AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
This appeal is filed by the assessee against the order of ld. Addl./JCIT (A)-1, Chandigarh [“Ld. CIT(A)”, for short] dated 21.03.2026 for the Assessment Year 2012-13.
Brief facts of the case are, during the year under consideration, the assessee is an individual and having income under the head income from business and profession and other sources. The assessee filed return of income on 29.03.2014 declaring an income of Rs.3,32,100/-. Based on the NMS information, the Assessing Officer noticed that during FY 2012-13, the assessee had deposited in cash of Rs.12,09,000/- in his saving bank account maintained with Canara Bank, Munirka, New Delhi. The Assessing Officer observed that assessee filed return of income for the AY 2012-13 declaring income of Rs.3,32,100/- which is not commensurate with the abovesaid transaction. Accordingly, the Assessing Officer recorded his reasons to believe that an income chargeable to tax has escapement assessment.
Thereafter, notice u/s 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short ‘the Act’) on 30.03.2019 to assessee on ITBA Portal as well as speed post for the AY 2012-13 after obtaining the necessary approval. In response thereto, assessee filed return of income for the AY. 2012-13 on 01.05.2019 declaring income of Rs.3,32,100/- through e-filing under the head income from business and profession and other sources.
During the course of assessment proceedings, notices u/s 143(2) and 142(1) of Act along with questionnaire were issued from time to time to the assessee on-line for furnishing the source of cash deposited of Rs.12,09,000/- in saving bank account maintained with aforesaid Canara Bank seeking documentary evidence, copy of all bank account statement maintained by the assessee individually or jointly for the year under consideration.
In response, assessee has furnished the details/information on line vide letter dated 03.12.201 9. The relevant contents of the letter are produced as under: -
“We are in receipt of your email dated 30-11-2019 requiring us to file the documents for the A.Y. 2012-13 for furnishing the cash deposited of Rs.12,09,000/- in saving bank account maintained with Canara Bank along with supporting documents. a) The Assessee is a retired official of Indian Airlines and post his retirement was working as a consultant to SAR Aviation Services Private Limited (PAN AAJCS6728F) during the relevant financial year. The spouse of the assessee is an Assistant Professor at University of Delhi. The assessee as well the spouse are Income Tax payer and file Income Tax return. b) Must it be mentioned here that the Assessee had advanced Rs.25,00,000/- on agreement to repay in Cheque and it was dated 04.03.2011 to SAR Aviation Services Private Limited (Borrower) vide three cheques 0853014-16 drawn on HDFC Bank amounting to Rs.10,00,000/-, Rs.10,00,000/- and Rs.5,00,000/- respectively; c)The borrower had repaid the said loan in various instalments in cash which were deposited in our bank accounts referred as above. d) This amount of Rs. 12,09,000/- had been received from SAR Aviation Services Private Limited as a repayment for Loan advance.”
Further, the assessee provided the cheque details of the amount of loan granted and the PAN number of SAR Aviation and the Balance Sheet of the relevant Year reflecting the loan received from the assessee.
