AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Since these appeals (criminal appeal, government appeal and Application U/S 372 CrPC (Leave to Appeal) arise out of same case crime number, they have been heard together and are being decided by a common judgment and order. Criminal Appeal No. 2090 of 2018 is being treated as a leading case.
Heard Sri Manish Chand Umrao, learned counsel for the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 2090 of 2018, Sri Apul Misra for the appellant / applicant in Criminal Misc. Application No. 142 of 2018 under Section 372 Cr.P.C. (Leave to Appeal), Sri Satya Dheer Singh Jadaun in Criminal Appeal No. 1685 of 2018, Sri Akhilesh Singh for the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 1752 of 2018, Sri Rajarshi Gupta for the appellant in Criminal Appeal Nos. 1998 of 2018, 2886 of 2018, Sri Ziya Uddin for the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 2205 of 2018, Sri Noor Mohammad for the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 3271 of 2019, Sri Harish Chandra Pratap, learned Additional Government Advocate for the State and perused the record.
The instant Criminal Appeals have been filed by the appellants against the judgment and order dated 22.02.2018 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 2, Firozabad in Session Trial No. 374 of 2013 arising out of Case Crime No. 333 of 2012, Police Station – Sikohabad, District – Firozabad, S.T. No. 374A/2013 under Sections 147, 148, 149. 435, 307, 302 IPC read with Section 7 of Criminal Law Amendment Act and Section 27 of the Arms Act, ST No. 375 of 2013 under Section 25 of the Arms Act, arising out of Case Crime No. 339 of 2012, ST No. 376 of 2013 under Section 25 of the Arms Act, arising out of Case Crime No. 340 of 2012, ST No. 377 of 2013 under Section 25 of the Arms Act, arising out of Case Crime No. 341 of 2012, ST No. 378/2013 under Section 25 of the Arms Act, arising out of Case Crime No. 366 of 2012, ST No. 379/2013 under Section 25 of the Arms Act, arsing out of Case Crime No. 391 of 2012, ST No. 380 of 2013 under Section 25 of the Arms Act, arising out of Case Crime No. 392 of 2012, ST No. 381 of 2013 under Section 25 of the Arms Act, arising out of Case Crime No. 409 of 2012, ST No. 382 of 2013 under Section 25 of the Arms Act, arising out of Case Crime No. 411 of 2012, ST No. 384 of 2013 under Section 25 of the Arms Act, arising out of Case Crime No. 413 of 2012 and ST No. 385 of 2013 under Section 25 of the Arms Act, arising out of Case Crime No. 427 of 2012, all police station – Shikohabad, District – Firozabad.
In the First Information Report lodged on 3.7.2012, which had given rise to Case Crime No. 333 of 2012 under Sections 147, 148, 149, 307, 302 IPC read with Section 7 of Criminal Law Amendment Act, it was stated that for the trial of a criminal case initiated after some incident had occurred on 01.08.2005 wherein Vasudev Singh was the informant, Dashmesh was the deceased and the accused were Ravi Kumar, behnoi Shashi Kumar, Abhishek Kumar (informant in the Case Trial No. 333 of 2012) and six other persons, sessions trial was going on in the court of Additional District Judge, Firozabad and a date was fixed on 3.7.2012. It was further alleged in the FIR of 2012 that another case under Section 307, which was initiated by Shashi Kumar against Bhuvnesh and others, was also listed on the same day before the Sessions Court in Firozabad and, therefore, the cases which were listed on the 03.07.2012 were to be attended by Shashi Kumar whose evidence was being recorded. The brother-in-law Ravi Kumar (Bahnoi) of the first informant Abhishek Kumar and also his own brother Shashi Kumar, son of Raghuveer Singh along with their maternal uncle (mausera chacha), Ramesh Chandra, son of Subedar Singh, were all going to the Sessions Court to attend to the case of 2005. They were also accompanied by one Ram Rishi, S/o Daya Kishan. They were going in an Indica car which had a registration number UP-83-M 431. In the FIR, it was stated that Ravi Kumar was driving the car, whereas Shashi Kumar, Ram Rishi and Ramesh Chandra were sitting in it. While the car was going towards Firozabad, another vehicle of the make of Bolero in which Munna alias Nitin, S/o Ram Sewak, Vikas, S/o Ram Ratan, Monu, S/o Avadhesh Upadhyay, Satyaveer Singh, S/o Shripal Singh and two others were seated and were carrying unlicensed firearms came from the opposite direction. The first informant Abhishek Kumar had stated that he was following the Indica car in his own car which had a number UP-82-F 4660, and along with him, Ram Niwas, S/o Ramdas, was also sitting in that car. It was further stated that the third passenger was one Udayveer Singh, S/o Janak Singh. The Indica car had crossed them and was much ahead of them, and while the Indica car reached the village Mohabbatpur Madai, a Bolero with Registration No.UP-83-W-8238, came in front of the Indica car and from it, Yogesh, S/o Everan Singh, Bhuvnesh alias Lakkhy, S/o Everan Singh, and Everan Singh himself, who was the son of Shri Chandra, along with Bhola, S/o Ram Lakhan, came out. The time when the Bolero came in front of the Indica car was 10:30 AM and it was then that the Bolero car UP-83-W-8238 rammed into the Indica car because of which the car driven by Ravi Kumar stopped. Ram Rishi and Shashi Kumar came out of their car and ran in different directions. Upon this, the persons who had come in the two Bolero cars, from their firearms, started firing on Shashi Kumar, Ravi Kumar and Ramesh Chandra. They were hit by the bullets and they died. Ram Rishi, however, managed to save himself. Thereafter, the car of Ravi Kumar (Bahnoi), was sprinkled with petrol and was set on fire and the persons sitting inside, i.e. Ravi Kumar and Ramesh Chandra, along with the car, got totally burnt. The Car Bolero which was numbered as UP-83-W 8238 was left at the site, and the accused got into the other Bolero car and escaped from the place of incident. Because of the incident, the Mainpuri road traffic came to a standstill. People left their cars on the road and ran for safe shelters. All the shops in the area were closed. In the FIR itself, it was further stated that these very people had earlier also, on the Shikohabad-Mainpuri crossing, fired upon them, and in that, they were all saved, whereas side passengers who were sitting in the neighboring roadways bus had got injured. It was further stated that it was because of these rivalries that the incident had occurred on the 03.07.2012. The first informant had very categorically stated that the incident was witnessed by Abhishek Kumar and other persons who were there at the spot. He had stated that the accused were a well-organized gang, and they also indulged in murder and loot, and thereafter prayed for action to be taken against them. The FIR was scribed by one Shri Kripa Shankar Singh, S/o Lokpal Singh. Upon the FIR having been lodged, the police got into action.
On 03.07.2012, burnt pistols and cartridges were also recovered from the Indica car and from outside it. Also on 03.07.2012, a recovery memo with regard to blood-stained and plain soil was made. Along with the blood-stained soil and plain soil, a recovery of Rs. 5500/- was made. With regard to these recoveries, specially with regard to the firearms, FIRs were lodged under relevant sections of the Arms Act.
On 03.07.2012, by exhibit Ka-4, the recovery memo of the ash of the burnt car and plain concrete road was made. Again on 03.07.2012, recovery memo of the revolver, cartridges, watch, PAN card, Rs. 1610/-, driving license, and 21 passport photographs were recovered from the car were prepared. On the same day, by exhibit Ka-6, the memo of the recovered Bolero car No. UP-83 W-8238 along with a belt of cartridges and an empty Can of 5 liters was prepared. This recovery memo, i.e. exhibit Ka-2, Ka-3, Ka-4, Ka-5, and Ka-6, were witnessed by Ram Rishi and Nandlal.
On 05.08.2012, the S.S.I. Satyapal Singh, along with Constable Rishi Kumar, Rajeev, Sharad, and Umesh Chandra, arrested Yogesh Yadav, Kuldeep, Nitij, and with their assistance, recovered certain firearms. Yogesh Yadav got a country made pistol of 315 bore recovered. Kuldeep alias Bhola, from the same place, again got a 315 bore country made pistol recovered. Nitij also got a country made pistol recovered from the same place. They all had got their statements recorded that by these weapons, they had committed the crime. The recovery memo of these three weapons was exhibited as Exhibit Ka-9.
On 10.07.2012, again on the pointing of the accused Ketan Upadhyay, another country-made pistol of 315 bore was got recovered. Thereafter, on 11.07.2012, two other country-made pistols of 315 bore and 10 bullets of 315 bore and one Mahindra Verito car were got recovered. This recovery was got done with the help of the accused Uma Shankar and Pushpendra Yadav. From Brijesh Bhadaria, the live bullets were recovered.
Then on 26.07.2012, on the pointing of Bhuvanesh, another accused, a country-made pistol of 315 bore was recovered. A recovery memo was prepared of it and was exhibited as Ex-Ka-78.
Similarly, on 27.07.2012, again on the pointing of accused Bhuvanesh, a licensed rifle and live cartridges were recovered.
Thereafter, again on 27.07.2012, the accused Yogesh had got recovered another country made pistol of 315 bore. Further, Yogesh Yadav, the same person, had from the Kali temple which was under construction, got recovered another 315 bore country made pistol which was in a polythene bag.
Thereafter, again on 30.07.2012, two country-made pistols of 315 bore were recovered by the help of the accused Pushpendra and Anand Yadav.
On 05.08.2012, again on the pointing of the accused Ketan alias Monu Upadhyay, another country made pistol of 315 bore was got recovered.
On 10.08.2012, on the pointing of the accused Vinay, another country-made pistol of 315 bore along with an empty cartridge of 315 bore was recovered.
With regard to all the recoveries, first information reports were also lodged on the very same day the recoveries were made.
With regard to the recovery of a Bolero which did not have a number on its number plate, a recovery memo was prepared which was exhibited as Exhibit Ka-80. This was prepared on the pointing of accused Bhola.
On 15.09.2012, 13 registers were taken by the police into custody and thereafter they were given in their "supurdagi" for the safe keeping, and a memo of it was prepared as Ex-Ka-83. Similarly, the police also took into custody a Dak Bahi and the memo by which it was taken into custody was displayed as Ex-Ka-91. This was done on 20.10.2012.
An inspection report also prepared with regard to the Bolero car numbered as UP-83-W-8238 and with regard to the Indica car, the number plate and their memos were exhibited as Ka-44 and Ka-45.
Thereafter, the panchayatnamas which were conducted of the dead bodies of Ramesh Chand, Ravi Kumar, and Shashi Kumar were exhibited as Ex-Ka-17, Ka-18, and Ka-19. Thereafter, the post-mortems of these persons were also conducted on 4th of July 2012, and the post-mortem reports were exhibited for Ramesh as exhibit Ka-12, viz-a-viz Ravi exhibit Ka-11, and viz-a-viz Shashi exhibit Ka-10.
On 06.12.2013 and on 12.12.2013, the reports of the Forensic Science Laboratories were also sent to the investigating agencies. However, before that the police reports in the main case and in the cases under the Arms Act were sent over to the court.
The police had charge-sheeted 14 accused persons. For the continuation of the prosecution under the Arms Act, sanctions of the District Magistrate were also issued and they are also on the record.
Upon the receipt of the police report, the court on 07.09.2013 framed charges. Thereafter, charges were framed by the Sessions Judge on 9.10.2013 in the following manner:
On 07.09.2013, charges were framed against Munna alias Nitij, Vinay alias Tunna, Yogesh alias Yogesh Babu, Bhuvnesh alias Luckhy, Evran Singh alias Ahivaran Singh, Yogesh Yadav, Ketan alias Monu Upadhyay, Kuldeep alias Bhola alias Bholu, Pushpendra Yadav, Uma Shankar, Brijesh Katheria, Pushpendra Yadav, S/o Jagdish Singh, Anand Yadav alias Luchky, S/o of Jagdish Yadav under Sections 147, 148, 307/149, 302, 435/149, Section 7 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act, and under Section 27 of the Arms Act.
On 09.10.2013, charge was framed against Satyaveer Singh under Sections 147, 148, 307/149, 302/149, 435/149 and under Section 7 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act.
Charge was framed on 07.09.2013 against Uma Shankar, Pushpendra Yadav, Brijesh Katheria, Yogesh Yadav, Pushpendra, Anand alias Jagdish Yadav, Ketan, Yogesh Yadav, Vinay and Nitih alias Munna under Section 25 of the Arms Act.
When the accused denied the charges, the cases were put to trial.
From the side of the prosecution, as many as 18 prosecution witnesses were produced.
PW-1 was Abhishek Kumar, who was the Brother-in-law (Sala) of the deceased Ravi. He had in his statement-in-chief stated that on 03.07.2012, in Fast Track Court No. 7, with regard to a case which was already pending, Shashi was going to the court and along with him, Ravi, his brother Ram Rishi and maternal uncle (mausera chacha) Ramesh Chand were also going. They were all in an Indica Car with Registration No. UP-83-M-4311 and they were going for the trial with regard to the case which had been initiated by Vasudev. Ram Rishi and Ravi were going in the car which was being driven by Ravi. Ramesh Chandra was also sitting in the car. The accused came from the side of Shikohabad and in that vehicle Yogesh, Bhuvnesh, Everan and Bhola were sitting. PW-1 had stated that this car was numbered as UP 83 W - 8238. Bhola who was in the vehicle No. UP 83 W 8238 was not known to PW-1. The witness Ram Rishi had told him about the accused Bhola. He had stated that the Indica car was coming from the side of Mainpuri and was going towards Shikohabad. The vehicle in which PW-1 was sitting had a number plate with the number UP 82 F 4660, and in that car, Ram Nivas and Udayveer were also sitting. The distance between the Indica car in which Shashi was sitting and the car in which the prosecution witnesses were sitting was around 200 to 250 meters. The car in which PW-1 was sitting was going ahead of the car of Shashi by 200 to 250 meters and as Shashi's car reached Mardai Mohammadpur near a bhatta, then the cars of Shashi and PW-1 were overtaken by a Mahindra Bolero car. In that Bolero Monu, Munna and Vikas along with one more person, whose name PW-1 did not remember, were present. The car which had come from the side of Shikohabad had collided with the car in which the deceased Shashi was sitting. The time was around 10:30 AM. After the Bolero car collided with the Indica car, Yogesh, Bhuvnesh and Ahibaran came out of it. All these persons were carrying licensed rifles along with country-made firearms in their hands and these persons started firing indiscriminately. This firing was directed at Ravi, Shashi, Ram Rishi and Ramesh. Upon seeing this happening, Ram Rishi and Shashi, who were sitting on the back seat, escaped from the Indica car. They fired upon Shashi from behind and thereafter they fled. Shashi, because of the injuries he received from the firing, died near the bhatta. Ravi and Ramesh, who were sitting in the car, were set on fire by sprinkling petrol over the Indica car.
