High CourtsDivision Bench(2004) 12 MAD CK 0103

Murugan and Another vs State

Madras High Court · Decided on 6 December 2004

RESULT
Allowed
CASE NUMBER
C.A. No. 754 of 2005

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

47 paragraphs · 3,523 words

M. Chockalingam, J.—The appellants, who stood charged, tried, found guilty as per the charge of murder and awarded life sentence by the Sessions Division, Thirunelveli, have assailed the judgment of the said Court in this appeal.

2.

Short facts necessary for the disposal of this appeal can be stated thus:

(a) The first and the second accused are son and father respectively. Equally, both the deceased Irulappa Konar and Kannan are father and son respectively. All were residents of Dharmathoorani Village, Sankarankovil Taluk. They had land dispute in the past. Both the accused party and the deceased party had a common well by name Karthiga Matha Kinaru. The second accused spent his moneys for deepening the same, and for the share of the deceased Irulappa Konar, he was demanding Rs.3,850/- from him. Whenever both the deceased went over for the purpose of watering their lands, the accused were quarrelling with them, and they removed the pipelines also. On 22.5.1999, one of the deceased Irulappa Konar gave a complaint to P.W.14 Balamurugan, the Sub Inspector of Police, Chinnakovilankulam Police Station. It was taken as petition No.36/99 under Ex.P22. Both the parties were called and enquired on 24.2.1999, and it was so decided that the deceased party should pay the amount within 15 days therefrom.

(b) On the date of occurrence namely 28.5.1999, both the deceased, father and son, went to their field for watering the lands. P.W.1 Subbammal, the wife of Irulappa Konar, was to take their food in the noon. P.W.3 Chellapandi, after cutting the grass, was coming back near the said Karthigai Matha Kinaru at about 11.00 A.M.P.W.3 found both the accused quarreling with both the deceased; but, he did not pay heed to the same, as they were relations and he thought it was usual. PW.4 Iyammal, when she was crossing the said well about 50 feet away, found the first and the second accused throwing stones inside the well. She did not entertain any suspicion, but went from there P.W.5 Mookaih also saw the accused, throwing stones inside the well. On seeing P.W.5, both the accused began to run from the place. Entertaining suspicion, P.W.5 went near the well and found both the deceased namely Irulappa Konar and his son Kannan lying with injuries within the well. P.W.5 also left from the place. P.W.1 at about 12.30 P.M., took the noon meal to Irulappa Konar her husband and her son Kannan. When she came near the well, she found both her husband and her son lying in the well with injuries. Then, she called the nearby relatives and found both of them dead. Thereafter, she proceeded to Chinnakovilankulam Police Station and gave Ex.P1 report at about 12.30 P.M. on the strength of which, a case came to be registered by P.W.14 Sub Inspector of Police, under Sec. 174 of Code of Criminal Procedure. Ex.P23 First Information Report was dispatched to the Judicial Magistrate, Sankarankovil.

(c) On the receipt of the copy of the FIR, P.W.20 Samikkannu, Inspector of Police, Karivalam Vandhanallur Police Station, took up investigation, proceeded to the spot, made an inspection and prepared in Ex.P9 observation mahazar and Ex.P24 rough sketch. He recovered M.O.s.1 to 4 and 10 under a mahazar. In the presence of witnesses and panchayatdars, he conducted the inquest on the dead bodies of Irulappa Konar and his son Kannan the same day and prepared Exs.P25 and P26 inquest reports. Both the dead bodies were sent to the government Hospital, Sankarankovil along with two requisitions for conduct of autopsy.

(d) On receipt of the requisitions, P.W.13 Dr.Balakrishnan, attached to Sankarankovil Government Hospital, conducted the autopsy on the dead bodies of Irulappa Konar and Kannan and noticed the following injuries.

In respect of deceased Kannan:

Injuries: 1 (Matter in another language) 2cm x 2cm x bone deep. Fracture frontal bone left side present. Subdural haematoma present 10 cm transverse.

2) (matter in other language) x bone deep (matter in other language) fracture left parietal bone present. Subdural haematoma present. Longitudinal 7cm.

3) (matter in other language) 10cm x 2cm x bone deep (matter in other language) fracture, (matter in other language)

4) (matter in other language) fracture right frontal bone extends into right orbit.

5) (matter in other language) 2 (matter in other language) x 2 (matter in other language)

6) (matter in other language) multiple small abrasions.

7) (matter in other language)

8) (matter in other language) 2 (matter in other language) x 2 (matter in other language) x black colour.

