AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
HARSH BUNGER J. (Oral)
For convenience, the parties herein are being addressed as per their status in the original suit.
This is plaintiffs' regular second appeal challenging the judgment and decree dated 24.03.2026 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Palwal.
Briefly, the plaintiff (Nripender Singh) filed a suit for possession by way of specific performance of an agreement to sell dated 30.05.2016 on the plea that the defendant (Moti Ram) is the owner in possession of land measuring 4 kanal - 0 marla (being 80/130th share out of total land measuring 6 kanal - 10 marla) comprising in khewat number 400, situated at village Meesa, Tehsil and District Palwal. It was stated that the said property was mortgaged with Sarva Haryana Gramin Bank, Branch Chandhat.
It is the case of the plaintiff that the defendant entered into an agreement to sell dated 30.05.2016 in respect of the aforesaid property for a total sale consideration of Rs.10,00,000/- and an amount of Rs. 3,42,000/-was given by the plaintiff to the defendant in the presence of witnesses as earnest money on 30.05.2016 itself. According to the plaintiff, the target date for execution of the sale deed was fixed as 30.05.2017 after receiving balance sale consideration of Rs. 6,58,000/-.
Plaintiff averred that before the date of execution of the sale deed i.e. 30.05.2017, plaintiff made an oral request to the defendant to execute sale deed in his favour after receiving the balance sale consideration and on 30.05.2017 he went to the office of Sub-Registrar, Palwal, along with the balance sale consideration, stamp expenses and other expenses and kept on waiting for the defendant, but he did not turn up. Thereafter, the plaintiff is stated to have made several requests to the defendant for executing sale deed in his favour, but the defendant replied that the land has not been redeemed. It is pleaded that plaintiff made several requests to the defendant to execute the sale deed after redeeming the suit property, but to no avail.
The plaintiff is stated to have got issued a legal notice dated 11.09.2018 to the defendant but he did not execute the sale deed. It was averred that the plaintiff was and is still ready and willing to perform his part of the contract. Accordingly, the suit was filed.
Upon issuance of notice of the suit, the defendant appeared in the suit and filed his written statement taking various preliminary objections. On merits, the defendant admitted his ownership and possession of the suit property, however, he denied having entered into any agreement to sell with the plaintiff. Defendant stated that he had borrowed a sum of Rs.2,57,500/-from plaintiff in the month of June, 2014 and in order to ensure repayment of the borrowed amount, the plaintiff had obtained signatures/thumb impressions of defendant on some blank papers on the premise of security for repayment of loan. Defendant averred that on 01.01.2016, he made payment of Rs.44,000/- to the plaintiff and accounts were settled between the parties and it transpired that an amount of Rs.2,75,500/- remained due to be paid to the plaintiff. According to the defendant, it was agreed that he will make payment of Rs.66,000/- as interest (up to 30.05.2017) on amount of Rs.2,75,500/- which was outstanding towards the defendant. Defendant further averred that the accounts were given in writing by the plaintiff to him and in the month of May, 2016, plaintiff again obtained signatures/thumb impressions of defendant on some blank papers on the pretext that the papers which were got signed/thumb-marked earlier were not traceable and fresh signatures/thumb impressions were required for security of repayment of loan amount.
It is the case of the defendant that in the month of May, 2017, he repaid entire borrowed amount in the presence of respectables of the community and no amount is outstanding towards the defendant. According to the defendant, the plaintiff in order to grab the land of the defendant, has converted those papers to agreement to sell, whereas the defendant is a marginal farmer and suit property is his only source of livelihood and that great hardship would be caused to him. It was further averred that the value of 4 kanal land in village Meesa is more than Rs.50,00,000/- and that the plaintiff has put forth a false and concocted story as he never executed any agreement to sell in favour of the plaintiff. Other averments of the suit were denied and prayer for dismissal of the suit was made.
From the pleadings of the parties, the learned Trial Court framed the following issues:-
“1.Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the decree of possession, as prayed for, on the grounds mentioned in the plaint? OPP
2.Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief of specific performance of the agreement dated 30.05.2016 by way of execution and registration of sale deed, as prayed for, on the grounds mentioned in the plaint? OPP
3.Whether the suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable? OPD
4.Whether the plaintiff has no locus-standi and no cause of action to file the present suit? OPD
5.Whether the plaintiff is estopped by his own acts and conduct and omissions to file the present suit? OPD
6.Whether the suit of the plaintiff is false, frivolous and malafide? OPD
7.Whether the suit of the plaintiff has harassed the defendant by filing the suit on false ground hence they are liable to be penalized under Section 35-A of CPC? OPD
8.Relief.”
Thereafter, the parties led their respective evidence on the aforesaid issues.
The learned Trial Court, upon appreciation of the matter, vide judgment and decree dated 11.04.2023, decreed the suit of the plaintiff.
