Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2019) 11 RERA CK 1015

Raghav Mittal vs Antriksh Dev. & Promoters Pvt. Ltd.

Real Estate Regulatory Authority National Capital Territory Of Delhi · Decided on 13 November 2019

CASE NUMBER
Complaint No: 44/2018

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

20 paragraphs · 2,392 words

Advocate of both sides present.

Order pronounced.

Both sides may obtain certified copies by applying for the same.

1.

This is a complaint filed by Shri Raghav Mittal (hereinafter referred to as the Complainant) against M/s. Antriksh Developers & Promoters Ltd. (subsequently revised to M/s. Antriksh Engicon Pvt. Ltd.) seeking several reliefs in respect of an apartment booked by him in 2015 in a project named 'Antriksh Urban Greek' promoted by Antriksh Group and located in L zone, Dwarka, Delhi. The reliefs sought by the Complainant include refund of the deposit with interest; compensations for unfair trade practices, and for causing mental harassment and anxiety; reimbursement of legal expenses; and interim compensation to be subsequently adjusted against the total refundable amount.

2.

Brief facts of the case as mentioned by the Complainant in his application on filed on 19 September 2018 in Form 'M' before the Authority are that the Complainant had approached M/s. Antriksh Developers & Promoters Pvt. Ltd. in the year 2015 for booking an apartment with a super area admeasuring 1600 sq. feet in a project 'Antriksh Urban Greek' and paid an amount of Rs.9,53,000/- (Rupees nine lakh fifty three thousand only) in more than one installments; that the application form for booking the apartment was signed and received by the Complainant on 5 June 2015; that as per the information of the Complainant the opposite party was not able to obtain any licenses and approvals from the concerned authorities for constructing the project in question; that the opposite party has failed to deliver the apartment or to refund the amount paid despite several successive efforts; that the Complainant had been cheated and defrauded by the opposite party, who had misappropriated the money and not offered possession of the apartment; and that the construction of the apartment or the project had not even commenced after more than three years after its date of booking. Based on the averments, the Complainant sought reliefs in terms of refund of the amount of Rs.9,53,000/- (Rupees nine lakh fifty three thousand only) paid by him to the opposite party along with 24% interest compounded quarterly; a sum of Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees five lakh only) as compensation for unfair trade practices; a sum of Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees five lakh only) as compensation for causing mental harassment and anxiety; and, a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh only) as reimbursement of legal expenses The Complainant further sought an interim relief of Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees five lakh only) as interim compensation which amount may be adjusted against the finally determined refundable amount.

3.

The complaint was brought before the Authority on 28 November 2018 when the Authority considered it necessary to first hear the Complainant in the interest of justice. A notice was accordingly issued to the Complainant to appear before the Authority on 12 December 2018 on which date, after hearing the Complainant, the Authority directed that a notice may be issued to the Respondent. On the following hearing on 2 January 2019, the Respondent did not appear and the Complainant filed some additional documents comprising a blank Memorandum of Understanding that carried the insignia of Antriksh Group and Urban Greek (the MoU also contained all the terms and conditions and specifications of the apartment offered by the Promoter in the project ‘Antriksh Urban Greek’) and a copy of the advertisement published on the website of the Antriksh group wherein a registration number issued by the Real Estate Regulatory Authority of Uttar Pradesh (UPRERA) had been quoted giving an incorrect impression in the public that the project Urban Greek was registered under the provision of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. The documents were taken on record, and the case was adjourned with directions to issue a fresh notice to the Respondent, M/s. Antriksh Developers & Promoters Ltd.

4.

