Tribunals and CommissionsFull Bench(2025) 01 RERA CK 2332

Mr. Shishir Kumar Sinha vs M/s Purearth Infrastructure Ltd. & Ors.

Real Estate Regulatory Authority National Capital Territory Of Delhi · Decided on 21 January 2025

RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Com/13/04/2023

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

39 paragraphs · 1,447 words
1.

A complaint was filed in Form ‘M’ on 12.04.2023 by Mr. Shishir Kumar Sinha (hereinafter referred to as ‘Complainant’) whereby the Complainant submitted an account of prolonged real estate transaction that spans nearly three decades with the Respondent No. 1 Purearth Infrastructure Limited and Basant Projects Limited.

2.

Complainant submitted that in 1992, the Complainant responded to an advertisement and booked a 3 BHK flat by making initial payments totalling Rs. 5,67,000. Despite the upfront payments, he was never provided possession or clear communication about the property's status. The initial booking was for a flat in Ansals DCM Greens Acres, but the project underwent multiple transformations over the years. The Respondent No. 1 introduced a Scheme of Financial Restructuring and Arrangement (SoA), allegedly approved by the High Court of Delhi, which led to multiple changes in the project's configuration. Through various communications, the Complainant was informed about allotment changes, including a shift from the original project to Park Square Project and subsequently to "The Amaryllis" Phase-1.

3.

The Complainant submitted that throughout the decades-long process, he continued to cooperate and make additional payments. These included flyover charges, allotment money, and subsequent demands made by the Respondent No. 1. After nearly 29 years of waiting, an offer of possession for apartment T-11/702 in "The Amaryllis" Phase-1 was made in June 2021. The Complainant continued to make payments in good faith, including substantial amounts in 2021 and 2022, totalling several lakhs of rupees. The Complainant has maintained throughout that he never requested any changes to the apartment's location or size, and has consistently sought timely possession of the property he initially booked in 1992.

4.

In light of the above submissions, the Complainant prayed as follows:

i.

to direct the Respondent No. 1 to pay compensation with interest at 10% per annum for the inordinate delay in handing over possession; and;

ii.

to direct the Respondent No. 1 to hand over the possession of the flat to the Complainant.

5.

A preliminary hearing in the case was held on 22.05.2023. Notice of complaint was sent to the Respondent No. 1 on 06.06.2023 via registered post and on 07.06.2023 via e-mail.

6.

The matter was subsequently heard on 26.07.2023, 21.09.2023, 13.12.2023, 08.02.2024, 21.03.2024, 28.05.2024, 31.07.2024 and 25.09.2024. Despite multiple scheduled dates for hearing, the Respondent No. 1 consistently failed to file any reply to the Complainant's submissions. Consequently, the proceedings were declared ex-parte against the Respondent No. 1 on 08.02.2024.

7.

On the subsequent date of hearing on 21.03.2024, the Complainant's legal representative submitted an application under Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) for withdrawal of the complaint, which was originally filed on 13.03.2024. Simultaneously, it was formally informed to the Authority that the parties had amicably reached a settlement, resulting in the successful transfer of possession of the disputed flat to the Complainant.

8.

For the sake of convenience, the arguments and submissions made by the Complainant in the afore stated application are as follows:

a. The Complainant highlighted that he had been allotted unit T11-702 in "The Amaryllis" project, with the initial offer of possession issued on 10.06.2021, following which the complaint was originally filed in April 2023 seeking possession and compensation. Subsequently, Purearth Infrastructure Ltd. communicated via email dated 05.03.2024, proposing a resolution contingent upon the settlement of outstanding amounts and withdrawal of the RERA complaint.

b. The settlement terms comprehensively addressed the dispute, wherein the Complainant agreed to:

(i)

Make full payment of all outstanding amounts;

(ii)

Unconditionally withdraw any claims for compensation or additional amounts;

(iii)

Discharge Respondent No. 1 from all existing obligations related to the unit; and;

(iv)

File a formal withdrawal application before the Real Estate Regulatory Authority.

c. The application explicitly stated that upon execution of the sale deed, all disputes between the parties would stand conclusively resolved. The Complainant's application sought the Authority’s permission to:

a)

Allow withdrawal of the complaint b) Pass any other orders deemed appropriate in the interests of justice. The application was duly signed and accompanied by a verifying affidavit, substantiating the information and terms of settlement presented before the forum.

