AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
(Per Ashish S. Chavan, J.):
By way of this Appeal, the Appellant husband has raised a challenge to a judgment of the Family Court at Bandra (“Family Court”) dated 23.09.2019 (“impugned order”) inter alia dismissing the Petition filed by him against the Respondent wife seeking divorce on the ground of cruelty u/s 13 (1) (ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (“HMA”). The Appeal being admitted on 28.06.2024 and the Respondent being served and represented before this Court, the same was heard finally.
Bereft of unnecessary details, the factual matrix can be summarized thus:
The marriage between the Appellant and the Respondent was solemnized on 28.04.2013 in Mumbai as per Buddhist rites and rituals.
It is the pleaded case of the Appellant that for initial 6 months there was happy cohabitation between them however thereafter, certain problems started cropping up leading to start of a marital discord between the Appellant and the Respondent. These events and incidents are set out in the Marriage Petition before the Family Court.
Shortly after the marriage, the Respondent wife after medical examination was informed by the doctor that she was pregnant. The Appellant accompanied her on various occasions to appointment with doctors and the Respondent stayed at her parents house in Nerul. One day, the Appellant received a call from the Respondent informing him that she had miscarried. The Appellant has pleaded that he was shocked on hearing this and that the Respondent thereafter started making allegations against him that he was responsible for the miscarriage. After this incident, the rift between the parties widened. The Respondent refused to return back to her matrimonial home.
The Appellant has narrated several incidents in his Petition before the Ld. Family Court describing how the Respondent behaved cruelly and caused distress to the Appellant. He has pleaded that despite the acrimonious behavior of his wife, he and his family members made all efforts to reconcile and requested the Respondent wife to come back to the matrimonial house.
On 24.09.2014, the Appellant received a letter from the Special Cell for Women and Children, CBD Belapur informing him that the Respondent had registered a complaint against him. During the course of inquiry with the lady police officer, seeking to explore an amicable solution to the martial discord, the Respondent remained adamant and refused to resume the conjugal life.
It is the specific case of the Appellant that the Respondent has left the matrimonial house on 13.05.2014 and since then she is residing at her parental house. This, as pleaded by the Appellant amounts to desertion and the acts of the Respondent make out a case of cruelty.
In the proceedings before the Ld. Family Court, the Respondent though served and marked her presence, failed to file her say. It is in this background, that the Ld. Family Court proceeded to hear the matter without the written statement of the Respondent.
Vide the impugned order dated 23.09.2019, the Ld. Family Court dismissed the Petition of the Appellant, aggrieved by which he has filed the present Appeal.
On behalf of the Appellant, reiterating his stand before the Ld. Family Court, it was sought to be argued that Respondent has deliberately and consistently through her conduct demonstrated that she had no interest in resuming the martial ties and the incidents pleaded by the Appellant husband before the Ld. Family Court and also before this Court which remain uncontroverted, clearly make out a case of cruelty within the provisions of Section 13 (1) (ia) of the HMA. It was submitted that the Respondent’s conduct towards the Appellant and his mother at various instances has caused distress to the Appellant, however, despite the same he made not one but multiple attempts to mend the marital relations. The Appellant submitted that he tried to convince the Respondent and even sought intervention of the elders in the family, all of which were in vain insofar as the Respondent continued to refuse to return to the matrimonial home. It is also pleaded that the Respondent has admitted that she was romantically involved with another man during the subsistence of her marriage with the Appellant, however, subsequently she claimed it to be a lie, which according to the Ld. Counsel for the Appellant was an upsetting and distressing event for him. It is also submitted that at various times, the Respondent has expressed her wish for the Appellant to seek divorce from her, however, on instituting proceedings for divorce, the Respondent though aware of the same, marked her appearance through her advocate but did not contest the same. It was sought to be argued that the Respondent left the matrimonial home since 13.05.2014 and hasn’t returned since. Therefore, it was argued that given the long period of separation and the conduct of the Respondent before the Ld. Family Court and this Court of neither contesting the proceedings nor seeking divorce by mutual consent, would amount to cruelty insofar as the Appellant is compelled to be part of a marital tie which has broken down irretrievably. Therefore it is prayed that the conduct of the Respondent amounts to cruelty u/s 13 (1) (ia) of the HMA and considering her refusal for cohabitation for almost 12 years, this is a case of desertion by the Respondent u/s 13 (1) (ib) of the HMA and hence, the Appellant deserves to be granted a decree of divorce from the Respondent.