9) (matter in other language) 2cm x 2cm x abrasion.

10) (matter in other language 1cmx 1cm x black colour."

In respect of deceased Irulappa Konar:

"Injuries : 1) (matter in other language) 2cm x 2cm x bone deep (matter in other language) Fracture right frontal bone present. Transverse 10cm x subdural haematoma present.

2) (matter in other language) 2cm x 2cm x bone deep (matter in other language) Fracture left parietal bone 13cm x longitudinal, subdural haematoma present.

3.

(matter in other language) 2cm x 2cm (matter in other language) on dissection right frontal bone fracture extends into right orbit.

4) (matter in other language) 2cm x 2cm x black colour transverse.

5.

(matter in other language) 2cm x 2cm x black colour.

6.

(matter in other language) 2cm x 2cm x black colour.

7.

(matter in other language) buttocks (matter in other language) 2cm x 2cm x black colour muscle deep.

8.

(matter in other language) 1cm x 1cm x black colour.

9.

(matter in other language) 2cm x 2cm."

The doctor has given post-mortem certificates under Ex.P17 in respect of the deceased Kannan and Ex.P20 in respect of the deceased Irulappa Konar the doctor has opined that the death would have occurred 24 to 48 hours prior to post-mortem.

(e) Pending investigation, the accused surrendered before the Judicial Magistrate, Sivagiri, on 17.6.1999. An application for police custody was filed, which was accordingly ordered. The investigating officer took custody of the accused. A-1 volunteered to give a confessional statement, the admissible portion of which is marked as Ex.P13. Pursuant to the same, he produced M.Os.8 to 10 stones, which were recovered under Ex.P14 mahazar. The investigating officer converted the case into Sec.302 I.P.C., since it has come to light pursuant to the confession made by A-1, that it was a murder. Then, amended report Ex.P27 was dispatched to the Court.

(f) When the matter was pending investigation, the Investigating Officer filed a report before the concerned Court stating that A-2 had no involvement in the crime. Hence, aggrieved over the same, P.W.1 filed a petition in Crl.O.P.No.12541/99 making allegations against the Police Officer, who conducted the investigation. This court passed an order for transferring the investigation from the hands of the said Investigating Officer to the Crime Branch. P.W.22 Krishnan, Inspector of Police Crime Branch, took up the investigation, proceeded to the spot, made an inspection and prepared Ex.P11 observation mahazar and Exs. P28 and P29 rough sketch. He recovered M.Os.5 to 7 under a mahazar. Then, he examined all the witnesses, and in particular, he recorded the statements of P.Ws.3, 4 and 5, and further, he also examined the Doctor, who conducted the post-mortem. The material objects were dispatched to Court for chemical analysis. Accordingly, they were subjected to chemical analysis, and Exs.P18 and P21 chemical analyst's reports were received by the Court. The Doctor, who conducted autopsy on the two dead bodies, has opined that both the deceased would appear to have died of head injury. On completion of the investigation, the investigating officer filed the final report alleging that it was these two accused, the appellants herein, who committed the crime of murder of both Irulappa Konar and Kannan.

3.

In order to substantiate both the charges of murder, the prosecution examined 22 witnesses and marked 29 exhibits and 12 material objects. On completion of the evidence on the side of the prosecution, the trial Court questioned both the accused under Sec.313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure as to the incriminating circumstances found in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses. They denied the case of the prosecution in entirety as false. No defense witnesses were examined; but, Exs.D1 to D3 were marked on their side at the time of questioning under Sec.313 Cr.P.C. After consideration of the rival submissions made and the scrutiny of the evidence both oral and documentary, the learned Sessions Judge found them guilty under both the charges and awarded the life imprisonment (two counts), which is being challenged before this Court.

4.

The learned Counsel appearing for the appellants inter alia made the following submissions.

(a) In order to substantiate the charges of the murders alleged to have been committed by the appellants, the prosecution relied on the evidence of P.Ws 3 to 5. On the report given by P.W.1 on the date of occurrence namely 28.5.1999 at 2.00 P.M., a case under Sec. 174 Cr.P.C. came to be registered. The investigation was taken up, and till the accused surrendered on 17.6.1999, the investigation in the case under Sec. 174, Cr.P.C. continued. No one came forward to speak anything about the complicity of the appellants.

