High CourtsDivision Bench(2026) 07 KL CK 1611

Matsyafed & Anr. vs Shibu P.C. & Anr.

High Court Of Kerala · Decided on 24 July 2026

CASE NUMBER
WA No. 2590 of 2025

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

68 paragraphs · 3,493 words

Devan Ramachandran, J.

While the respondents were serving the appellants - the Kerala State Co-operative Federation for Fisheries Development Ltd (“Matsyafed” for short), they were purportedly retrenched from service on 26.02.2011. This led to the respondents moving the Presiding Officer under the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (for short "ID Act"); and thereafter, invoking the provisions of Section 2A of the said Act, they moved the Labour Court, through independent claims.

2.

The learned Labour Court, took all the claim petitions to trial, adverting to the counter pleadings of the appellants; and allowed the parties to mark documents and to offer oral testimony.

3.

Accordingly, MW1 and MW2 were cited as witnesses on the side of the management; while WW1 to WW6 offered testimony on the side of the workmen. In addition, Exts.M1 to M28 were marked on the side of the management; while Exts.W1 to W19 on the side of the Workmen.

4.

The Labour Court assessed the evidence and the testimonies of the parties; and delivered award dated 07.11.2018, setting aside the orders of retrenchment, finding it to be illegal and unlawful, but denied back wages to the employees.

5.

The Matsyafed challenged the Award on the ground that the setting aside of the retrenchment is illegal, as also the consequent order of reinstatement; while, the respondents assail it to the extent to which it has denied them back wages.

6.

For the record, W.P.(C) No.6022 of 2019, 6084 of 2019, 6104 of 2019, 6149 of 2019 and 6153 of 2019 were filed by the appellants - Matsyafed; while W.P.(C) Nos.11174, 11242, 11808, 11813, 11839 and 18459 of 2020 were filed by the workmen.

7.

The learned Single Judge dismissed all the writ petitions of the appellants – management; and allowed the writ petitions by the workmen, thus allowing them back wages and continuity of service from the date they were illegally retrenched from service.

8.

The appellants - Matsyafed, is thus before us in these appeals, calling into question, the correctness of judgment of the learned Single Judge.

9.

Sri. T. P. - Pradeep, learned Standing Counsel for the Matsyafed, argued that, when the respondents - workmen were only temporary employees, within the sweep of the concept of “Badli” - as available in the Kerala Casual, Temporary and Badli Workers (Wages) Act, 1989 (for short "Badli Act) - there was no question of any continuity in service for them; nor could they have been directed to be reinstated. He contended that the retrenchment was without error, though no notice had been given to the employees; but, adding that they were offered retrenchment compensation of a few months' salary, which they did not accept. He argued that, in such scenario, the grant of the back wages by the learned Single Judge, even when it was correctly declined by the learned Labour Court, is in error. He prayed that these appeals be, therefore, allowed.

10.

Sri.Anil Kumar - learned counsel for the respondents in all these matters, in response, submitted that his clients never have been construed to be “Badli”, within the ambit of the “Badli Act”, as has been now asserted, because they were appointed through valid appointment orders -copies of which have been marked as Ext.M6 series. He further submitted that their terms of service and wages were regulated by various orders, including that of the jurisdictional District Labour Officer (“DLO” for short), as luculent from Ext.W1. He then contended that, as clear from Ext.M5 dated 24.02.2011, the Managing Director of the appellants had then ordered that each of the employees be paid salary equivalent to Operator Grade-II at the starting scale – which was in tune with the decision of the “DLO” aforementioned in Ext.W1 - the Manager took a detour and issued Ext.W2 on 01.03.2010, reducing the salary unilaterally to that of Grade III post and clarified that such sum will also be governed by the “Badli Act”. He contended that, in such circumstances, his clients are fully entitled to continuity in service, being protected from unilateral and illegal retrenchment, as has been attempted in this case, which has been rightly set aside by the Labour Court as well as the learned Single Judge.

11.

Sri.Anil Kumar, thereafter argued that when the reinstatement is rendered wholly unwarranted in this case, the only surviving question was the quantum of the wages due to his clients. He contended that in this regard, Ext.W1 order of the “DLO” and Ext.M5 order of the Managing Director of the appellants would come to play; and hence that his clients are entitled to seek that amount, which they would have drawn in the post of Operator Grade II, at the time when they were illegally retrenched. He concluded saying that, his clients have, therefore, filed applications under Section 33C(2) of the “ID Act” before the Labour Court, claiming various amounts in the range of Rs.45 lakhs to Rs.68 lakhs - depending upon the period of their service and such other. He, nevertheless, told us that, only one of the six employees involved are now serving, while the others have retired; and that they are also entitled to retiral benefits and such other, consequent to their reinstatement.