On the next two hearing held on 30 January and 27 February 2019, the Respondent sought adjournment for filing a detailed reply and on the subsequent next hearing on 27 March 2019, the Counsels for M/s. Antriksh Developers & Promoters Ltd. while filing their Vakalatnama submitted that the project had been promoted by M/s Antriksh Engicon Pvt. Ltd. and not by M/s. Antriksh Developers & Promoters Pvt. Ltd., though both the companies were part of the Antriksh Group. The Complainant sought time to file an amendment to the application which he did file on the next hearing on 1 May 2019, where-after the Respondent sought time to file a reply to the amended complaint. However, no one appeared for the Respondent at the next hearing on 29 May 2019 and instead an email message was sent saying that an amicable settlement with the Complainant was under consideration. On the Complainant denying any awareness of any such attempt at amicable settlement between the two sides, a last opportunity was granted to the Respondent to file a reply.

5.

In its reply, which was finally filed on 13 June 2019, M/s Antriksh Engicon Pvt. Ltd. (hereinafter called the Respondent) submitted that the Respondent had been in the business of construction and development of projects for more than a decade and had successfully delivered projects in the National Capital Region; that it was currently developing several other projects that were nearing completion; that in the year 2015 it had launched a project by the name of Urban Greek wherein the Complainant approached the Respondent for booking a residential apartment out of his own free will; that the Respondent had every intention to develop the project but owing to Government's policies and administrative procedures which were beyond its control, the Respondent had not been able to obtain the Land Transfer Certificate which was a pre-requisite for developing the project; that the Respondent upon realizing a delay in execution of the project had given an option to all existing 'investors' to either stay invested and await the requisite clearances from the competent authority, or in the alternate to opt for a refund; that at the relevant point the Complainant had opted to stay invested and did not opt for a refund; that the Complainant has deployed extortive tactics to extract large sums of money from the Respondent; that the Respondent has accepted cheque payments from the Complainant and has issued receipts upon receiving such payments indicating the bonafides of the Respondent; that the Respondent was amenable to a settlement; that at no point in time had the Respondent cheated or had any intention to cheat any person including the Complainant; and confirmed that an initial payment of Rs.9,53,000/- (Rupees nine lakh fifty three thousand only) had been received by the Respondent from the Complainant in the year 2015. Along with its reply, the Respondent also filed three documents (a blank application form, a copy of Delhi Development Authority Land policy and a copy of a news item relating to approval of Housing Ministry to the Land Pooling Policy) and submitted that the terms and conditions mentioned in the booking formed a part and parcel of the reply filed by the Respondent.

6.

Upon being confronted with the query relating to the advertisement appearing on their website where the project Urban Greek was shown to have been registered with UPRERA, and to which allegation the Respondent had not responded specifically in its reply, the Counsel for the Respondent requested for time to file an affidavit on the issue, which affidavit was subsequently filed on 26 June 2019. In the Affidavit the Respondent submitted that it had not published nor circulated any erroneous information and that the Respondent was not aware of the source of the advertisement in which a registration number issued by UPRERA had been mentioned; that the Respondent was not able to access the website source or obtain a physical copy of such an advertisement; that upon getting cogent information with regard to such advertisement the Respondent will initiate necessary legal action against the offenders; and, requested that the Complainant may be directed to produce the original copies along with source of such advertisement in order that the real offender could be brought to book in accordance with the law. In its reply to the averments made by the Respondent in the above affidavit, the Complainant reiterated that the registration number UPRERAAGT10087 has been quoted in their website where details of Antriksh Urban Greek, Dwarka, Delhi had been mentioned and submitted copies of printouts from the website http://www.antrikshurbangreek.org.

7.

On subsequent successive dates of hearings on 17 July, 31 July, 19 August and 26 August 2019, the Respondent sought adjournments on one pretext or the other despite clear directions by the Authority that no further adjournment will be granted on any ground. The Authority took a serious note of the delaying tactics adopted by the Respondent and in allowing a short adjournment on 19 August 2019, it imposed a burden of a cost of Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand only) on the Respondent. On the following date of hearing again a Proxy Counsel appeared on behalf of the Respondent and sought to file an application under Section 151 CPC for waiver of the cost imposed on the Respondent and made yet another request for adjournment on the plea of ill-health of the main Counsel without adducing any evidence such as a medical certificate despite the Counsel for the Complainant having brought to the notice of the Authority that the Counsel for the Respondent had been seen appearing in other cases before other fora while seeking adjournments on the plea of ill-health before this Authority. The pattern of delaying tactics and successive attempts by the Respondent to obtain adjournments on some pretext or the other having now become clear, the Authority proceeded with hearing the matter in order to decide the case on the basis of records available on the case-file.

