High CourtsDivision Bench(2026) 11 AHC CK 0482

Madhav & Ors. vs State

Allahabad High Court, Lucknow Bench · Decided on 3 November 2026

RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Criminal Appeal No. - 300 of 1985

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

140 paragraphs · 8,213 words

(Dictated by Hon’ble Pramod Kumar Srivastava, J.)

1.

Heard Sri Vivek Kumar Rai, learned counsel for the appellants No. 1, 2 and 4, Shri Kaushal Kishore Tiwari, learned counsel appearing for the appellant No. 3 as well as Sri Pawan Kumar Mishra, learned A.G.A. for the State.

2.

The instant Criminal Appeal under Section 374(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.P.C.) has been filed against the judgment and order dated 17.04.1985 passed by the learned Xth Additional Sessions Judge, Sitapur in Sessions Trial No. 460 of 1983 (State vs. Madhav & Ors.), arising out of Case Crime No. 50 of 1983, Police Station Talgaon, District Sitapur.

3.

By means of the impugned judgment and order dated 17.04.1985 passed in Sessions Trial No. 460 of 1983, the trial court convicted the appellant Madhav under Section 302 I.P.C. for intentionally causing the death of Smt. Malho, along with convictions under Sections 307 and 324 I.P.C. and convicted the co-appellants Sheo Kumar, Sheo Ram and Munna under Sections 302/34, 307/34 and 324/34 I.P.C., sentencing them to undergo Imprisonment for Life, 7 years' R.I. and 1 year's R.I. respectively, with all sentences ordered to run concurrently.

4.

The prosecution story, in brief, is that the informant and injured witness Lachhmi Narain (P.W. 1) along with his family resided in Village Madarpur Angrasi, Police Station Talgaon, District Sitapur. The accused persons—namely Munna, Madhav, Shiv Kumar and Sheo Ram (all sons of Sri Bhagwan Deen)—are cousins of the informant, their respective houses being situated in close proximity within the same village. On 19.04.1983, at about 04:00 P.M., a dispute arose when accused Madhav forcibly broke and removed the water spout (parnala) fixed on the eastern wall of the informant's house having a grievance that the discharge of water was damaging his adjacent tomato crop.

5.

To amicably resolve the dispute, a relation/villager, Sri Jagannath Prasad Tiwari (P.W. 2), was called and a settlement talk was convened near the spot around sunset. However, negotiations broke down when accused Madhav refused to abide by any settlement terms, whereupon the informant turned to return home. At that juncture, the four accused persons, in furtherance of common intention, intercepted the informant, with co-accused Munna, Sheo Kumar and Sheo Ram catching hold of him from behind, while accused Madhav was armed with a knife.

6.

It is specifically alleged that accused Madhav launched an assault, stabbing the informant Lachhmi Narain (P.W. 1) from behind in the lumbar region near the back bone. Seeing her husband being attacked, the deceased, Smt. Malho, rushed forward to shield and rescue him, whereupon accused Madhav thrust the knife into her left chest. The blow resulted in a punctured wound that penetrated her thoracic cavity, cutting the ascending aorta and causing her instantaneous death on the spot. Simultaneously, when the informant's daughter, Smt. Bitto, came down from the roof to intervene and protect her parents, she was also assaulted and inflicted with knife injuries by accused Madhav.

7.

Following the cries of distress, other villagers including Chhotey Lal Pasi arrived at the scene and attempted to apprehend the assailant Madhav, but the accused wrenched himself free and all four accused persons fled towards Angrasi while hurling threats and intimidation. Promptly thereafter, a written First Information Report (Ex. Ka-1) scribed by Bankey Lal (P.W. 3) at the dictation of the informant was dispatched to Police Station Talgaon.

8.

On the basis of the written tehrir (Exhibit Ka-1) submitted by the informant Lachhmi Narain (P.W. 1), a formal First Information Report (Exhibit Ka-5) was registered on 19.04.1983 at 23:15 hours as Case Crime No. 50 of 1983 under Sections 302 and 307 I.P.C. at Police Station Talgaon, District Sitapur.

9.

