High CourtsSingle Bench(2026) 09 BOM CK 7471

Narayan Kolhe vs State Of Maharashtra

Bombay High Court, Aurangabad Bench · Decided on 9 September 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
Sushil M. Ghodeswar, J
RESULT
Allowed
CASE NUMBER
Criminal Appeal No.554 of 2001 With Criminal Application No.2256 of 2021

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

29 paragraphs · 2,488 words
1.

Appellant is challenging the judgment and order dated 11/12/2001, passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Aurangabad, in Sessions Case No.10/2001, whereby he came to be convicted for the offence punishable under Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for seven years and to pay a fine of Rs.500/-, in default, to suffer rigorous imprisonment for one month.

2.

The brief facts of the case are as under: Prosecutrix, wife of Ashok, lodged First Information Report bearing C.R. No.54/2000 at Sillod Gramin Police Station, Dist. Aurangabad. As per the report, after marriage, she started residing with her husband, parents-in-law, and sister-in-law at village Kegaon. Her mother-in-law allegedly had gone to village Chincholi on 17/04/2000 to attend a marriage. After dinner, the prosecutrix went to the inner room to sleep after bolting the door from inside. At about 1:00 to 1:30 a.m. on 18/04/2000, the accused/her father-in-law entered the room by unbolting the door and committed a rape on her. As per the said report, the police registered the offence punishable under Section 376 of the IPC and arrested the appellant-accused on 29/04/2000. After completing the investigation, charge-sheet was filed and the case was committed to the Sessions Court, Aurangabad. The case came to be registered as Sessions Case No.10/2001. The learned Sessions Judge framed the charge under Section 376 and 506 of the IPC against the appellant-accused, to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.

3.

The prosecution, in order to prove its case, examined five witnesses. After recording the evidence of the said witnesses and hearing the arguments of the parties, the learned Sessions Court convicted the appellant-accused for the offence punishable under Section 376 of the IPC and sentenced him as aforesaid, however, acquitted him under Section 506 of the Indian Penal Code.

4.

Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment, the appellant-accused has approached this Court by filing an instant criminal appeal.

Heard Ms. Vidya Raut, learned Advocate (appointed) the appellant and learned APP Ms Gunjal for respondent/State.

5.

Learned Advocate Ms Raut for the appellant submits that the prosecution has miserably failed to prove the charges against the appellant-accused. She then submits that the prosecutrix had admitted in her cross-examination that her matrimonial house has two rooms which are adjacent to each other and there is opening between the rooms and has no door. She had also admitted that at the relevant time, her sister-in-law was sleeping in the adjoining room. She also stated that she woke up and shouted when her father-in-law entered her room and committed alleged incident, adding that the said incident lasted for about half an hour. Thus, according to learned Advocate for appellant, the entire story of the prosecutrix is completely unbelievable, especially since her sister-in-law was sleeping in the adjacent room and could have heard everything as regards alleged incident.

6.

Learned Advocate for the appellant then submits that the entire case of the prosecution collapses because the prosecutrix’s story is full of contradictions, and completely disapproved by the medical and forensic evidence on record. In this regard, she submits that, during cross-examination, the prosecutrix alleged that she resisted the assault and scratched the accused with her nails, causing noticeable scratch marks on his hand, however, the official medical examination report of the accused reveals an absolute absence of any corresponding scratch marks, abrasions, or injuries. The Chemical Analyst (C.A.) report notes an absolute absence of blood on the prosecutrix's nail clippings. She, therefore, submits that had the prosecutrix physically resisted and scratched the accused as claimed, blood or biological material would inevitably be present. The negative C.A. report entirely disproves her claim of a physical struggle. Thus, the material contradiction proves that the physical resistance alleged by the prosecutrix is a manufactured afterthought, severally undermining her credibility. She then submits that the C.A. report notes a complete absence of blood or semen stains on the prosecutrix’s clothes. In an alleged incident, the total absence of biological stains on the victim’s clothes strongly points to the innocence of the appellant and shows that no such incident occurred.

7.

