AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
his Petition is iled seeking release of the Petitioner by declaring his arrest to be illegal in connection with Crime No.250/2020 registered at Mapusa Police Station, Crime No.67/2021 registered at Valpoi Police Station, Crime No.142/2022 registered at Mapusa Police Station and Crime No.123/2024 registered at Old Goa Police Station, on the grounds of violation of fundamental rights guaranteed under Articles 21 and 22 of the Constitution of India as well as for violation of Section 47(1) of Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS). he other prayer is for quashing the remand orders in the above ofences.
Heard Mr Sahil Sardessai for the Petitioner and Mr P. Faldessai, learned APP for the State.
Rule. Rule is made returnable with the consent of the learned counsel for the parties.
he main contentions of the learned counsel for the Petitioner are that at the time of the arrest in connection with Crime No.250/2020 of Mapusa Police Station he was not given grounds of arrest in writing and he was not handed over a copy of the arrest memo and secondly none of his friends, relatives or any other person was informed about his arrest as required under Section 48 of BNSS and hence the arrest becomes illegal. Learned counsel for the Petitioner relied on the order passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ahmed Mansoor & Ors. V/s. he State represented by Assistant Commissioner of Police & Anr. in Criminal Appeal No.4505/2025 passed on 14.10.2025. Based on these submissions, the learned counsel for the Petitioner prays for release of the Petitioner.
Since the matter involved the liberty of a citizen and there is allegedly violation of Articles 21 and 22 of the Constitution of India, we directed the learned APP to respond to these submissions by iling aidavit in reply. Accordingly, the aidavit in reply is iled. Learned APP relied on the recent Supreme Court judgments in the case of State of Karnataka v/s Sri Darshan reported in 2025 0 Supreme (SC) 1201 and Mihir Rajesh Shah v/s. State of Maharashtra & Anr. in Criminal Appeal No.2195/2025 decided on 06.11.2025. He submitted that in the case of Sri Darshan it is clearly held that the Petitioner will have to show prejudice caused to him and he cannot simply argue that the grounds of arrest were not given in writing. hat alone cannot be a ground for declaring his arrest as illegal.
Learned APP submitted that now fresh guidelines are issued by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Mihir Rajesh Shah which are prospective in nature and therefore the Petitioner’s case will have to be tested in the light of the ratio of Sri Darshan’s case. Learned APP further submitted that there is no force in the submission of the learned counsel for the Petitioner that his friends or relatives were not informed. he investigating oicer, at the time of his arrest, had informed one Satish Naik, who was the nephew of the Petitioner. Learned APP relied on the deposition recorded by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Panaji on 17.08.2016 in Sessions Case No.57/2014, when the said Satish Naik was examined as PW9. On that occasion, the said Satish Naik, on oath, had stated that the Petitioner was his uncle. herefore, knowing the past history the police were aware that Satish Naik was the Petitioner’s nephew and therefore he was informed about the Petitioner’s arrest. Learned counsel for the Petitioner vehemently opposed this submission. He relied on the statement of the said Satish Naik recorded by the police under Section 161 of Cr.P.C. in connection with Crime No.250/2020 registered at Mapusa Police Station on 12.04.2024. He also relied on the statement of Satish Naik recorded on 04.02.2025 under Section 180 of BNSS in connection with Crime No.142/2022 registered at Mapusa Police Station, wherein he had denied that the Petitioner was his uncle.
We have considered these submissions. For reference, it is necessary to refer to the aidavit in reply so that there would be clarity as to which ofences are registered against the Petitioner and in which ofences he was arrested. he aidavit in reply mentions that the irst of these ofences referred to by the Petitioner in his prayer was Crime No.250/2020 registered at Mapusa Police Station under Sections 419, 465, 466, 467, 468, 471, 472 and 420 of IPC. It was registered on 19.09.2020 on the complaint lodged by one Arjun Shetye, Civil Registrar cum Sub-Registrar, Bardez Goa in respect of forged and fraudulent sale deed having been registered by impersonating the lawful owner of the property surveyed under Chalta No.2 of P.T. Sheet No.67 of Mapusa city.
During the course of the investigation, the involvement of the Petitioner was revealed. he Petitioner himself iled Anticipatory Bail Application before the Additional Sessions Judge, Panaji vide Anticipatory Bail Application No.60/2022 which was rejected vide order dated 13.05.2022.
Even this Court rejected his Anticipatory Bail Application preferred vide Criminal Misc. Application (Bail) No.314/2022 (F), vide order dated 13.07.2022.