On behalf of the Respondent wife, although, an appearance was entered into and she was represented by an advocate, despite giving number of opportunities to her advocate, to make submissions, the Ld. Advocate for the Respondent wife on instructions submitted that the Respondent has nothing to say in the matter and has left it to this Court to pass appropriate orders. She also submitted that the Respondent did not want to obtain divorce by way of mutual consent.
The facts in the present proceedings have given rise to a peculiar situation which would adequately set out the context in which we would base our observations and findings. The Respondent wife, although served in the proceedings before the Ld. Family Court and this Court has been represented by an Advocate. However, she has chosen not to contest the contentions of the Appellant husband, while at the same time, refusing to dissolve the martial ties by way of divorce by mutual consent.
The Appellant has approached this Court making out a case of cruelty and desertion against the Respondent which forms part of the pleadings before the Ld. Family Court. A perusal of the pleadings reveals that for a brief period of six months following the marriage, the Appellant and the Respondent were happily cohabiting in their matrimonial home along with the Appellants mother. After about six months, the Respondent on finding out that she is pregnant, left the matrimonial home and stayed at her parental house. Under the impression that the Respondent was staying at her parental house for pre-natal care, and with the understanding that she will return in a few days, the Appellant did not make any grievance and on the contrary accompanied her to various medical appointments. He also visited the Respondent from time to time and inquired after her health. After about a month, on one such occasion, when the Appellant requested her to come back to her matrimonial home, the Respondent replied that she would do so only if the Appellant agreed to live in a nuclear family system, in a separate house from that of his parents. After much deliberation and convincing, the Respondent wife agreed to return to her matrimonial house.
Shortly thereafter, the Respondent wife suffered a miscarriage, due to which she was distressed and underwent mental trauma. She repeatedly started attributing the blame for the miscarriage to the Appellant for no perceivable fault of his, which was upsetting to him.
On noticing that the Respondent would spend considerable time chatting with someone on voice calls, the Appellant inquired about the same, to which the Respondent replied that she used to talk to one of her female friends Neha. However, subsequently, the same turned out to be a lie as admitted by the Respondent herself and she claimed that she was infact talking to her paramour. She expressed her wish to marry him and for the Appellant to seek a divorce from her. At first, the Appellant although taken aback by this turn of events, disbelieved her and brushed aside her assertions, giving her the benefit of doubt . However, since she reiterated these assertions repeatedly, the Appellant was given in to believing her and this caused him extreme mental distress. The consistent attempts of the Appellant to mend the marital ties were rebuffed by the Respondent wife. The Appellant has cited one such occasion of ‘Valentines Day’, when the he had decided to spend some time together with the Respondent, who cancelled the plans at the eleventh hour pointedly reiterating her love for her paramour.
The Appellant has pleaded that subsequently, the Respondent retracted the aforesaid story admitting it to be false and on the contrary told the Appellant that she was only talking with her female friend Neha. These diametrically opposed versions of the Respondent’s narrative caused a great deal of mental disturbance to the Appellant.
It is the contention of the Appellant that the Respondent’s conduct during an incident in the month of May 2014 marked the ultimate collapse of an already strained marriage. One day the Appellant’s mother received a phone call from the Respondent’s mobile number and a lady named Neha informed her that the Respondent will not be coming home that night due to some celebrations. Both, the Appellant and his mother insisted for the Respondent to return home by 9.00 pm, however, she refused. At about 9.30 pm on the same night, the Appellant called the Respondent out of worry, however, her phone was switched off and hence they called Neha’s mother who informed that both Neha and the Respondent were sleeping. It is the Appellant’s contention that the Respondent did not like that he called Neha’s mother and the same led to a fight between the parties the very next morning.
Following the marital discord, the Respondent lodged a NC Report with the Nerul Police Station, wherein the Appellant was called for an inquiry and then released. Thus began a series of attempts to salvage the marital tie. The Appellant involved the Respondent’s parents in the matter, hoping for a reconciliation with the intervention of the elders, however the same yielded no positive outcome. The Respondent filed another complaint with the Special Cell for Women and children, CBD Belapur. Pursuant to the said complaint, a series of meetings were held to bring about reconciliation between the parties. During the course of these hearings, the Respondent expressed her wish to seek divorce from the Appellant. As a final attempt to save the marital tie, the Respondent’s father referred the dispute to Buddhist Panchayat, Kamothe. Despite meetings involving the parties as well as the elders of the family, there was no positive outcome.