Thereafter, when the occupants of the car that had collided with the Indica car fled, the car which was left on the spot was UP 83 W 8238. He categorically stated that the accused persons had come in two vehicles. Thereafter, the villagers arrived at the spot. He had stated that he had got the FIR lodged after getting it scribed by his brother Shiv Kendra Singh. He categorically had stated that the accused had killed the brother of the bahnoi and their chacha as they were going for the trial in the Dashrath murder case. He had also stated that he was not on good terms with the accused as he was implicated in certain cases regarding the Pradhani of the village. This prosecution witness was cross-examined and in the cross-examination, he had stated that his brother Shiv Kendra Singh, who had scribed the FIR, was a resident of Shikohriya and was serving in the police. He had stated that his village was around 17 kilometers away from the place of incident. Abhishek Kumar was answering various questions which were put in the cross-examination and he had stated that in fact his village was 70 kilometers away from the place of incident and if it was written as 17 kilometers earlier then it was wrong. He had also tried to correct the narration with regard to the smaller car of the Mahindra Company and had stated that its make was Varito and not Vento and, therefore, the earlier statement of his, he prayed, be accordingly corrected. He had stated that the occupants of the two vehicles in which the complainant's side was there, he had not mentioned the name of Shiv Kendra and he had then further stated that Shiv Kendra was an employee of the police department and was working at the Vidhuna police station and that he had come on that particular date to his bahnoi's house which was in village Vahmai. PW-I was not aware whether he had come on leave and whether Shiv Kendra had come to the place of incident upon getting the information. He has further clarified that the name of the son of Ram Rishi was Nandlal and both Ram Rishi and Nandlal were residents of Nagla Lekhraj, Police Station Sirsaganj, District Firozabad. On the date of the incident, in none of the vehicles Nandlal son of Ram Rishi was there and also Nandlal was not present at the time of the incident. When Nandlal had arrived, the first informant along with others had reached the Kotwali Shikohabad and the time was around 12.00 noon and at that point of time Ram Rishi, the PW-2 was there along with PW-1. In fact he has stated that the police had asked him as to who all had come with him and in reply the PW-1 had stated that Ram Rishi had accompanied him to the Thana. Apart from Ram Rishi, Ram Niwas; Udayveer and Shiv Kendra had also come. He had stated that certain other persons were also there. He has stated that it was wrong to say that he had not got himself marked as present in the Thana. He had denied the suggestion that at that particular point of time, he was not there at the place of incident but was in the village. He had also denied the suggestion that he had actually gone to his village Chikuria where he received the news of the incident and thereafter he had gone with Shiv Kendra and a brother to his and had got the FIR scribed. He had also denied the suggestion that Ram Rishi along with the son Nandlal had come at the place of incident subsequently to the incident having occurred. Similarly, he had denied the suggestion that Udayveer had also come later on. He had stated that such names as were known to him, he had got them mentioned in the FIR and the names of the others whose names he had not known, were so written in the FIR after the persons present at the spot had told him about them. Munna @ Nitin son of Ram Sewak was known to him and therefore he had got his name entered in the FIR. Similar, was the case of Vikas. Also he had stated that he had known Vikas son of Ram Ratan from before. He had then mentioned about the two cases with regard to which they were all going to Shikohabad. He had further stated that in that case he was an accused. Vasudev, Bhuvnesh and Ram Ratan had already got their evidence recorded. Bhuvnesh's father's name was Evaran and he was an accused in the instant case. Yogesh was the son of Evaran and he was also present in the Court. Father of Yogesh and Bhuvnesh i.e. Evaran was also present in the Court and he was an accused in the case. He had stated that it was wrong to say that since he was an accused in the murder case of Dashmesh, therefore, he and other persons who were close to Dashmesh were embroiled in the case. He had further stated that Ram Ratan was the uncle of Dashmesh and therefore to create a pressure on Ram Ratan, his son had been falsely implicated in the case. He had then stated that he was being tried as a juvenile in the murder case of Dashmesh and on that date his hearing was not there in the Juvenile Justice Board. He was also not summoned to be a witness in any case. He had then stated that he had no knowledge of the pendency of the criminal cases in the Fast Track Court. He denied the suggestion that he was not there in the car which was following the Indica car. He then had stated that in the Varito car, Bhuvnesh Kumar, Umashankar and Brijesh Katheriya were sitting. He then goes on to say that in all there were three cars and that the three cars had found mention in the FIR and thus he says that the accused side had three cars whereas his side had two cars and therefore in toto there were five cars. When upon showing the FIR it was brought to his notice that he had not mentioned about the Varito car and about the accused persons who were allegedly sitting in that car then he had stated that this aspect of the matter had probably slipped from his mind. He had stated that it was correct to say that even in his examination-in-chief he had not mentioned about the third car. He had also admitted that he had not mentioned in any application whatsoever about the fact that he had missed out the third car in the FIR. On 23.9.2013 he had stated that Shashi's car which he had earlier by mistake called Velto, was in fact Varito. He had stated that it was correct to say that he had not mentioned about any accused by the name of Vinay Kumar @ Tunna. He had stated that he had also not mentioned about Vinay Kumar @ Tunna even in the statement given under section 161 Cr.P.C. before the police. He had stated that after 12.00 noon he had reached the police station and thereafter he remained there for 2-3 hours. The statement he had given with regard to the lodging of the FIR was : "िरपोटर् करने हेतु 12.00 बजे थाने गए थे और दो-तीन घंटे रहे थे। दो-तीन घंटे बाद िफर अस्प ताल पहुँ च गया था जहाँ पोस्ट माटर्म होना था। स्व यं कहा िक ड़़़ेड़़़बॉ ड़़़ी पहले ही अस्प ताल पहुँ च गई थी। मैं तीन बजे अस्प ताल पहुँ चा। मुझसे पहले ड़़़ेड़़़ बॉ ड़़़ी अस्प ताल पहुँ च गई थी। ड़़़ेड़़़ बॉ ड़़़ी 11.30 बजे घटना वाले िदन अस्प ताल पहुँ च गई थी।" He had then stated that the panchayatnama etc. was done at the hospital itself where the dead body was lying. He had then stated that after the Station House Officer had sent the dead body at around 11.30 AM to the hospital, thereafter he had accompanied the Station House Officer to the Police Station and thereafter he had stayed at the police station for around three hours with the Station House Officer and at that point of time at the police station when the Tehrir was to be scribed, Shiv Kendra was present and round about this time Ram Rishi and his son Nandlal had also reached the police station. The post mortem of the three bodies were done on the next day. He had stated that on 3.7.2012 no signature was got done by Ram Rishi and Nandlal in their presence. He had then, upon a specific question being put as to who was driving the Indica car, stated that the car was being driven by Ravi and by the side of the driver seat, Ramesh was sitting. Shashi was sitting on the back seat along with Ram Rishi and this seating arrangement he had seen by his own eyes. They had sat in the car in this manner while they had started and the car had not stopped anywhere in between. He specifically denied the question put to him as to whether while Ravi was driving the car, Ramesh Chandra and Ram Rishi were sitting in the back seat. He has stated that this seating arrangement he had also stated to the Investigating Officer while getting his statement recorded under section 161 Cr.P.C. and if this fact was not mentioned in it, then he did not know the reason why it was not so mentioned. He had stated that a lot many Press Reporters had come on the spot and the Indica car had been abundantly photographed by the public and the police and the photographs had also appeared in various newspapers like Hindustan, Dainik Jagran and Ankinchan Bharat etc. on 4.7.2012. The annexures which were there in the NSA Case were of the newspaper reporting which was done on the next date of the incident. The car which had collided with the Indica car was left by the accused persons at the place of incident itself. He admitted upon seeing the photographs which were annexed as Annexures 48 to 53 that the Bolero car though was there and was damaged, was not appearing to have really collided with the Indica car. Whether the Indica car and Bolero were taken into custody by the police, he stated, he did not know. He had specifically stated, to a question as to how Ram Rishi and Shashi were running. He had stated that they were running away from the place of incident and from behind the firing was being done. Ram Rishi while had gone unhurt as he had hidden himself behind a 'patel', Ravi had got injured and had died. He had stated that it was correct to say that he had mentioned in the FIR that Ram Rishi and Shashi had got down of the car and ran in different directions and the accused from the vehicles had got down and shot at Shashi Kumar, Ravi Kumar and Ramesh. He had stated that the car was travelling from Mainpuri to Shikohabad and that it was coming from east to west. The two doors of the car opened in the northern and southern side. However, Ram Rishi (PW-2) and Shashi (deceased) who were sitting on the backseat had got down from the northern side. They had not come out from the different doors opening on the two sides i.e. southern and northern side. He had stated that in the FIR he had wrongly mentioned that the two, Ram Rishi and Shashi had escaped from the car in two different directions. This portion of the statement of PW-2 is being reproduced here as under :-
"यह स ड़़़़क पूरब से पिश्च म को मैनपुरी की ओर से िशकोहाबाद की ओर जाती है। हमारी गाड़़़़ी इंिड़़़ का का मुँह िशकोहाबाद की ओर था इसिलए इंिड़़़ का की िपछली सीट के दरवाजे एक उत्त र की और एक दिक्ष ण की ओर खुलता था तथा गवाह रामऋिष और मृतक शशी दोनों एक ही उत्त र की िदशा में भागे अलग अलग िदशाओं में नहीं भागे। मेरे आज के बयान की बात सही है। प्रथम सूचना िरपोटर् में यह गलत िलखा है िक रामऋिष व शशी दोनों अलग अलग िदशाओं में भागे थे।"
He emphatically thereafter had stated that Ram Rishi and Shashi had escaped from the northern side and to say that they had tried to escape from the southern side would be a wrong fact to state. He had stated that he had parked his car around 30-40 feet behind the Indica car. However, this position of parking was not shown when the site plan was being prepared. He denied the fact that he had not been at the place of incident at all and, therefore, he had not told the Investigating Officer about the place of parking his car. The Indica car, he had stated, was on fire and had burnt for about half an hour. All the tyres had got burnt and the inside of the car had also got burnt. The car had oil which assisted the car in getting further burnt. The people who had collected around the place of incident tried to extinguish the fire and thereafter only when the fire-brigade came after around 40 minutes, the fire extinguished. In between the initiation of burning of the car and the extinguishing of the fire, the two cars i.e. Indica and Bolero were in the same position as they were, when they collided with each other. He had stated that because of the burning of the Indica car, the paint of Bolero had become spoiled at places. Further there was a bumper which separated the two cars and, therefore, the Bolero car had not caught fire. There was no rain etc. on that day and that it was a hot july month. Upon a question being put that after he had come on the place of incident, he had remained in the hospital and thereafter in the village Bahmai on 4.7.2012, then how he had gone to get the site map prepared, he had answered that he had forgotten about this aspect of the matter that on 4.7.2012 he had also gone to get the sitemap prepared. He had stated that he had somehow missed to mention that the fire was extinguished with the help of fire brigade. Even in the statement under section 161 Cr.P.C. he had not mentioned about the fire brigade coming to the place of incident. He had further stated to a question as to what was the distance between the assailants and Ram Rishi and Shashi, he had answered that Ram Rishi and Shashi were being chased by the accused persons and there was a distance of around 30 feet and from that distance the accused were firing on Ram Rishi and Shashi. The exact statement which he had made, is reproduced here as under :-
"रामऋिष व शशी आगे-आगे भाग रहे थे और मुिल्ज मान पीछे-पीछे भाग रहे थे। अंदाज से मुिल्ज मान शशी से 30 फीट पीछे रह गए थे जहाँ से शशी पर फायर िकए थे। मौके पर एक ही भट्टा है दो भट्टे नहीं हैं। स ड़़़़क से भट्टे के बीच लगभग आधी दूरी का मुिल्ज मान प हुँच गए थे।"
Thereafter the PW-1 was examined by the defence counsel of Monu and Bhola. He had stated upon a question being asked as to whether he had identified Bhola since Bhola's name was not mentioned in the FIR, then the PW-1 had stated that he had seen him for the first time in the Court. He had then introduced the story that a few of the accused persons were also not identifiable as they had covered their faces with a cloth "danta". He had then stated that none of the deceased could use the firearms which they were carrying. Still further he had stated that at the time of accident, one car was running at a speed of 50-60 kilometers whereas the Bolero car was running with a speed of around 80 kilometers. This portion of his statement is being reproduced here as under :-
"िकसी मृतक ने कोई फायर नहीं िकया था। कोई मृतक अपने असलाह प्रयोग नहीं कर पाये। िजस समय दोनों गािड़़़़ याँ टकरा ईं, उस समय एक गाड़़़़ी 50-60 िकलोमीटर की स्पी ड़़़पर थी और बोलेरो करीब 80 िकलोमीटर की स्पी ड़़़पर रही होगी।"