12.

Before we move forward, we must record that we were told at the Bar by Sri.T.P.Pradeep that the orders of reinstatement has been complied with by his clients pending these matters, but without being subject to their contentions; and that while doing so, two of them were de facto brought back to service, while the others had already attained the age of superannuation, or was incapacitated because of age and health related issues.

13.

We, therefore, first proceed to decide whether the learned Single Judge has erred in confirming the order of the learned Labour Court in reinstating the employees. We notice that this issue has been considered by the learned Single Judge in great detail; and has concluded in favour of the directions of the learned Labour Court, relying upon various judgments, which are mentioned in paragraph 12 of the award. For ease of reference, we extract the said paragraph below;

“12.

The learned counsel appearing for the workmen invited attention of the court to the oral testimonies of the witnesses and documents produced from either sides to convince this court that the retrenchment of these workmen were not in tune with either under the provisions under section 25F or Section 25N of the I.D. Act. This is a net making unit under Matsyafed at Kochi. In this public undertaking, more than 100 workmen are employed and therefore, the special provisions related to retrenchment provided under chapter VB are applicable. First of all, I considered the submission advanced by the workmen regarding the infraction of the provisions under section 25G of the I.D. Act.

Section 25 G: Procedure for

retrenchment - Where any workman in an industrial establishment, who is a citizen of India is to be retrenched and he belongs to a particular category of workmen in that establishment, in the absence of any agreement between the employer and the workman in this behalf, the employer shall ordinarily retrench the workman who was the last person to be employed in that category, unless for reasons to be recorded the employer retrenches any other workman. It is relevant to note the entries in Ext.W12. Ext.W12 is an order of re-appointment of the employees dated 20.10.2010 after break in service for one day. The employee referred to No.36 Abdul Rasheed is seen joined the service on 20.10.2005. Sri. Abdul Rasheed joined the service subsequent to the dates of joining of all these workmen who have raised this industrial dispute. Ext.W12 would reveal that some of the employees who got absorbed in the service have actually joined the service later to the date of entry of these employees. Ext.W11 is the order dated 15.7.2013. The management by virtue of the order regularised certain employees. It is the case of the management that such a decision was taken by the Administrative Committee of Kerala State Co-operative Federation for Fishermen Development Limited. The persons numbered from No.18 to 34 and 54 to 58 in Ext.W11 were absorbed in the category of Operator Gr.II. The 36 man Abdul Rasheed in Ext.W12 was junior to all these employees. So the action of the management in picking and choosing the employees for termination was in conflict with the provisions under Section 25G of the I.D. Act and this conduct of management amounts to unfair labour practice.”

14.

We have little doubt that the learned Single Judge has considered the issue correctly and has delivered judgment, which cannot call for interference for the reason that, even going by the documents relied upon by the appellants - namely Ext.M5 and Ext.W2 - it is indubitable that the employees were not casual or temporary workers, as has been alleged; but were given substantive postings with their wages being decided and fixed in a particular manner. The only point in controversy is whether Ext.W2 proceedings of the appellants went contrary to the directions of the Managing Director in Ext.M5, which is an issue we will decide in the latter part of the judgment; but as far as the question of reinstatement is concerned, we find no reason to intervene; and therefore, approve the holdings and directions of the learned Single Judge.

15.

Coming to the second limb of the arguments, namely that back wages ought not to have been granted to the respondents, we notice that the learned Single Judge has decided this in paragraph 13 of the judgment, which is as under:

“13.

The remaining question arising for consideration is with reference to the six writ petitions filed at the instance of the workmen. They contend that the Labour Court, having found that the retrenchment was illegal while ordering reinstatement, back wages ought to have been extended to the workmen. The learned counsel Sri.Anil Kumar relied on Surendra Kumar Verma and others v. The Central Government Industrial Tribunal Cum Labour Court, New Delhi and Another [1980 (4) SCC 443] and M/s. Hindustan Tin Works Pvt. Ltd. v. The Employees of M/s. Hindustan Tin Works Pvt. Ltd. And others [1979 (2) SCC 80] in support of the afore contention. The Apex Court in Surendra Kumar Verma (supra) has found as under;