Following the registration of the case, inquest proceedings (panchayatnama, Exhibit Ka-7) were conducted by the police on the morning of 20.04.1983 and the dead body of Smt. Malho was dispatched for post-mortem examination. The autopsy was conducted on 20.04.1983 by Dr. M.K. Pandey (P.W. 6) at the District Hospital, Sitapur, wherein the cause of death was opined to be shock and hemorrhage as a result of ante-mortem sharp-edged injuries, including the punctured chest wound.

10.

The initial investigation of Case Crime No. 50 of 1983 was undertaken by S.O. Ashok Kumar Singh (P.W. 9), who inspected the place of occurrence, prepared the site plan (Exhibit Ka-12) and collected material physical evidence, including the broken wooden spout (Exhibit Ex. 1) and blood-stained earth (Exhibit Ka-15). The investigation was subsequently taken over on 16.06.1983 by S.O. Balram Rai (P.W. 5), who completed the investigation and submitted the charge-sheet (Exhibit Ka-17) against the accused persons—Madhav, Sheo Kumar, Sheo Ram and Munna—under Sections 302 and 307 read with Section 34 I.P.C.

11.

After ensuring compliance with the provisions of Section 207 of the Cr.P.C. regarding the supply of copies of the police papers to the accused, the committal court (IVth Additional Munsif Magistrate, Sitapur) committed the case to the Court of Sessions vide order dated 08.09.1983 under Section 209 of the Cr.P.C. The case was thereafter made over to the Court of the Xth Additional Sessions Judge, Sitapur for trial as Sessions Trial No. 460 of 1983.

12.

The learned Trial Court, on 07.11.1983, framed formal charges against accused Madhav under Section 302 I.P.C. (for the murder of Smt. Malho) and Section 307 I.P.C. (for causing injuries to Bitto and Lachhmi Narain) and against accused Munna, Sheo Kumar and Sheo Ram under Sections 302/34 and 307/34 I.P.C. The charges were read over and explained to the accused persons, who pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.

13.

In order to substantiate its case, the prosecution produced and examined nine witnesses, namely: Sri Lachhmi Narain (P.W. 1, the injured informant), Jagannath Prasad Tiwari (P.W. 2, mediator/alleged eye-witness), Bankey Lal (P.W. 3, scribe of the FIR), Guru Sewak (P.W. 4, village Chaukidar), Balram Rai (P.W. 5, S.O. who filed the charge-sheet), Dr. M.K. Pandey (P.W. 6, Medical Officer who conducted the autopsy of Smt. Malho), Dr. A.A. Khan (P.W. 7, Medical Officer who examined the injured Lachhmi Narain and Bitto Devi), Nathu Lal (P.W. 8, Constable who escorted the dead body) and Ashok Kumar Singh (P.W. 9, Investigating Officer).

14.

Apart from ocular evidence, the prosecution also adduced and proved several contemporaneous documentary evidences, including the written tahrir (Exhibit Ka-1), the post-mortem report of Smt. Malho (Exhibit Ka-2), the injury reports of Lachhmi Narain and Smt. Bitto Devi (Exhibits Ka-3 and Ka-4), the chick report (Exhibit Ka-5), the General Diary entry (Exhibit Ka-6), the panchayatnama of the deceased (Exhibit Ka-7), the site plan (Exhibit Ka-12) and recovery memos for the ornaments, broken spout and blood-stained earth (Exhibits Ka-13, Ka-14 and Ka-15).

15.

For the purpose of clarity, convenience and systematic analysis of the oral, documentary and forensic evidence available on record, the details of witnesses, exhibits, statements recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C. and defence evidence are tabulated hereunder:

Table-A: Summary of Examined Witnesses

Witness No.Name & Description
PW-1Lachhmi Narain (Informant / Injured)
PW-2Jagannath Prasad Tiwari (Mediator / Eye-Witness)
PW-3Bankey Lal (FIR Scribe)
PW-4Guru Sewak (Village Chaukidar)
PW-5Balram Rai (Sub-Inspector / Subsequent I.O.)
PW-6Dr. M.K. Pandey (Medical Officer)
PW-7Dr. A.A. Khan (Medical Officer)
PW-8Nathu Lal (Constable No. 549)
PW-9Ashok Kumar Singh (Sub-Inspector / Initial I.O.)
DW-1Shiv Bhagwan (Defence Witness)