The PW-2 was Ram Rishi and it was alleged that he was also accompanied by Ravi, Shashi, Ram Chandra while were in the Indica car when they were going to attend their case at Firozabad. He had also stated that against him and his brothers Ravi and Shashi along with Brijesh, a case had been registered for the murder of Dashmesh. This was initiated by the uncle of Dashmesh who was known by the name of Vasudeo and the hearing of the case was on that date. He had stated that there was rivalry between the family of Shashi, Ravi Kumar, his family and that of Yogesh etc. He had also narrated the case in the same way as the PW-1 had done. He had, however, stated that the moment the two cars collided with each other, Ahivaran Singh, Yogesh, Lakkhi @ Bhuvnesh, Kuldeep @ Bhola had started firing on the Indica car. Shashi Kumar had opened the window of the car and PW-2 and Shashi Kumar ran on the eastern side towards the 'bhatta' and on the place of incident, another Bolaro car had come and from it Monu Upadhyay, Satyaveer, Munna @ Nitin, Vikas @ Vinay @ Tinna, Pushpendra and Anand had alighted and they had all started firing towards Shashi. Because of the firing done by the accused persons, Ravi and Ramesh had died in the car itself. Shashi Kumar had run about 135 to 140 steps towards the 'bhatta' where the accused killed him and thereafter the accused had put the car on fire by pouring petrol on it and Ravi and Ramesh, who were inside the car, had got burnt. He had also stated that the accused had come on three cars. Out of those cars, two were Bolero and one was a smaller car. In the smaller car, Yogesh, Brijesh Katharia, Umashankar and Pushpendra had also come. These persons were also involved in the incident and they had also fired. After the incident had occurred, the police had reached the place of incident and had also recovered certain firearms from the burnt car. He had also proved various recovery memos by which the recoveries were made and he had signed on them. In the cross-examination, he had stated that Ravi was the driver in the car and immediately behind him, he i.e. PW-2 was sitting and that Shashi was sitting on his left side behind Ramesh Chandra. He had also stated that it was wrong to say that Shashi was sitting in the front seat beside the driver. He thereafter had stated that if any of his statement had been recorded under section 161 Cr.P.C. otherwise then it was erroneous. He had stated that the Tehrir, i.e. the written report, which was exhibited as Ka-1 was that of the first informant and that the PW-2 and the PW-1 had after discussing amongst themselves got the FIR scribed. He had stated that he did not remember as to how many names he had suggested. Similarly he also did not remember how many names Abhishek had suggested. He also did not remember as to how many names the people in the crowd had suggested. However, the Station House Officer of P.S. Shikohabad was present at that point of time. Half of the Tehrir was got written while they were sitting at the police station Shikohabad and thereafter the Station House Officer had taken them to the place of incident and thereafter the other half of the FIR was got written. He had stated that when the Tehrir had got completed then it was almost 5.00 to 5.30 in the evening. He had stated that the scribe of the FIR was Shiv Kendra, the brother of Abhishek and Abhishek was made to sign on the FIR. Thereafter the Station House Officer had taken the PW-2, Abhishek and Nandlal, the son of PW-2 to the Shikohabad hospital. The relevant portion of the statement made by the PW-2 is being reproduced here as under :
"यह बात सही है िक तहरीर वादी प्रदशर् क-1 मैंने व अिभषेक ने आपस में सलाह मशिवरा करके िलखायी थी। मैं नहीं बता सकता िक िकतने नाम मैंने िलखाये, िकतने अिभषेक ने िलखाये व िकतने नाम भी ड़़़़में मौजूद लोगों ने िलखाये। थाना अध्य क्षथाना िशकोहाबाद तहरीर िलखाते समय मौजूद थे। आधी तहरीर थाना िशकोहाबाद में बैठकर िलखी गयी िफर थाना अध्य क्षिशकोहाबाद हमें मौके पर ले गये और मौका मुआयना िकया िफर तहरीर पूरी करायी। जब तहरीर थाना अध्य क्ष ने पूरी करायी तब शाम का पाँच साढ़े पाँच बजे का समय रहा होगा। यह तहरीर वादी अिभषेक के भाई िशवकेंद्र ने िलखी थी व अिभषेक के दस्त खत करा िलये थे। उसके बाद थाना इंचाजर् हमें मौके से मुझे व अिभषेक व मेरे पुत्र नंदलाल को िफरोजाबाद अस्प ताल ले गये थे। मुझे व अिभषेक को थाना िशकोहाबाद नहीं ले गये थे।"
Upon asking as to how the police had reached the place of incident, he had stated that some Master (teacher) had rung up the police and therefore they had come on the spot. He had stated that neither he himself nor his companions had rung up the police. He denied the suggestion that they had not rung up the police because they were not there. He had stated that it would be correct to say that when the Bolero car had collided with the Indica car then Shashi and he himself had come out of the car from two different doors and had run in two different directions. He had stated that he ran in sourthern direction while Shashi had run in the northern direction and the road was running east to west. This portion of the statement of PW-2 is being reproduced here as under:-
"यह कहना सही होगा िक बुलैरो द्वा रा सामने से इंिड़़़ का कार में टक्क र मारने के बाद मैं शशी दोनों अलग-अलग िदशाओं में भागे। मैं दिक्ष ण िदशा में व शशी उत्त र िदशा में भागे थे। सड़़़़ क पूवर् पिश्च म जाती है।"
He had further stated that after the collision, the Bolero car had moved around 3-4 steps backwards and after the collision, the firing etc. had started. He denied the suggestion that the mention of the smaller car was not made earlier and that it was being now made in the statement of witnesses on legal advise. He had very categorically stated that with regard to the two unknown accused persons, as had been mentioned in the FIR, no test identification parade had been got done by the police. He was also not aware as to how and when the names of the two unknown persons were revealed. The recovery memos, which were Ka-2, Ka-3, Ka-4, Ka-5 and Ka-6, were not prepared in his presence but were got signed on the next day. This particular paragraph in which he had mentioned that the recovery memo was not prepared in his presence and that his signatures were taken on the next day, is being reproduced here as under :-
"फदेर् जो दरोगा जी ने प्रदशर् क-2, 3, 4, 5 व 6 बनाई थी वह मेरे सामने नहीं बनाई थी मुझसे बाद में दूसरे िदन दस्त खत कराये थे और सामान िदखाया था। सामान पहले िदखाया था तब जब लाशें वामई गांव में जल गयी थी उसके बाद फदोर्ं पर दस्त खत कराये थे। मुझे जो सामान दरोगा जी ने िदखाया उसमें एक जला हु आ तमंचा व 500/- का नोट एवं जली हुई आठ गोिलयां िदखाये थे। िरवाल्व र व 7 गोिलयां तथा गोिलयों की बैल्ट व ड़़़्रा इवरी लाइसेंस, पैनका ड़़़र्व कई फोटो िदखाये थे। फोटो शशी के व उनकी पत्नी के थे। और िकसी के फोटो थे या नहीं मैं नहीं बता सकता क्यों िक मैंने फोटो देखे नहीं थे।"
He has further upon a question being asked as to whether the other witnesses of the public were there, he denied the same. Also, he denied the presence of Nandlal, the son of Ram Rishi, at the place of incident and that he was called on phone. He had stated that it was wrong to say that he himself and his son had not visited the site and therefore their signatures were got at village Vahmai. It has further been stated by the PW-2 that he had stayed at the place of incident till 3.00 PM despite the fact that the police had reached the place of incident by 11.00 AM. He had thereafter stated that he had remained at the police station till 5.00 to 5.30 PM and there itself the report was scribed. At the police station, Abhishek and Shiv Kendra had also reached from before. This portion of the statement of the witness is being reproduced here as under :-
"इस ड़़़ र व भय के माहौल में कौन पुिलस वाला क्या कायर्वाही करता रहा यह मुझे नहीं मालूम। तीन सवा तीन बजे पुिलस की सभी गािड़़़़ यां चली गई थी और पुिलस मुझे वगजर् सुर क्षा िशकोहाबाद थाना ले गई थी। पांच साढ़े पांच बजे तक मैं थाना में बैठा रहा था िरपोटर् िलखी गई थी। थाना में अिभषेक व िशवकेंद्र पहले ही पहुं च गए थे।"
He had further stated that after the collision had taken place, Shashi Kumar had escaped from the Southern direction and had run for around 125 to 130 paces and thereafter he had died. In the 125 paces, Shashi Kumar could not take out the revolver and that all the firing had taken place from behind and that there was a trail of blood for the entire distance he had run. This trail was also shown to the police officials. He had stated that at the place of incident no one had appeared from the family which was inimical to the PW-1 and PW-2 and this was something which the prosecution side felt bad about. He had further, upon a certain question being asked, stated that the police officials had tried to find out the true story and therefore they had got into action and upon enquiries made by them by the evening, it was discovered that 8 persons were involved in the case and after naming them, the FIR was lodged and at that point of time he had stated that two vehicles were shown in the FIR. However, there were in fact three vehicles. This relevant portion of the statement is being reproduced here as under:
"पुिलस के बड़़़़े अिधकािरयों ने दरोगा जी से कहा िक इस कांड़़़ की सही जानकारी चािहए। पुिलस काम में जुट गई। पता करने के िलए िक िकस-िकस ने घटना की है। शाम तक मुन्ना आिद के आठ नाम सामने आ गए। उन आठ को नािमत करते हु ए िरपोटर् की गई। उस समय िरपोटर् में बदमाशों की दो गािड़़़़ यों को िदखाया गया लेिकन तीन गािड़़़़ याँ थीं । िकसी गाड़़़़ी का नंबर मैं नहीं देख पाया था, कलर देखा था। उन गािड़़़़ यों के कलर वाली बात दरोगा जी ने नहीं पूछी इसिलए नहीं बताई थी।"
He had stated that he had not got the knowledge as to whether there were 14 persons involved in the case and about there being the involvement of the 14 persons, the police had told him. When the accused had been apprehended then the police had called PW-2 and then he had come to know that there were not just 8 accused involved in the case but there were 14 persons who were involved in the case and those 14 persons were also shown to PW-2 in the jail. He had stated that police had told him that it was very difficult for the 14 persons to fit into two vehicles and therefore the police had suggested that a case had to be established by the prosecution showing three vehicles and therefore he had stated in the court on that day that he was stating that there were three vehicles. The relevant portion of the paragraph is being reproduced here as under:
"जब मुिल्ज मान पक ड़़़़ेगए तब पुिलस ने मुझे बुलाया तब पता लगा िक घटना 8 ने नहीं 14 ने की है और मुिल्ज मान पुिलस ने मुझे थाने में बंद िदखाए। पुिलस ने कहा 14 बदमाश दो गािड़़़़ यों में नहीं आ सकते, गािड़़़़ यां तीन रखनी पड़़़़ें गी। उसी िहसाब से मैंने आज तीन गािड़़़़ यां बताई है।"
In the jail before the accused were shown to the PW-2, no test identification parade was done and only on the basis of information provided by the police, 14 persons were now being introduced as accused persons in the case. He had further stated that he did not have all the ten fingers in his both hands and therefore he was not in a position to hold anything in the car in which he was sitting, yet he had not received any injury from which bleeding might have happened. The moment the collision had taken place firing had started. He had stated that he had not stated anything as to in what manner firing etc. had taken place and at the moment the collision had taken place he had got out of the car and had run away to save his life and that after running on the Southern side of the road he had fallen inside an unused bhatta (brick kiln). He had stated that after he had come out of the bhatta, he had seen Shashi Kumar lying dead. He had further stated that he was a military man and that he had correctly guessed that Shashi Kumar had died in the firing which had taken place and thereafter he had stated that immediately he had telephoned while he was sitting near the dead-body (it was in contradiction to the statement of PW-1 who had stated that Ram Rishi had hidden himself in a 'patel'). He had stated that the crowed which had accumulated at the place of incident had extinguished the fire by pouring water mud. How much time was taken to extinguish the fire, he did not remember. He further stated that after the fire was extinguished, he peeped into the car and found that two of his own acquaintances had got charred and they were Ravi Kumar and Ramesh.
PW-3 was Udayveer Singh and he was also the brother-in-law (sala) of the deceased Shashi Kumar. He had also narrated the facts in a similar manner which was that because of the case which was to be taken up in the Sessions Court, the four persons i.e. Ravi Kumar, Ramesh Chandra, Shashi Kumar and Rishi Ram were going in the Indica car and that he himself i.e. Udayveer Singh was coming from behind in another Maruti car of which the owner was one Ram Niwas and in that car the PW-3 himself, Abhishek the PW-1, the first informant and Ram Niwas were there. Ram Niwas was the person who was driving the car. He had stated that his Maruti car was taken over by a vehicle called Bolero in which according to him there were six persons sitting in the car i.e. Satyaveer Singh, Monu, Munna, Vikas, Pushpendra and Anand and that when the Indica car reached somewhere near the bhatta (brick klin) then another Bolero car coming from Sikohabad collided with the Indica car. The time of the incident was 10:30 AM. From the vehicle called Bolero which had hit the Indica car Bhuvnesh, Yogesh, Evaran and Bhola the four persons had come out. They had all jumped out from the vehicle and started firing on Ravi, Ramesh, Shashi and Ram Rishi i.e. on all the four who were in the Indica car. When the firing started, it hit Ravi and Ramesh. Shashi and Ram Rishi got out from the car and started to run away. The persons who were there in the Bolero which had hit the Indica car and the persons who had come out of the Bolero which came from behind the car of the PW-3, all of them had started shooting at the persons who were there in the Indica car. The third car Verito contained four persons namely Pushpendra, Uma Shanker and Brijesh Kathariya. Name of the fourth person he did not remember. They also were having country made pistols. After the firing etc. was done, petrol was poured over the Indica car and it was put on fire, wherein Ravi and Ramesh got burnt. Shashi Kumar and Ram Rishi both got down from the Northern side and started to run. Ram Rishi hid somewhere while Shashi Kumar ran towards the bhatta (brick kiln). Ram Rishi was also shot at but Shashi was the one who got injured with the bullets which were fired and he died. He has also stated that to extinguish the fire, fire brigade had come. Only one vehicle had remained at the place of incident while the two others i.e. the Bolero which was coming from behind and Verito car escaped with all the accused.
