AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Deepak Gupta, J.
The present appeal has been preferred by the claimants against the award dated 19.01.2022 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sonipat (hereinafter referred to as 'the Tribunal'), whereby the claim petition filed under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, seeking compensation on account of death of Amin in a motor vehicular accident dated 11.06.2018, has been dismissed.
Briefly, the case of the claimants is that on 11.06.2018, at about 4:00 a.m., deceased Amin, who was a driver by profession, was assisting complainant Narender in removing the tyre of a stationary vehicle near Rama School, Dujana-Beri Road, Jhajjar. At that time, truck bearing registration No.HR-73-7249, driven by respondent No.1-Om Kumar, allegedly in a rash and negligent manner, struck against the vehicles and thereafter hit Amin, resulting in his death on the spot. FIR No.279 dated 11.06.2018 was registered at Police Station Beri, District Jhajjar, under Sections 279, 337 and 304-A IPC.
The claim petition was filed by the widow, two minor sons and parents of the deceased, claiming compensation of ₹50,00,000. It was pleaded that the deceased was about 30 years old and was earning ₹25,000 per month as a heavy motor vehicle driver.
The driver and owner of the offending truck denied its involvement in the accident, whereas the Insurance Company also disputed the involvement of the vehicle and raised objections regarding liability.
The claimants examined Sharmila (PW1) widow of the deceased, Narender (PW2) complainant and eyewitness, and HC Sunil Kumar (PW3) Investigating Officer. The respondents did not examine any witness in oral evidence.
The Tribunal dismissed the claim petition primarily on the ground that the initial complaint, on the basis of which the FIR was registered, did not mention the registration number of the offending vehicle or the identity of its driver. The Tribunal noticed that the vehicle number and the driver's name surfaced in the supplementary statement of Narender recorded on 13.06.2018. Finding certain contradictions between the testimony of Narender and that of the Investigating Officer, the Tribunal concluded that the involvement of the offending truck and negligence of its driver had not been established. Consequently, the remaining issues were decided against the claimants without determining the compensation payable.
Assailing the award, Learned counsel for the appellants submits that the Tribunal has adopted an unduly technical approach while appreciating the evidence. It is contended that the accident itself was never in serious dispute and the deceased admittedly lost his life in the occurrence. Narender (PW2), who was himself injured, supported the involvement of the offending truck. The vehicle was subsequently taken into police possession, mechanically inspected and released on superdari to its registered owner. The Investigating Officer also filed the charge-sheet against respondent No.1. It is submitted that these circumstances, considered cumulatively, establish the involvement and negligent driving of the offending truck on the touchstone of preponderance of probabilities.
Conversely, learned counsel for the respondents supports the impugned award and contends that the initial complaint was against an unknown vehicle and driver. It is argued that the subsequent introduction of the vehicle number, without any independent evidence regarding its identification, creates serious doubt about its involvement. The contradictions in the statements of Narender and the Investigating Officer are stated to be material and sufficient to sustain the dismissal of the claim petition.
I have considered the rival submissions and perused the impugned award.
It is well settled that proceedings before a Motor Accident Claims Tribunal are summary in nature and the standard of proof applicable to a criminal trial cannot be imported into proceedings under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act. Negligence is required to be established on the touchstone of preponderance of probabilities. In Bimla Devi and others v. Himachal Road Transport Corporation and others, (2009) 13 SCC 530, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the Tribunal must adopt a holistic approach while appreciating the evidence concerning the occurrence of a motor vehicular accident. Similar principles were reiterated in Mangla Ram v. Oriental Insurance Company Limited, (2018) 5 SCC 656, and Sunita and others v. Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation and another, (2020) 13 SCC 486.
In the present case, the Tribunal has attached decisive importance to the omission of the registration number of the offending truck in the initial complaint. Undoubtedly, such an omission is a relevant circumstance requiring examination, particularly where the involvement of the vehicle is disputed. However, the omission cannot, by itself, justify the rejection of the claim when subsequent evidence and surrounding circumstances furnish material connecting the vehicle with the accident.
Narender (PW2) was not merely a witness introduced subsequently. He was the complainant and had himself sustained injuries in the occurrence. His presence at the spot is, therefore, supported by the circumstances in which the accident took place. He categorically deposed regarding the involvement of truck bearing registration No.HR-73-7249 and denied the suggestion that the vehicle had been falsely implicated to facilitate the claim for compensation.
The Tribunal noticed that Narender had stated during cross-examination that he had disclosed the registration number to the police on the date of the accident, whereas his supplementary statement dated 13.06.2018 indicated that he subsequently came to know about the vehicle and its driver when the driver approached him for a compromise. The said discrepancy certainly required consideration. However, the Tribunal treated it as sufficient, by itself, to discredit the entire claim, without appreciating the remaining evidence in its proper perspective.