(b) It is pertinent to point out that P.Ws.3 to 5, whose evidence was relied on by the prosecution and accepted by the lower Court, belonged to the same place, which was a small village, and the prosecution came forward with an explanation to state that these three witnesses have actually last seen the accused at the place of occurrence at or about the time of murder. But, they have not spoken anything about the occurrence or the accused for a period of five months.

(c) The case was converted into Sec.302, I.P.C. after they surrendered before the Court and pursuant to their alleged confession. At this juncture, it has to be pointed out that even after the registration of the case under Sec.302, I.P.C., these three witnesses did not come forward to speak anything about the accused. After the investigation of the case was transferred to the Crime Branch, these three witnesses were examined, and their statements have also been recorded. No convincing or acceptable explanation was forthcoming how these witnesses kept mum for a period of five months.

(d) It remains to be stated that all these three witnesses were very well available in the village throughout the day of occurrence. The crime of murder was also well within their knowledge. If to be so, the reasonable conduct of anyone would be to speak about the conduct of the accused; but in the instant case, they have not done so. In such circumstances, the lower court should not have believed the evidence of P.Ws.3 to 5, as it was artificial and interested to suit the prosecution case. In support of the said contention, the learned counsel for the appellants relied on two decisions reported in State of Orissa Vs. Mr. Brahmananda Nanda, and in Jamiruddin Molla Vs. The State and Others, .

5.

The learned Counsel would further add that originally on the basis of Ex.P1 alleged to have been given by P.W.1, a case came to be registered under Sec. 174 of Cr.P.C; that according to her evidence, she went to the Police Station and gave the second complaint under Ex.P2 on the next day, that was on 29.5.1999. A perusal of Ex.P2 would reveal that she has clearly and categorically spoken about the fact that she saw at the time of occurrence, the first and second accused running from the place of occurrence, and then, she went near the well and found the dead bodies; that if to be so, the Police Officer concerned should have converted the case into one under Sec.302 I.P.C. the very next day, but not done so, that Ex.P2 has reached the concerned court only on 4.2.2000 i.e., near about 9 months later; that no explanation was forthcoming to show how the said delay had happened; That apart from that, in the post-mortem certificates originally given, the Post-mortem Doctor has not given any final opinion, but, the final opinion was given subsequently, as if the death could have been caused by throwing of stones also; that the Doctor has also given another opinion stating that due to accidental fall such injuries could have caused also, and under the circumstances, it cannot be stated that the said opinion of the Doctor was in support of the prosecution case; that it is true that there has been evidence speaking about the previous motive between the parties; but the same cannot be taken as proof or the act of the accused is proved thereby.

6.

Added further the learned Counsel that there was a direction by this Court for transferring the investigation from the hands of the investigating officer attached to the Police Station, to the Crime Branch; that the pursuant to the same, P.Ws.3 to 5 have been introduced, and their statements have been recorded by the police in such a way to make out a case against appellants; that the lower Court has also much relied on the surrender of the accused; that surrender of an accused before a court of law cannot be taken as a proof or factor for proving their guilt; but, it may even be due to the circumstances of the fear or threat or torture in the hands of the police, and hence, the same cannot be a circumstance, which would indicate the complicity of the accused, and under such circumstances, the lower Court should not have accepted the prosecution case and should have acquitted the accused of the charges.

7.

This Court heard the learned Additional Public Prosecutor on the above contentions.

8.

This court paid its full attention on the submissions made and had a thorough scrutiny of the available materials.

9.

It is not in controversy that one Irulappa Konar and his son Kannan were found dead in a well called Karthigar Matha Kinaru on 28.5.1999. After the inquest was made by the investigating officer the post-mortem was conducted. The postmortem certificates were marked, and the final opinion has also been given later by the Doctor, who conducted the autopsy, that due to fatal injuries on the head, they have met their death. The contention of the appellants'' side that the death would not have been caused by the homicidal violence, but due to a fall in the well, cannot be accepted. In the instant case, the prosecution has got medical evidence to show before the trial Court that Irulappa Konar and his son Kannan met their death due to homicidal violence. Hence, the lower Court has correctly found that they died on account of homicidal violence.

10.