Subsequent to the submissions of the assessee, the Assessing Officer show-caused the assessee as to why section 269SS of the Act should not be initiated. The above show cause was pursued by the AO with the conclusion/finding that, “No person shall take or accept from any other person (herein referred to as the depositor), any loan or deposit or any specified sum, otherwise than by an account payee cheque or account payee bank draft or use of electronic clearing system through a bank account if the amount is Rs.20,0000 or more.” He observed that as such, neither assessee has furnished confirmation from SAR Aviation Services Private Limited that amount of Rs.25,00,000/- was taken on 04.03.2011 as Loan and made the payment in cash subsequently nor copy of account of the above said company in which loan shown for the period 01.04.2010 to 31.03.2011, nor how much amount assessee received cash date-wise from the SAR Aviation Private Limited and reply of show caused notice as to why section 269SS should not be initiated till date. In the absence of the above details/documents, Assessing Officer observed that assessee has nothing to say in this regard and whatever documents furnished by the assessee on line during the course of assessment proceedings is not cogent evidence. Assessing Officer was of the view that it is a fabricating storey to avoid the tax on escapement income. Hence, Assessing Officer observed that the contention of the assessee that whatever amount of cash deposited in saving bank account maintained with Canara Bank, Munirka, New Delhi during the year under consideration is received as loan payment from SAR Aviation Services Private Limited in cash is not accepted. With the above findings, the AO held that the explanation of the assessee that it has received the cash as repayment of loan is not acceptable. Hence, he held that the income be assessed as unexplained Income under section 69A and accordingly added Rs.12,09,000/- as unexplained cash deposit and assessed the income at Rs.15,41,100/-
Aggrieved with the above order assessee preferred an appeal before the ld. CIT(A), Chandigarh. There was no compliance for various notices issued by the ld. CIT(A) under section 260 of the Act. Before ld. CIT(A), assessee has filed only paper book without any other submission or supporting documents. Based on the information available on record, ld. CIT(A) dismissed the appeal preferred by the assessee by observing as under
“1.I have carefully considered the order u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 147, grounds of appeal and statements of facts in Form 35. No written submission was made by the assessee in response to the notices issued by Addl. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals). Total non-compliance on the part of the appellant to notices u/s 250 dated 22.01.2021, 15.06,2023, 22.06.2023, 12.07.2023, 10.12.2024, 25.02.2025, 13.03.2025, 09.06.2025, 10.12.2025, 05.03.2026 leaves me with no option other than deciding the appeal ex-parte, on merits on the case.
2.No written submissions were made by the appellant in response to the notices issued by Addl. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals). Total non-compliance on the part of the appellant leaves me with no option other than deciding the appeal ex-parte, on the merits of the case, after perusing the assessment order u/s 143(3) r.w.s 147.
3.The Appeal cannot be kept pending for indefinite period without reasonable cause. It is observed that the appellant is not interested in prosecuting the appeal filed by him.
4.Hon'ble Punjab & Haryana High Court in the case of Shahbad Cooperative Sugar Mills Ltd., 38 taxman.com 204 (P&H) have held that when notices were hot received back, it raises a presumption of service under section 27 of General Clause Act, 1897, In such a situation when the notices have been served upon the assessee at the addresses specified in the Appeal filed by the Appellant, it is clear that the Appellant has no intention to effectively pursue the Appeal.
5.In CIT vs. B.N. Bhattacharya (1977) 118 ITR 461 (SC), the Hon'ble Supreme Court while dealing with the issue of prosecution of appeal has stated that "preferring an appeal means more than formally filing it but effectively pursuing it".
6.Total non-compliance on the part of the appellant leaves me with no option other than deciding the appeal ex-parte, on merits of the case.
7.This appeal has been filed by the appellant claiming that the action of the assessing officer is not supported by facts and case laws. In such a situation, it is for the appellant to furnish submissions with relevant evidence(s), case laws, if any, to support its claim. The burden of proof is always on the person who makes the claim. In this case, it is the appellant who has made the claim by filing the appeal. Thus, wherever the appellant claims that certain receipt should not be taxed, the burden is on the appellant to prove its claim. The appellant has not avail any opportunity to do so.
8.Since the appellant has not presented any argument not submitted any paper in support of its claim, the appeal is decided judiciously based on materials available on record.
9.I have perused the impugned assessment order. The appellant has not prosecuted this appeal. Therefore, the addition made by the Assessing Officer is sustained, on the reasons given in the assessment order.
Aggrieved with the above order, assessee is in appeal, raising following grounds of appeal :-
“1.That the learned Addl./Joint Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)-1, Chandigarh ["the learned CIT(A)"] erred in law and on facts in sustaining the addition of Rs.12,09,000 under section 69A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 ("the Act"), without properly adjudicating the appellant's explanation that the cash deposits represented repayment of an earlier loan advanced by the appellant through banking channels to SAR Aviation Services Pvt. Ltd.