Significantly, the offending truck was taken into police possession on 20.06.2018 and subjected to mechanical inspection. The claimants specifically pointed out before the Tribunal that the vehicle was found damaged and was subsequently released on superdari to its registered owner on 21.06.2018. These circumstances were relevant to the question of involvement of the vehicle. Although seizure, mechanical inspection and release on superdari do not independently establish negligence, they constitute corroborative circumstances which were required to be considered along with the testimony of the eyewitness and the investigation conducted by the police.
Further, HC Sunil Kumar (PW3), the Investigating Officer, appeared before the Tribunal and proved the investigation conducted in the criminal case. The investigation culminated in the prosecution of respondent No.1. The filing of a charge-sheet is not conclusive proof of negligence, but is a relevant circumstance which cannot be disregarded merely because the vehicle was identified after registration of the FIR.
Another significant circumstance is that respondent No.1-Om Kumar, who was driving the offending truck and was best placed to explain the manner of occurrence, did not enter the witness box. The respondents did not lead any oral evidence to substantiate their plea that the truck was falsely implicated. Though the burden of establishing negligence initially rested upon the claimants, the failure of the driver to controvert the material evidence assumes relevance once the claimants have produced an eyewitness account supported by the subsequent investigation.
The Tribunal has also referred to Section 11 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, while considering the alleged contradictions in the testimony of Narender. However, the mere existence of an inconsistency does not necessarily render the entire testimony unreliable. The Court is required to examine whether the inconsistency goes to the root of the matter and whether the remaining evidence, considered cumulatively, establishes the occurrence on the applicable standard of proof. The approach adopted by the Tribunal, in treating the discrepancy regarding the stage at which the registration number became known as virtually conclusive against the claimants, is not in consonance with the principles governing adjudication of motor accident claims.
The circumstances emerging from the record, namely, the testimony of injured eyewitness Narender (PW2), the supplementary statement identifying the offending vehicle, its subsequent seizure and mechanical inspection, release on superdari, filing of the charge-sheet against respondent No.1 and the absence of any rebuttal evidence from the driver, are required to be appreciated collectively. The fact that the registration number was not mentioned in the initial FIR does not outweigh all these circumstances. The evidence is sufficient, on the touchstone of preponderance of probabilities, to establish that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of truck bearing registration No.HR-73-7249 by respondent No.1.
Consequently, the finding returned by the Tribunal on Issue No.1 is legally unsustainable and is hereby set aside. Issue No.1 is decided in favour of the claimants and against the respondents, holding that the accident dated 11.06.2018, resulting in the death of Amin, occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the aforesaid truck by respondent No.1-Om Kumar.
Remand on remaining issues
Having reversed the finding on negligence, the question arises whether this Court should itself determine compensation or remit the matter to the Tribunal. A perusal of the impugned award reveals that the Tribunal, having decided Issue No.1 against the claimants, did not undertake any meaningful assessment of the deceased's income, loss of dependency or compensation payable under the conventional heads. The other issues were also decided consequentially, without independent adjudication of the material questions concerning liability.
Although the appellate Court is ordinarily expected to decide the controversy finally and avoid unnecessary remand, the present case stands on a different footing. The Tribunal has not returned findings on the essential components necessary for determination of just compensation. It would, therefore, be appropriate that these questions be examined by the Tribunal in the first instance, particularly as the parties may be required to address the evidence concerning the deceased's occupation, income and other relevant circumstances.
Accordingly, the matter is remitted to the Tribunal for fresh adjudication confined to Issue Nos.2, 3 and 4, including determination of just compensation and liability of the respective respondents. The finding recorded by this Court on Issue No.1 regarding involvement of the offending truck and negligence of its driver shall be final for the purposes of the remanded proceedings and shall not be reopened.
The Tribunal shall determine the compensation payable to the claimants in accordance with the settled principles laid down in Sarla Verma and others v. Delhi Transport Corporation and another, (2009) 6 SCC 121; National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi and others, (2017) 16 SCC 680; and other applicable judgments. The respective entitlement of the widow, minor children and parents of the deceased shall also be considered in accordance with law.
Since the claim petition was instituted in the year 2018 and considerable time has already elapsed, the Tribunal shall endeavour to decide the remaining issues expeditiously, preferably within four months from the date of appearance of the parties. The parties shall be afforded an opportunity to address arguments on the evidence already available on record. If the Tribunal considers any additional evidence necessary for proper adjudication of the remaining issues, it may permit the same for reasons to be recorded, without allowing the parties to reopen the question of negligence already determined by this Court.
Consequently, the present appeal is allowed. The impugned award dated 19.01.2022 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sonipat, dismissing the claim petition, is set aside. The finding on Issue No.1 is reversed and the said issue is decided in favour of the claimants. The matter is remitted to the Tribunal for fresh adjudication of the remaining issues in accordance with the directions contained hereinabove.
The parties, through their respective counsel, are directed to appear before the Tribunal on 07.12.2026. The Tribunal shall proceed further without awaiting any separate notice to the parties represented before this Court.
The appeal stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall also stand disposed of.
Copy of this order be sent to concerned Court immediately.