Being aggrieved, defendant filed an appeal against learned Trial Court judgment and decree dated 11.04.2023 before the learned Additional District Judge, Palwal, which came to be partly allowed vide impugned judgment and decree dated 24.03.2026. Consequently, judgment and decree for specific performance and permanent injunction passed by learned Trial Court was set aside and instead a money decree has been passed in favour of plaintiff and against defendant for a sum of Rs.3,42,500/- with interest @ 9% per annum, to be calculated from 20.05.2016 till realization.
In the aforementioned circumstances, the present regular second appeal has been filed before this Court.
I have heard learned counsel appearing for the appellant and perused the paper-book with his able assistance.
The settled position of law is that the grant of relief of specific performance of contract is discretionary and is not a matter of right. The Court in deciding the proper course has to see all those host of surrounding circumstances, right from the time of agreement up till the decision, particularly ascertaining as to if the proposed vendee secured an unfair advantage over the proposed vendor when he entered into an agreement whether performance of contract would involve the defendant in some hardship which he had not foreseen. Moreover, the approach of the proposed vendee must not be found to be unclean in any manner.
The equitable discretion to grant or not to grant the relief of specific performance also depends upon the conduct of the parties. The plaintiff therefore is called upon to prove necessary ingredients so that discretion would be exercised judiciously in his favour.
In order to come to a conclusion as to if the case is a fit one for grant of a decree for specific performance of the contract, the Court has always to be circumspect and to advert its judicial attention towards the facts and circumstances of the case in hand.
In the present case, the learned Trial Court decreed the suit of the plaintiff by observing that although there were monetary transactions between the parties and the defendant failed to repay the loan amount therefore it was possible that agreement to sell was executed due to non-payment. Apparently, the conclusion drawn by the learned trial court is based upon mere possibility rather than legal proof. Merely because the defendant failed to repay the loan amount does not lead to an inference that agreement to sell was executed. The burden was upon the plaintiff to prove due execution of the agreement to sell the suit property.
It is a matter of record that in the suit, there is no reference to any monetary transactions between the parties, however the plaintiff admitted in his cross-examination that the defendant used to take financial assistance from him from time to time. He further admitted that on 01.07.2014, an agreement like the present agreement was executed for an amount of Rs. 2,57,000/- and that the said amount of Rs. 2,57,000/- formed a part of total consideration alleged in the agreement. Thus, the prior monetary transactions between the parties stand proved on record.
Further, once there was already an earlier agreement between the parties (as admitted by plaintiff in his cross-examination), the execution of second agreement in 2016 becomes doubtful, especially when it is not shown that the earlier agreement was cancelled. Rather, the plaintiff had conveniently concealed the factum of earlier agreement, which clearly points towards the conduct of the plaintiff.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of “Thiruvengada Pillai v. Navaneethammal & anr.” AIR 2008 Supreme Court 1541 held that once various circumstances taken together create a doubt about the genuineness of an agreement, burden to prove that defendant had executed the agreement would be on the plaintiff and not on the defendant to prove in the negative.
Although the learned Trial Court had decreed the suit for specific performance filed by the appellant/plaintiff, however, the learned First Appellate Court has reversed the findings vide impugned judgment and decree dated 24.03.2026 by observing as under:
“16.Now the main point for determination is whether the agreement in question was executed with the intent to sell the suit property to the plaintiff or it was executed merely as security of the loan transaction?
17.It is well settled that a civil suit is to be decided on the principle of preponderance of probabilities and not on proof beyond reasonable doubt. The court has not to examine only the documents in question, but also the surrounding circumstances and the conduct of the parties in order to ascertain the true nature and intent of the transaction. In the present case, though the plaintiff has examined PW2 Lal Chand Sharma, deed writer and PW3 Man Singh, attesting witness to prove the execution of agreement and receipt in question and they have supported his version in their testimonies. However, the admissions made by the plaintiff during his cross examination are of greater probative value, as they reveal the true nature of the transaction.
18.The plaintiff in his cross examination has admitted that defendant used to take financial assistance from him from time to time. He further admitted that on 01.07.2014, an agreement like the present agreement was executed for an amount of Rs. 2,57,000/- and that said amount of Rs.2,57,500/- formed part of total consideration allegedly paid in the present agreement. This admission of the plaintiff clearly establishes that there were prior monetary dealings between the parties.
19.Moreover, the plaintiff has failed to explain the nature and status of the earlier agreement. Once it is admitted that an earlier agreement existed between the parties, the execution of second agreement in 2016 becomes doubtful. If the earlier agreement was existing, there was no occasion or necessity for executing a fresh agreement, without enforcing or formally cancelling the earlier one. This omission on the part of the plaintiff to disclose about the earlier agreement creates a serious doubt regarding the genuineness of the subsequent agreement.
