in view of its subsequent judgment in Shiva Kant Jha (supra)."
Thus, the ratio of law laid down by the Division Bench in Manoj Jain’s case (supra) is directly applicable to the facts of the present case. The petitioner's wife was suffering from chronic kidney disease and she had been taking treatment from BLK Hospital, New Delhi since 2016, when the said hospital was an empanelled hospital under the Government scheme. The fact that the hospital was subsequently de-empanelled on 05.11.2023, by itself, cannot disentitle the petitioner from claiming reimbursement for the treatment taken thereafter, particularly when the treatment was a continuation of the treatment for a chronic and life-threatening disease. There is no allegation that the petitioner had deliberately chosen a non-empanelled hospital to claim reimbursement or the treatment was unnecessary. The petitioner was required to ensure timely and continuous treatment of his wife and the mere subsequent de-empanelment of the hospital could not reasonably be made a ground to deny the medical expenses actually incurred for such treatment. The action of the respondents in rejecting the claim solely on the ground of non-empanelment of the hospital, therefore, cannot be sustained. The preservation of human life is a fundamental right and the medical reimbursement scheme being a welfare measure must be interpreted in a broad and purposive manner as laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Shiva Kant Jha v. Union of India, AIR 2018 Supreme Court 1975.
In view of the foregoing reasons, the test of essentiality and emergency stands fully satisfied. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed and the impugned letter dated 27.06.2024 (Annexure P-6) and the order at Sr. No.2 of the table appended to letter dated 28.03.2025 (Annexure P-8), are hereby quashed. The respondents are directed to process and reimburse the petitioner's medical claim of Rs.2,76,700/- in respect of the treatment of his wife at BLK Hospital, New Delhi, for the period from 12.12.2023 to 19.05.2024. The admissible amount shall be paid along with interest @ 6% per annum from the respective dates of submission of the reimbursement claims till the date of actual payment. The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within a period of 03 months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