8.

Upon examination of the various pleadings, arguments, submissions and documents filed by the Complainant and the Respondent, the following points emerged:-

(a)

The Complainant submits and the Respondent admits that the project by the name 'Antriksh Urban Greek' was promoted by the Respondent in the year 2015;

(b)

The Complainant submits and the Respondent admits that the Complainant had booked an apartment in the said project and paid as deposit a sum of Rs.9,53,000/- (Rupees nine lakh fifty three thousand only) on 5 June 2015;

(c)

The Complainant submits and the Respondent admits that there has been no progress at all in the construction of the said project as the Respondent has not been able to obtain the necessary approvals and sanctions of various authorities, which the Respondent claimed were beyond its control;

(d)

The Respondent claims that upon realizing that a delay in execution of the project was inevitable, it had offered all such persons who had booked apartment in this project to either continue with the project until the project was completed or to opt for a refund; and further claims that the Complainant had at the relevant point in time not opted for a refund;

(e)

Both the Complainant and the Respondent have furnished, along with their pleadings, copies of blank application forms, blank MoU and details relating to the transactions. Clause 20 of the terms and conditions as laid down on the Application Form stipulates that if the NOC/sanction plans for commencement of construction of the said housing complex is not obtained by the first party (the Respondent) within three years from the date of this application form then the company (the Respondent) shall be liable to the refund of amounts received with an interest @ 6.99% per annum;

(f)

The Respondent claims that it has accepted cheque payments from the Complainant against receipts and that it has been amenable to settling the case and has relied on the terms and conditions included in the booking form for this purpose.

9.

In addition to the above points relating to the present dispute between the Complainant and the Respondent which is under consideration of the Authority, two more issues emerged that merit consideration; namely, i) whether the Respondent was in violation of the provisions of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 by not registering, within the prescribed time frame, the said project (Antriksh Urban Greek) as an ongoing project particularly as the said project was admittedly promoted in the year 2015 and had not been completed as on the date of coming into force of the relevant provisions of the Act, and ii) whether by the alleged publication of an advertisement on its website or elsewhere relating to its project the Antriksh Urban Greek, the Respondent was in violation of the provisions of the Act by projecting an inaccurate and inapplicable registration number granted by UPRERA to another project and thereby giving false and incorrect information to the prospective home buyers. These two issues may be examined by Secretary of the Authority and a suitable action may separately be proposed in an existing or a new case to be instituted against the Respondent appropriately.

10.

In view of the facts and circumstances of the complaint, we have no hesitation to hold that the Complainant is entitled to a refund of the amount of Rs.9,53,000/- (Rupees nine lakh fifty three thousand only) deposited by him, along with interest @ 6.99% per annum in accordance with the terms and conditions referred to both by the Complainant and the Respondent. The Respondent is directed to pay the above amount and interest from the date of receipt of each such amount until the date of full payment to the Respondent and further direct that the Respondent shall pay this entire amount within a period of 45 days of this Order.

11.

With regard to the claim made by the Complainant for payment of interest@ 24% compounded quarterly, we hold that any interest beyond that ordered in the preceding para (para 10) would squarely lie in the realm of compensation and this claim along with other reliefs sought by the Complainant such as compensation for unfair trade practices; compensation for causing mental harassment and anxiety; and, reimbursement of legal expenses may be agitated by him before the Adjudicating Officer in accordance with the provisions of Section 71(1) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 by filing such claims in the prescribed Form 'N'. The Complainant shall be at liberty to file such claims for compensation at an appropriate time.