Learned Advocate for the appellant then submits that, the learned Sessions Court did not take into account the inordinate delay caused in filing the First Information Report. The story put forth by the prosecution as regards commission of the crime is highly improbable. The prosecutrix allegedly had filed the First Information Report on the say of her uncles, and there is a delay of almost 10 days in registering the crime. The explanation for delay provided by the prosecutrix was that she was prevented from leaving the house. Furthermore, whenever she did go out, her sister-in-law’s children accompanied her, and her father-in-law threatened to kill her if she disclosed the alleged incident. However, in the cross-examination, the prosecutrix admits that, after alleged incident, she was doing all household and agricultural work, and thus, she had sufficient opportunity to disclose the alleged act of the appellant to others. Thus, the delay has not been properly explained.

8.

Learned Advocate for the appellant then submits that the First Information Report (FIR) was not narrated by the prosecutrix herself. In her admission, she submits that she went to the police station accompanied by her four uncles, who informed the police about the alleged incident. The police recorded the FIR based entirely on the narration of her uncles, after which she was merely asked to put her thumb impression on the FIR. This clearly shows that the FIR is a made-up document and was created as an afterthought.

9.

Learned Advocate for the appellant then submits that The advocate for the appellant submits that the evidence of PW-2 (Vithal) does not support the prosecution's case at all. PW-2 only stated that the prosecutrix asked him to tell her parents to take her away from her in-laws' house, however, PW-2 denied that the prosecutrix ever told him that her in-laws were going to kill her. Therefore, his testimony completely fails to support her claim of receiving death threats.

10.

According to learned Advocate for the appellant, the testimonies of witnesses are highly improbable, and the same cannot be said to be truthful. Their testimonies are not corroborating each other, and as such, the conviction cannot be based upon the aforesaid quality of evidence. The learned Advocate for the appellant, therefore, prays for allowing the instant appeal by acquitting the appellant.

11.

Per contra, Ms Gunjal, learned APP for the respondent-State, vehemently opposes the instant criminal appeal and states that the impugned judgment and order passed by the learned Sessions Court is correct and proper and requires no interference at the hands of this Court. She submits that the testimony of prosecutrix as regards the alleged incident of crime, is inspiring and there is a corroboration from the other witnesses to her testimony, and as such, the same has been properly appreciated by the learned Sessions Court while convicting the appellant. She vehemently submits that even though there is no medical evidence directly connecting the accused to the offence, both the prosecutrix and appellant were sent for a medical examination after 8 to 10 days after incident. Therefore, it was impossible to obtain any medical evidence to connect the appellant to the crime. However, evidence of prosecutrix is reliable and trustworthy and the alleged incident cannot be discarded considering relationship between accused and prosecutrix. She then submits that there was no domestic harassment to the prosecutrix at inlaw’s house and therefore, there was no reason for her to lodge false complaint to implicate appellant in such a type of offence. Additionally, the prosecutrix had nothing to gain by making such an allegations against her father-in-law, especially when it risked her marriage and social status. She then submits that the appellant has committed a very serious and heinous crime against a woman. She therefore states that, no leniency can be shown towards such accused, who has been found to be guilty of the heinous crime under Section 376 of the IPC. Hence, she prays for dismissal of the instant appeal.

12.

After hearing the learned Advocate for the parties and going through the record, it is found that the prosecutrix has lodged the report on 28/04/2000. As per her report, on 18/04/2000, in the middle of the night, the appellant-accused, who is her father-in-law, came inside her room by unbolting the door by inserting his hand through the gap, and committed forcible sexual intercourse with her. The prosecution tried to prove its case on the basis of evidence of PW1/ prosecutrix; PW2/Vitthal Shenphadu Gore who is an independent witness related to the prosecutrix; PW3/Tejrao Rama Gonge, an uncle of prosecutrix; PW4/Vilas Pandurang Nikam, who is a cousin and PW5/Hemant Motiram Mankar, who was the ASI at Sillod Rural Police Station at the relevant point of time. On the basis of the these witnesses, the prosecution tried to prove the case of the prosecutrix that the appellant-accused has committed forcible sexual intercourse with the prosecutrix on 18/04/2000 by entering her room.

13.

As per the evidence of PW1/prosecutrix at Exh.9, she got married about four and a half years back. After her marriage, she started residing with her husband. Her sister-in-law, mother-in-law, and father-in-law were also residing with them. It came to be stated that, in the night of 18/04/2000, her mother-in-law had gone to some other village, and her husband was sleeping to the threshing floor. In the said night, her father-in-law entered her room in the middle of the night and slept besides her, and thereafter, he pressed her mouth and committed rape on her. On the next day, she informed her informed the incident to her husband and as well as her mother-in-law. According to her, they did not speak anything about the said incident, and on the contrary, they threatened her, if she discloses the said incident to anyone.