9.

Despite the withdrawal application being submitted, on 28.05.2024, the Ld. Counsel appearing for the Complainant acknowledged receipt of possession while simultaneously asserting that issues regarding delayed compensation remained unresolved.

10.

The Authority noted that while the withdrawal application was duly executed and signed, the Complainant expressed a desire to be personally heard. Consequently, an opportunity was extended for personal appearance. However, the Complainant failed to utilize this opportunity, remaining absent from the subsequent hearing.

11.

On 25.09.2024, with the Complainant again failing to appear, the Authority made a procedural determination to reserve the matter for orders regarding the withdrawal application. In the interest of justice, both the Complainant and Respondent No. 1 were granted an opportunity to file written submissions, with a stipulated deadline of 10.10.2024.

12.

On 10.10.2024, the Respondent No. 1 filed written submissions. The Respondent No. 1 argued that an amicable settlement had been reached, wherein the Complainant had taken possession of the unit T-11/702 in "The Amaryllis" Phase-1 project and executed a conveyance deed. They highlighted that the Complainant had voluntarily filed a withdrawal application on 06.03.2024 under Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 accompanied by an affidavit of undertaking that discharged the Respondent No. 1 from all obligations.

13.

Key contentions in the Respondent No. 1's submissions included:

(i)

The complaint was filed with fraudulent intentions to mislead the Authority.

(ii)

The Complainant had agreed to multiple settlement terms, including making full outstanding payments, waiving all compensation claims and discharging the Respondent No. 1 from all liabilities.

(iii)

The Complainant's failure to formally withdraw the complaint after receiving possession was characterized as a deliberate and unlawful strategy.

14.

The Respondent No. 1 emphasized that after receiving possession and executing the conveyance deed, the Complainant had no legal standing to continue the proceedings. They argued that the complaint was not maintainable in law and should be dismissed with substantial costs.

15.

The Respondent No. 1 further submitted that the Complainant had failed to file any written submissions or challenge the settlement terms, further undermining the credibility of the ongoing proceedings. Notably, the Complainant did not submit any written response or counter-arguments to the Respondent No. 1s’ detailed submissions.

Analysis and Consideration

16.

The present matter focuses on a real estate transaction that has spanned over nearly three decades, concerning a withdrawal application and associated compensation claims.

17.

The withdrawal application, submitted on 06.03.2024, stems from a real estate transaction that began in 1992. Throughout this period, the project underwent several transformations and involved substantial financial investments. A significant development in this case was the Complainant's voluntary execution of the withdrawal application along with an affidavit.

18.

The legal principle of approbate and reprobate plays a crucial role in this analysis. This principle prevents parties from simultaneously accepting and rejecting the same agreement. In this case, Complainant’s actions clearly demonstrate this conflict - he accepted possession of the unit and executed a conveyance deed, yet attempted to continue complaint proceedings by making submissions through the Ld. Counsel maintaining a claim for compensation. Such submissions contradict the basic principles of contractual good faith.

19.

The doctrine of promissory estoppel further supports the settlement's validity. Through his actions of executing promises within the settlement agreement, making payments and accepting the possession, the Complainant created legitimate expectations for the Respondent No. 1. Legal principles clearly establish that parties cannot unilaterally withdraw from such negotiated settlements, particularly after receiving and acknowledging substantial benefits based on the principles that one cannot blow hot and cold at the same point of time.

20.

The voluntary nature of the settlement holds particular importance in this case. Complainant executed the documents with complete understanding, free from external pressure. This voluntary participation significantly strengthens the settlement's legal validity. It is well-established that parties who make informed choices with full knowledge cannot later seek to undo their commitments.

21.

It is to be noted that during the hearings on 21.03.2024 and 28.05.2024, Advocate Meenu Pandey appeared on behalf of the Complainant and requested additional time to address the Authority on certain issues. However, no vakalatnama has been filed by the Ld. Counsel, and the Complainant has not personally appeared at these hearings. Consequently, the Authority cannot consider the submissions made by the Ld. Counsel, particularly given the lack of his proper legal authorization and the Complainant's absence.

22.

In the light of the aforesaid, the withdrawal application filed by the Complainant is hereby accepted.

23.

The complaint stands dismissed as withdrawn.

24.

The case is disposed of accordingly.

25.

No order as to costs.