“ 6. ..............Plain common sense dictates that the removal of an order terminating the services of workmen must ordinarily lead to the reinstatement of the services of the workmen. It is as if the order has never been and so it must ordinarily lead to back wages too. But there may be exceptional circumstances which make it impossible or wholly inequitable vis a vis the employer and workmen to direct reinstatement with full back wages. For instance, the industry might have closed down or might be in severe financial doldrums; the workmen concerned might have secured better or other employment elsewhere and so on. In such situations, there is a vestige of discretion left in the Court to make appropriate consequential orders. The Court may deny the relief of reinstatement where reinstatement is impossible because the industry has closed own. The Court may deny the relief of award of full back wages where that would place an impossible burden on the employer. In such and other exceptional cases the Court may mould the relief but, ordinarily the relief to be awarded must be reinstatement with full back wages. That relief must be awarded where no special impediment in the way of awarding the relief is clearly shown. True, occasional hardship may be caused to an employer but we must remember that, more often than not, comparatively far greater hardship is certain to be caused to the workmen if the relief is denied than to the employer if the relief is granted.” To the same effect is the judgment in M/s.Hindustan Tin (supra)."

16.

The mentation of the learned Single Judge is certainly irreproachable; and in any event, when the retrenchment has been found to be illegal, one wonders how eligible back wages could have been fully denied to the respondents, as has been done by the learned Labour Court.

17.

This is more so because, while deciding point No.2 in the Award of the Labour Court, it records that the management did not adduce any evidence to prove that the workmen were gainfully employed during the period of unemployment; and that the delay in deciding the matter was not on account of any reason that can be attributed to them. It then concluded, rather abruptly: “However, considering the long period of seven years, I am of the view that a direction to the management to make payment of the entire back wages is not justifiable.” (sic).

18.

It does not require us to expatiate that, once the learned Labour Court had found that the delay was not attributable to the respondents, they could not have been thereafter punished, by denying them back wages in toto. Perhaps, we would have been relieved, had the learned Labour Court granted a portion of the back wages, but denying them the entire, obtains no justification at all - either in law or in facts.

19.

Mercifully, the learned Single Judge has rectified this deficiency, by ordering full back wages to the employees.

20.

The axiomatic question, therefore, before us is whether this is fair and right in law.

21.

As has been already noticed by the learned Single Judge, the line of precedential declarations by this Court, and by the Honorable Supreme Court, is that normally, when an order of retrenchment or termination is set aside, it is as if it were never in existence; and consequently, back wages must follow suit. As declared by the Honorable Supreme Court in Surendra Kumar Verma (supra), the exceptions in this are strictly limited to cases where the industry has closed down; is in financial crisis; or the workmen had been engaged in better avocations or employment.

22.

There is nothing on record to show that either of the afore exceptions can be drawn in this case; and, in fact, the learned Single Judge has concluded that the appellants are not in financial crisis. In any event, even if there was any such contention to be impelled, it should have been done based on cogent and reliable evidence; but that has not been done by the appellants before the Labour Court, or before this Court.

23.

Coming to the back wages entitled to the workmen, there is a paradox before us, whether we should go by Ext.M5 or Ext.W2. As noticed above, Ext.M5 is the proceedings of the Management, dated 24.02.2011, which orders the respondents herein to be entitled to the wages under the “Badli Act”, as applicable to an Operator Gr.II, at the starting level. However, when the subsequent order was issued on 01.03.2010, namely, Ext.W2, the Manager appears to have ordered that the respondents will only be entitled to the scale of Operator Grade-III, at the starting level.

24.

In this context, we notice that the learned Labour Court has entered into an enquiry as to whether the respondents are entitled to be reinstated into Grade II, or Grade III; and this was necessitated because the claim filed by them was to the effect that they be reinstated as Operator Grade-II, with all benefits. The learned Labour Court has concluded that, going by the available materials, there was no post of Operator Grade III in the 1st appellant; and that therefore, the respondents can only be accommodated as Operator Grade III. In holding so, the learned Labour Court relied upon Ext.W1, which is the proceedings of the “DLO” dated 27.04.2009.

25.

We find a small problem at this stage because, it is well settled that proceedings of an authority like the DLO is not conclusively determinative of the service conditions of employees in an industry. This is normally governed by the settlements between the management and the employees, or by such other statutorily permissible documentation. In such perspective, we cannot grant primacy to Ext.W1 - which is the order of the DLO, though we certainly will have to look into Ext.M5 and Ext.W2 as mentioned above.

26.

It is brought to our notice by T.P.Pradeep, and which is conceded by Sri.Anil Kumar, that at the time when the retrenchment order was issued on 26.02.2011, all the the respondents were being paid an amount of Rs.8,241/- per month, which is a consolidated figure at the last scale of pay of Operator Grade III. We do not propose to enter into a roving inquiry whether this was right or wrong, because this is a fact conceded by both sides.

