AI Structured Summary
Facts, law points, precedents, ratio and the final ruling — distilled from the full judgment
AI Structured Summary
Facts, law points, precedents, ratio and the final ruling — distilled from the full judgment
Facts
The petitioner originally belonged to Uttar Pradesh. After the creation of Uttarakhand and cadre bifurcation under the U.P. Reorganization Act, 2000, her father was allocated to the Uttarakhand cadre and was posted as District Judge, Bageshwar. The petitioner, residing with him at Bageshwar, was issued a Scheduled Caste certificate on 14 June 2002. It was undisputed that she belongs to Jatav caste, which is a Scheduled Caste in Uttarakhand as well as Uttar Pradesh. In the 2008 selection for Civil Judge (Junior Division), she applied in the Scheduled Caste (horizontal reservation for women) category and was placed at serial No. 17 of the select list; the intervention applicant Ms. Shalini Dadar was at serial No. 18. Both had 489 marks, but the petitioner was placed higher because she had higher written examination marks. Although her name appeared in the select list and vacancies existed, she was not appointed by the State Government. She filed Writ Petition No. 44 of 2009 seeking inclusion in the appointment order dated 19 March 2009 and action on her representation dated 17 March 2009. During the pendency of that petition, the State Government by order dated 25 April 2009 referred the Scheduled Caste certificate dated 14 June 2002 to a scrutiny committee, which found that she should not be given Scheduled Caste reservation benefit; the State Government agreed with that report. By consequential order dated 6 May 2009, the State Government held that she was not entitled to Scheduled Caste reservation benefit on the basis of the certificate dated 14 June 2002 and cancelled the certificate. Writ Petition No. 44 of 2009 was then withdrawn on 8 May 2009 with liberty to apply afresh for a caste certificate. In that order the Court directed the Competent/Prescribed Authority to process any fresh application by 12 May 2009 and pass final order before 20 May 2009, and directed the State Government to take consequential action before 27 May 2009; the existing Scheduled Caste (Women) vacancy was not to be filled till then. The petitioner applied to the Tehsildar, Haridwar, claiming entitlement because she had married Rohit Sikhola, a permanent resident of Uttarakhand, on 14 December 2005 and because she belonged to Jatav caste, a Scheduled Caste in Uttarakhand. The Tehsildar rejected her application by order dated 19 May 2009. The present petition challenges that order and seeks her inclusion in the appointment order, issuance of a caste certificate, and reservation of one Civil Judge (Junior Division) Scheduled Caste (Women) post pending disposal of the petition.
Law Points
The Court considered whether, in the facts and circumstances, the petitioner was entitled to be issued a caste certificate and consequently to the benefit of reservation as a Scheduled Caste candidate. It also considered whether the Tehsildar, Haridwar was justified in rejecting her application for a caste certificate by order dated 19 May 2009. A further question was what relief could be granted in the peculiar facts, particularly whether any benefit could be given for the 2008 selection process when the petitioner did not then possess a valid Scheduled Caste certificate, and whether the Court could mould relief on equitable considerations in exercise of its extraordinary jurisdiction.
Acts & Articles
U.P. Reorganization Act, 2000. No sections or constitutional articles are specifically named in the judgment.
Judgments Referred
Jyotibala v. State of Uttarakhand and Anr., W.P. No. 297 (SB) of 2008, Division Bench judgment dated 16 December 2008 — referred to for the ratio regarding the petitioner becoming a permanent resident and permanent domicile of Uttarakhand by virtue of her marriage to a permanent resident of Uttarakhand; the Court records and relies on that legal position.
Obiter Dicta
The Court observed that it should not be bound by technicalities of law and had to balance equities, since otherwise appropriate relief could not be granted and there would be denial of substantial justice to the petitioner. It also remarked that small time limits were fixed because candidates already appointed were undergoing training at the State Judicial Academy, and any delay in the petitioner's appointment would deprive her of that training and jeopardize her interests and future career prospects without any fault of hers.
Ratio Decidendi
At the interim stage, the Court took the prima facie view that the petitioner, being a domicile of Uttarakhand by her marriage to a permanent resident of Uttarakhand and belonging to Jatav caste, a recognised Scheduled Caste in Uttarakhand, could not be deprived of the benefit available to an Uttarakhand Scheduled Caste; accordingly, the Tehsildar's rejection of her caste certificate application was prima facie not justified and was against the established law. On equitable considerations, and because the earlier order of 8 May 2009 contemplated consequential action depending upon the fresh certificate, the Court held that the benefit could not be denied to her with respect to the 2008 selection process, even though the respondents argued that any relief should operate only prospectively because she did not possess a valid Scheduled Caste certificate when she applied. The Court therefore moulded interim relief, subject to the final result of the writ petition.