Table-B: Chart of Exhibited Documents & Proof

Exhibit No.Description of Document
Ex. Ka-1Written Tahrir / Complaint
Ex. Ka-2Post-Mortem Report of Smt. Malho
Ex. Ka-3Medico-Legal Injury Report of Lachhmi Narain
Exhibit No.Description of Document
Ex. Ka-4Medico-Legal Injury Report of Smt. Bitto Devi
Ex. Ka-5Chick First Information Report
Ex. Ka-6General Diary Entry No. 36
Ex. Ka-7Inquest Report (Panchayatnama)
Ex. Ka-12Site Plan (Naksha Nazari) & Index
Ex. Ka-13Recovery Memo of Ornaments / Supurdginama
Ex. Ka-14Recovery Memo of Broken Spout
Ex. Ka-15Recovery Memo of Earth
Ex. Ka-17Charge-Sheet
Ex. Kha-1General Diary Entry No. 20
Ex. Kha-2Contradiction Statement u/s 161 Cr.P.C.
Material Ext.1Broken Wooden Spout (Parnala)
16.

PW-1, Lachhmi Narain, the informant and injured star witness, deposed in his examination-in-chief that the accused persons—Madhav, Munna, Shivkumar and Sheo Ram—are his real cousin brothers and reside in close vicinity. He testified that on a Tuesday in the month of Chait at about 04:00 P.M., accused Madhav forcibly broke his wooden water spout (parnala) fixed on the eastern wall of his house. Around sunset, their relative Jagannath Prasad Tiwari (PW-2) arrived to mediate the dispute. When negotiations failed as Madhav refused to settle, PW-1 turned to return to his house. At that juncture, the three co-accused Munna, Shivkumar and Sheo Ram caught hold of him from behind, whereupon accused Madhav pulled out a knife and stabbed him near the lumbar vertebrae of his spine. He further deposed that when his wife, Smt. Malho, rushed to shield him and wrapped herself around him, accused Madhav stabbed her in the left chest, as a result of which she collapsed and died on the spot. Simultaneously, when his daughter Bitto jumped down from the roof to rescue them, Madhav stabbed her on her wrist and fingers. PW-1 proved the written tehrir (Exhibit Ka-1) scribed by Bankey Lal. During cross-examination, he admitted that tomato plants were standing over the disputed land, but denied that his family uprooted them. Crucially, when confronted with his police statement and the FIR, he conceded that he had not specified in the FIR or to the Investigating Officer as to which accused held which specific part of his body.

17.

PW-2, Jagannath Prasad Tiwari, the independent mediator and alleged eye-witness, deposed that he went to the village to mediate the dispute between the parties. He testified that after talks failed, Madhav stabbed Lachhmi Narain. However, he categorically stated in his deposition: "Munna was standing far away and remained standing there". He further deposed that immediately after Lachhmi Narain was assaulted and started bleeding, he left the spot and returned home, stating unequivocally that no other incident took place in his presence and that he only heard about the death of Smt. Malho subsequently. In his cross-examination, PW-2 admitted that Lachhmi Narain and his wife were actively uprooting tomato plants and that a scuffle (lipta-lipti) had ensued between Madhav and the deceased lady.

18.

PW-3, Bankey Lal, the scribe of the First Information Report, deposed that on 19.04.1983, he scribed the written report (Exhibit Ka-1) at the dictation of the complainant Lachhmi Narain. However, during cross-examination, he made a vital concession, admitting: "On the night of the incident, the Sub-Inspector had arrived in the village at 10:00 P.M. I scribed the report in the presence of the Sub-Inspector. Lachhmi Narain was dictating and wherever any sentence was erroneous, the Sub-Inspector got it corrected".

19.

PW-4, Guru Sewak, the village Chaukidar, deposed that upon receiving information, he reached Village Madarpur at about 06:00 P.M., where he found the deceased lying dead and Lachhmi Narain and his daughter injured. He stated that he received the written tehrir from the informant and carried it on foot to Police Station Talgaon (a distance of 8 kilometers), returning to the village at 01:00 A.M. in the night. He also proved accompanying Constable Nathu Lal with the dead body to the mortuary on the following morning. In his cross-examination, he admitted that despite the village having 40 to 50 households, no villager provided a conveyance to transport the injured or the dead body.

20.