27.

We would, therefore, deem it appropriate to accept the afore figure as being the last drawn wages - in any case, this being the figure adopted when this Court issued orders under Section 17B of the “ID Act” - and to direct the appellants to work out the figures eligible to the respondents -employees for the period during which they were kept in retrenchment illegally, by an apposite incremental increase, on account of the depreciation in money value.

28.

To paraphrase, we are not proposing to decide whether Ext.M5 or Ext.W2 should hold the field, but to take the de facto last drawn wages of each of the respondents at the time when they were illegally retrenched on 26.02.2011, to be the base year; and to build on it with a 10% incremental increase every three years, terms until the employee attains the age of superannuation.

29.

By a rough calculation that this Bench has done, the individual figures would be in the vicinity of Rs.16 to Rs.17 lakhs or thereabout. Of course, this is not the final figure; which will have to be worked out by the management in terms of our directions.

In such circumstances, we allow these appeals in part, confirming the directions of the learned Labour Court and that of the learned Single Judge, reinstating the respondents in service; but modifying the impugned judgment, by ordering that the back wages entitled to each of the respondents be in terms of our observations above.

Needless to say, any amounts that had been paid by the management - either under Section 17B of the “I.D.Act”, or otherwise - when these proceedings were pending - will be entitled for them to reduce from the sum ordered above.

APPENDIX OF WA NO. 2590 OF 2025

RESPONDENT ANNEXURES

Annexure R 1(a) True copy of the Order No. Matsyafed/E4/3088/2020 dated 01.04.2025 issued by the 1st applicant/Appellant to the three employees covered by the impugned judgment, along with its English translation

APPENDIX OF WA NO. 2575 OF 2025

RESPONDENT ANNEXURES

Exhibit R1 (a) True copy of the Order No. Matsyafed/E4/3088/2020 dated 01.04.2025 issued to the 1st respondent along with its English translation

Exhibit R1 (b) True copy of the order No. Matsyafed E4/3088/2020 dated 02.05.2025 issued by the 1st applicant/appellant along with its English Translation

Exhibit R1 (c) True copy of the notice issued by the Labour Court, Ernakulam in C.P. No. 59/2025

APPENDIX OF WA NO. 2577 OF 2025

RESPONDENT ANNEXURES

Annexure R1 (a) True copy of the Order No. Matsyafed/E4/3088/2020 dated 01.04.2025 issued to the 1st Respondent by the 1st Applicant along with its English translation

ANNEXURE R1 (b) True copy of the notice issued by the Labour Court in C.P. No. 60/2025 dated 16.07.2025

APPENDIX OF WA NO. 2579 OF 2025

RESPONDENT ANNEXURES

Annexure R1 (a) True copy of the Order No. Matsyafed/E4/3088/2020 dated 01.04.2025 issued by the 1st applicant/Appellant along with its English translation

Annexure R1 (b) True copy of the notice issued by the Labour Court in C.P. No. 58/2025

APPENDIX OF WA NO. 2580 OF 2025

RESPONDENT ANNEXURES

Annexure R1 (a) True copy of the Order No. Matsyafed/E4/3088/2020 dated 01.04.2025 issued by the 1st Applicant/Appellant along with its English translation

Annexure R1 (b) true copy of the notice issued by the Labour Court in C.P. No. 60/2025

APPENDIX OF WA NO. 2581 OF 2025

RESPONDENT ANNEXURES

Annexure R 1(a) True along with its English translation

Annexure R 1(b) True copy of the order No. Matsyafed E4/3088/2020 dated 02.05.2025 issued by the 1st applicant/appellant

Annexure R1(c) A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.MATSYAFED/E4/3088/2020 DATED 01.04.2025 ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT

Annexure R1(d) A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO. MATSYAFED E4/3088/2020 DATED 02.05.2025 ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT TO APPLICANT

Annexure R1(e) A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 08.05.2025 SUBMITTED BY APPLICANT TO THE 1ST RESPONDENT

Annexure R1(f) A TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED 02.07.2025 SUBMITTED BY APPLICANT TO THE RESPONDENTS

Annexure R1(g) A TRUE COPY OF THE PAYSLIP ISSUED TO APPLICANT BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT FOR THE MONTH OF OCTOBER 2025

Annexure R1(h) A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.MNF/EKM/ESTT/004/2023-24(VOL II)/1691 DATED 26.03.2026 ISSUED TO APPLICANT BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT

Annexure R1(i) A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER MATSYAFED/E4/3088/2020 DATED 04.05.2026 ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT