AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Deepak Gupta, J.
The defendant has preferred the present regular second appeal against the judgment & decree dated 11.01.2024 passed by learned Additional District Judge, Chandigarh, whereby his first appeal against the judgment & decree dated 12.07.2018 passed by learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Chandigarh, decreeing the respondent-plaintiff's suit for recovery of ₹2,98,409/- along with interest, was dismissed.
Briefly, the respondent-plaintiff had inducted the appellant as a tenant in the premises bearing No.624, Ground Floor, Kesho Ram Complex, Sector 45-C, Chandigarh, at an initial monthly rent of ₹10,500/-, subject to annual enhancement of 7.5%. The rent subsequently stood enhanced to ₹14,023/- per month. An eviction petition filed by the plaintiff on the ground of personal necessity was allowed on 30.03.2015 and possession of the premises was delivered to her through the Court Bailiff on 18.09.2015. Alleging non-payment of rent for the period from 01.03.2014 to 18.09.2015, the plaintiff instituted the present suit for recovery.
The defendant contested the suit, inter alia, pleading that the entire liability had been settled upon payment of ₹1,50,000/- in cash and adjustment of ₹21,000/- towards security.
Both Courts below, upon appreciation of evidence, rejected the plea of payment and decreed the suit.
Assailing the concurrent findings, Learned counsel for the appellant contends that the plaintiff had earlier instituted a suit, which was dismissed as withdrawn, as reflected in Annexure A-3. It is further submitted that the plaintiff had also filed an eviction petition on the ground of non-payment of rent, wherein she could have pursued recovery of the alleged arrears. Having failed to press the said claim and having withdrawn the earlier eviction proceedings, the plaintiff could not maintain a separate suit for recovery of the same amount. Thus, according to learned counsel, the subsequent suit is barred by the principles underlying Order II Rule 2 CPC and so, the judgments of the Courts below are legally unsustainable.
Having heard learned counsel for the appellant and perused the impugned judgments, this Court finds no merit in the submissions.
Admittedly, the relationship of landlord and tenant between the parties, the agreed rate of rent of ₹14,023/- per month and delivery of possession to the plaintiff on 18.09.2015 are not in dispute. The defendant also did not specifically dispute that rent for the period from 01.03.2014 to 18.09.2015 had become payable. His principal defence was that the liability stood discharged pursuant to an oral settlement. However, no receipt or other reliable documentary evidence establishing the alleged payment of ₹1,50,000/- and adjustment of ₹21,000/- was produced. Both Courts below have concurrently rejected the said defence upon appreciation of evidence. Such findings of fact cannot be reopened in second appeal merely because another view of the evidence is suggested.
As regards maintainability, an eviction petition founded upon non-payment of rent and a civil suit seeking recovery of arrears do not necessarily involve identical reliefs. Proceedings for eviction under the rent control legislation are primarily concerned with determination of the landlord's entitlement to recover possession on the statutory grounds pleaded. The opportunity afforded to a tenant to tender arrears of rent in such proceedings does not, by itself, convert the eviction petition into a suit for recovery of money or extinguish the landlord's independent right to recover legally payable arrears.
The mere fact that the plaintiff could have sought payment of arrears during eviction proceedings does not establish that she was legally precluded from instituting a separate recovery suit. The bar under Order II Rule 2 CPC requires identity of the cause of action and omission or relinquishment of a relief, which the plaintiff was entitled to claim in the earlier proceedings. Such bar cannot be inferred merely from the fact that the two proceedings arise out of the same tenancy relationship. Reference in this regard may be made to Gurbux Singh v. Bhooralal, AIR 1964 SC 1810, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court explained the essential requirements for attracting Order II Rule 2 CPC.
Insofar as the contention regarding withdrawal of the earlier civil suit, as reflected in Annexure A-3, is concerned, the same is equally devoid of merit. Admittedly, the earlier suit pertained to recovery of water charges, whereas the present suit has been instituted for recovery of arrears of rent for the period from 01.03.2014 to 18.09.2015. The subject matter and causes of action in the two suits are distinct. Merely because both claims arose during subsistence of the same tenancy does not render them part of an identical cause of action. Consequently, withdrawal of the earlier suit concerning water charges does not attract the bar contemplated under Order II Rule 2 or Order XXIII Rule 1(4) CPC against the present suit for recovery of rent.
Likewise, withdrawal of the earlier eviction petition on the ground of non-payment of rent, after possession of the premises had already been recovered pursuant to a separate eviction order, does not extinguish the landlord's independent right to recover outstanding rent. The eviction petition was withdrawn as having become infructuous consequent upon delivery of possession. There is nothing on record to establish that the plaintiff had expressly relinquished her monetary claim or that the same stood satisfied. The appellant's plea of full and final settlement having been concurrently rejected by both Courts below, the objection regarding maintainability is without substance.
The concurrent findings regarding existence of arrears and failure of the defendant to prove their discharge are based upon appreciation of the evidence on record. No perversity, misreading of material evidence or application of an erroneous legal principle has been demonstrated warranting interference under Section 100 CPC.
The jurisdiction of this Court in a regular second appeal is confined to substantial questions of law. Reappreciation of evidence or substitution of a different factual conclusion is impermissible unless the concurrent findings suffer from perversity or are contrary to settled principles of law. Reference may be made to Hero Vinoth (Minor) v. Seshammal, (2006) 5 SCC 545.
In view of the foregoing discussion, no substantial question of law arises for consideration in the present appeal. Consequently, the appeal is dismissed and the concurrent judgments and decrees passed by the Courts below are affirmed. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall also stand disposed of.