PW-5, Balram Rai, Sub-Inspector, deposed that he took over the investigation of the case on 16.06.1983 from the previous Investigating Officer, perused the Case Diary and interrogated the accused persons. He examined the chaukidar and witness Jagannath Tiwari and upon completion of investigation, submitted the formal charge-sheet (Exhibit Ka-17) against all four accused persons under Sections 302, 307 and 324 read with Section 34 I.P.C.

21.

PW-6, Dr. M.K. Pandey, Medical Officer, District Hospital, Sitapur, proved the post-mortem examination report of deceased Smt. Malho (Exhibit Ka-2). He deposed that on 20.04.1983 at 02:30 P.M., he conducted the autopsy and noted five ante-mortem injuries, including a punctured wound measuring 5 cm x 1 cm x chest cavity deep on the left upper chest, which penetrated the left lung, costal cartilages and cut the ascending aorta by 0.5 cm, causing about two litres of blood to pool in the thoracic cavity. He opined that the cause of death was shock and hemorrhage resulting from ante-mortem injuries. In his cross-examination, PW-6 admitted that injury Nos. 1 and 2 were more likely to have been caused by a double-edged weapon (do-dhari hathiyar) and conceded that the possibility of injury Nos. 1 and 2 being inflicted by a single stroke was low.

22.

PW-7, Dr. A.A. Khan, Medical Officer, District Hospital, Sitapur, proved the injury reports of the injured witnesses. He deposed that on 20.04.1983 at 11:15 A.M., he examined Lachhmi Narain (Exhibit Ka-3) and found a vertical incised wound measuring 2 cm x 1.5 cm x 1 cm on the left lumbar back at the level of the 3rd lumbar vertebra. He also proved the injury report of Smt. Bitto Devi (Exhibit Ka-4) examined on the same day at 11:00 A.M., which revealed two superficial incised wounds on her right elbow and right middle finger. In cross-examination, PW-7 admitted that Lachhmi Narain's wound appeared triangular in shape and that both injuries found on Bitto were superficial and could have been caused by contact with broken glass.

23.

PW-8, Nathu Lal (Constable No. 549), deposed that on 20.04.1983 at 07:45 A.M., he was handed over the sealed dead body of Smt. Malho along with the inquest papers from Village Madarpur, which he safely brought and deposited at the mortuary in Sitapur at 11:20 A.M. without any tampering.

24.

PW-9, Ashok Kumar Singh, Sub-Inspector and initial Investigating Officer, deposed that on 19.04.1983 at 23:15 hours, the crime was registered in his presence at Police Station Talgaon. He reached the scene of crime at 00:45 hours and dispatched the injured to the hospital via bullock cart at 02:05 hours. He conducted the inquest proceedings (Exhibit Ka-7), prepared the site plan (Exhibit Ka-12) and effected recovery of the ornaments (Exhibit Ka-13), the broken wooden spout (Exhibit Ka-14) and blood-stained earth (Exhibit Ka-15). In cross-examination, PW-9 admitted that he omitted to show the exact spot where the dead body originally lay on the site plan because it had already been shifted onto a quilt (kathri). He further admitted that although parts of the ground appeared dug up and tomato plants were found uprooted, he did not record these details in the Case Diary.

25.

DW-1, Shiv Bhagwan, was examined as a defence witness. He deposed that his house is situated 30–35 yards right opposite the complainant’s house. He testified that at sunset, he heard a commotion and saw deceased Malho rushing towards Madhav armed with a 1.5-cubit bamboo stick (danda) and striking him. In order to defend and free himself, Madhav pulled out a small vegetable-cutting knife and struck her once or twice. At that time, Lachhmi Narain and his daughter were uprooting tomato plants and they grappled with Madhav. DW-1 categorically testified that co-accused Munna, Sheo Ram and Shivkumar were not present at the spot and that only Madhav was there.

26.

Upon the prosecution adducing and formally exhibiting the written report (Exhibit Ka-1), post-mortem report (Exhibit Ka-2), injury reports (Exhibits Ka-3 & Ka-4), chick FIR (Exhibit Ka-5), General Diary entry (Exhibit Ka-6), inquest report (Exhibit Ka-7), site plan (Exhibit Ka-12), recovery memos (Exhibits Ka-13 to Ka-15), charge-sheet (Exhibit Ka-17) and material exhibit broken spout (Material Exhibit 1), the prosecution closed its evidence.