Final Ruling
The writ petition was admitted to hearing and the respondents were permitted to file counter affidavits after admission. The operation of the impugned order dated 19 May 2009 passed by respondent No. 3 was stayed. Being of the prima facie opinion that the petitioner was entitled to the grant of a caste certificate showing that she belongs to a Scheduled Caste, the Court directed respondent No. 3 to issue a formal certificate to that effect within two days. Being armed with that certificate, respondent No. 1 was directed to issue an appointment order in favour of the petitioner within one week thereafter. The Court fixed these short timelines because candidates already appointed were undergoing training at the State Judicial Academy and delay would deprive the petitioner of that training. The interim arrangement, both as to issuance of the certificate and appointment, was made subject to the final result of the writ petition.
Plain-Language Gist
The petitioner belonged to a Scheduled Caste and had become a permanent resident of Uttarakhand through marriage, but the Tehsildar rejected her fresh application for a caste certificate, affecting her selection in the 2008 Civil Judge examination. The High Court, at an interim stage, found her prima facie entitled to the certificate and directed that it be issued and that she be appointed, while admitting the writ petition. This interim relief was expressly made subject to the final outcome of the case.
AI-generated summary — verify against the full judgment text before relying on it in practice.
Judgment
V.K. Gupta, C.J.—The issue involved for consideration in this case is very peculiar as well as it is important and interesting. The facts are equally peculiar and interesting. In the ultimate analyses, how would the relief be moulded is also very peculiar as well as important. Facts first:
The petitioner originally belonged to the State of U.P.. After creation of the State of Uttarakhand, by virtue of cadre bifurcation in terms of U.P. Reorganization Act, 2000, the petitioner's father was allocated to the Uttarakhand Cadre. At the relevant time he was posted and serving as District Judge, Bageshwar. Since the petitioner was residing in Bageshwar town alongwith her father, on 14th June 2002 the Competent Authority issued a caste certificate in her favour certifying that she belonged to Scheduled Caste. It is the undisputed case of the parties before us that the petitioner does belong to Jatav Caste, which undoubtedly is a Scheduled Caste in the State of Uttarakhand as well as in the State of U.P.
The petitioner appeared in the selection process for appointment as Civil Judge (Jr. Div.) in the year 2008 in the reserve category of Scheduled Caste (horizontal reservation for women). Petitioner's name figured at serial No. 17 of the select list and this was on the basis of reservation benefit having been given to her in the Scheduled Caste quota and that too based on horizontal reservation (of women's quota). The intervention applicant Ms. Shalini Dadar also in the Scheduled Caste quota (horizontal-women) having also appeared in the same selection process found her name figuring at serial No. 18 in the select list. Both the petitioner as well as the intervention applicant had obtained 489 marks in aggregate but petitioner was placed higher in order of merit by virtue of the fact that she had obtained higher marks in the written examination. This rule position is not under challenge before us. Whereas the petitioner had obtained 437 marks in written examination and 52 marks in vice-versa, totaling 489, Ms. Shalini Dadar had obtained 434 marks in written examination and 55 marks in vice-versa, totaling 489.
Despite the fact that petitioner's name had appeared at serial No. 17 in the select list and vacancies were available but she not having been appointed by the State Govt., she filed Writ Petition No. 44 of 2009 in this Court, in which the following prayers were made:
i. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus commanding the respondent to include the name of petitioner in the Appointment Order No. 327/30-1-2009-25 (16) 2004 T.C.-1 Dehradun dated 19.3.2009 and to allocate here posting in pursuance to her selection for the post of Civil Judge (J.D.) in the examination of Civil Judge (J.D.) Examination of 2008.
ii. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus commanding the respondent to take an appropriation action on the petitioner's representation dated 17.3.2009 (annexure No. 12 to the writ petition).
iii. Issue a writ, order or direction which this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper under the circumstances of the case,
iv. Award the cost of the petition.
While the aforesaid writ petition was pending in this Court an order came to be passed by the State Govt. on 25th April 2009. In this order making a reference to the Scheduled Caste certificate issued in petitioner's favour on 14th June 2002, State Govt. directed District Magistrate, Bageshwar to constitute a scrutiny committee to find out as to whether the aforesaid certificate dated 14th June 2002 was correctly issued or not? The scrutiny committee upon an inquiry came to the conclusion that the petitioner should not be given the benefit of reservation in Scheduled Caste category based upon the aforesaid certificate dated 14th June 2002. The State Govt. accordingly came to the conclusion in the aforesaid order dated 25th April 2002 that it was in agreement with the report and finding of the scrutiny committee.
