AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Heard.
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard finally with the consent of the learned counsel appearing for the parties.
The present petition prays for quashing and setting aside and cancelling of minutes of meeting dated 26.09.2026, 04.10.2026, order dated 07.10.2026 minutes/order sheet dated 24.10.2026 and the order dated 24.10.2026 passed by the learned Arbitral Tribunal in Arbitration Case No.04/2024.
The brief facts necessary for the disposal of the present petition are as under : -
(4.1) The petitioners herein are the respondents before the Arbitral Tribunal and present respondents are claimant before the Tribunal. The petitioner No.1 and respondent were partners in a partnership firm namely ‘Shreem Infratech’, wherein, petitioner No.2 was subsequently inducted as partner by amending the partnership deed on 18.02.2021.
(4.2) It is alleged by the petitioners that respondent started taking decisions without informing/consulting them and gradually sidelined them and their access to financial operations of the firm. He also alleges that respondents have misappropriated funds of the partnership firm approximately to the tune of Rs.2.19 Crores. Aggrieved thereby the petitioners resigned from the partnership firm in terms of Amended Deed of Partnership, and subsequently constituted another partnership firm under the name and style of ‘Power Tech Infra’.
(4.3) However, the respondents subsequently alleged that the petitioners were seeking to poach clients from them and took advantage of the goodwill of ‘Shreem Infractech’. Pursuant to which the respondents invoked arbitration, and filed an application before this Court under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,1996 vide MCA (Arbitration) No.642 of 2023, pursuant to which this Court vice its order dated 03.10.2024 was pleased to appoint Shri A.S. Shivankar, retired District and Session Judge as sole Arbitrator.
(4.4) Pursuant to constitution of Arbitration Tribunal first sitting took place on 07.01.2025. Thereafter, on 13.05.2026 petitioners filed an application seeking disclosure of several documents lying in possession of the respondents, however, the same is still pending before the learned Tribunal. In the interregnum pleadings were completed between the parties on 18.06.2026. Thereafter, on 30.06.2026, learned Tribunal directed the respondents to submit their affidavit of evidence-in-chief before 13.07.2026. Pursuant to which respondents filed their affidavit of evidence-in-chief on 20.07.2026. Thereafter, the matter was fixed for evidence (i.e. Cross-examination of respondent’s witness) on 26.07.2026, however, as pleaded by the petitioners that their counsel appearing before learned Tribunal was suffering from severe ailment and was under treatment, therefore, an application for adjournment was filed by learned counsel for petitioners and the matter was adjourned to 26.09.2026.
(4.5) Thereafter, on 26.09.2026, learned Arbitrator in his minutes of meeting recorded that neither the petitioners nor their counsel attended the meeting and noted that despite giving sufficient time, the petitioners conduct appears to be casual. Further, the respondents vide pursis at Exh C-48 filed evidence closure pursis and accordingly, the learned Tribunal closed the matter for petitioners evidence and adjourned the meeting to 04.10.2026.
(4.6) On 04.10.2026 again petitioners via e-mail filed an application for adjournment at Exhibit R-7 and an application at Exhibit R-8 seeking recall of the procedural order dated 26.09.2026 which closed the right of the petitioners for cross-examination, and also prayed for disposal of pending interlocutory application and rescheduling the matter for recording of evidence.
(4.7) However, vide Order dated 07.10.2026, the learned Tribunal was pleased to reject the applications at Exhibit R-7 and R-8, by observing that the application seeking adjournment is nothing but a duplicate copy of the earlier application for adjournment and the application at Exhibit R-8 is neither signed by the petitioner nor his Counsel and the said application were filed only to protract and delay the proceedings. Consequently, the learned Tribunal closed the case for final arguments on 24.10.2026.
(4.8) Subsequently, on 24.10.2026, vide Exhibit R-9 and R-10, the petitioners through representative of their counsel filed an application for grant of adjournment till the disposal of Arbitration Appeal No.256 of 2026 pending before this Court and an application under section 14 (1) (a) and 18 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 respectively. However, the learned Tribunal vide Order dated 24.10.2026, passed below Exhibit R-9 and R-10 was pleased to reject the said applications, by observing that the matter was already adjourned multiple times and mere pendency of a matter before the higher court cannot be a ground for adjournment. The learned Tribunal further observed that the application at Exhibit R-10 was prima facie frivolous, baseless and untenable, and accordingly proceeded to close the matter for passing of Award. Aggrieved thereby the petitioners have approached this Court by invoking Article 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.
I have heard learned counsel appearing for the respective parties.