27.

Upon closure of the prosecution evidence, the statements of the accused persons were recorded under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. All incriminating circumstances appearing against them in the prosecution evidence were put and explained to them.

28.

Co-accused Munna (aged 24 years), Sheo Ram (aged 16 years) and Shivkumar (aged 14 years, student) pleaded total denial and false implication, specifically stating that they were not present at the spot ("main mauke par nahi tha") and were falsely roped in due to family enmity arising from their brother Madhav's dispute.

29.

Accused Madhav Ram (aged 29 years), in his examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C. read with his separate written statement (Paper No. 57), set up a specific plea of the Right of Private Defence. He stated that the complainant party was forcibly uprooting and destroying his fruit-bearing tomato crop sown over his land. When objected to, the deceased Malho assaulted him with a stick. He admitted that to save himself and free himself from the assault, he struck her using a small, single-edged vegetable knife without any intention to cause death and pushed away Lachhmi Narain and Bitto when they grappled with him. He reiterated that he was alone at the spot and none of his three brothers were present.

30.

Learned Trial Court, after hearing learned counsels for both the parties, considering the overall facts and circumstances of the case and the evidence on record, concluded that the prosecution had successfully proved its case against all four accused persons beyond all reasonable doubt. The Trial Court completely rejected the plea of right of private defence set up by appellant Madhav, holding that the force used was grossly disproportionate to the alleged damage caused to tomato plants. The Trial Court further held that co-accused Munna, Sheo Kumar and Sheo Ram shared a common intention with Madhav, as they actively caught hold of the victims from behind, facilitating the deadly stabbing. Consequently, the learned Trial Court convicted appellant Madhav under Section 302 IPC (for the murder of Smt. Malho), Section 307 IPC (for the assault on Lachhmi Narain) and Section 324 IPC (for the injury to Smt. Bitto), sentencing him to undergo Imprisonment for Life, 7 years' R.I. and 1 year's R.I. respectively. The co-accused Munna, Sheo Kumar and Sheo Ram were convicted under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC, Section 307 read with Section 34 IPC and Section 324 read with Section 34 IPC and awarded identical concurrent sentences.

31.

Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 17.04.1985 passed in Sessions Trial No. 460 of 1983, the appellants have preferred the instant criminal appeal before this Hon'ble Court.

Finding of the learned Trial Court

32.

The learned Trial Court, upon a holistic appreciation of the evidence, observed that the testimony of the injured complainant Lachhmi Narain (PW-1) was natural, reliable and trustworthy, which stood fully corroborated by the medical evidence adduced by Dr. M.K. Pandey (PW-6) and Dr. A.A. Khan (PW-7). The Trial Court discarded the defence theory of right of private defence of person and property, holding that human life cannot be sacrificed for a few tomato plants, especially when the complainant party was unarmed. The Trial Court disbelieved the testimony of DW-1 Shiv Bhagwan as being partisan and untruthful and rejected the plea of delayed FIR set up by the defence. Regarding co-accused Munna, Sheo Ram and Sheo Kumar, the Trial Court recorded a categorical finding that their presence at the spot and their overt act of catching hold of the victims established prior meeting of minds and common intention under Section 34 IPC. The Trial Court also repelled the argument regarding juvenility raised on behalf of Sheo Kumar and Sheo Ram, holding that both possessed sufficient maturity and understanding of the consequences of their acts, thereby sustaining their conviction along with appellant Madhav.

33.

We have heard learned counsel for the appellants and learned A.G.A. for the State.

34.

Upon hearing learned counsel for the parties and examining the lower court record, the following points arise for our determination in this appeal:

(i)

Whether the trial court could legally convict the accused-appellants Munna, Shiv Kumar and Sheo Ram with the aid of Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) in the absence of a specific charge framed under Section 302 IPC?

(ii)

Whether the prosecution has established that the appellants acted in furtherance of a common intention, or whether it failed to prove a prior concert or meeting of minds among them?

(iii)

Whether the complainant party was the aggressor and appellant Madhav acted in the exercise of the right of private defence of person and property?