2.That the impugned order is contrary to section 250(6) of the Act because it does not identify and decide the material points arising from the grounds of appeal, record reasoned findings on the explanation and evidence concerning the deposits, or give an independent basis for sustaining the addition; it substantially adopts the Assessing Officer's conclusion.
3.That the learned CIT(A) failed to adjudicate the appellant's jurisdictional challenge to reassessment under sections 147/148 of the Act, including the validity of the notice dated 30.03.2019 and compliance with the applicable statutory conditions and sanction requirements. The reassessment and consequential addition are liable to be annulled if the jurisdictional requirements were not fulfilled.
4.That the learned CIT(A) erred in treating alleged non-compliance or non-prosecution as a basis for dismissing the appeal and sustaining the addition. Although the order states that the appeal was decided ex parte on merits, it also records that the appellant was not interested in prosecuting the appeal and confirms the addition by relying on the assessment order without independently deciding the disputed grounds. The appeal required a reasoned decision on the issues raised.
5.That the learned CIT(A) erred in sustaining the addition without determining whether the statutory conditions for invoking section 69A were met, and without independently evaluating the appellant's explanation and the material concerning the nature and source of the deposits. The absence of a borrower confirmation or other particular document, by itself, could not replace a reasoned determination of the explanation and evidence on the record.
6.That the learned CIT(A) erred in sustaining the addition of Rs 12,09,000 without undertaking a proper transaction-wise and date-wise reconciliation of the underlying Canara Bank entries which constituted the disputed amount, and without determining which specific deposits were relied upon for the addition. The bank statement and the surrounding material required examination to establish the precise deposits forming the subject matter of the addition and their relevance to the appellant's explanation.
7.That the learned CIT(A) failed to consider and evaluate the contemporaneous evidence of the underlying advance of Rs 25,00,000 to SAR Aviation Services Pvt. Ltd. through three cheques dated 04.03.2011, including the cheque particulars and the company's relevant financial statements recording the amount received from the appellant, which the impugned order itself records as having been furnished during assessment proceedings. This evidence was relevant to the existence and source of the loan relationship.
8.That the learned CIT(A) erred in sustaining the addition without examining the appellant's explanation that the deposits were instalment-wise repayments of the said advance, and without findings on the dates and amounts of repayments, the relevant bank records, or why the explanation was rejected. The issue required an evidence-based determination and, if necessary, verification from SAR Aviation Services Pvt. Ltd.
9.That the learned CIT(A) failed to consider the appellant's Form 3 dated 27.12.2019 asserting a monetary claim of Rs 20,50,000 against SAR Aviation Services Pvt. Ltd., the company's advocate's reply dated 17.01.2020, related correspondence and relevant banking/source records, insofar as these documents form part of the appellate record or are admitted under the separate application for additional" evidence. These materials were relevant corroboration and required consideration with the other evidence.
10.That the Assessing Officer's reliance on section 269SS to reject the explanation was misconceived on the appellant's case that the amount represented repayment of a loan originally advanced by cheque. Any alleged contravention concerning repayment in cash would require consideration under section 269T and the applicable separate penalty provisions; it does not, by itself, establish that the deposits were unexplained money taxable under section 69A. The learned CIT(A) failed to address this distinction.
11.That the appellant seeks admission and consideration under Rule 29 of the Income-tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963, of the documents specified in the separate application filed with the appeal. The documents are material to the source explanation and to a proper adjudication of the grounds. The appellant prays that they be admitted and considered, with such verification or remand as the Hon'ble Tribunal may deem appropriate.”