14.

After 8 to 10 days, she had been to one ceremony of Jawal of the son of her sister-in-law, and in that ceremony, her relative, namely, Vitthal, had come. There she gave message to said Vitthal to inform her father and uncle to take her from the said house. On next date, her uncle Bajirao and Tejrao came to her matrimonial house, and in front of them, she disclosed the incident of crime committed by her father-in-law. On that account, the father-in-law alleged to have assaulted her uncle and maternal uncle, and also scuffled with her cousin. Therefore, she went to the police station at Sillod along with her uncles and relatives and lodged the complaint.

15.

In the cross-examination, the prosecutrix has stated that when she went to police station with her two uncles and two maternal uncles. The said uncles informed police that they wanted to lodge complaint. They informed about the incident to police. Police recorded complaint as was told by her uncles and maternal uncles, and thereafter, she was asked to put her thumb impression, and from there, her uncles brought her to Aurangabad.

16.

The aforesaid piece of evidence itself goes to show that the FIR came to be lodged after a period of 10 days. There is no explanation by the prosecution, as to why the delay has been caused in registering the offence. Moreover, the FIR has been stated to have been lodged by the complainant herself on the basis of complaint given by the uncles to the police station, and she put her thumb impression. There is also no averment that whatever was written in the said complaint was read over to her. In such background, it is very difficult to consider the case of the prosecution that, on the given time, date and at a named place, the appellant had committed the crime as alleged by the prosecutrix.

17.

It is also not explained by the prosecution why the husband and the mother-in-law of the prosecutrix remained silent and failed to lodge the FIR against the appellant-accused. Moreover, the parents of the appellant-accused did not come forward to support the prosecution, instead, it was her maternal and paternal uncles who came to the spot and took her away. There is no evidence of scuffle and quarrel between the parties, and as such, the false implication of the appellant-accused in the crime cannot be ruled out.

18.

PW2/Vitthal Gore has been declared hostile, and he has not supported the case of the prosecution. The very case of the prosecutrix that she had given the message to said Vithal to inform her parents, is therefore, itself does not appear to be probable. Even in the testimony of the PW3/Tejrao Gonge, there are various omissions as regards giving the message to him by PW2/Vithal and further that there are also various omissions in the evidence of PW3/Tejrao as regards that the accused had threatened to kill the prosecutrix, if she discloses about the incident to anyone, and that the accused had come in her room in a drunken condition. He had also not stated that the accused had pushed him.

19.

With the aforesaid quality of evidence, it is very difficult to prove that the prosecution has proved the case against the appellant-accused. It is required to be seen that the sole testimony of the prosecutrix is sufficient enough to convict the accused, however, in the case in hand, particularly the filing of the FIR after the period of 10 days, and moreover, the complaint came to be filed at the behest of the uncles, i.e. relatives of the prosecutrix, itself creates doubt. Moreover, there is no corroboration from the prosecution witnesses to the testimony of the prosecutrix, and thus, the prosecution has miserably failed to prove the case against the appellant-accused. Therefore, it is not possible to hold the appellant-accused guilty of the offence punishable under Section 376 of the IPC and he is required to be acquitted from the crime bearing Crime No.54/2000. Hence, in view of the aforesaid observations, I am inclined to allow the instant appeal. Hence, the following order :-

ORDER

(I)

The appeal is allowed.

(II)

The judgment and order of conviction dated 11/12/2001, passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Aurangabad, in Sessions Case No.10/2001, convicting the appellant-accused for the offence punishable under Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), is hereby quashed and set aside.

(III)

The appellant-accused is acquitted of all the charges framed against him.

(IV)

The fine amount, if any, deposited by the appellant-accused shall be refunded to him upon proper verification.

(V)

The bail bonds and surety bonds executed by the appellant-accused, if any, stand discharged.

(V)

Record and proceedings be sent to the concerned Court.

20.

In view of disposal of criminal appeal, Criminal Application No.2256/2021 is also disposed of.

21.

Fees of learned Advocate Ms Raut, appointed to represent appellant/applicant is to be paid through the High Court Legal Services Sub-Committee, Aurangabad as per Rules.