Before adverting to the facts of the case, it would be apposite to set out set out various judicial pronouncements relating to matrimonial jurisprudence relating to the grounds of cruelty and desertion as defined in the HMA. Although the term “irretrievable breakdown of marriage” has been the focal point of several judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court, one of the earliest references to this term is found in the judgment of the Apex Court in Ms. Jorden Diengdeh vs S S Chopra1. The concept of irretrievable breakdown of marriage was commented upon and exercising its power under Article 142 of the Constitution of India, in several judgments, the Hon’ble Apex Court has given its imprimatur to the concept of “irretrievable breakdown of marriage” as a ground for divorce, especially in the framework of HMA.
In the case of Samar Ghosh vs. Jaya Ghosh2, the Apex Court has given several illustrations of cruelty which are as under:
“101.No uniform standard can ever be laid down for guidance, yet we deem it appropriate to enumerate some instances of human behaviour which may be relevant in dealing with the cases of “mental cruelty”. The instances indicated in the succeeding paragraphs are only illustrative and not exhaustive:
(i)On consideration of complete matrimonial life of the parties, acute mental pain, agony and suffering as would not make possible for the parties to live with each other could come within the broad parameters of mental cruelty.
(ii)On comprehensive appraisal of the entire matrimonial life of the parties, it becomes abundantly clear that situation is such that the wronged party cannot reasonably be asked to put up with such conduct and continue to live with other party.
(iii)Mere coldness or lack of affection cannot amount to cruelty, frequent rudeness of language, petulance of manner, indifference and neglect may reach such a degree that it makes the married life for the other spouse absolutely intolerable.
(iv)Mental cruelty is a state of mind. The feeling of deep anguish, disappointment, frustration in one spouse caused by the conduct of other for a long time may lead to mental cruelty.
(v)A sustained course of abusive and humiliating treatment calculated to torture, discommode or render miserable life of the spouse.
(vi)Sustained unjustifiable conduct and behaviour of one spouse actually affecting physical and mental health of the other spouse. The treatment complained of and the resultant danger or apprehension must be very grave, substantial and weighty.
(vii)Sustained reprehensible conduct, studied neglect, indifference or total departure from the normal standard of conjugal kindness causing injury to mental health or deriving sadistic pleasure can also amount to mental cruelty.
(viii)The conduct must be much more than jealousy, selfishness, possessiveness, which causes unhappiness and dissatisfaction and emotional upset may not be a ground for grant of divorce on the ground of mental cruelty.
(ix)Mere trivial irritations, quarrels, normal wear and tear of the married life which happens in day-to-day life would not be adequate for grant of divorce on the ground of mental cruelty.
(x)The married life should be reviewed as a whole and a few isolated instances over a period of years will not amount to cruelty. The ill conduct must be persistent for a fairly lengthy period, where the relationship has deteriorated to an extent that because of the acts and behaviour of a spouse, the wronged party finds it extremely difficult to live with the other party any loner, may amount to mental cruelty.
(xi)If a husband submits himself for an operation of sterilisation without medical reasons and without the consent or knowledge of his wife and similarly, it the wife undergoes vasectomy or abortion without medical reason or without the consent or knowledge of her husband, such an act of the spouse may lead to mental cruelty.
(xii)Unilateral decision or refusal to have intercourse for considerable period without there being any physical incapacity or valid reason may amount to mental cruelty.
(xiii)Unilateral decision of either husband or wife after marriage not to have a child f rom the m arriage may amount to cruelty.
(xiv)Where there has been a long period of continuous separation, it may fairly be concluded that the matrimonial bond is beyond repair. The marriage becomes a fiction though supported by a legal tie. By refusing to sever that tie, the law in such cases, does not serve the sanctity of marriage; on the contrary, it shows scant regard for the feelings and emotions of the parties. In such like situations, it may lead to mental cruelty.”
(emphasis supplied)
The judgment of Rakesh Raman vs Kavita3 further expands the horizon of the interpretation of the concept of cruelty within the framework of HMA, incorporating the elements of irretrievable breakdown of marriage. Quoting extensively from Samar Ghosh (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court observes that although irretrievable breakdown of marriage may not be a statutory ground for dissolution of marriage under HMA, however cruelty certainly is. Speaking through Sudhanshu Dhulia J (as his Lordship then was), the Court observed:
“22.Irretrievable breakdown of a marriage may not be a ground for dissolution of marriage, under the Hindu Marriage Act, but cruelty is. A marriage can be dissolved by a decree of divorce, inter alia, on the ground when the other party “has, after the solemnisation of the marriage treated the petitioner with cruelty”.
