AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Harsimran Singh Sethi, J. (Oral)
CM-8411-LPA-2025
As prayed for, application if allowed.
LPA-1985-2019
In the present appeal, the challenge is to the order dated 08.07.2019 passed by the learned Single Judge of this Court in CWP-10108-2017 wherein, the Haryana Revenue Patwaris (Group-C) Service Rules, 1981 (hereinafter referred to as ‘1981 Rules) have been interpreted to mean that the merit list which has been prepared by the Subordinate Service Selection Board, Haryana (for short, ‘the Board’) while recommending the candidate to be selected and sent for training, has to be taken into account as a merit and not the merit which a candidate obtained in the training so as to supersede the selected candidates and maintain the inter-se seniority between the selected candidates.
Learned Senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant argues that the view taken by the learned single judge is contrary to 1981 Rules and therefore, the same is liable to be set aside.
Learned Senior counsel for the appellant further argues that as per 1981 rules, as amended in the year 2011, Rule 10(1) which deals with the Patwari training, does not envisage any merit, though, such candidates are to be recommended by the Board to the Director for sending them to the Patwar school for training.
Learned Senior counsel for the appellant further submits that once the candidates who have passed the Patwar training course, the word merit has been envisaged in section 10(2) and therefore, such word merit has to relate to the merit obtained in the Patwar training school ignoring the initial merit prepared by the Board while recommending the candidates. Learned Senior counsel for the appellant further submits that the recommendation has to be made based upon such merit obtained by a candidate in the Patwar school and therefore, the view taken by the learned single judge that the merit initially obtained and prepared by the Board is to prevail over any merit if any, prepared by the Patwar school course to decide inter-se seniority of direct recruits in a batch is perverse to the actual intention of the rule.
We have heard the learned Senior counsel for the appellant and have gone through the record with his able assistance
It may be noticed that the posts are advertised upon a requisition by the administrative department wherein, the candidates who are recruited as Patwaris undergo a selection process. On the basis of the competitive selection process, a merit is prepared by the Board after which, the successful candidates are recommended to the Director Land Records, Haryana for sending them to the Patwar training course. The Patwar training course is a training which is given to the candidates in order to make them understand what is the job profiles of the post in question and the candidates who clear the same, are ultimately appointed to the service. Once, the Board prepares a merit list on the basis of which the candidates are sent to the Patwar training course, it cannot be said that any merit prepared by the Director while undertaking the training, will supersede the merit prepared by the Board so as to seek the appointment as well as the consequent seniority.
The training is given to ensure that the candidate fulfills the requisite of performing the duties keeping in view the job profile. Any candidate who fails in the training, will be ousted from appointment but that does not mean that the candidate's initial merit prepared by the Board while recommending them to the Director for undergoing the training for appointment as a Patwari is of no consequence in case said candidate clears the training rather, the merit is to be prepared afresh based upon the performance of a candidate in the “training” so as to completely whitewash the initial merit of a candidate prepared by the Board.
Further, the seniority rule governs the issue is also very essential to keep in mind, which is as under:-
“15.Seniority-Seniority, inter se of members of service shall be determined by the length of continuous service on any post in the Service:
Provided that where there are different cadres in the Service, the seniority shall be determined separately for each cadre;
Provided further that in the case of members appointed by direct recruitment, the order of merit determined by the Board, shall not be disturbed in fixing the seniority;
XX XX
16.Seniority, inter se of the members of the Service shall be determined by the length of continuous service on any post in the Service;
Provided that where there are different cadres in the Service, the seniority shall be determined separately for each cadre;
Provided further that in the case of members appointed by direct recruitment, the order of merit determined by the Commission shall not be disturbed in fixing the seniority:"
A perusal of the above seniority rule would show that in the seniority list, it has been mentioned that in the case of members appointed by direct recruitment, the order of merit prepared by the Board/Commission shall not be disturbed while fixing the inter se seniority which is conceded by the learned Senior counsel.
It may be noticed that in case the argument raised by the learned Senior counsel for the appellant is accepted, the seniority prepared by the Board will be disturbed. That being so, the argument raised by the learned Senior counsel for the appellant that the seniority based upon the merit prepared while undergoing the training is the relevant merit to be taken into account for fixing the inter se seniority of a particular batch directly recruited, if accepted, will go contrary to the Rule-15 which deals with the seniority. Hence, the harmonious reading has to be given to both the rules to achieve the purpose and such harmonious reading can only be given in case, the initial merit prepared by the Board by which the candidates are recommended for undergoing the Patwar training course so as to give the appointment in case they clear the same is to be govern the inter-se seniority, has rightly been done by the learned single judge while interpretig the 1981 Rules as amended in the year 2011.
No other argument has been raised.
Keeping in view the facts and circumstances recorded hereinbefore, no ground for interference by this Court is made out and the appeal is accordingly dismissed.
Civil miscellaneous application pending, if any, is also disposed of.