The specific case of the prosecution was that on 28.5.1999, both the accused, the appellants herein, due to prior enmity pushed both the deceased Irulappa Konar and his son Kannan into the well, threw stones and caused fatal injuries, and they died out of the same. The prosecution has mainly relied on the evidence of P.Ws.1, 3 to 5 and 19. So far as P.W.1 is concerned, the earliest document, which came into existence through her, was Ex.P1. On the strength of Ex.P1, a case came to be registered at about 2.30 P.M. by P.W.14, the Sub Inspector of Police, Chinnakovilankulam Police Station. A reading of Ex.P1 would clearly indicate that nowhere, she has whispered anything about the accused and thus, the case came to be registered under Sec. 174 of Cr.P.C. The next document that came into existence, was Ex.P2, a perusal of which would go to show that no date is mentioned therein. But, Ex.P2 has reached the concerned Magistrate's Court only on 4.2.2000. That apart, once a case has been registered on the strength of Ex.P1 report, Ex.P2 document cannot be taken as a complaint or a first information in the eye of laws; but, it could be treated only as a subsequent statement. A reading of Ex.P2 would indicate that she has mentioned that she saw both the accused standing near the well, and on seeing her, they ran away, and she went near the well and found the dead bodies of both the deceased. P.W.1 in her evidence has stated that she gave Ex.P2 the very next day. Has it been true, then, the police should have converted the case originally registered under Sec. 174 Cr.P.C, into a case of murder against these two accused and proceeded with the investigation in that line. For reasons best known to the police, no case was altered into Sec.302 I.P.C. immediately; But, on the contrary, after the accused surrendered before the concerned court, their police custody was obtained, and pursuant to the confessional statement, the case came to be registered under Sec.302, I.P.C.

11.

The prosecution has well relied on the evidence of P.Ws.3 to 5. P.W.3 in the course of the chief-examination would state that he found both the accused quarrelling with both the deceased at that time; but, he did not give any importance for it and went away. He would further add that after some hours, when he returned; he came to know that both the deceased were found dead within the well. If to be so, the natural human conduct, under the circumstances, would be to immediately reveal that he saw both the accused quarreling with the deceased; but, he has not done so. In the instant case, he has given a statement to the police, after a period of five months. It is highly improbable and against the ordinary human conduct, and hence, his evidence would be of no avail to the prosecution.

12.

So far as P.W.4 is concerned, she has stated in the chief-examination that she saw both the accused throwing stones into the well, and after seeing this, she left the place. She would add that after some time, she came to know that both Irulappa Konar and his son Kannan were found dead in the well, and the police was investigating the matter at about 3.00 P.M. Knowing well about those things, she did not reveal anything about the same. It is pertinent to point out that P.W.4 was a Panchayat Board Member. Under the circumstances, no one can expect a person that too a Panchayat Board member, to keep mum, when the police is investigating in a case of murder. She has given a statement after a period of five months. This would be indicative of the introduction of a witness in the instant case.

13.

Equally so, according to P.W.5, he saw both the accused throwing stones into the well, and on seeing him, both the accused ran away, and entertaining suspicion, he went near the well and saw both the deceased Irulappa Konar and his son Kannan lying inside the well with injuries. If to be so, the natural conduct of a person would be to immediately reveal the same; but, he has not done so for a period of five months. This unreasonable delay would be indicative of the fact that they could not have been at the place of the occurrence, and only after a long time, the case was converted into Sec.302 I.P.C. It is quite clear that they have been planted as witnesses in order to suit the prosecution case and nothing else. Thus, the lower Court should not have relied on the evidence of P.Ws.3 and 5, since it did not bring forth the true version of the prosecution case. This court is of the considered opinion that the evidence of P.Ws.3 to 5 can not be relied on, and on their evidence, it would be unsafe to find the accused/appellants guilty. If the evidence is to be rejected, then, the prosecution did not have any evidence to bring forth.

14.

The learned Additional Public Prosecutor would submit that P.W.19 has given evidence stating that the first accused was proceeding in a bus, where P.W.19 was also travelling, at one point, he was informing him that he need not purchase pooja articles, and he can well go to the native place and know the reason for the same. It may throw a doubt on the conduct of the accused; but, the same cannot be taken as a proof therefore. Thus, as could be seen above, the prosecution has proved the fact that Irulappa Konar and his son Kannan were done to death by throwing the stones on their head; but, the prosecution has failed to establish the nexus of the accused with the crime beyond reasonable doubt. In such circumstances, this court is unable to accept the case of the prosecution. The lower Court has taken a contrary view, which could be set right only by setting aside the judgment of the lower Court. The appellants/accused are entitled to acquittal.

15.

In the result, this criminal appeal is allowed, setting aside the judgment of the lower Court. The appellants/accused are acquitted of the charges leveled against them. They are directed to be set at liberty forthwith, unless their presence is required in any other case. The fine amount, if any paid, has got to be refunded.