23.In our considered opinion, a marital relationship which has only become more bitter and acrimonious over the years, does nothing but inflict cruelty on both the sides. To keep the facade of this broken marriage alive would be doing injustice to both the parties. A marriage which has broken down irretrievably, in our opinion spells cruelty to both the parties, as in such a relationship each party is treating the other with cruelty. It is therefore a ground for dissolution of marriage under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the Act.”
This view has also been echoed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the recent case of Sonal Talpada vs. Veerbhan Singh4 where after referring to several previous judgments, including Samar Ghosh (supra), dealing with a case arising out of an Appeal from the High Court where the parties had been living separately for several years, observed this:
“24.This Court in multitude of cases, has held that in situations where parties have been living separately for a considerable time without any hope for reconciliation amounts to cruelty to both the parties.
25.In the light of the above, it can be said that the High Court has rightly assessed that where parties have been living separately for several years and at this stage asking them to live together after a prolonged duration would amount to cruelty to both the parties and divorce can be granted on this ground as provided under section 13 (1) (ia) of HMA. It may be added here that desertion as a ground requires an initial period as mentioned under the statute but if such desertion continues for a long period of time without any effort on the part of the parties to restore cohabitation would itself be a ground to be considered by the Appellate Court. This we say in the light of the fact that human relations are dynamic and once the initial mandate under the statute stands satisfied, continuation thereof during the litigation would aggravate the said agony which could be confirmational in substantiating the basis and pleaded ground for divorce. The same can be taken into consideration for formation of an opinion to accept the prayer by the Appellate Court. Appeal is the continuation of a suit and therefore, the Appellate Court would be entitled and justified to consider the conduct of the parties during the pendency of litigation. The same can also be looked into to support or reject an opinion on the ground in question.
26.An Appellate Court, while carefully ensuring that a party does not profit from their own manifest wrong or unilateral desertion, may legitimately treat a prolonged period of separation as an indicator of mental cruelty within the meaning of Section 13(1)(ia) of the HMA. The Appellate Court is not precluded from examining whether continuous separation over a substantial period, coupled with absence of any genuine effort at reconciliation, complete cessation of cohabitation and emotional alienation has resulted in mental cruelty. Subsequent events occurring during pendency of proceedings may legitimately be taken into consideration while undertaking such assessment. In such circumstances, the confirmation of a decree of divorce by an Appellate Court is not an invocation of extraordinary constitutional jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution of India, but a lawful and realistic application of the statutory ground of cruelty to the facts of the case.”
(emphasis supplied)
Revisiting the facts of the present case, in the backdrop of the preceding discussion, we find that the Appellant has made out a case of cruelty against the Respondent which has not been contested by the Respondent. It is also not in dispute that there has been 12 years of continuous separation between the parties which, leads us to observe that the matrimonial bond is beyond repair. The prolonged separation in itself is mental cruelty as can be seen from the various judicial pronouncements referred to hereinabove. In the facts of the present case, the marital relationship has only become more bitter and acrimonious over the years. To keep the facade of this broken marriage alive, would be doing injustice to both parties. Consequently, in the facts of the present case, in our opinion, the Appellant has made out a case of cruelty and desertion.
We find substance in the submissions of the Ld. Counsel for the Appellant that the unprovoked and unreasonable withdrawal of the Respondent from the company of the Appellant, contradictory stands taken by her regarding her romantic involvement with another man, her persistent and unreasonable refusal to resume her matrimonial ties with the Appellant despite consistent efforts made by him and his family to reconcile and the vexatious and vindictive criminal proceedings initiated by the Respondent amount to cruelty as per Section 13 (1) (ia) of the HMA.
It is not disputed that the Respondent has withdrawn from the company of the Appellant since 13.05.2014. Thus, the Appellant has demonstrated desertion by the Respondent for the last 12 years, satisfying the ingredients of Section 13 (1) (ib) of the HMA.
In the wake of the aforesaid discussion, we have no hesitation in coming to a conclusion that the impugned order deserves to be set aside and the parties be granted divorce u/s 13 (1) (ia) and 13 (1) (ib) of HMA.
Hence the following order:
: ORDER :
Family Court Appeal No. 11 of 2022 is allowed. Impugned order passed by the Family Court, Bandra dated 23.09.2019 in Petition No. A – 795 of 2016 is set aside.
The marriage solemnized between the parties on 28.04.2013 stands dissolved under Section 13 (1) (ia) and 13 (1) (ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
Decree to be drawn up accordingly.