At the time of hearing, assessee himself appeared and submitted the relevant informations. At the time of hearing, assessee brought to our notice page 109 of the paper book which is the details of cheque payments made by him to SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd. and further he brought to our notice page 49 of the paper book which is the balance sheet of SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd. in which at Note 3 of the Balance Sheet Schedule ‘Long Term Borrowings’, the company had disclosed borrowings from the assessee as on 31.03.2011 of Rs.25,00,000/- and as on 31.03.2012, the loan was reduced to Rs.20,50,000. Further, he brought to our notice page 2 of the assessment order and submitted that as per the NMS information received from ITD system by the AO, he noticed that assessee had deposited cash of Rs.12,09,000/- in his saving bank account maintained with Canara Bank, Munirka, New Delhi. Based on the above information, the case of the assessee was reopened and after considering the submissions of the assessee, AO rejected the submissions of the assessee that assessee has received back the loan amount from SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd. and not convinced with the submissions of the assessee, AO proceeded to treat the cash deposit made by the assessee of Rs.12,09,000/- as undisclosed money under section 69A of the Act. He further brought to our notice page 63 of the paper book which is the financial statement for the financial year ending 31.03.2013. The outstanding long term borrowings were shown as nil as far as loan taken from the assessee is concerned. Further, he brought to our notice page 125 of the paper book which is the email sent by the assessee to one Capt. Pandey and Ms. Rashmi Pandey to whom assessee has addressed the various details asking for details of settlement of long term loan taken from the assessee. He also brought to our notice trail of emails sent to Capt. Pandey on various dates. He also brought to our notice his appointment letter in which assessee was appointed as head of operations with effect from 01.10.2010. Further he brought to our notice that the assessee being appointed as Vice President (Chartered Operations). Since there was no response from the SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd., he submitted that it is fact on record that he has lent loan to the company and get settlement also. The only issue is mode of settlement. He submitted that since the company had settled the loan by cash, they are not coming forward to acknowledge the same, in the result, the assessee is suffering. He also brought to our notice legal notice issued by SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd. denying any receipt of money from the assessee. He prayed that the proper justice may be rendered.
On the other hand ld. DR of the Revenue heavily relied on the findings of the lower authorities.
Considered the rival submissions and material placed on record. We observed that assessee has paid Rs.25,00,000/- to SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd. on 04.03.2011 and the assessee has collected back Rs.4,50,000/- as under :-
Page 119 paper book
It is supported by the following bank statement for the period 01.01.2010 to 07.02.2013 (We have reproduced the transaction of payment of loan to SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd.) :-
* Closing balance includes funds earmarked for hold and uncleared funds.
Contents of this statement will be considered correct if no error is reported within 30 days of receipt of statement.
HDFC Bank Service Tax Registration Number : M-IVISTIBANK & OTHER SERVICES / 20/2001.
From the above schedule, it is clear that assessee has made payment of Rs.25,00,000/- to SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd.. This is being supported by the declaration of above liability in the balance sheet of the SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd. as on 31.03.2011 and 31.03.2012 wherein the liability was clearly disclosed in the financial statement itself. Further, we noticed that the above said liability was settled during financial year 2012-13. We noticed from the financial statement of SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd. as on 31.03.2013 wherein liability of the assessee was brought to nil. Before us, assessee himself appeared and submitted that the above said liability was settled by SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd. by cash and the same cash was deposited by the assessee in his bank account. We also observed from the legal notice issued by the SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd. to the assessee dated 17.01.2020 at para 6 of the above legal notice, the advocate mentioned as under
“6.My client had no occasion to borrow any money from you and as such there is no question of you claiming any amount from my client. The amount mentioned by you in your notice is your figment of imagination and a cooked up story denied by my client. Even from your own knowledge also, you are not entitled to recover any money from my client legally or otherwise on account of having worked with my client till the year 2012.”
After considering the above legal notice wherein through an Advocate, SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd. has categorically denied that they have not borrowed any money from the assessee whereas the facts available on record clearly indicate that they have in fact borrowed from the assessee of Rs.25,00,000/-as disclosed in their own balance sheet. This clearly indicates that SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd. is afraid to disclose the mode of settlement to the assessee. If that being the case, they should have given the details of settlement to the assessee. Therefore, considering the overall facts on record, the claim of the assessee seems to be proper. Therefore, we direct the AO to treat cash deposit made by the assessee out of the settlement amount due to him out of SAR Aviation Pvt. Ltd. against the loan borrowed by them. Since the source of cash deposited by the assessee has been explained, we are inclined to delete the addition made by the AO.
In the result the appeal filed by the assessee is allowed
