AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
K. V. Jayakumar, J.
This writ petition is instituted to quash Ext. P13 order of the Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board. The petitioner also seeks to quash Ext. P9 decision taken by the Area Committee constituted by the 3rd respondent, Assistant Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board.
The petitioner, Pavithran P.V., states that he is a devotee of Kanathoor Sree Maha Vishnu Temple, Pallikunnu (for the sake of brevity, ‘the Temple’). The said Temple was notified as a public religious institution, coming under the Madras Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1951 (for the sake of brevity, ‘the HR & CE Act’). The administration of the Temple is vested with the committee of five non-hereditary trustees.
The petitioner contended that the 3rd respondent issued Ext. P1 notification dated 19.02.2025 inviting applications from the eligible candidates for the appointment to the post of trustees in the Temple. As per clause 5(2) of the said notification, those who are active politicians are disqualified from applying for the post of non-hereditary trustee.
The petitioner herein has obtained a list of candidates who submitted applications to the said post. He has placed on record a true copy of the list of candidates as Ext.P2. The petitioner contends that the 5th respondent, Jayakrishnan P.K., is an active member of the Communist Party of India [CPI(M)] and he is the Branch Secretary of the said political party. His election as the Branch Secretary of the CPI(M) was reported in a daily newspaper on 28.09.2024. The petitioner has placed on record the true copy of the said newspaper report as Ext. P3.
He has also produced some photographs showing the involvement of the 5th respondent in the political events. Therefore, the petitioner and other devotees submitted Ext. P5 complaint to the Commissioner. The petitioner and 7 others appeared before the Inspector, Thalassery Division and filed a statement seeking the disqualification of the 5th respondent due to his political activities.
According to the petitioner, despite the complaint and the objections, the 5th respondent was appointed as the Chairman of the Trustee Board of the Temple vide Ext.P8 order dated 10.07.2025. The appointment of the 5th respondent is based on Ext. P9 decision of the Area Committee dated 05.07.2025.
Thereafter, the petitioner submitted a petition before the 1st respondent, Commissioner, challenging Ext.P8 order and Ext.P9 decision, seeking to set aside the same and to conduct a de novo selection pursuant to Ext.P1 notification. Ext.P11 is a copy of the said petition.
According to the petitioner, the 1st respondent has refused to consider Ext. P11 petition in a time-bound manner. Therefore, the petitioner filed W.P.(C) No. 36505 of 2025 seeking to quash Ext. P8 order and to dispose of Ext. P11 petition. This Court, by Ext. P12 judgment dated 07.10.2025, directed the Commissioner to consider and dispose of Ext. P11 petition, in the light of the observations made by this Court in K. Chathu Achan v. State of Kerala1 and Gopinatha Menon (Kenathachan) v. Malabar Devaswom Board2.
The Commissioner, by Ext. P13 order rejected Ext. P11 petition filed by the petitioner. It is in the afore context that the petitioner has approached this Court seeking the following reliefs:
1.Issue a writ of certiorari or such other appropriate writ, order or direction to quash Exhibit P13 order issued by the 1st respondent after calling for the records related to the same.
2.Issue a writ of certiorari or such other appropriate writ, order or direction to quash Exhibit P9 decision taken as per the resolution no:220 dated 05/07/2025 of the Area Committee constituted by the 3rd respondent and after calling for the records related to the same from the office of the 3rd respondent.
3.Issue a writ of mandamus or such other appropriate writ, order or direction to the 1st respondent to hold fresh appointment to the post of non-hereditary trustees to the Kanathoor Shri Maha Vishnu Temple, Pallikunnu, Kannur based on Exhibit P1.
The 2nd respondent, Malabar Devaswom Board, has placed on record a counter statement contending that the 5th respondent had worked as a non-hereditary trustee of the Temple for two terms of two years each from 2022 to 2026. The writ petition is preferred on the basis of a newspaper report published in Deshabhimani daily dated 28.09.2024. There was no complaint at the time of his first appointment and thereafter during his tenure. The petitioner has not invoked Section 45 of the Act, seeking the removal of the trustee.
It is further stated in the statement that though the petitioner has produced a copy of the newspaper report, a printout of E-paper and photocopies of screenshots from WhatsApp, the petitioner has failed to prove the involvement of the 5th respondent in politics. It is further contended that the petitioner did not mount to the box to give evidence about the allegations.
The 5th respondent has filed a counter affidavit refuting the allegations stated in the writ petition. He denied that he is an active member of CPI(M) and the branch Secretary of that political party. He denied the news report published in the Deshabhimani daily on 28.09.2024. It is further contended that, as per section 39(4) of the HR& CE Act, an application to set aside the appointment of a non-hereditary trustee is to be filed within 30 days from the date of the order. The petitioner submitted the application only on 25.08.2025.
Sri. M. K. Sumod, the learned counsel for the petitioner, submitted that Ext. P13 order was passed by the Commissioner in total disregard of the law laid down in Chathu Achan (supra). According to the learned counsel, the Commissioner ought to have held that the 5th respondent is disqualified from being appointed as the non-hereditary trustee of the temple. The 5th respondent is an active politician and branch Secretary of a political party. The learned counsel would point out that Ext. P13 order was passed without adverting to the contentions advanced by the petitioner.
We have heard the submissions of Sri. M. K. Sumod, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, Smt. R. Ranjanie, the learned Standing Counsel appearing for the Malabar Devaswom Board, and Sri. P.U. Shailajan, the learned counsel appearing for the 5th respondent.
We have carefully considered the submissions advanced and perused the materials placed on record.
The principal contention of the petitioner is that the 5th respondent, Jayakrishnan, is an active worker and office bearer of a political party. In order to substantiate this fact, he relied on the photocopies of certain newspaper reports, photographs and e-paper reports. The 5th respondent has denied his involvement in political activities.
We find from Ext.P.13 order that the petitioner did not mount into the box or file an affidavit in support of the allegations. In view of the specific denial of the allegations of political affiliation by the 5th respondent, it is for the petitioner to prove the said allegations by adducing proper evidence, oral or documentary. The petitioner did not choose to give oral evidence before the Commissioner. He has not made any efforts to summon the necessary documents from the appropriate authorities to substantiate his contentions. It is pertinent to note that the 5th respondent was appointed as the non-hereditary trustee in 2022 and 2024. Furthermore, as per Section 39(4) of the HR & CE Act, the time prescribed for setting aside an order appointing a non-hereditary trustee is 30 days. No such application was filed in the instant case seeking to set aside or modify the order of the Commissioner.
An order passed by the Commissioner is revisable under Section 99 of the HR & CE Act. The petitioner did not opt to prefer such a revision under Section 99 of the Act.
On careful consideration of Ext. P13 order, we do not find any illegality or arbitrariness in the order. The writ petition lacks merits, and it is liable to be dismissed.
The writ petition is dismissed.