In the cross-examination, the accused had stated that only 8 persons were named in the FIR lodged by Abhishek but there were, in fact, 14 persons. The others who were not named in the FIR were Pushpendra son of Pheru Singh, Pushpendra son of Jagdish, Uma Shanker, Brijesh Kateriya and Anand and one name, he did not remember. At the place where the FIR was being scribed, Ram Rishi was very much present. At that point of time the PW-3 and Ram Rishi had not told the names of any of the accused who were not named in the FIR. He had stated that Shiv Kendra had scribed the F.I.R. while he was sitting in the Thana Kotwali, Sikohabad. The FIR was scribed at around 12:00 Noon to 12:30 PM. He had then stated that he had already met the police officials before the F.I.R. was scribed and the police personnel had asked him to proceed towards the Thana where he would tell him how the F.I.R. was to be scribed. The relevant portion of the statement is being reproduced here as under :-
"िजन लोगों को अिभषेक ने प्रथम सूचना िरपोटर् में नामजद नहीं िकया था उनके नाम पुष्पें द्रपुत्र फेरू िसह, पुष्पें द्रपुत्र जगदीश, उमाशंकर, बृजेश कठेिरया, आनंद है एक का नाम ध्या न नहीं है। जहाँ तहरीर िलखायी जा रही थी वहाँ पर रामऋिष मौजूद थे। उस समय मैंने व रामऋिष ने आठ मुिल्ज मान के अलावा अन्य के नाम नहीं बताए थे। मैं मृतक शशी का खास साला हूँ। दशमेश के कत्ल के तीन साल बाद मैंने हािजर अदालत मुिल्ज मान योगेश आिद के िखलाफ 307 आई पी सी का मुकदमा िलखाया था। िशवकेंद्र द्वा रा तहरीर वादी थाना िशकोहाबाद कोतवाली में बैठकर िलखी गई थी। तहरीर वादी लगभग बारह साढ़े बारह बजे िलखी गई थी। उससे पहले मेरी थाना अध्य क्षिशकोहाबाद व अन्य पुिलस किमयों से मुलाकात हो चुकी थी। थाना अध्य क्षने कहा था िक थाना चलो हम बताते हैं िरपोटर् कैसे िलखी जाती है।"
He had stated that after the fire was extinguished he and other persons had gone to the police station. He had stated that he had parked his car on the opposite side of the road where the incident had taken place. He had also stated that Ram Rishi when had escaped from the car had hidden himself behind a patel. He had stated that he had stayed at the Thana till 03:00 PM. He had also stated, upon a question being put as to when the firing had started, that even before he had reached, the firing had started. The relevant portion of the statement is being reproduced here as under:
"मेरे घटना स्थ ल पर पहुँ चने से पहले फायिरग शुरू हो चुकी थी। मुझे नहीं मालूम इस घटना में िकतने फायर हुए थे।"
He had stated that in the Verito car he had not recognized the accused sitting therein and also no test identification parade was done with regard to those accused persons. The names of those accused were told to him by Ram Rishi. He had stated that when he had come out of his car, Shashi had already escaped from the Indica Car and had run towards the bhatta (brick kiln). When the firing was being done he had not seen Shashi inside the car. Instead he had seen him running away from the car. He had however seen that Ram Rishi was hiding behind a patel. The relevant portion of the statement is being reproduced here as under :-
"मैं गाड़़़़ी से उतरा तब तक शशी अपनी गाड़़़़ी से उतरकर भट्टा की ओर भागने लगे थे। जब मैंने उतरकर देखा तो शशी भट्टे तक पहुँ च गए थे। गोली चलते समय मैंने शशी को कार में नहीं देखा बिल्क भागते देखा। मैंने पहली बार देखा। तब शशी भट्टे के नजदीक थे। िकतना नजदीक थे यह नहीं बता सकता। यह भी नहीं बता सकता िक कार से िकतनी दूर थे। मैं नहीं बता सकता िक जब मैंने देखा तब शशी खारजा भट्टा से िकतनी दूर थे। मैं यह भी नहीं बता सकता िक वह दूसरे भट्टे से िकतने दूर थे।"
He had stated that on the date of incident, he had gone at the place of incident, thana and the hospital but he had not made his signature on any of the documents, whatsoever. In the cross-examination he had clearly stated that he was the sala (brother-in-law) of Shashi Kumar and therefore he used to respect Shashi Kumar a lot. The relevant portion of the statement is being reproduced here as under :-
"घटना वाले िदन मैं घटना स्थ ल पर रहा, थाना गया व अस्प ताल गया लेिकन िकसी भी कायर्वाही पर मेरे हस्ता क्षर नहीं हुए। ………………. शशी कुमार को मेरी सगी बहन ब्या ही है। बहन से मेरे अच्छे संबंध है। भाई के नाते दु खद थे उसकी मदद करता था। बहनोई शशी कुमार भी मेरा बहु त स म्मा न करते थे।"
PW-4 was the Constable (Clerk) Udayveer Singh who had proven the G.D. and the chik and he had stated that the police report was sent after two days. He had stated that he was not aware as to where the F.I.R. was kept since 03.07.2012 to 05.07.2012. He had also stated that the Magistrate had seen the report on 05.07.2012 only.
PW-5 is Dr. Ram Asre Sudhakar and he had done the post-mortem of Shashi Kumar. The injuries as were found on the dead-body are being reproduced here as under and they had found mentioned in the postmortem report:
"मृत्यु पूवर् चोटे-
1.आग्ने य अस्त्र प्रवेश घाव 1½ x ½ cm X आर पार (Through & Through) जो िक बांये जबड़़़़े के नीचे था कािलमा मौजूद थी िकनारे फटे हुये एवं अन्द र की तरफ घुसे हुये थे।
2.चोट नं0 1 का िनकासी घाव 6 X 6 cm X (Through & Through) आर पार जो िक दांयी कनपटी पर था इसके िकनारे बाहर की तरफ मु ड़़़़े हुये थे।
3.आग्ने य अस्त्र का प्रवेश घाव 1.50 X 1.50 cm X आर पार (Through & Through) जो िक मुंह के बांयी तरफ था इसके िकनारे भरे हुये एवं अन्द र की तरफ मुड़़़़े हुये थे कािलमा मौजूद थी। (Blacking)
4.घाव नम्ब र 3 का िनकासी घाव नं0 2 से कनै क्टे ड़़़था।
5.आग्ने यअस्त्र का प्रवेश घाव 1.50 X 1.50 cm cavity deep जो िक बांयी छाती में िन प्प ल से 5 cm अन्द र की तरफ 9 O, clock पोजीशन पर था ब्लै किनग मौजूद थी।
6.आग्ने यअस्त्र का प्रवेश घाव 1.50 X 1.50 cm X आर पार (Through & Through) जो िक पेट के िनचले िहस्से में हड़़़्ड़़़ी के ऊपर था इसके िकनारे फटे एवं आन्त िरक मु ड़़़़ हुये थी कािलमा मौजूद थी।
7.घाव नं० छः िनकासी घाव पेट के दांयी तरफ बीच में मौजूद था।
8.आग्ने यअस्त्र का प्रवेश घाव 1.50 X 1.50 cm X आर पार (Through & Through) जो बांयी छाती के िनिप्प ल के 6 cm नीचे था। इसके िकनारे अन्द र की तरफ मु ड़़़़े हुये व फटे हुये थे कािलमा मौजूद थी।
9.आग्ने य अस्त्र घाव 4 X 4 cm X आर पार (Through & Through) जो िक दांये क न्धे के ऊपरी तरफ था। जो िक ऊपर वाली बांयी चोट से कनै क्टैं ड़़़थी।
10.आग्ने य अस्त्र का प्रवेश घाव 1.50 X 1.50cm X आर पार (Through & Through) जो िक पेट के िनचले िहस्से में टुन्ड़़़ी से 7 से० मी० नीचे था इसके िकनारे अन्द र की तरफ मु ड़़़़े हुये थे। कािलमा मौजूद थी।
11.उक्त चोट का िनकासी घाव 4 X 4cm X आर पार (Through & Through) जो िक पीठ के मध्य में था।"
Similarly, he had also done the post-mortem of Ravi Kumar and his injuries were also proven by him. The injuries are being reproduced here as under:
"उसीिदन मेरे द्वा रा शाम ड़़़े ढ़बजे िदनांक 04.07.12 के मृतक रिव कुमार उम्र लगभग 37 साल पुत्र श्री रघुवीर िसह िनवासी नगला लेखराज थाना िसरसागंज िफरोजाबाद िजसके शव को कान्स टेिबल 904 उदयवीर िसह 934 सूरजपाल (कां0 904 उदय वीर िसह कां0 934 सूरजपाल) थाना िशकोहाबाद शव लेकर आये थे िजसके शव का मेरे द्वा रा पोस्ट माटर्म िकया गया था। शव िवच्छे दन के समय शव की िन म्न िस्थ त पायी गई।
वाह्य परीक्षण -
मृतक का शव बुरी तरह से जला हुआ था तथा खोपड़ी पेट एवं छाती खुल गये थे जलने से। दोनों आँखें बन्द थीं, जो बाहर की तरफ निकली हुई थीं, कान, नाक, मुँह, गुदा बुरी तरह से जले हुये थे।
आन्तरिक परीक्षण -
खोपड़ी की हड्डियाँ टूटी हुई थीं, खोपड़ी का बाहरी हिस्सा बुरी तरह जला हुआ था, छाती जली हुई थीं, Soot Particles (शूट कप) श्वास नली में मौजूद थे, दोनों फेफड़े बुरी तरह जले हुये थे। हृदय की झिल्ली जली हुई थीं, दोनों चिम्बर खाली थे और जले हुये थे। पेट की भित्तियाँ जली हुई थीं, एवं पेट की केविटी खुली हुई थीं। दाँत 12 by 14 थे, आमाशय छोटी आंत, बड़ी आंत, लीवर, तिल्ली दोनों गुर्दे जले हुये थे और मूत्राशय खाली था, जनन के अंग बुरी तरह जले हुये थे।
कपड़े - रिस्ट वाच एक, मोबाइल एक,
मृतक के शव का X Ray कराया गया था (Plat no. R-6010 जिसके अनुसार कई एक मिटेलिक (माइनर) शैडोज थी। अत्यधिक प्रयास करने के बावजूद कोई भी मिटेलिक वस्तु रिकवर्ड नहीं की जा सकी।
संलग्नक - संलग्नक दस थे जिनको देखकर पुलिस को सौंप दिया था।
मेरी राय में मृतक की मृत्यु मृत्यु पूर्व जलने से शोक में जाने से होना सम्भव है।
पत्रावली में कागज संख्या 7 अ/2 पी एम आर मेरे लेख व हस्ताक्षर में है जिसकी मैं शिनाख्त करता हूँ। जिस पर ईकज क-11 डाला गया।
He had also done the post-mortem of Ram Rishi and his injuries were also proven by him and they are being reproduced here as under :
"उसी दिनांक 04.07.12 समय 2:10 बजे शाम को उसी दिन मैंने मृतक रमेश उग्र लगभग 55 साल पुत्र श्री सुबेदार सिंह निवासी नगला जोखार थाना घिरोर के जिला मैनपुरी के शव को कं0 904 उदयवीर सिंह एवं कं0 934 सुरजपाल थाना शिकोहाबाद अनशील्ड अवस्था में लेकर आये थे। मृतक के शव का शव विच्छेदन करके मैंने निम्नवत रिपोर्ट तैयार की थी।
वाह्य परीक्षण - दोनों आँखें अपशेन्ट थीं, कान, नथने मुख गुदा बुरी तरह से जले हुये थे। मृतक का शरीर बुरी तरह से जला हुआ था, एडविनल केविटी एवं चेस्ट केविटी खुली हुई थी। खोपड़ी की सारी हड्डियाँ जलने से टूट गई थीं, दिमाग की झिल्लियाँ एवं दिमाग जला हुआ था, दोनों फेफड़े एवं उनकी झिल्लियाँ जले हुये थे, हृदय एवं हृदय की झिल्ली जली हुई थीं, श्वास नली में शूट पार्टीकल्स मौजूद थे। उदर की भित्तियाँ जली हुई थीं। एवं उदर गुहा खुली हुई थीं, दाँत मौजूद नहीं थे, आमाशय, छोटी आंत, बड़ी आंत, लीवर, तिल्ली एवं दोनों गुर्दे जले हुये थे, मूत्राशय खाली थे, जनन अंग जले हुये थे।
मृतक के शरीर का एक्स रे कराया गया था जिसकी प्लेट नम्बर 6009 मिटेलिक शैडोज दर्शायी गई है, अत्यधिक प्रयास करने के बावजूद भी मृतक के शरीर से कोई भी मिटेलिक वस्तु नहीं प्राप्त की जिसकी। रेडियोलोजिस्ट की रिपोर्ट एवं एक्स रे रिपोर्ट पुलिस को हैण्ड ओवर कर दिये गये थे।
कपड़े - कपड़े निल थे। कोई कपड़ा मृतक के शरीर पर मौजूद नहीं था
संलग्नक - संलग्नक दस थे जिनको देख कर पुलिस को सौंप दिये गये थे। मेरी राय में मृतक की मृत्यु मृत्यु पूर्व जलने के द्वारा शॉक (सदमा) जाने से हुई संभव है। समय लगभग एक दिन पूर्व पत्रावली में कागज संख्या 7 अ/1 पी एम आर मेरे लेख व हस्ताक्षर में है। जिसकी मैं शिनाख्त करता हूँ। जिस पर इंकज क- 12 डाला गया।”
PW-6 was the Police Personnel (Clerk) Deepak who had proven the chik etc. of the Arms Act.
PW-7 was S.H.O. Sri Satya Pal Singh in whose presence the panchayatnama was drawn. He had stated that the panchayatnama had taken place at the place of incident.
PW-8, Dr. Santosh Kumar Gupta, is the radiologist and he stated the manner in which he had done the ex-ray.
PW-9, Ramesh Chandra Arya, is the constable, who scribed the FIR with regard to the Arms Act.
PW-10, Sri Ranvir Singh, was the Head Constable who had done the technical inspection of the two vehicles, namely, the Bolero having number U.P.83 W 8238 and the Indica Car having number 83 M 4311 (there is no number of Indica car in the statement of P.W.-10). He had very confidently stated that in the Bolero Car, there was no damage. Only the bumper and the show grill placed in front of the bumper were slightly compressed. Light and the indicator were damaged. There was no sign of any smoke in the Bolero. Also, the bumper and the grill were not burnt. Also, the tyres of the Bolero U.P. 83 W 8386 was not deflated. There was no damage whatsoever to the tyres.
PW-11, Sri Jaivir Singh, is the police official who had made the recovery under the Arms Act.
PW-12, Sri Dalvir Singh, is the Head Constable. He was also the person who had proven the chick of the Arms Act.
PW-13, Sri Ram Babu Pathak, is the Sub Inspector. He was also the Investigating Officer under the Arms Act.
PW-14, Sri R.P. Chaudhary, was also the Investigating Officer with regard to the Arms Act.
PW-15, Mohd. Abid Khan was the Investigating Officer who had arrested Uma Shankar, Pushpendra, Brijesh Katariya and Yogesh and had also remained the Investigating Officer in one of the cases under the Arms Act.