(iv)

Whether the incident occurred upon a sudden quarrel on the spur of the moment without premeditation?

(v)

Whether the testimonies of the eye-witnesses (PW-1 and PW-2) are of sterling quality and inspire confidence?

(vi)

Whether the trial court failed to give due weightage to the testimony of defence witness DW-1?

(vii)

Whether the sentence awarded to appellants Sheo Ram and Shiv Kumar is contrary to the statutory protection governing juveniles?

(viii)

Whether the findings recorded by the learned trial court suffer from patent perversity warranting interference in appeal?

Point No. (i): Omission to Frame Charge under Section 302 IPC

35.

Learned counsel appearing for the appellants vehemently contended that while a formal charge under Section 302 IPC was framed against appellant Madhav, no charge under Section 302 IPC was framed against the remaining three appellants—Munna, Shiv Kumar and Sheo Ram. It is submitted that the trial court framed charges against them only under Section 307 read with Section 34 IPC and Section 341 IPC. Consequently, their conviction under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC is contrary to law and stands vitiated on the ground of non-framing of charge.

36.

Per contra, learned A.G.A. submitted that from the inception, the FIR (Exhibit Ka-5) was registered against all four appellants under Sections 302 and 307 IPC. Following the investigation, the Investigating Officer submitted the charge-sheet (Exhibit Ka-17) under Sections 302 and 307 read with Section 34 IPC. The competent Magistrate took cognizance and committed the case to the Court of Session on 08.09.1983, specifically noting the allegations under Sections 302 and 307 IPC. Throughout the trial, the prosecution led evidence focusing on the fatal assault and the defence cross-examined the prosecution witnesses fully aware of the core accusations. Furthermore, during their examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C., the circumstances relating to the murder were specifically put to Munna, Shiv Kumar and Sheo Ram. Learned A.G.A. submitted that under Section 464 read with Sections 211, 212, 213, 214 and 215 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.P.C.), an omission or defect in framing a charge does not invalidate a conviction unless the accused demonstrates that actual prejudice and a failure of justice have been occasioned.

37.

We have considered the rival submissions on this point. Sections 211 to 215 Cr.P.C. govern the contents and particulars of a charge, the primary object being to provide the accused with clear notice of the accusations to be met. Section 464 Cr.P.C. provides that an order or finding of a competent court cannot be deemed invalid merely due to an omission, error, or absence of charge, unless the appellate court concludes that a failure of justice has in fact occurred.

38.

In Kamil v. State of U.P., (2019) 12 SCC 600, the Hon’ble Supreme Court examined the scope of Section 464 Cr.P.C. and reviewed the legal principles governing prejudice and failure of justice from foundational authorities, including the Constitution Bench decision in Willie (William) Slaney v. State of M.P (AIR 1956 SC 116), Gurbachan Singh v. State of Punjab (AIR 1957 SC 623), Main Pal v. State of Haryana [(2010) 10 SCC 130] & Darbara Singh v. State of Punjab [(2012) 10 SCC 476]. The Hon’ble Supreme Court emphasized that procedural provisions are designed to advance justice rather than frustrate it through technicalities. A defect or omission in framing a charge will not vitiate the proceedings if the accused understood the basic ingredients of the offence, had the case fairly explained to him and received a full opportunity to defend himself.

39.

Applying these principles to the record, the gravamen of the charge-sheet (Exhibit Ka-17) clearly alleged that the appellants acted with common intention in the fatal assault. During their examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C., the incriminating circumstances emerging from the ocular and medical evidence were explicitly put to Munna, Shiv Kumar and Sheo Ram. Each of them answered these questions without raising an objection that they were unaware of the allegations of murder.

40.

Furthermore, upon being held guilty by the trial court, when heard on the quantum of sentence, the only plea advanced on behalf of Shiv Kumar and Sheo Ram was regarding their juvenility (aged about 15 and 17 years). No grievance was voiced that they were prejudiced by the absence of a specific charge under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC. It is evident that the appellants were fully conversant with the allegations and defended themselves against the charge of murder throughout the trial.

41.

Thus, from the above, it is clear that non-framing of a charge will not vitiate the trial and conviction when the accused was aware of the accusation and had been given an ample opportunity of defence. We find no failure of justice on this score and the contention raised by learned counsel for the appellants is without merit.

