High CourtsSINGLE BENCH(2017) 05 KL CK 0017

OUSEPH @ JOSEPH vs DAVID

High Court Of Kerala · Decided on 23 May 2017

HON’BLE JUDGES
A.M.Babu
CASE NUMBER
2991 of 2013

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

11 paragraphs · 475 words

1.Petitioners seek to quash a private criminal prosecution initiated against them. They seek the relief under Sec.482 of Cr.P.C .

2.The 1st respondent filed a complaint against 13 persons. Annex-A1 is a copy of it. It was filed alleging commission of offences under Secs 465 and 468 of IPC . The learned magistrate took the case on file as C.C.261/2013 under Sec.465 of IPC against respondents 1 to 10 in annex-A1 complaint and issued process to them. They are the petitioners herein who are accused 1 to 10 in C.C.261/2013. Annex-A2 is the copy of the order of the magistrate on annex-A1 complaint.

3.Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners and the learned counsel for the 1st respondent. Heard the learned public prosecutor also.

4.I have carefully read annex-A1 complaint. The dispute is all about the title to a pathway. The 1st respondent in his annex-A1 complaint asserts himself to be the owner of the pathway. He claims to have purchased it under a registered sale deed.

His grievance is that the petitioners while selling their property to the persons who are arrayed in annex-A1 complaint as respondents 11 and 12 included the said pathway also. Annex-A4 is a copy of the sale deed. The dispute is purely civil in nature. There is no element of forgery in the execution of annex-A4 sale deed.

5.Civil suits between the parties are pending in two courts. Those suits are O.S.50/2004 pending before the Munsiff's Court, Kolencherry and O.S.35/2011 pending before the Sub-Court, Perumbavoor. Annex-A5 is a copy of the plaint in O.S.50/2004. That was a suit filed by the 1st respondent against petitioners 1 to 3 and another.

The 1st respondent sought transfer of O.S.50/2004 to the Sub-Court, Perumbavoor for joint trial with O.S.35/2011. Annex-A6 is a copy of the application filed by the 1st respondent to stay the proceedings in O.S.50/2004 till the disposal of the transfer petition. The subject-matter in both the suits is the pathway referred to above. The 1st respondent himself stated so in his annex-A6 application.

Civil litigations are pending between the parties and the dispute between them is purely civil in nature. No criminal court has any role in deciding such a dispute.

6.The only argument the learned counsel for the 1st respondent could raise was that the pathway was owned by the 1st respondent. That itself is a disputed fact which is to be decided by the civil

court. Civil suits are pending to decide the dispute. Prosecuting the petitioners in a criminal court in respect of a purely civil dispute does amount to abuse of the process of the court. Such a criminal prosecution is liable to be quashed.

7.The Criminal miscellaneous case is allowed. All proceedings against the petitioners in C.C.261/2013 on the file of the court of the judicial magistrate of the first class, Kolencherry stand quashed.