A subsequent, consequential order was passed by the State Govt. on 6th May 2009, in which after making a mention of the aforesaid fact, it took two decisions; firstly, that the petitioner was not entitled to the benefit of reservation as a Scheduled Caste candidate on the basis of the certificate dated 14th June, 2002 and secondly to cancel the said certificate.
The aforesaid two orders were passed by the State Govt. on 25th April 2009 and 6th May 2009 respectively during the pendency of W.P. No. 44 of 2009 filed by the petitioner. W.P. No. 44 of 2009 came up for consideration in the Court on 8th May 2009 when the following order was passed:
As the arguments were in progress, Mr. Sharad Sharma, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that the petitioner be permitted to withdraw this petition, in the process the petitioner also relinquishing her claim vis-à-vis the caste certificate issued on 14th June 2002 in her favour but with liberty to the petitioner to apply afresh for the grant of a caste certificate in her favour to the effect that she belongs to a Scheduled Caste (Jatav). According to Mr. Sharad Sharma, the fact of the petitioner being married to a domicile of Uttarakhand in the year 2005, apart from her now having become a domicile of Uttarakhand State on the strength of her marriage with a domicile of Uttarakhand State, her belonging to Jatav caste, which is a recognized Scheduled Caste in Uttarakhand and she would be entitled to be granted the caste certificate by a Competent/Prescribed Authority.
Mr. Sharad Sharma prays that the petitioner be permitted to withdraw this petition with liberty to apply to Competent/ Prescribed Authority for the grant of caste certificate in the light of the submission made and recorded herein above.
Writ petition is dismissed as withdrawn. Liberty prayed for is allowed.
If the petitioner applies to the Competent/ Prescribed Authority for the grant of a fresh caste certificate in her favour in the light of the submissions recorded herein above, before 4:00 p.m. by or before 12th May, 2009, the Competent/ Prescribed Authority is directed to receive and process the petitioner's said application and pass final order thereupon before 20th May 2009. The petitioner shall be entitled to a personal hearing also before Prescribed/Competent Authority. Time shall not be extended and if the final order is not passed before 20th May 2009, action shall be initiated against the Prescribed/ Competent Authority for disobeying the Court's order. While passing final order, the Prescribed/Competent Authority shall not be, in any manner, influenced by any earlier order passed on the subject by any Authority or the Government.
Depending upon the order to be passed upon petitioner's aforesaid application and the result thereof, the State Govt. is directed to take consequential action before 27th May 2009. Till 27th May, 2009 the existing vacancy in the Scheduled Caste (Women) category shall not be filled.
The order to be passed shall be communicated to the petitioner the same evening by personally serving the same upon her.
The petitioner shall have the liberty to approach this Court again if a fresh cause of action accrues to her.
Petition disposed of finally. No order as to costs.
After withdrawing the aforesaid writ petition, the petitioner indeed applied to Tehsildar, Haridwar- Respondent No. 3 herein for issuance of the caste certificate in her favour on the basis and force of two factors which she claimed entitled her to receive the caste certificate. Firstly, because she had married with Rohit Sikhola, a permanent resident of Uttarakhand State on 14th December 2005 and, secondly she belonged to Jatav caste which was a Scheduled Caste in Uttarakhand State. According to the petitioner her being a domicile of Uttarakhand by virtue of her marriage to a permanent resident of Uttarakhand entitled her to receive and be issued the caste certificate as well as the benefit thereof. In compliance with this Court's order dated 8th May 2009 (Supra), Tehsildar, Haridwar (Competent Authority) rejected the petitioner's application for issuance of caste certificate. Rejection clearly meant that the petitioner cannot be granted the benefit of belonging to Scheduled Caste category and the reservation with respect thereto. This was done by the Tehsildar by passing order dated 19.05.2009. Inter-alia, challenging this order, the petitioner accordingly has filed the present petition seeking the following reliefs:
i. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus commanding the respondents to include the name of the petitioner in the appointment order No. 327/3030-1-09-25 (16)/2004 T.C.-1 Dehradun dated 19.03.09 and to allocate her posting in pursuance to her selection for the post of Civil Judge (J.D.) in the examination of Civil Judge (J.D.) Examination of 2008.
ii. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari quashing the impugned order datred 19.05.2009 passed by Tehsildar Haridwar i.e. respondent No. 3,
iii. Issue a writ of mandamus commanding and directing the respondents to issue Caste Certificate in favour of the petitioner and further to direct the respondent No. 1 to keep one post reserve of Civil Judge (Junior Division) (S.C.-Women category) till the disposal of the present writ petition,
iv. Any other order or direction which this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the case,
v. Award cost of the petition.
What has come up for consideration in this case is whether in the light of the aforesaid facts the petitioner was entitled to be issued a caste certificate and consequently the benefit of reservation belonging to the reservation category.
Two facts at the risk of re-iteration are required to be stated which are also undisputed. Firstly, that after December 2005 the petitioner became a permanent resident and a permanent domicile of Uttarakhand by virtue of her marriage to a permanent resident of Uttarakhand (refer to the ratio laid down with respect to this legal position in the Division Bench Judgment of this Court dated 16th December 2008 in the case of Jyotibala v. State of Uttarakhand and Anr. in W.P. No. 297 (SB) of 2008). The second undisputed fact is that the petitioner belongs to Jatav caste which is a recognized Schedule Caste in the State of Uttarakhand. The cumulative effect therefore, is that the petitioner being a domicile of Uttarakhand by virtue of her having married a permanent resident of Uttarakhand State cannot be deprived of the benefit available to an Uttarakhandi Schedule Caste by virtue of the fact that she indeed is a Scheduled Caste belonging to Jatav Caste. In our prima facie opinion therefore, the Tehsildar, Haridwar was not justified in rejecting the petitioner's application for grant of a caste certificate vide the impugned order dated 19th of May 2009. He ought to have allowed this application and issued the certificate.
The impugned order apparently and prima facie suffers from an error apparent on the face of the order itself as well as it is against the established law on the subject.
The question which now arises for consideration, very peculiarly is as to what relief can be granted to the petitioner in the facts and circumstances of the present case. Mr. P.C. Bisht, learned Brief Holder appearing for respondent No. 1 and 3 and Mr. Manoj Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel appearing for Shalini Dadar (intervention applicant) have very vehemently argued that even if the action of Tehsildar, Haridwar in rejecting the petitioner's application for grant of caste certificate is held to be invalid by this Court and even if the petitioner is held entitled by this Court to be issued a caste certificate in her favour, all this will and should operative prospectively in the sense the petitioner cannot be given the benefit of reservation with respect to 2008 selection process because undoubtedly as on the date of submission of application with respect to 2008 selection process the petitioner was not possessed of a valid Scheduled Caste Certificate. The argument does appear appealing at first sight but when we proceed to examine the issue in its correct perspective and also in the process proceed to invoke equity jurisdiction of this Court in the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case, and based on equitable consideration as we are proceeding to mould the relief in the exercise of our extraordinary jurisdiction, we find that the aforesaid benefit cannot be denied to the petitioner with respect to the selection process having been undertaken in the year 2008. We are saying so because we cannot remain oblivious to the fact that in the year 2008 when the petitioner had applied, she indeed was a domicile of Uttarakhand State and did belong to Jatav caste which is a recognized Scheduled Caste in the State of Uttarakhand. She was also in possession of a Scheduled Caste Certificate issued on 14th of June 2002 which lateron was cancelled. It is by virtue of the order passed by this Court on 8th of May 2009 that the petitioner was permitted to apply for the grant of a fresh caste certificate. In that order this Court had clearly observed that the consequential action would follow depending upon the order to be passed by the Tehsildar upon the petitioner's application for grant of caste certificate. In other words what this Court intended to convey was that if the caste certificate was issued in favour of the petitioner the consequential action of her being appointed based upon her selection would follow. It was thus, in effect and substance in the midst of judicial proceedings pending in this Court that the aforesaid action was taken.
In the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case we feel we should not be bound by the technicalities of law. We have to balance equities because unless the equitable consideration overrides other considerations in this case, appropriate relief cannot be granted which would amount to denial of substantial justice to the petitioner.
The writ petition is admitted to hearing. The respondents may file counter affidavits post admission.
In the light of the facts and circumstances of this case and based upon the reasoning that we have offered, we feel convinced that the petitioner deserves interim relief from this Court. While therefore staying the operation of the impugned order dated 19th May 2009 passed by the respondent No. 3 and being of the prima facie opinion that the petitioner is entitled to the grant of a caste certificate of belonging to a scheduled caste, we direct respondent No. 3 to issue a formal certificate to this effect to the petitioner within two days from today.
Being armed with this certificate, we direct respondent No. 1 to issue appointment order in favour of the petitioner within one week thereafter. We are fixing these very small time limits because of the fact that the candidates who have already been appointed in the Service are already undergoing training in the State Judicial Academy. Any delay with respect to the petitioner's appointment shall result in her being deprived of the aforesaid training, thus jeopardizing her interests as well as future career prospects without any fault of her.
The aforesaid interim arrangement, both with respect to the issuance of the certificate as well as the appointment is subject to the final result of this writ petition.
