AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
The petitioner is a sub-contractor, engaged in a works contract within the State of Kerala. Admittedly the petitioner purchased an electric generator for the purpose of using it in execution of the works contract. The petitioner availed of concessional rate on the ground of C-Form sales as available in Section 8(1) of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 [for brevity " CST Act "]. The petitioner also uploaded Form No.8F as per Exhibit P4.
The goods, however, were transported based on Form No.16, Exhibit P5, as goods for own use. The goods were detained at the check post and notice at Exhibit P1 was issued. The petitioner submits that the petitioner is ready to pay the advance tax and further even furnish bank guarantee as security deposit. The petitioner also is a registered dealer.
Petitioner, obviously, has attempted evasion of tax on two counts; one by claiming concessional rate of CST under Section 8(1) when the petitioner had not purchased the goods for re-sale within the State. The petitioner admittedly is using the same for his own purposes. If the petitioner had purchased the same for re-sale within the State of Kerala, then necessarily the petitioner ought to have paid advance tax, since generator is notified for levy of advance tax under the Kerala Value Added Tax Act 2003 [for brevity "KVAT Act"]. But, the petitioner transported the goods on the strength of Form No.16. The petitioner is, hence, prima facie, found to be guilty of attempt to evade tax on two counts; (i) claiming concessional rate from outside State and (ii) claiming own use, by transporting the goods on the strength of Form 16.
If the petitioner's purchase was entitled to be levied concessional rate under Section 8(1) of the CST Act, then the petitioner ought to have paid advance tax at the entry point. If the
petitioner was brining the goods for own use [Form 16], then the petitioner ought not to have availed the concessional rate in the State of purchase. Though the sales tax authority of the recipient State would not be able to detain the goods for reason of the evasion attempted at the originating State, this Court, under Article 226 of the Constitution, would be aptly justified in not exercising discretion in the case of a person who had attempted such evasion.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner refers to Exhibit P4, Form No.8F and Form No.16, produced at Exhibit P5, and the distance of time, in the execution of both the documents to contend that it is a bona fide mistake. This Court is unable to countenance such a contention, especially since the petitioner having uploaded Form No.8F on the basis of the concessional rate availed under the CST Act at the originating State, necessarily had to pay advance tax at the check post of entry, which the petitioner sought to evade tax by producing a Form 16 declaration.
This Court, in the aforesaid circumstances, declines exercise of discretion and the writ petition would stand dismissed.
All the same, the petitioner would be entitled for release of the goods on the petitioner paying half the amounts demanded and also providing sufficient bank guarantee for the balance demand.