The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the impugned orders have been passed without giving an opportunity of hearing to the petitioners. He further submits that the minutes of the meeting dated 26.09.2026, which deprived the petitioners from their right to cross-examine the respondents witness was not received by the petitioners through the designated channels of communication, and the same was only discovered through a third party communication.
He further submits that the orders passed by the learned Tribunal are ex-facie non speaking and are vitiated by non application of mind, as the learned Tribunal has rejected the applications by merely describing them as frivolous, baseless and untenable without addressing a substantive allegation alleged therein.
He further relies on the Judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Deep Industries Ltd. Vs. Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. and anr., reported in (2020) 15 SCC 706, to contend that this Hon’ble Court can invoke its Writ Jurisdiction under Article 227.
Per contra the learned counsel appearing for the respondent supports the impugned order and relies on the following judgments:-
Deep Industries Ltd. Vs. Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. and anr., reported in (2020) 15 SCC 706; and
GTPL Hathway Ltd. vs. Strategic Marketing Pvt. Ltd., R/SCA No. 4524 of 2019, High Court of Judicature at Ahemdabad.
I have heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and rival contentions fall for my consideration. From the narration of facts as stated supra, it is clear that there has been some negligence on the part of the present petitioners in prosecuting the arbitration proceedings.
The learned counsel for the petitioners has relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court reported in Deep Industries Ltd. Vs. Oil and National Gas Corporation Ltd., reported in (2020) 15 SCC page 706 and more particularly, para 17 thereof. In the said paragraph, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed as under:
“17.This being the case, there is no doubt whatsoever that if petitions were to be filed under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution against orders passed in appeals under Section 37, the entire arbitral process would be derailed and would not come to fruition for many years. At the same time, we cannot forget that Article 227 is a constitutional provision which remains untouched by the non-obstante clause of Section 5 of the Act. In these circumstances, what is important to note is that though petitions can be filed under Article 227 against judgments allowing or dismissing first appeals under Section 37 of the Act, yet the High Court would be extremely circumspect in interfering with the same, taking into account the statutory policy as adumbrated by us hereinabove so that interference is restricted to orders that are passed which are patently lacking in inherent jurisdiction.”
It is, thus, clear that the judgment in S.B.P. and Co. Vs. Patel Engineering Ltd. and anr., referred to supra, has been considered and relied upon in the present matter. Thus, the question which fell for consideration in Deep Industries was regarding maintainability of petition under Article 227 after decision of an appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
As per the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in SBP Limited, referred to supra, there is no scope for interference in the interim orders of the Arbitral tribunal. The reliance placed by learned counsel for the petitioner in the judgment of Deep Industries, and more particularly, para 17 thereof, cannot be disputed. But it also cautions that this Court should be extremely circumspect in interfering with the order passed under 37 of the Act. Thus, as I have stated supra, the question which fell for consideration in Deep Industries was entirely different. It, therefore, follows that the authoritative pronouncement of SBP Company being a binding precedent needs to be followed.
A beneficial reference can be made by reproducing paragraph 45 of the judgment in the case of S.B.P. and Co. Vs. Patel Engineering Ltd. and another.
“45.It is seen that some High Courts have proceeded on the basis that any order passed by an arbitral tribunal during arbitration, would be capable of being challenged under Article 226 or 227 of the Constitution of India. We see no warrant for such an approach. Section 37 makes certain orders of the arbitral tribunal appealable. Under Section 34, the aggrieved party has an avenue for ventilating his grievances against the award including any in-between orders that might have been passed by the arbitral tribunal acting under Section 16 of the Act. The party aggrieved by any order of the arbitral tribunal, unless has a right of appeal under Section 37 of the Act, has to wait until the award is passed by the Tribunal. This appears to be the scheme of the Act. The arbitral tribunal is after all, a creature of a contract between the parties, the arbitration agreement, even though if the occasion arises, the Chief Justice may constitute it based on the contract between the parties. But that would not alter the status of the arbitral tribunal. It will still be a forum chosen by the parties by agreement. We, therefore, disapprove of the stand adopted by some of the High Courts that any order passed by the arbitral tribunal is capable of being corrected by the High Court under Article 226 or 227 of the Constitution of India. Such an intervention by the High Courts is not permissible.”
In view of that authoritative pronouncement, the interim orders passed by the Arbitral Tribunal during the arbitration proceedings cannot be interfered with. In addition to this, the present petition also challenges orders passed by the Tribunal under Section 17 of the Act. The challenge, in my considered opinion, is misconceived, in as much as there is an appeal provided under Section 37 of the said Act to the said challenge. Taking overall view of the matter and in view of the binding precedent of SBP, I am of the considered opinion that no interference is called for. In that view of the matter, the petition is liable to be dismissed.
