AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
P.Somarajan, J
It is so unfortunate that the learned Magistrate did not even understand the legal position laid down by the Apex Court in Bir Singh v. Mukesh
Kumar [AIR 2019 SC 2446], so as to observe that when signature affixed in the cheque is admitted, it is immaterial in whose handwriting the entries were filled up. The expression execution stands for execution of a document with the intention to give legal validity and enforceability to the document so executed and mere admission of the signature in the cheque alone will not suffice and it was settled by a catena of decisions rendered by the Apex
Court as well as this Court. The initial burden to prove due execution of the cheque always would stand with the complainant and when signature is
admitted, the burden lies on the complainant would be less onerous. That doesn't mean that it would ipso facto prove the due execution of the
document. The observation made by the learned Magistrate in paragraph 6 of the impugned order, hence, cannot be sustained.
The application is submitted for sending the disputed handwriting for expert opinion and it is neither permissible nor advisable to deny the valuable
right to adduce evidence by obtaining expert opinion under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act, unless there is warranting reason. No such warranting reason made mentioned in the order or brought to the notice of this Court, and as such, the impugned order is set aside. The order of the trial court in Ext.P4 application (CMP No.2044 of 2021) is hereby set aside and the application will stand allowed.
The parties shall appear the trial court on 05.08.2021 so as to enable the Magistrate to proceed further in the application by sending the disputed and the admitted handwriting for expert opinion.