Point No. (ii): Common Intention under Section 34 IPC

42.

Learned counsel for the appellants next submitted that the prosecution failed to prove that the appellants acted in furtherance of a common intention. It is urged that the FIR and ocular testimonies do not disclose any prior concert or pre-arranged plan among the brothers. PW-2 Jagannath Prasad Tiwari testified that Munna was standing far away and denied that Shiv Kumar or Sheo Ram actively participated. Furthermore, PW-1 Lachhmi Narain was only assigned a general role of catching hold without attributing individual actions to the brothers in his earlier statement to the police. Learned counsel placed reliance on Dharam Pal v. State of Haryana, 1978 CriLJ 1338 and Ramashish Yadav v. State of Bihar, (1999) 8 SCC 555, to contend that mere presence or a sudden catching hold during an unexpected quarrel does not warrant the invocation of Section 34 IPC.

43.

Per contra, learned A.G.A. contended that the participation of all four brothers is clearly established from the evidence of the injured star witness PW-1. Appellant Madhav was armed with a knife, while the other three brothers actively restrained the informant, facilitating the stabbing. It is submitted that common intention can form on the spur of the moment and does not always require prior concert.

44.

To properly evaluate these contentions, it is pertinent to review the undisputed family tree deposed to by PW-1 Lachhmi Narain:

Matadeen ___________________|___________________ | | | Puttoo Lal Prayag Dutt Bhagwan Deen | | | Jagdish Laxmi Narayan | (PW-1) | _________________________________________ | | | | Madho Munna Shiv Kumar Sheo Ram

45.

As seen from the pedigree, the parties are first cousins residing in close proximity within Village Madarpur. The topography deposed to by PW-1 establishes that the water spout (parnala) was fixed on the eastern wall of the informant's house, while the disputed land below it was claimed by Madhav for his tomato crop. The broken parnala and damaged crop formed the source of their strained relationship, prompting the arrival of PW-2 Jagannath Prasad Tiwari to mediate.

46.

In criminal jurisprudence, for establishing constructive liability with the aid of Section 34 IPC, the prosecution must establish a meeting of minds and a shared intention to commit the crime. In Jasdeep Singh @ Jassu v. State of Punjab, (2022) 2 SCC 545, reiterated in Surendra Singh v. State of Uttarakhand, (2025) 5 SCC 433, the Hon’ble Supreme Court affirmed that conviction with Section 34 IPC requires the prosecution to prove that the criminal act was committed in furtherance of a shared common intention and that the accused had a prior understanding, either pre-arranged or formulated, immediately prior to the act.

47.

At the same time, it is well established that common intention need not always be the result of long premeditation; it can develop on the spot during the course of the occurrence. As observed in Suresh Chauhan v. State of M.P., 2000 SCC (Cri) 772, the essence of Section 34 IPC is a simultaneous consensus of minds among persons in criminal action, which may develop at the scene. This principle was also affirmed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Karnataka v. Battegowda, Criminal Appeal No. 1694 of 2014 (referring to Dharnidhar v. State of U.P., (2010) 7 SCC 759), observing that a meeting of minds and common intention can develop on the spur of the moment during the course of an incident.

48.

The existence of common intention is an inference of fact to be drawn from the conduct of the accused and the surrounding circumstances with a reasonable degree of certainty (Bengai Mandal v. State of Bihar, AIR 2010 SC 686). In the present case, when the talks broke down, PW-1 turned to return to his house. At that moment, the three brothers—Munna, Shiv Kumar and Sheo Ram—restrained PW-1, enabling Madhav to strike him with a knife in the back. Their collective act of holding the informant immobilized him and directly aided the armed assailant. The nature and manner of their active participation demonstrate a shared consensus on the spot to commit the assault, establishing that the acts were executed in furtherance of their common intention.

Points No. (iii), (iv), (v) & (vi): Private Defence, Aggression and

Credibility of Eye-Witnesses

48.

Learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the deceased Smt. Malho was the aggressor, having attacked Madhav with a bamboo stick (danda) while uprooting his tomato plants and that Madhav acted in private defence to protect himself and his property. It is further argued that the testimonies of PW-1 and PW-2 do not meet the standard of sterling quality, whereas the testimony of defence witness DW-1 Shiv Bhagwan was arbitrarily discarded by the trial court.