After both these applications were rejected, the Petitioner was not available for a long time. A look-out notice was issued against him on 14.10.2024. Finally, he was traced and arrested on 12.11.2024 from Hubli, Karnataka. It is mentioned in the aidavit in reply that after informing him the grounds of his arrest and apprehension, the Petitioner was placed under arrest on 12.11.2024 at 22.55 hrs. Intimation of his arrest was given to his nephew Satish Naik over phone and his Advocate Mr Salman Pathan, resident of Pune, Maharashtra was also informed. he Petitioner was produced before the JMFC, Mapusa on 13.11.2024 and initially nine days police custody remand was granted.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner submitted that on the irst date of remand, his Advocate Mr Salman Pathan was not present which indicated that the police had not informed the said Advocate Mr Pathan. he other submission of the learned counsel for the Petitioner as mentioned above is that Satish Naik is not his relative.
As far as the other three ofences are concerned, it is undisputed that he was already in custody in connection with Crime No.250/2020 of Mapusa Police Station and his custody was transferred in connection with all the other ofences. Learned counsel for the Petitioner has not made any submissions in respect of his transfer of custody in the other ofences. His only ground of challenge is in respect of non-compliance of Sections 50 and 50-A of Cr.P.C. corresponding to Sections 47 and 48 of BNSS in connection with Crime No.250/2020. herefore, from that point of view, we have considered the submissions made by both the learned counsel. he aidavit goes on to mention that even subsequent to his arrest, the Petitioner escaped from SIT custody on 13.12.2024 and he was re-arrested from Kochi, Kerala on 23.12.2024.
Consequently, Crime No.142/2024 was registered at Old Goa Police Station. he aidavit also mentions a list of eleven antecedents regarding the ofences pending against the Petitioner. In this background, the Petitioner is seeking his release on bail on the grounds of non-furnishing of the grounds of arrest in writing and not informing his friends or relatives about his arrest.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner has relied on the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ahmed Mansoor & Ors. We are unable to give any beneit to the Petitioner based on the said order. he said order refers to the judgment in the case of Sri Darshan referred to herein above. Reference to the said judgment of Sri Darshan in the order of Ahmed Mansoor & Ors. is as follows:-
“In State of Karnataka v. Sri Darshan Etc. (supra) the facts governing are quite diferent. It was a case dealing with the cancellation of bail where the charge sheet had been iled and the grounds of detention were served immediately. his Court has, in fact, given its approval to the decision in Vihaan Kumar State of Haryana & Anr. (supra). Similarly, in Kasireddy Upender Reddy v. State of Andhra Pradesh and Ors. (supra), this Court was pleased to hold in para 27 that the object underlying the provision that the grounds of arrest should be communicated has been explained by this Court in Vihaan Kumar v. State of Haryana & Anr (supra). herefore, the law as laid down in Vihaan Kumar v. State of Haryana & Anr (supra) has been approved and reiterated in the abovesaid decisions.”
herefore, it is necessary to refer to the discussion and ratio laid down in the case of Sri Darshan. he relevant portion from the judgment of Sri Darshan is mentioned in paras 20.1 to 20.1.7 which read as follows:-
“20.1 Delay in furnishing the grounds of arrest cannot, by itself, constitute a valid ground for grant of bail:
20.1.1.he learned counsel for the respondents-accused contended that the arrest was illegal as the grounds of arrest were not furnished immediately in writing, thereby violating Article 22 (1) of the Constitution and Section 50 Cr.P.C. (now Section 47 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita). his submission, however, is devoid of merit.
20.1.2.Article 22(1) of the Constitution mandates that "no person who is arrested shall be detained in custody without being informed, as soon as may be, of the grounds for such arrest, nor shall he be denied the right to consult and to be defended by, a legal practitioner of his choice." Similarly, Section 50 (1) Cr.P.C. requires that "every police oicer or other person arresting any person without warrant shall forthwith communicate to him full particulars of the ofence for which he is arrested or other grounds for such arrest.
20.1.3.he constitutional and statutory framework thus mandates that the arrested person must be informed of the grounds of arrest but neither provision prescribes a speciic form or insists upon written communication in every case. Judicial precedents have clariied that substantial compliance with these requirements is suicient, unless demonstrable prejudice is shown.
20.1.4.In Vihaan Kumar vs. State of Haryana, 2025 SCC Online SC 456 it was reiterated that Article 22(1) is satisied if the accused is made aware of the arrest grounds in substance, even if not conveyed in writing. Similarly, in Kasireddy Upender Reddy vs. State of Andhra Pradesh, 2025 INSC 768 it was observed that when arrest is made pursuant a warrant, reading out the warrant amounts to suicient compliance. Both these post-Pankaj Bansal decisions clarify that written, individualised grounds are not an inlexible requirement in all circumstances.
20.1.5.While Section 50 Cr.P.C. is mandatory, the consistent judicial approach has been to adopt a prejudice-oriented test when examining alleged procedural lapses. he mere absence of written grounds does not ipso facto render the arrest illegal, unless it results in demonstrable prejudice or denial of a fair opportunity to defend.