20.Further, it is admitted fact that suit property was mortgaged with the bank. In such circumstances, it is highly improbable that a prudent person would first advance considerable amount in the year 2014 and thereafter, without ensuring the discharge of the mortgage, again advance further payment and enter into another agreement to purchase the same property. Such conduct is not consistent with the normal human behaviour. The plaintiff has nowhere explained as to why he continued to advance money, despite the subsisting mortgage. If the plaintiff was genuinely interested in purchasing the property, the natural conduct of a reasonable man would have been to insist upon clearance of the loan immediately before advancing any further amount. In common parlance, a man of reasonable prudence would not advance additional money when the property itself was under mortgage and the vendor had not discharged the liability. However, in the present case, instead of demanding immediate clearance of loan from the defendant, the plaintiff paid him additional money and executed fresh agreement. No oral or documentary evidence has still been placed on file to show that the said loan had been cleared. This improbable behaviour of the plaintiff further creates doubt regarding genuineness of the sale transaction.
21.Further, trial court has observed in the impugned judgment that although there were monetary transaction between the parties, the defendant failed to repay the loan amount and therefore, it was possible that agreement to sell was executed due to non payment. The conclusion drawn by the trial court is based on mere possibility, rather than legal proof. This approach of the trial court is legally untenable as mere failure of the defendant to prove repayment of loan amount does not lead to inference that an agreement to sell immovable property was executed. The burden of proof squarely lies upon the plaintiff to establish the execution of agreement and payment of consideration amount and this burden can not be shifted on the defendant merely because he failed to prove the repayment of borrowed amount. Even if it is assumed that the borrowed amount remained to be paid, then also it would not automatically result in agreement to sell immovable property. In absence of any convincing evidence to show that the alleged agreement was a consequence of failure to repay the loan amount, conclusion drawn by the trial court cannot be accepted.
22.Further, the trial court appears to have proceeded on admission of his signatures by the defendant himself. Mere admission of signatures does not amount to proof of valid execution of a document when the defendant has taken a consistent plea that his signatures were obtained on blank papers in lieu of loan transaction and said plea can not be discarded merely on the basis of admission of signatures without analyzing the conduct of the plaintiff which as discussed above, is itself improbable and doubts indicates the execution of agreement to sell the suit property.
23.It is well settled that the relief of specific performance is discretionary and equitable in nature. In the present case, the admission of plaintiff in cross examination, existence of prior financial dealings, unexplained execution of second agreement and the inherent improbabilities in the conduct of the plaintiff create a serious doubt about the genuineness of the transaction.
24.Accordingly, on the basis of above discussion, it can be said that the version of defendant/ appellant appears to be more probable that the agreement in question was executed as security of loan amount and not with intention to sell the suit property and the trial court has erred in granting the decree of specific performance and permanent injunction in favour of plaintiff, without ascertaining the true nature of the transaction.
25.Nevertheless, the defendant had admitted in his written statement that he has taken a loan of Rs.2,57,500/- from the plaintiff in June 2014. It is also admitted in written statement that an amount of Rs.3,41,500/- including interest was due towards the plaintiff upto 30.05.2017. The receipt i.e. Ex.P2, on which the defendant has admitted his signatures when he appeared in the witness box as DW1, shows receiving of payment of Rs.3,42,000/- by the defendant from the plaintiff. No cogent oral or documentary evidence has been placed on file by the defendant, so as to show that he had repaid the loan amount to the plaintiff. DW2 Dharambir has stated that entire borrowed amount was repaid by the defendant, however, except his oral testimony, there is nothing on record to suggest that any amount was repaid by the defendant to the plaintiff. The alleged repayment is not supported by any written receipt or bill or independent corroboration. Therefore, when the existence of prior financial transactions between the parties has been admitted and the defendant himself admitted borrowing money from the plaintiff, then the plea taken by the defendant that no amount is due towards the plaintiff can not be accepted.
26.In view of the above discussion, it is held that the decree for specific performance can not be granted to the plaintiff, but the plaintiff is entitled to the recovery of amount i.e. Rs.3,42,500/- alongwith interest. Consequently, the appeal is partly allowed. The judgment and decree passed by the trial court granting specific performance and permanent injunction is hereby set-aside. Instead a money decree is passed in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant for a sum of Rs.3,42,500/- with interest at the rate of 9% per annum which is to be calculated from 30.5.2016, till its realization.”
Having considered the matter in its entirely, I am of the considered view that in the attending circumstances, the findings returned by the learned first appellate court are based upon proper appreciation of facts, pleadings as well as evidence available on record. Learned counsel for the appellant has failed to show as to how the findings of the learned First Appellate Court are either illegal or perverse or based upon any misreading or misappreciation of material evidence on record. No question of law, much less any substantial question of law arises for consideration by this court in the present appeal.
Resultantly, the instant regular second appeal fails and the same is accordingly, dismissed.
All the pending application(s), if any, shall also stand closed.