PW-16, Constable Rajeev Kumar, was also a police official who had done the Investigation with regard to one of the country made pistol.
PW-17, Suresh Veer Singh, is the Investigating Officer in the Case Crime No. 333 of 2012 and had stated the manner in which he had got the information i.e. when the village pradhan Dharmendra Yadav from his mobile phone no. 9837500154 had rung up on his mobile number, he had stated that he was the one who had rung up the fire brigade and had upon reaching the place of incident found that there was one person burning in the front seat of the car i.e. on the driving seat and one person was on fire in the back seat. The relevant portion of the statement in chief of the Investigating Officer is being reproduced :-
"मैं तत्का ल जीप से सायरन व हूटर का इस्ते माल करता हुआ सीकोहाबाद मैनपुरी रोड़़़ पर ग्रा म मा ढ़ई से आगे घटना स्थ ल पर पहुँ चा तो एक इंिड़़़ का कार िसलेटी रंग की, िजसका मुँह सीकोहाबाद की तरफ था, में आग जल रही थी और उक्त गाड़़़़ी को एक आदमी ड़़़्रा इिवग सीट पर तथा दूसरा आदमी पीछे की सीट पर जल रहे थे।"
He had also noted the presence of the Bolero car which had collided with the Indica Car and had found that it was stationed opposite the Indica Car in which only the main shaft was broken. In the rest of his examination-in-chief and in the cross-examination, he had only narrated the manner in which the investigation had taken place. In the cross-examination, he had tried to be consistent with what he had stated in the examination-in-chief. At page 342, however, he had stated about the ownerships of the vehicles which were recovered. With regard to U.P. 83 W 8238 Bolero car, he had stated that it belonged to Bhuvnesh Kumar. The other Bolero car which had come from behind the Indica car and Maruti car and was having registration number as U.P. 83 V 8981 belonged to Kuldeep @ Bhola, U.P. 83 M 4311, the indica car, belonged to the deceased Ravi Kumar and the Verito car with registration number U.P. 84 L 5006 belonged to the accused Uma Shankar.
The PW-18 is the Head Constable Dalveer Singh. He was also an Investigating Officer in the case which was registered under the Arms Act.
Thereafter the statements of the accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C. were recorded. The testimonies of certain defence witnesses were also recorded during the course of the trial.
DW-1, Dharmendra Pradhan, who, as per his own statement and that of P.W.-17 was the person who had informed the police with regard to the incident. he had stated in his examination-in-chief that when he was present at the place of incident at around 10:30 P.M., no relative of the deceased was present. He also had stated that the Bolero vehicle was not present and that only the burning Indica car was present; no vehicle was parked opposite it.
D.W.-2, D.W.-3, D.W.-4 and D.W.-5 have tried to prove the alibi of Yogesh, who was also a police personnel. The defence witnesses were also police personnel. They had tried to establish that Yogesh was posted at Mathura and, therefore, it was not possible for him to be present at the place of incident.
Thereafter, upon the completion of the trial and the recording of the evidence, the court of Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 2, Firozabad, on 22.2.2018, found the appellants guilty under Sections 147, 148, 307/149, 302/149 and 435 IPC and Section 7 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act.
Various criminal appeals were thereafter filed. The Criminal Appeal No. 1685 of 2018 was filed by Ketan @ Monu Upadhyay and was argued by Sri S.D.S. Jadaun; Criminal Appeal No. 2205 of 2018 was filed by Abran Singh @ Ahivaran Singh and was argued by Sri Ziya Uddin; Criminal appeal No. 3271 of 2019 was filed by Satyaveer Singh and was argued by Sri Yogesh Kumar Srivastava and Sri Noor Mohammad; Criminal Appeal No. 1752 of 2018 was filed by Pushpendra Yadav and Anand and was argued by Sri Shivam Yadav and Sri Akhilesh Singh; Criminal Appeal No. 1998 of 2018 was filed by Yogesh @ Yogesh Babu and was argued by Sri Rajrshi Gupta; Criminal Appeal No. 2090 of 2018 was filed by Munna @ Nitij and was argued by A.C.Srivastava, Ajay Kumar,Manish Chand Umrao ; Criminal Appeal No. 2886 of 2018 was filed by Bhuvnesh @ Lakkhi and was argued by Rajrshi Gupta ; Government Appeals No. 330 of 2025 and 329 of 2025 were filed by the State of U.P. and a Criminal Misc. Application U/s 372 Cr.P.C. (Leave to Appeal) No. 142 of 2018 was filed by Madhu Yadav and was argued by Apul Mishra, learned Senior Counsel and was assisted by Sri Harish Chandra Pratap.
Learned counsel for the appellants in the various appeals have argued that the incident which had taken place on 3.7.2012 was such an incident which could have been proved only by independent eye witnesses. This the prosecution was very well aware of.
Under such circumstances, they produced, as witnesses of fact, three witnesses. P.W.-1, Abhishek Kumar, was the first informant and he had got the FIR lodged. Ram Rishi, the P.W.-2, was also a witness of fact and it was the case of the prosecution that he was sitting in the Indica Car in which the deceased Ravi, Shashi and Ramesh Chandra were also traveling. The case of the prosecution was that there was a murder case in which the persons sitting in the Indica Car, namely, Ravi and Shashi were the accused and, therefore, to attend that case at Farrukhabad they started from Mainpuri and were heading towards Farrukhabad. At around 10:00AM, while the car was in village Mohabbatpur Madhai, a Bolero Car with a registration number UP 83 W 8238 came from the side of Farrukhabad and collided with the Indica Car in which Ravi, Shashi, Ramesh Chandra and Ram Rishi were travelling. The further case of the prosecution was that all the accused - appellants after having managed to stop the Indica Car came out of their Bolero vehicle and started shooting the occupants with firearms they were carrying. While the person sitting in the front i.e Ravi and Ramesh Chandra could not escape, Ram Rishi and Shashi escaped from the car. However, while escaping, Shashi was shot at in a manner wherein the injuries were such that he died. Now, to prove that the accused had, in fact, attacked on the deceased, the prosecution witnesses had come forward with their version. Learned counsel to establish that the witnesses of fact were not there at teh spot had come up with the instances to indicate how there were contradictions in the statements of teh witnesses. He had stated that the P.W.-2 had stated that the two occupants of the back seat i.e. Shashi and Ram Rishi had escaped on two different directions. As per him i.e. PW-2 while Shashi had escaped after opening the door on the northern side, P.W.-2 had escaped after opening the door on the southern side. Learned counsel had stated that this was in contradistinction to the statement made by the PW1 who had very categorically stated that he had seen, from the car parked behind the Indica car, that both P.W.-2 Ram Rishi and Shashi had escaped from the same side i.e. the northern side.
The PW-1, in his evidence had stated that he was coming in another Maruti Car which was following the Indica Car in which the three deceased and Ram Rishi were seated. From behind, the Indica Car and Maruti Car, another Bolero had come and this Bolero was carrying Monu, Munna, Vikas and one more person and the Bolero which had hit the Indica Car was carrying Yogesh, Bhunesh, Ahirvan and Bhola. After having managed to stop the Indica car, the prosecution had come up with a story that all 8 persons had come out of their two Bolero car and had started shooting at the occupants of the Indica car. To prove that the prosecution case was concocted and false, learned counsel argued that, in fact, the witnesses of fact PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3 were not present at the place of incident at all. To establish this fact, learned counsel for the appellants further tried to point out various discrepancies in the evidence led by the PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3. The PW-1 had stated that Ravi was the driver of the Indica car and Ramesh Chandra was sitting beside him in the front seat while PW-2 was sitting behind Ramesh Chandar and Shashi was sitting behind the drivers seat. This was a story which is very different from the one which was narrated by the PW-2 who had stated that it was Ravi who was driving car and Ramesh Chandra was sitting beside and at the back seat Shashi was sitting behind Ramesh Chandra and PW-2 was sitting behind Ravi.
What is more, learned counsel for the appellants further stated that even in the statement with regard as to how the fire was extinguished, there were discrepancies. The PW-1 stated that a fire brigade had come at the site to extinguish the fire. The PW-2 had stated that the crowd which had collected had extinguished the fire by mud and water.
Still further, to bring to the fore the discrepancies, learned counsel for the appellant had stated that PW-1 had stated that both the occupants of the back seat of the Indica car i.e. Shashi and PW-2 had come out of the car from the door of the car on the northern side while the PW-2 had stated that while Ravi had got out on the northern side, the PW-2 had got down from southern side. To add to the confusion, the Investigating Officer had stated that when he had gone to the site he had found that one burnt dead body was there on the back seat and one dead body which was again totally burnt was on the driver's seat. This was an absolutely different story from what the PW-1, PW-2 and PW -3 had told. Learned counsel for the appellants, therefore, states that in fact the PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3 were not there on the spot and they had only created evidence by saying that they were there and had tried to come up with a case that they were eye-witnesses.
Still further learned counsel for the appellants had stated that the DW-1 had stated that when he had gone on the site then no person of the family of the deceased was there at the site and, therefore, he was the person who had actually rung up the police and this fact was also corroborated by the PW-17 who had stated that it was the DW-1 who had actually informed the police. Learned counsel had stated that had a discrepency of this sort been committed by just one of them then the implication would have been different but when three eye witnesses were coming up with three different stories and when none of them matached with what the Investigating Officer had seen, then definitely the contradiction had to be taken seriously.
The next argument which the learned counsel for the appellants have submitted is that the FIR was ante-timed. Learned counsel for the appellants has stated that the chick if is seen it would be evident that the FIR was lodged on 3.7.2012 at 12:25 PM. However, if the statements of the various witnesses of fact are seen then we find that at page 152 of the paper book, the P.W.-1 had stated that after 12:00 noon, he had remained at the police station for 2 to 3 hours more. Learned counsel for the appellants states that there was absolutely no requirement for the PW-1 to have stayed at the police station for 2 to 3 hours more after the actual lodging of the FIR at 12:25 PM. To corroborate the statement of the PW-1, the PW-2, at page 171 of the paper book, had stated that the Tehrir was scribed in two stages. First, it was written at the Shikohabad police station and, thereafter, the Station House Officer had taken the PW-1 and PW-2 to the place of incident and thereafter the entire Tehrir was scribed. Further the PW-2 had stated that when the Tehrir was actually completed, the time could be anything from 5:00 PM to 5:30 PM. This fact also gets corroborated by the statement of the PW-1 who had stated that he had stayed at the police station for 3 more hours after the lodging of the FIR.
Still further, at page 180 of the paper book, the PW-2 had stated that he had sat at the police station till 5:00PM to 5:30 PM and that Abhishek Kumar and Shiv Kendra (scribe) and the brother of PW-1 were also there at the police station. Learned counsel for the appellants, therefore, states that, in fact, the PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3 were not aware as to who was the actual accused and after much thinking and application of mind the persons who were inimical to them and against whom criminal cases were being fought in the criminal court at Farrukhabad were named as accused in the case.
Learned counsel for the appellants further states that as per the FIR the Bolero vehicle which had come from the side of Farrukhabad had collided with the Indica car which was carrying Yogesh, Bhuvnesh, Evaran and Bhola and the Bolero vehicle which had come from behind the Indica and Maruti and the number of which had never been disclosed was carrying 6 persons, namely, Monu @ Ketan, Munna @ Nitin, Satyaveer, Vikas and 2 other persons whose names the first informant was not knowing but later on he came to know that they were Pushpendra Yadav and Anand. Learned counsel for the appellants states that even though in the FIR, there was mention only of two vehicles from which various persons came out, PW-1 and PW-2 had further improved their case and had stated that one more car of the make of Verito had come at the place of incident and from it Yogesh, Brijesh Katiyar, Uma Shankar, Pushpendra Yadav son of Feru Singh had emerged.
Learned counsel for the appellants states that initially 8 persons were named in the FIR and it was stated that the names of two were not known. However, subsequently the prosecution itself had stated that the arrested accused persons were shown to them in jail and, therefore, they had come to know about them and were mentioning their names in the court for the first time. He states that no test identification parade was ever done and, therefore, the entire prosecution vis-a-vis at least the two unnamed persons became false.
Learned counsel for the appellants further has stated that the medical evidence was, in fact, very different from what the ocular evidence had suggested. All the witnesses had stated that Shashi was shot at from behind but the post mortem report which had been proven by the Prosecution Witness-8, Dr. Santosh Kumar Gupta indicated that all the bullets which had entered the deceased Shashi were from the front. What is more, it was always stated that while Shashi was running out from the northern side and was trying to save his life, the shooting vis-a-vis Shashi had taken from a distance of 30 to 35 feet but, in fact, all the injuries which were to be found on the front side of the body of Shashi were all having blackening and tattooing, suggesting that it was fired from a very close range.
What is more, learned counsel for the appellants has further argued that if the evidence is weighed in the manner it was brought then also the prosecution case gets falsified. If the accident inspection reports which are exhibited as Exhibit - Ka-44 and Ka-45, are seen then learned counsel submits that it can be found that the Indica car was travelling at around a speed of 60 kms. and Bolero was speeding at a velocity of almost 80 kms per hour. He states that if that had been the case and if both the cars had collided and if there was only an intention of the occupants of Bolero to only stop the car without applying brake then there would have been actual damage to the Bolero car. In the instant case, he states that there was no damage caused to the Bolero car other than the breaking of the shaft which can happen even without an accident. There was absolutely no other damage of any importance. Still further, he has argued that if the Indica car was burning in the manner it had been shown to have been burnt at the place then definitely there would have been marks of burn also on the Bolero vehicle. The Bolero vehicle also ran on inflammable fuel and if a car which had rammed into, it had burnt then definitely the fire would have got transferred to the Bolero vehicle as well and it would have also started burning. In the instant case, he states that there was absolutely no burn marks on the Bolero. What is more, he states that the headlight etc. which was broken could have been so broken by the prosecution itself so that it could come out with a false / planted case.
Learned counsel for the appellants states that in the instant case the cars as per the RTO reports which was mentioned by the P.W.17 in his statement in the Court belong to the accused. The car UP 83 W 8238 Bolero car belonged to Bhuvnesh Kumar. This was the car which had met with an accident with the Indica car U.P. 83 V 8981 which had come from behind the Bolero car was of the accused Kuldeep and U.P. 84 L 5006 the Verito car belonged to the accused Uma Shankar. He, therefore, stated that a question arose as to how when the cars of the accused were, involved, the accused could wriggle out of the case. He submitted that when the cars were being used by the accused persons then definitely it was their responsibility to explain as to how the cars reached there. To explain this, learned counsel for the appellants stated that the fact of the matter was that all the three cars were planted. The Verito car and the car which came from behind were used to escape and, therefore, it was not certain whether they were there at all and that they might have been later on captured and made case property. However, so far as the vehicle number U.P. 83 W 8238 was concerned, learned counsel submitted it was also somehow planted. Learned counsel submitted that the recovery memo of these cars was exhibit as ka-6 and this was signed by the PW-2 Ram Rishi and his son Nandlal. The PW-2 in his statement before the Court had stated at page 177 that he had not signed the recovery memos, exhibit ka-2 to ka-6 and that he was made to sign on them on the next date. Learned counsel for the appellants, therefore, states that the recovery of the Bolero car which was apparent through the recovery memo exhibited as ka-6 became an absolutely sham recovery. He stated that the recovery definitely did not take place from the place of incident and, therefore, no explanation was required from the side of the appellants to explain as to how their cars had reached there. Normally, he states what happens is that after a person is arrested his entire house becomes open for the police to ransack and if the Bolero of the accused persons was taken away from the house and planted at the place of incident then the accused had absolutely no connection with the planted car, even if the same was theirs.
Still further learned counsel for the appellants states that the signature on the police report of the Magistrate when he had received the same on 5.7.2012 which was with regard to the FIR lodged on 3.7.2012, then there was definitely a delay of 48 hours. This also, he submitted, showed that the FIR was ante-timed. The police and the informant side had much thought over the entire case and had placed the accused in the FIR after having concocted the entire case against them.
On the other hand, learned Additional Government Advocate supporting the impugned judgment and order of conviction passed by the learned trial court submitted that :
The prosecution has successfully established the guilt of the appellants beyond all reasonable doubt through a cogent, continuous and unassailable chain of direct ocular, medical, and documentary evidence. He contended that the learned trial court has meticulously analyzed the entire record, properly appreciated the statements of the eyewitnesses, and arrived at a well-reasoned conclusion which calls for no interference by this Court in the present appeals.
Abhishek Kumar (PW-1), Ram Rishi (PW-2), and Udayveer Singh (PW-3) are natural and truthful eyewitnesses, whose presence at the scene of the occurrence at the time of incident is fully established. He argued that the minor variations regarding seating arrangements inside the Indica car or the exact direction taken while fleeing under a rain of bullets are natural, given the terror and panic created by an armed ambush involving fourteen assailants. He submitted that a person fleeing for his life cannot be expected to remember exact details. He further submitted that PW-2 himself sustained injuries during the incident, and under the settled law, an injured witness stands on a higher footing of credibility, whose presence cannot be doubted. The testimony of Village Pradhan (DW-1) is merely a defence - sponsored attempt to dilute the prosecution case and cannot override the sworn testimony of eye-witnesses, who survived a deadly assault.
Medical evidence fully corroborates the ocular narrative. He argued that when assailants surround a victim and fired indiscriminately while the victim was trying to escape, gunshot entry wounds can naturally occur on the front as well as the side of the body, along with blackening and tattooing (kalima). He submitted that the eyewitnesses clearly deposed that the assailants chased Shashi Kumar and fired upon him at close range when he was cornered near the brick kiln (bhatta). Therefore, the presence of close-range entry wounds on the face and chest is in total harmony with the ocular account, and the medical opinion of Dr. PW-5 does not contradict the core sequence of events.
FIR was not ante-timed or deliberated upon. He submitted that the incident took place around 10:30 AM, and the FIR was promptly lodged at 12:25 PM on the very same day at Police Station Shikohabad, which was situated at a distance from the remote spot.
Mention of eight named accused and two unknown persons in the initial FIR was based on the immediate observation of the informant in a state of extreme shock. During investigation, as the full extent of the conspiracy unfolded, the involvement of fourteen accused persons and three vehicles including the Verito car came to light. He argued that the law does not require every detail or vehicle number to be recorded in the initial FIR. Regarding the absence of a Test Identification Parade (TIP), he submitted that the appellants were well known to the witnesses prior to the incident due to ongoing litigation and regional acquaintance. Therefore, a formal TIP was unnecessary in law, and the substantive identification of the accused made by the eyewitnesses before the trial court is completely valid, legal, and binding.
The Bolero was used by the assailants to ram into the Indica car and block its path. Once the Indica car was brought to a halt and set on fire by pouring petrol, the assailants abandoned their vehicle at a safe distance on the side of the road to avoid damage from the fire. He submitted that Head Constable Ranvir Singh (PW-10) noted mechanical damage to the front bumper, show grill, and radiator shaft, which clearly proves a high-impact collision. The fact that the tires of the Bolero did not catch fire merely shows that the vehicle was standing away from the direct flames of the burning Indica, and this physical fact completely supports the prosecution narrative rather than disproving it.
The search and recovery memos (Exhibits Ka-2 to Ka-6) were prepared in strict compliance with procedural requirements. He argued that the recovery of burnt ash, cartridges, weapons, driving licenses, and the Bolero vehicle were made directly from the spot and in pursuance of the disclosure statements of the accused. He submitted that the signature of Ram Rishi (PW-2) on the recovery memos is admitted. The contention that signatures were obtained subsequently is merely a result of pressure or confusion during cross-examination which was conducted after a lapse of several months after the incident. He urged that minor procedural irregularities committed by the investigating agency during seizure cannot wash away the hard physical recoveries made from the spot, and the recovery memos fully satisfy the statutory mandate under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act.
The trial court committed no error of law or fact in convicting and sentencing the appellants. He prayed that all the criminal appeals filed by the accused be dismissed and their convictions be upheld, while the Government Appeals may be allowed.
We have considered the rival submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the entire record including the impugned judgment and order and the case laws relied upon by the parties carefully. After meticulously evaluating the oral as well as documentary evidence brought on record, we are of the view that for a comprehensive and just adjudication of the case, the core issues to be determined are :
(1). Whether the prosecution eyewitnesses, Abhishek Kumar (PW-1), Ram Rishi (PW-2), and Udayveer Singh (PW-3) are natural, sterling witnesses whose presence at the scene of crime at the time of incident is established beyond resonable doubt, or whether their testimonies are vitiated by fatal material contradictions, unnatural conduct, and station-house tutoring ?
(2). Whether the ocular version regarding the manner, direction, and range of the gunshot assault upon deceased Shashi Kumar is completely falsified by, and irreconcilable with, the medical and post-mortem findings (Ex. Ka-10) proven by Dr. Ram Asre Sudhakar (PW-5) ?
(3). Whether the First Information Report was ante-timed and lodged after post-event consultations, and whether the unexplained 48-hour delay in its transmission to the jurisdictional Magistrate is fatal to the prosecution case?
(4). Whether the material embellishments and improvements from the initial FIR, specifically the introduction of a third vehicle (Verito car) and an inflated array of 14 accused instead of 8 named and 2 unknowns, coupled with the total absence of a Test Identification Parade (TIP), vitiate the conviction of the appellants ?
(5). Whether the physical, mechanical and forensic condition of the recovered Bolero car (UP-83-W 8238), showing zero burn damage, unburnt bumpers, and fully inflated tires despite a claimed head-on collision scientifically proves that the collision narrative and vehicle recovery were fabricated and planted ? and
(6). Whether the search and recovery memos (Exhibits Ka-2 to Ka-6) under Section 25/27 of the Arms Act can be legally relied upon in light of the unequivocal admission by prosecution witness PW-2 that his signatures were extracted ex-post-facto on the following day without contemporaneous execution on the spot ?
Now we proceed to analyze the aforesaid issues sequentially on the touchstone of facts, evidence, established law and binding precedents.
So far as the ISSUE NO.1 is concerned, we have given our profound consideration to the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the appellants and the learned Additional Government Advocate representing the State, while closely evaluating the depositions of the prosecution witnesses of fact on record. The foundational premise of any criminal prosecution resting upon charges of murder requires that the ocular witnesses produced by the prosecution must pass the rigorous test of sterling quality, unblemished creditworthiness and absolute consistency. In the instant case, the prosecution heavily relied upon the testimonies of Abhishek Kumar (PW-1), who claims to have been following the victims / deceased vehicle in a separate Maruti car, Ram Rishi (PW-2), who claims to have been an occupant sitting inside the Indica car bearing registration number UP-83-M-4311 and Udayveer Singh (PW-3), who similarly asserts his presence in the trailing vehicle. However, upon subjecting their depositions to a judicial scrutiny, we find that their claimed ocular presence is undermined by a series of irreconcilable contradictions, discrepancies and fatal admissions of police tutoring that strike at the very root of the prosecution's case.
The legal benchmark governing the appreciation of eyewitness testimony, particularly in cases involving pre-existing enmity and multiple accused, has been authoritatively delineated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the landmark ruling of Rai Sandeep @ Deepu v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2012) 8 SCC 21, wherein the Apex Court propounded the doctrine of a "sterling witness" in paragraph 22 of the report, observing as under:
"22.In our considered opinion, the "sterling witness" should be of a very high quality and calibre whose version should, therefore, be unassailable. The court considering the version of such witness should be in a position to accept it for its face value without any hesitation. To test the quality of such a witness, the status of the witness would be immaterial and what would be relevant is the truthfulness of the statement made by such a witness. What would be more relevant would be the consistency of the statement right from the starting point till the end, namely, at the time when the witness makes the initial statement and ultimately before the court. It should be natural and consistent with the case of the prosecution qua the accused. There should not be any prevarication in the version of such a witness. The witness should be in a position to withstand the cross-examination of any length and howsoever strenuous it may be and under no circumstance should give room for any doubt as to the factum of the occurrence, the persons involved, as well as the sequence of it. Such a version should have co-relation with each and every one of other supporting material such as the recoveries made, the weapons used, the manner of offence committed, the scientific evidence and the expert opinion. The said version should consistently match with the version of every other witness. It can even be stated that it should be akin to the test applied in the case of circumstantial evidence where there should not be any missing link in the chain of circumstances to hold the accused guilty of the offence alleged against him. Only if the version of such a witness qualifies the above test as well as all other such similar tests to be applied, can it be held that such a witness can be called as a "sterling witness" whose version can be accepted by the court without any corroboration and based on which the guilty can be punished. To be more precise, the version of the said witness on the core spectrum of the crime should remain intact while all other attendant materials, namely, oral, documentary and material objects should match the said version in material particulars in order to enable the court trying the offence to rely on the core version to sieve the other supporting materials for holding the offender guilty of the charge alleged."
This principle was further reinforced in Amar Singh v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2020) 19 SCC 165, wherein the Supreme Court emphatically ruled that variations relating to the prosecution narrative cannot be brushed aside as inconsequential minor discrepancies. The Apex Court held that where witnesses exhibit unnatural conduct during a sudden violent incident without taking any steps to protect the victims or save themselves as well as give contradictory account of the incident, their claimed presence becomes gravely suspect and cannot be accepted at face value.
The necessity for absolute harmony in ocular accounts has been again reiterated in recent jurisprudence. In Kannaiya v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 2025 SCC OnLine 2270, the Hon'ble Supreme Court set aside convictions holding that when the genesis and the manner of the incident are rendered doubtful by conflicting versions given by eyewitnesses regarding who was present, where they stood, and how they escaped, such versions cannot co-exist within a credible judicial narrative, thereby mandating the extension of the benefit of doubt to the accused.
Similarly, in the recent pronouncement of Ashok Upadhyay and Anr. v. The State of Bihar, 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1804, the Apex Court held that where related eyewitnesses exhibit a "ring of falsity," major omissions from police statements under Section 161 CrPC and evidence of premeditation to falsely implicate adversaries due to pre-existing village and political rivalry, their testimonies must be evaluated with extreme judicial caution and treated with absolute distrust.
When we examine the factual matrix of the present case in the light of these binding judicial precedents, the testimonies of PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3 disintegrate due internal contradictions. The first major contradiction appears in the irreconcilable descriptions of the seating arrangements inside the Indica car. Abhishek Kumar (PW-1) deposed in his examination-in-chief that Ravi Kumar was driving the Indica car, Ramesh Chandra was sitting beside him on the front passenger seat, and Shashi Kumar was sitting on the rear seat behind the driver. However, Ram Rishi (PW-2), who claims to have been seated inside the very same vehicle, gave a different and incompatible seating arrangement, testifying that while Ravi drove and Ramesh Chandra sat beside him in front, Shashi Kumar was sitting on the back seat behind Ramesh Chandra, and PW-2 himself was sitting behind the driver. Such a fundamental variance in describing the seating configuration of a small vehicle carrying four people demonstrates that these witnesses were not actually present in the vehicle at the time of the occurrence.
This inherent falsity is further compounded by their accounts regarding the escape of the survivors from the vehicle. In the initial First Information Report, it was categorically asserted that upon the Bolero ramming into the Indica car, Ram Rishi (PW-2) and Shashi Kumar managed to get out of the car and ran away in different directions but in cross-examination, PW-2, admitting on record that both he and deceased Shashi actually escaped from the same northern door and did not run in separate directions. An ocular narrative that contradicts its own foundational First Information Report on vital operational details loses all semblance of truth.
Most important is the explicit confession of Ram Rishi (PW-2) regarding police tutoring and fabrication. PW-2 admitted during his cross-examination that after the accused persons were apprehended, the police called him to the police station and informed him that 14 accused persons could not possibly be accommodated within two vehicles, and therefore instructed him that the prosecution case had to be structured around three vehicles. PW-2 expressly stated:
"जब मुिल्ज मान पक ड़़़़ेगए तब पुिलस ने मुझे बुलाया तब पता लगा िक घटना 8 ने नहीं 14 ने की है... पुिलस ने कहा 14 बदमाश दो गािड़़़़ यों में नहीं आ सकते, गािड़़़़ यां तीन रखनी पड़़़़ें गी। उसी िहसाब से मैंने आज तीन गािड़़़़ यां बताई है।"
This admission lays down the manufacturing of the prosecution case, wherein the entire framework of vehicles and accused numbers was staged by the investigating agency.
The fabrication of the eyewitnesses' presence is further sealed by the independent and official testimony on record. Dharmendra Pradhan (DW-1), the Village Pradhan of Mohabbatpur Madhai, who made the initial emergency call to the police and fire brigade, categorically deposed that when he reached the spot immediately after the incident at 10:30 AM, no relatives or family members of the deceased were present at the scene. This crucial circumstance is corroborated by the main Investigating Officer, Suresh Veer Singh (PW-17), who confirmed that upon receiving the telephonic information from the Pradhan and arriving at the burning car, no eyewitness relatives were found at the site.Thus, the presence of PW-1, PW-2, and PW-3 at the time of the incident is shrouded in doubt, their testimonies are riddled with fatal contradictions and their claims stand utterly discredited by independent official testimony. Consequently, Issue No. 1 is answered in the negative.
As regards ISSUE NO. 2 is concerned, from a perusal of the record it is clear that what the eyewitnesses said in court completely contradicts the actual medical evidence. It is a foundational principle of criminal law that while witness testimony is the main basis for establishing guilt, it must align with physical and scientific facts most notably, the medical evidence. Where testimony comes from biased or interested witnesses, the post-mortem report serves as a vital benchmark to test whether the prosecution's version of events is truthful. In this case, key prosecution witnesses Abhishek Kumar (PW-1), Ram Rishi (PW-2) and Udayveer Singh (PW-3) gave a detailed, consistent account of the event. They claimed that after the Bolero rammed into the Indica car, the victim Shashi Kumar, managed to step out, ran 135 to 140 paces toward an unused brick kiln, and was chased and shot from behind from a distance of about 30 to 35 feet. However, when this version of events is examined against the expert medical findings, it completely falls apart due to clear scientific impossibility. The legal parameters governing the evaluation of medical evidence vis-à-vis ocular testimony have been authoritatively formulated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the landmark ruling of Solanki Chimanbhai Ukabhai v. State of Gujarat, (1983) 2 SCC 174, wherein the Apex Court delineated the exact evidentiary value of medical reports, holding that the use which the defence can make of the medical evidence is to prove that the injuries could not possibly have been caused in the manner alleged and thereby discredit the eye-witnesses. Unless, however, the medical evidence in its turn goes so far that it completely rules out all possibilities whatsoever of injuries taking place in the manner alleged by eyewitnesses, the testimony of the eye-witnesses cannot be thrown out. But where medical evidence proves the oral version completely impossible the ocular evidence may be disbelieved.
This salutary principle was further reinforced in Thaman Kumar v. State of Union Territory of Chandigarh, (2003) 6 SCC 380, where the Supreme Court formulated different categories in which the medical and ocular evidence may contradict with each other and unequivocally ruled that where the eyewitness account is totally irreconcilable with the medical evidence on material particulars the foundational pillars of the prosecution case crumble, making it wholly unsafe to base a conviction thereon.
The necessity for strict alignment between oral assertions and medical findings has been reiterated in recent pronouncements. In the recent case of Ram Singh v. The State of Himachal Pradesh, 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1536, the Hon'ble Supreme Court reaffirmed that where the oral testimony of witnesses regarding injuries and physical facts is directly contradicted by medical and forensic examination, the prosecution fails to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt, and exculpatory medical findings that negate the core narrative cannot be brushed aside. Similarly, in Punimati v. State of Chhattisgarh, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2866, the Apex Court held that when ocular testimonies fail to match medical evidence and recovery findings, the cumulative effect creates an unbridgeable lacuna in the prosecution case, mandating the extension of the benefit of doubt to the accused.
When these established principles are applied to the witness testimony and medical evidence in this appeal, an unbridgeable conflict emerges between what the eyewitnesses stated and what the medical findings scientifically prove. Prosecution witnesses PW-1 and PW-2 explicitly testified that Shashi Kumar was fleeing for his life, chased from behind by assailants 30 to 35 feet away. Given this account, a person actively running away with his back to his pursuers any gunshot fired from behind would naturally hit the back of his body, such as his back, the rear of his thighs, or the back of his head. However, the post-mortem report of the deceased (Exhibit Ka-10), submitted and confirmed by Dr. Ram Asre Sudhakar (PW-5), reveals a completely contradictory and decisive reality.A careful examination of the injuries detailed in the post-mortem report (Exhibit Ka-10) shows that several firearm entry wounds were located directly on the front of his body: Injury No. 1 was an entry wound below the left jaw; Injury No. 3 was an entry wound on the left side of the mouth; Injury No. 5 was an entry wound on the left chest near the nipple; Injury No. 8 was an entry wound below the left nipple and Injury No. 10 was an entry wound on the lower abdomen below the navel. Most decisively for the prosecution's case, blackening and tattooing (kalima) were clearly present around these entry wounds. Under established principles of forensic science and criminal law, the presence of blackening, scorching and tattooing around an entry wound scientifically proves that the firearm was discharged at point-blank range (typically within 1 to 6 feet) while directly facing the victim.
Consequently, the testimony of PW-1 and PW-2, claiming that the assailants fired from a distance of 30 to 35 feet from behind a fleeing victim, is completely contradicted by the medical evidence showing close-range firing from the front. It is physically and scientifically impossible for a person running away from pursuers to sustain multiple close-range gunshot wounds on the front of his face, chest, and abdomen containing gunpowder burns. This direct conflict between the witness accounts and the medical evidence establishes beyond doubt that the eyewitnesses were not present at the scene, and that the story of the chase was fabricated after the bodies were found. Therefore, when evaluated against precedents such as Solanki Chimanbhai Ukabhai (supra), Thaman Kumar (supra), Ram Singh (supra) and Punimati (supra) cases, the medical findings entirely destroy the credibility of the prosecution's witness narrative. Thus, Issue No. 2 is resolved in favor of the appellants, confirming that the medical evidence fundamentally disproves the prosecution's case.
In regard to ISSUE NO. 3 which assails the very genesis and lodging of the First Information Report, it is a foundational and time-tested canon of criminal jurisprudence that the First Information Report is a vital contemporaneous record providing the earliest account of an occurrence, thereby acting as an indispensable shield against subsequent embellishment, deliberation, or false implication of rivals. When the promptness and genuineness of an FIR are rendered gravely suspicious by explicit admissions of prosecution witnesses revealing that the written complaint (Tehrir) was compiled in stages until late evening after site visits and consultations at the police station, the sacred authenticity of the FIR is destroyed, casting an insurmountable shadow of doubt over the entire prosecution superstructure.
The legal principles governing the necessity of a prompt FIR and the fatal impact of antedating have been authoritatively articulated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the landmark ruling of Thulia Kali v. State of Tamil Nadu, (1972) 3 SCC 393, wherein the Apex Court emphasized the grave peril of delayed and deliberated reporting:
"12.….. First information report in a criminal case is an extremely vital and valuable piece of evidence for the purpose of corroborating the oral evidence adduced at the trial. The importance of the above report can hardly be overestimated from the standpoint of the accused. The object of insisting upon prompt lodging of the report to the police in respect of commission of an offence is to obtain early information regarding the circumstances in which the crime was committed, the names of the actual culprits and the part played by them as well as the names of eyewitnesses present at the scene of occurrence. Delay in lodging the first information report quite often results in embellishment which is a creature of afterthought. On account of delay, the report not only gets bereft of the advantage of spontaneity, danger creeps in of the introduction of coloured version, exaggerated account or concocted story as a result of deliberation and consultation. It is, therefore, essential that the delay in the lodging of the first information report should be satisfactorily explained…………..."
This salutary doctrine was further amplified in Meharaj Singh and Others v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Others, (1994) 5 SCC 188, wherein the Supreme Court held that statutory provisions mandating prompt recording and dispatch of the FIR to the Magistrate serve as a vital check against antedating and post-event consultation. The Apex Court explicitly ruled that where the FIR is shown to have been recorded later after prolonged deliberations, the entire prosecution case becomes tainted :
"12.FIR in a criminal case and particularly in a murder case is a vital and valuable piece of evidence for the purpose of appreciating the evidence led at the trial. The object of insisting upon prompt lodging of the FIR is to obtain the earliest information regarding the circumstance in which the crime was committed, including the names of the actual culprits and the parts played by them, the weapons, if any, used, as also the names of the eyewitnesses, if any. Delay in lodging the FIR often results in embellishment, which is a creature of an afterthought. On account of delay, the FIR not only gets bereft of the advantage of spontaneity, danger also creeps in of the introduction of a coloured version or exaggerated story. With a view to determine whether the FIR was lodged at the time it is alleged to have been recorded, the courts generally look for certain external checks. One of the checks is the receipt of the copy of the FIR, called a special report in a murder case, by the local Magistrate. If this report is received by the Magistrate late it can give rise to an inference that the FIR was not lodged at the time it is alleged to have been recorded, unless, of course the prosecution can offer a satisfactory explanation for the delay in despatching or receipt of the copy of the FIR by the local Magistrate. Prosecution has led no evidence at all in this behalf. The second external check equally important is the sending of the copy of the FIR along with the dead body and its reference in the inquest report. Even though the inquest report, prepared under Section 174 CrPC, is aimed at serving a statutory function, to lend credence to the prosecution case, the details of the FIR and the gist of statements recorded during inquest proceedings get reflected in the report. The absence of those details is indicative of the fact that the prosecution story was still in an embryo state and had not been given any shape and that the FIR came to be recorded later on after due deliberations and consultations and was then ante-timed to give it the colour of a promptly lodged FIR. In our opinion, on account of the infirmities as noticed above, the FIR has lost its value and authenticity and it appears to us that the same has been ante-timed and had not been recorded till the inquest proceedings were over at the spot by PW 8"
These principles have been steadfastly reaffirmed in recent legal precedents. In Rama Devi v. The State of Bihar, 2024 (10) SCC 462, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that where the lodging and dispatch of the FIR are shrouded in suspicious, unexplained delays an adverse inference arises that the report was antedated.
When we evaluate the factual matrix and trial court record of the present case against these established legal standards, the plea of ante-timing advanced by the learned counsel for the appellants stands fully substantiated. According to the official prosecution record and the chick FIR, the incident allegedly occurred at 10:30 AM on 03.07.2012, and the FIR was recorded as lodged at 12:25 PM on the same day. However, a close examination of the depositions of the witnesses of fact completely demolishes this official timestamp. At page 152 of the paper book, Abhishek Kumar (PW-1) categorically admitted during cross-examination that after 12:00 noon, he remained continuously present at the police station for another 2 to 3 hours. As forcefully submitted by the learned counsel for the appellants, there was absolutely no legitimate requirement or justification for PW-1 to have remained detained at the police station for 2 to 3 hours further if the FIR had already been formally lodged at 12:25 PM. This discrepancy is conclusively corroborated by Ram Rishi (PW-2) at page 171 of the paper book. PW-2 explicitly disclosed under oath that the Tehrir was scribed in two distinct, separated stages. First, a portion was written at the Shikohabad police station. Thereafter, the Station House Officer took PW-1 and PW-2 from the police station to the place of incident. It was only after inspecting the crime scene that the remaining and entire Tehrir was finally scribed. PW-2 unambiguously admitted that when the Tehrir was actually completed, the time was anywhere between 5:00 PM and 5:30 PM. This fact finds further corroboration at page 180 of the paper book, where PW-2 reaffirmed sitting at the police station till 5:00 PM to 5:30 PM along with Abhishek Kumar (PW-1), Shiv Kendra (the scribe), and the brother of PW-1. The admitted timeline proving that the Tehrir was finalized only between 5:00 PM and 5:30 PM after site visits and extended deliberations, exposes the true nature of the FIR. As submitted by the learned counsel for the appellants, PW-1, PW-2, and PW-3 were initially completely unaware as to who the actual assailants were. During their prolonged stay at the police station until late evening, after much calculation, application of mind and consultation, they selected and named persons who were pre-existing inimical adversaries against whom criminal litigations were actively being fought in the criminal courts at Farrukhabad. Compounding this fatal infirmity is the gross, unexplained delay of approximately 48 hours in transmitting the FIR to the Chief Judicial Magistrate, before whom it was produced only on 05.07.2012. This prolonged delay in judicial dispatch of documents leads to lost their official protection against tampering. This gave the police an easy opportunity to make up names and vehicles.
Therefore, tested on the touchstone of Thulia Kali case (supra), Meharaj Singh case (supra) and Rama Devi case (supra) , the sworn admissions of PW-1 and PW-2 proving that the Tehrir was finalized only by 5:30 PM after site visits, combined with the consultation to frame Farrukhabad litigation adversaries and the 48 hour delay in transmission to the Court of concerned C.J.M., lead to the inescapable judicial conclusion that the FIR was ante-timed and engineered as an afterthought. Issue No. 3 is accordingly answered in the affirmative in favour of the appellants.
The ISSUE NO. 4 is regarding the major changes, additions, and structural expansions made to the story set-up in the First Information Report as well as the complete failure of the police to properly identify the accused persons. It is a well-settled principle of criminal law that a criminal trial must stand firmly on the facts stated in the original First Information Report. Minor natural variations or minor clarifications do not harm a case. However, when the prosecution makes major structural changes to its story, adds entirely new vehicles, and brings in unknown accused persons without conducting a Test Identification Parade, the core truth of the prosecution case is destroyed, leaving the entire case unreliable.
The law regarding the legal value of identifying unknown accused persons for the first time in court without a prior Test Identification Parade was clearly laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kanan & Ors. v. State of Kerala, (1979) 3 SCC 319 wherein the Apex Court held that when accused persons are not known to the witnesses beforehand, identifying them for the first time inside the courtroom without a Test Identification Parade has almost no legal value and cannot be used to convict anyone. This strict requirement for proper identification and the rejection of later improvements has been repeatedly upheld in recent judgments. In Wahid v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi), (2025) 2 SCC (Cri) 99, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that when accused persons are not named in the FIR and are not previously known to the witnesses, and no Test Identification Parade is conducted during investigation, identifying them months later in court is unsafe and unreliable, so the benefit of doubt must be given to the accused.
When we apply these binding legal rules to the facts of the present case, we see a complete and impermissible change in the prosecution case from the time of lodging the FIR to the time the witnesses testified in court. In the original First Information Report, the informant named only 8 specific individuals and clearly stated that the names of 2 persons were unknown. In addition, the FIR specifically stated that only two vehicles were involved in the incident, one Bolero coming from the side of Farrukhabad carrying Yogesh, Bhuvnesh, Evaran, and Bhola, and another Bolero coming from behind carrying 6 persons, including Monu @ Ketan, Munna @ Nitin, Satyaveer, Vikas, and 2 unknown persons. The FIR made no mention whatsoever of any third vehicle. Further, during the trial, the prosecution witnesses i.e. PW-1 and PW-2 made a major addition to their story by introducing a completely new third car, a Mahindra Verito. They claimed for the first time in court that four additional accused persons, Yogesh, Brijesh Katiyar, Uma Shankar, and Pushpendra Yadav came out of this third Verito car. Thus, this addition of a third vehicle and extra accused persons is a clear result of police tutoring and police station (house) fabrication. As disclosed in the testimony of PW-2, after the police arrested the accused persons, they showed them to the witnesses in police custody and in jail. The witness Ram Rishi (PW-2) specifically admitted in his cross-examination that:
"जब मुिल्ज मान पक ड़़़़ेगए तब पुिलस ने मुझे बुलाया तब पता लगा िक घटना 8 ने नहीं 14 ने की है और मुिल्ज मान पुिलस ने मुझे थाने में बंद िदखाए। पुिलस ने कहा 14 बदमाश दो गािड़़़़ यों में नहीं आ सकते, गािड़़़़ यां तीन रखनी प ड़़़़ेंगी। उसी िहसाब से मैंने आज तीन गािड़़़़ यां बताई है।"
As emphasized by the learned counsel for the appellants, the police never conducted any Test Identification Parade (TIP) for the unnamed accused persons. Identifying unknown accused persons in court for the first time after seeing them in police custody and jail and without any formal identification parade makes the prosecution case against the unnamed persons completely false and legally invalid. Therefore, in view of the settled law in the cases of Kanan (supra) and Wahid (supra), these major improvements i.e. addition of a third vehicle and accused persons and the complete failure to hold a Test Identification Parade destroy the credibility of the prosecution case. Accordingly, Issue No. 4 is answered in favour of the appellants.
As far as ISSUE NO. 5 is concerned, it is a well-settled rule of criminal law that oral statements made by witnesses, no matter how strongly asserted, must align with physical reality, scientific facts and expert inspection reports. The legal principles regarding the value of physical and mechanical evidence over oral claims are well settled. When the physical or mechanical evidence makes the oral testimony impossible or highly improbable, the court is legally bound to reject the oral narrative. Similarly, in the present case as the physical condition of the car at the crime scene verified by technical inspection completely contradicts the oral claim of a violent vehicle crash and a long, intense fire, oral account cannot be accepted. Where the physical layout, vehicle conditions and scene records are completely inconsistent with natural laws, the entire narrative of prosecution becomes highly doubtful and scene of crime must be treated as a staged and fabricated police setup.
The importance of technical and scientific reports over oral claims has been repeatedly upheld catena of authoritative judgments. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has times and again reiterated that objective technical and scene-inspection evidence is a vital protection against false implication, and where technical reports contradict the basic physical facts of a crime, the prosecution case fails. Where material objects such as vehicles are shown to have been manipulated or planted, no criminal liability can be fixed on the accused.
When we apply these legal principles to the physical and technical evidence recorded in the present case, the prosecution story of a high-speed collision and a 40-minute fire completely falls apart. The prosecution claimed that a Mahindra Bolero (UP-83-W 8238) travelling at a high speed of about 80 km/h rammed head-on into the Indica car (UP-83-M 4311) running at 50–60 km/h. They further claimed that right after the impact, petrol was poured on the Indica car, setting it on fire, and that it burned fiercely for 30 to 40 minutes until its metal body, interior, and tires were completely charred. The technical inspection of the Mahindra Bolero (UP-83-W 8238) conducted by Head Constable Ranvir Singh (PW-10) exposes the complete falsity of this claim. PW-10 deposed clearly that:
"बोलेरो गाड़़़़ी के िनरीक्ष ण से गाड़़़़ी में जलने का कोई िनशान नहीं था। बम्प र व शो िग्र ल पर जलने का कोई िनशान नहीं पाया गया। बोलेरो गाड़़़़ी के चारों टायर सही सलामत व हवा भरी हालत में थे, वे िब ल्कु ल नहीं जले थे।" PW-10 specifically confirmed that the Bolero suffered no burn damage, its front bumper and show grill had no fire or smoke marks, and all four tires were completely intact and fully inflated. Further, the Investigating Officer, Suresh Veer Singh (PW-17), admitted that when he reached the spot, the Bolero was present near the Indica Car with only a broken main shaft and the informant Abhishek Kumar (PW-1) was also agreed upon seeing the crime scene photographs that the Bolero did not look like it had collided with the Indica car. Thus, under the simple laws of physics and common sense, this technical finding makes the prosecution story physically impossible. If a vehicle (Bolero) is stationed immediately next to or locked in a head-on collision with another car (Indica) that burns fiercely for 30 to 40 minutes hot enough to melt metal and reduce human bodies to ashes the adjacent Bolero (made of plastic grilles, rubber tires, and painted metal) would naturally suffer heavy fire damage, melted plastic, smoke soot, and burnt tires. The complete absence of any burn marks, unburnt bumpers and fully inflated tires scientifically proves that the Bolero was never present during the fire and was later planted there. Therefore, keeping in view the settled law in the cases of Mahavir Singh (supra), Bhajan Singh (supra), Ram Singh (supra) and Punimati (supra), the official technical report and physical facts completely disprove the collision and fire story, proving that the vehicle recovery was a staged police fabrication. Accordingly, Issue No. 5 is answered in favour of the appellants.
Finally, the ISSUE NO. 6 which challenges the legality, genuine execution and evidentiary value of the recovery memos and weapon seizures under the Arms Act, is concerned, it is a fundamental rule of criminal law that any recovery of incriminating weapons, ammunition, personal items or vehicles made during a police investigation must strictly follow statutory safeguards under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act. Such recoveries must be proved by clear, reliable and contemporaneous documentation created on the spot in the presence of independent witnesses. Where the seizure memos which form the very foundation of the weapon charges are proved to have been drafted post-facto, signed the next day away from the scene and prepared without actual recovery in the witness's presence, those seizure memos lose all legal value and cannot be used to convict anyone. The legal position regarding recoveries under Section 27 of the Evidence Act has been authoritatively settled by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the landmark ruling of Subramanya v. State of Karnataka, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1400. In this landmark decision, the Supreme Court laid down strict operational guidelines for proving recoveries under Section 27 of the Evidence Act holding that the mere production of a recovery memo signed by witnesses is not enough. The Apex Court held that the prosecution must prove that the disclosure statement was recorded voluntarily before the recovery was made, contemporaneously and that the physical recovery was witnessed on the spot in real time.
This core principle laid down in the case of Subramanya (supra) aligns with established Apex Court jurisprudence. In Mohd. Aman v. State of Rajasthan, (1997) 10 SCC 44, the Supreme Court ruled that when the police recover evidence in a way that violates legal procedures, it raises serious doubts about whether the items were tampered with or fabricated. Without a secure and verifiable chain of custody, courts cannot trust the integrity of the seized items.
When we apply the aforesaid settled proposition of law to the facts of the present case as recorded in the trial court paper book, the recovery proceedings are exposed as completely invalid in law. The prosecution relied heavily upon recovery memos marked as Exhibits Ka-2 to Ka-6. These memos related to the ash of the burnt car, plain concrete, a burnt pistol, cartridges, a watch, a PAN card, currency notes of Rs. 1,610/-, driving licenses, passport-size photographs, and the Bolero car (UP-83-W 8238) along with a cartridge belt and a 5-liter empty can. These recovery memos were said to be prepared on the spot before Ram Rishi (PW-2) and Nandlal but during cross-examination at page 177 of the paper book, Ram Rishi (PW-2), made a fatal admission that completely demolished these exhibits. He admitted under oath that :
"फदेर् जो दरोगा जी ने प्रदशर् क-2, 3, 4, 5 व 6 बनाई थी वह मेरे सामने नहीं बनाई थी मुझसे बाद में दूसरे िदन दस्त खत कराये थे और सामान िदखाया था। सामान पहले िदखाया था तब जब लाशें वामई गांव में जल गयी थी उसके बाद फदोर्ं पर द स्त खत कराये थे।" Thus, this explicit admission of PW-2 proves beyond any doubt that Exhibits Ka-2 to Ka-6 were never prepared on the spot at the scene of the incident in the presence of PW-2 rather the recovered items were shown to this witness next day at village Vahmai, long after the dead bodies had already been cremated and his signatures were obtained on the memos post-facto. Hence, under the law settled by Apex Court, such ex-post-facto signature collection without contemporaneous spot preparation renders the recovery memos completely void and inadmissible under Section 27 of the Evidence Act. Since the recovery memos themselves are invalid, the prosecution has failed to establish any legal link between the appellants and the alleged firearms, ammunition, or recovered articles. Therefore, the admitted post-facto signing of Exhibits Ka-2 to Ka-6 destroys all recoveries. The charges against the appellants under Section 25 and Section 27 of the Arms Act, as well as the corroborative link for the main offences, completely fail. Accordingly, Issue No. 6 is answered in favour of the appellants.
In view of the aforesaid consideration and appreciation of the facts, evidence and law, we now proceed to evaluate the cumulative impact of these findings upon the overall fabric of the prosecution case.
The criminal jurisprudence mandates that a conviction for such offences cannot be founded upon isolated fragments of suspicion or disjointed claims. The prosecution must construct an unbroken chain of reliable evidence that proves guilt of accused beyond reasonable doubt. In the present matter, from the aforesaid discussions, it is evident that there was a comprehensive, multi-layered collapse of the prosecution's entire narrative from its very inception. The collapse begins at the foundational level with Issue 1 and Issue 3, where the genesis of the incident and the presence of eye-witnesses are rendered deeply suspect. The admissions by Ram Rishi (PW-2) that the Tehrir was completed only by 5:30 PM after visiting the site, coupled with the unexplained 48-hour delay in placing the FIR before the Magistrate, conclusively establish that the FIR was ante-timed and engineered after post-event consultation. The contradictory accounts of seating arrangements and escape routes by PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3, combined with the independent testimony of Village Pradhan (DW-1) and I.O. (PW-17) proving that no family members were present at the scene, further shakes the root of the prosecution. The narrative crumbles further when tested against physical and medical science under Issue 2 and Issue 5. The ocular claim that deceased Shashi Kumar was shot from behind from a distance of 30 to 35 feet while fleeing is flatly contradicted by the post-mortem report (Ex. Ka-10) and Dr. PW-5, which revealed multiple close-range (1 to 6 feet) frontal entry wounds with blackening and tattooing (kalima). Equally fatal is the mechanical impossibility revealed by PW-10 and PW-17; the Mahindra Bolero (UP-83-W 8238), which allegedly rammed head-on into the Indica car at high speed and sat adjacent to a 40-minute thermal inferno, exhibited zero burn marks, unblemished bumpers, and fully inflated tires. Under the laws of physics, this scientific impossibility proves that the collision story was fabricated and the Bolero was planted post-facto. Finally, Issue No. 4 and Issue No. 6 expose the systemic fabrication and procedural irregularity that pervaded the police investigation. The prosecution case went from naming 8 accused and 2 vehicles in the FIR to 14 accused and 3 vehicles at trial, backed by PW-2's confession that the police explicitly instructed him to introduce a third vehicle (Verito) because 14 men could not fit into two cars. This tutored dock identification, executed without any Test Identification Parade (TIP), is completely neutralized by PW-2's further admission under Issue No. 6 that all recovery memos (Exhibits Ka-2 to Ka-6) were signed ex-post-facto on the following day at village Vahmai without contemporaneous execution. Thus, the prosecution has failed to establish a single reliable link in its chain of proof. The presence of eyewitnesses at the scene of crime at the time of incident is doubtful, the medical evidence refutes the ocular account, the FIR is ante-timed, the scene of crime is mechanically impossible, the array of accused is tutored and the recovery memos are legally void.
Hence, upon careful analysis and consideration of the settled legal position in the backdrop of the facts and circumstances of the present case, we are of the opinion that the conclusion taken by the Trial Court in the impugned judgment and order is not in accordance with law and the evidence available on record. Thus, this Court is of the considered view that the prosecution has not been able to establish the guilt of the accused appellants beyond reasonable doubt. Therefore, the Court is inclined to grant benefit of doubt to the accused appellants on the ground of rule of caution.
In view of the above discussions, we are of the opinion that the prosecution has failed to establish the guilt of the accused appellants for the alleged offences punishable under Sections 147, 148, 307/149, 302/149, 435/149 IPC, Section 7 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act, and Section 25/27 of the Arms Act beyond reasonable doubt and to the satisfaction of the judicial conscience of the Court. So, the impugned judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 22.2.2018, which has been sought to be assailed, calls for and deserves, interference. The criminal appeals are liable to be allowed.
Accordingly, criminal appeals are allowed and the conviction and sentence imposed upon the accused appellants is set-aside, as the accused appellants are found not guilty for the aforesaid offences. They are honourably acquitted of all the charges framed against them. Accused appellants are in jail. They be set at liberty. They shall be released forthwith, if not wanted in any other case.
On perusal of the impugned judgment and order and the evidence available on record, we are of the view that the trial court has rightly acquitted the other accused persons, against whom the aforesaid Government Appeal Nos. 329 of 2025, 330 of 2025 and Criminal Misc. Application U/S 372 Cr.P.C. (Leave To Appeal) No. 142 of 2018 and have been moved before this court. Hence, the said government appeals filed on behalf of the State and application U/S 372 CrPC (Leave to Appeal) filed on behalf of the informant are dismissed.
Copy of this order be also placed on the records of Criminal Appeal Nos. 1685 of 2018, 1752 of 2018, 1998 of 2018, 2205 of 2018, 3271 of 2019,2886 of 2018, Government Appeal Nos. 329 of 2025, 330 of 2025 and application U/S 372 CrPC (Leave to Appeal) No. 142 of 2018.
Office is directed to communicate this order to the court concerned forthwith for compliance and also to send back the trial court record.
Pending application, if any, stands disposed of.
The Court would like to record its appreciation of the assistance rendered by Ms. Anjali Singh, Research Associate.