20.1.6.he High Court, however, relied heavily on the alleged procedural lapse as a determinative factor while overlooking the gravity of the ofence under Section 302 IPC and the existence of a prima facie case. It noted, inter alia, that there was no mention in the remand orders about service of memo of grounds of arrest (Para 45); the arrest memos were allegedly template-based and not personalised (Para 50) and eyewitnesses had not stated that they were present at the time of arrest or had signed the memos (Para 48). Relying on Pankaj Bansal vs. Union of India, (2024) 7 SCC 576 and Prabir Purkayastha vs. State (NCT of Delhi) (supra), it concluded (Paras 43, 49-50) that from 03.10.2023 onwards, failure to serve detailed, written, and individualised grounds of arrest immediately after arrest was a violation entitling the accused to bail.
20.1.7.In the present case, the arrest memos and remand records clearly relect that the respondents were aware of the reasons for their arrest. hey were legally represented from the outset and applied for bail shortly after arrest, evidencing an immediate and informed understanding of the accusations. No material has been placed on record to establish that any prejudice was caused due to the alleged procedural lapse. In the absence of demonstrable prejudice, such as irregularity is, at best, a curable defect and cannot, by itself, warrant release on bail. As reiterated above, the High Court treated it as a determinative factor while overlooking the gravity of the charge under Section 302 IPC and the existence of a prima facie case. Its reliance on Pankaj Bansal and Prabir Purkayastha is misplaced, as those decisions turned on materially diferent facts and statutory contexts. he approach adopted here is inconsistent with the settled principle that procedural lapses in furnishing grounds of arrest, absent prejudice, do not ipso facto render custody illegal or entitle the accused to bail.”
After considering the earlier judgments and in particular referring to the judgment in the case of Vihan Kumar v/s. State of Haryana, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sri Darshan’s case laid down that “while Section 50 of Cr.P.C. was mandatory, the consistent judicial approach was to adopt a prejudice-oriented test when examining alleged procedural lapses. he mere absence of written grounds does not ipso facto render the arrest illegal, unless it results in demonstrable prejudice or denial of a fair opportunity to defend”.
In the present case, the learned APP has produced a copy of the order dated 13.05.2022 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Mapusa in the Petitioner’s Anticipatory Bail Application No.60/2022 in which he was seeking anticipatory bail in connection with Crime No.250/2020. Perusal of the said order shows that the entire allegations and material available against the Petitioner was discussed. he IO had iled a reply. he Petitioner was represented by his advocate Mr S. K. Pathan. he facts were discussed in detail. It was the case of the Petitioner that he had not committed any ofence as alleged, that he was falsely implicated, that he was prosecuted only on the ground of suspicion and that he had visited the Police Station several times concerning the investigation in that particular case.
After rejection of his anticipatory bail application by the Additional Sessions Judge, Mapusa, the Petitioner preferred anticipatory bail application before this Court vide Criminal Misc. Application (Bail) No.314/2022 (F) which was rejected vide order dated 13.07.2022. Again on this occasion, he was represented by his advocate Mr S. K. Pathan. Again the entire allegations were discussed and argued. he arguments of the Petitioner’s advocate were also noted in that order. hus the Petitioner was fully aware of the facts of the case pertaining to Crime No.250/2022 registered at Mapusa Police Station. After his anticipatory bail application was rejected, he was not available and he could inally be traced in Hubli, Karnataka as mentioned earlier and was arrested only after two years. It is speciically mentioned by the Investigating Oicer in his aidavit in reply that the Petitioner was arrested on 12.11.2024 and after informing him the grounds of arrest and apprehension, he was placed under arrest on 12.11.2024 at 22.55 hrs. Intimation of his arrest was given to his nephew Satish Naik over phone and his advocate Mr Salman Pathan, resident of Pune, Maharashtra was also informed. he background, and in particular the two orders passed in the anticipatory bail applications before the Sessions Court and this Court clearly establish that the Petitioner was fully aware of the facts of the case and as to why he was arrested. he requirement of informing him the grounds of arrest is suiciently complied with. He himself had remained absconding for over two years. herefore it cannot be argued on his behalf that he was not aware as to why he was arrested. hus from the record, it is obvious that no prejudice was caused to him when he was arrested. Moreover, there is no reason to doubt the statement made by the investigating oicer on aidavit that the Petitioner was informed regarding the grounds of arrest.
he next question raised in the argument was that the grounds of arrest were not given in writing. he same is taken care of by the observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Sri Darshan. In any case, the subsequent judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Mihir Rajesh Shah, also discusses this issue. Paragraph 50 of the said judgment reads thus:-
“50.It may so happen that in the presence of a police oicer a cognizable ofence is being committed and the factual matrix presents a tangible and imminent risk of the suspect absconding or committing further ofence(s). For instance, in a case involving a murder being committed in front of a police oicer, it may not be possible for the oicer to provide the grounds of arrest in writing before the arrest or forthwith on the arrest to the accused. A rigid insistence upon informing of written ground(s) of arrest before or at the time of efecting the arrest or immediately thereafter may result into police oicer not being able to discharge their duty and responsibility eiciently and efectively. he constitutional safeguards, valuable as they are, cannot be interpreted in a manner so as to allow it to metamorphose into a procedural impediment that handicaps the law enforcing agencies in due lawful discharge of their duties. herefore, a balance between compliance of the constitutional as also the statutorily mandated safeguards on the one hand vis-a-vis the efective discharge of lawful statutory law enforcement duties and responsibilities cast upon the State agencies must be struck.”
he case before us is a good example of the discussion made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Mihir Rajesh Shah’s case, necessitating striking of balance. he Hon’ble Supreme Court in conclusion held in paragraph 56 as follows:-
“56.In conclusion, it is held that:
i)he constitutional mandate of informing the arrestee the grounds of arrest is mandatory in all ofences under all statutes including ofences under IPC 1860 (now BNS 2023);
ii) he grounds of arrest must be communicated in writing to the arrestee in the language he/she understands;
iii) In case(s) where, the arresting oicer/person is unable to communicate the grounds of arrest in writing on or soon after arrest, it be so done orally. he said grounds be communicated in writing within a reasonable time and in any case at least two hours prior to production of the arrestee for remand proceedings before the magistrate.
iv) In case of non-compliance of the above, the arrest and subsequent remand would be rendered illegal and the person will be at liberty to be set free.”
More importantly, these guidelines are made prospective as is clear from paragraph 58 of the said judgment, which reads thus:-
“58.We are cognizant that there existed no consistent or binding requirement mandating written communication of the grounds of arrest for all the ofences. Holding as above, in our view, would ensure implementation of the constitutional rights provided to an arrestee as engrafted under Article 22 of the Constitution of India in an efective manner. Such clarity on obligation would avoid uncertainty in the administration of criminal justice. he ends of fairness and legal discipline therefore demand that this procedure as airmed above shall govern arrests henceforth.”
he concluding lines in paragraph 58 are clear enough to emphasize the conclusion we have reproduced hereinabove as “the ends of fairness and legal discipline therefore demand that this procedure as airmed above shall govern arrests henceforth”. (emphasis supplied)
Learned APP produced a copy of the memo of arrest dated 12.11.2024 signed by PSI, Margao Police Station wherein it was mentioned that the Petitioner was informed that he was arrested in connection with Crime No.250/2020 registered at Mapusa Police Station and intimation of his arrest was given to his family. Said memo of arrest bears signature of the Petitioner. A copy of the memo of arrest is taken on record and marked ‘X’ for identiication.
Copies of the documents referred to herein above are produced by the learned APP and the learned counsel for the Petitioner. he same are taken on record and marked as ‘Y Colly’ for identiication.
hus the ratio of all these judgments is now clear enough. he present case and the arrest was much prior to the date of the judgment in the case of Mihir Rajesh Shah which was delivered on 06.11.2025. We are dealing with the Petitioner’s arrest on 12.11.2024. In this view of the matter, the observations in the case of Sri Darshan govern the present facts and therefore the Petitioner does not deserve any beneit as is prayed for by the learned counsel.
hough it is not speciically pleaded, in the interest of justice, since the ground of liberty is raised, we have considered the Petitioner’s submissions that even his relatives or friends were not informed. here is a serious dispute raised by the learned counsel for the Petitioner and he has relied on the statement recorded by the police under Section 161 of Cr.P.C. (corresponding to Section 180 of BNSS). he provisions are very clear that the use of those statements is very limited and therefore those statements cannot be used for any other purpose and in particular for the purpose of observing whether said Satish Naik was the Petitioner’s relative or not.
On the other hand, the Investigating Oicer relied on the deposition of said Satish Naik recorded by the Additional Sessions Judge, North Goa, Panaji in Sessions Case No.57/2024. It was a statement on oath and was recorded on 17.08.2016. In that deposition under oath, the said Satish Naik had clearly stated that the Petitioner was his uncle. herefore we cannot ind fault with the Investigating Oicer’s approach in informing Satish Naik regarding the arrest of the Petitioner on 12.11.2024 in connection with Crime No.250/2020 registered at Mapusa Police Station.
For all the aforesaid observations, we are not inclined to grant any relief to the Petitioner. he Petition is accordingly dismissed. he Rule is discharged.