49.

Per contra, learned A.G.A. submitted that the defence version of the deceased wielding a danda was an afterthought. No stick was recovered from the spot by the Investigating Officer and no suggestion to that effect was put to the eye-witnesses during their cross-examination.

50.

Further, learned A.G.A. submitted that PW-1 Lachhmi Narain is an injured eye-witness whose presence at the scene of crime is stamped by his bodily injuries and stands on a higher evidentiary pedestal. His testimony is natural, cogent and unimpeached and finds complete corroboration from the medical evidence proved by Dr. M.K. Pandey (PW-6) and Dr. A.A. Khan (PW-7).

51.

We have evaluated the ocular evidence in juxtaposition with the medical findings. Under Section 134 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, no particular number of witnesses is prescribed to establish any fact, as it is the intrinsic quality and not the quantity of evidence that determines its probative worth. As held by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Vadivelu Thevar v. State of Madras, AIR 1957 SC 614, witnesses broadly fall into three categories: (i) wholly reliable, (ii) wholly unreliable and (iii) neither wholly reliable nor wholly unreliable.

52.

In the present case, PW-1 Lachhmi Narain is an injured victim whose testimony carries inherent credibility. He consistently narrated the overt acts, stating that when he turned back, co-accused Shiv Kumar and Sheo Ram pinned his arms from behind while Munna held his leg, enabling appellant Madhav to stab him in the back, followed by the fatal assault on his wife Smt. Malho and the injury to his daughter. No material contradiction or embellishment could be elicited in his cross-examination. So far as PW-2 Jagannath Prasad Tiwari is concerned, his testimony must be evaluated in its entirety; while he deposed that he left the spot immediately upon Lachhmi Narain sustaining the initial knife blow, he never affirmatively ruled out the presence of the other accused persons at the place of occurrence.

53.

Furthermore, appellant Madhav, in his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. read with his written statement (Paper No. 57), explicitly admitted to having inflicted knife blows upon Lachhmi Narain, Smt. Malho and Kumari Bitto. This unequivocal admission of the assault substantially corroborates the ocular version. Merely because the witnesses are related to the deceased does not render them untruthful, particularly when the occurrence unfolded at the doorsteps of their adjoining houses. We find that the testimony of PW-1 is cogent, credible and fully inspires confidence.

54.

Further, a careful scrutiny of the cross-examination of PW-1 Lachhmi Narain reveals the sequence of the attack which follows as under:

"Only a single knife blow was inflicted upon me. Since my wife came in between, Madho inflicted a knife blow on her chest. No injury was caused to me thereafter. After I sustained the knife blow, my wife rushed to save me. At that time, I was sitting with the support of one foot/leg. My wife was shorter in height than me and reached up to my shoulders. My wife slumped over me from the front to cover me. She had rushed in from the southern direction and clung to me from the right side. While she was clinging to me in order to protect me, Madho inflicted a knife blow on her left side. Madho struck the knife blow on my wife from the front. I saw the knife blow being struck right in front of me, after which my wife fell down. By that time, Bitto jumped down from above and came there. Then Madho started assaulting Bitto as well. When my wife fell down after sustaining the injury, I remained sitting in the very same position because I could not stand up at all. When Bitto arrived, my wife was bleeding and lying on the ground. My wife was lying towards my south. At that time, Madho was towards the north of my wife. There was a distance of about one to one-and-a-half cubits between my wife and me. Immediately upon my wife falling down, my daughter Bitto jumped down; she had jumped to save us. Madho inflicted a knife blow upon her as well."

55.

This deposition demonstrates that when PW-1 sustained the initial stab wound, his wife Smt. Malho rushed in unarmed to shield her injured husband. Both PW-1 and the deceased were unarmed. During the cross-examination of PW-1, the defence did not put any suggestion that the deceased was armed with a stick or that she had struck Madhav.

56.

Similarly, PW-2 Jagannath Prasad Tiwari, who arrived to arbitrate the dispute, confirmed that an argument ensued regarding the drainage and the tomato crop, during which a scuffle took place. However, his evidence does not show that the deceased, her husband, or their daughter held any weapon.

57.

The plea of the deceased wielding a danda was introduced for the first time by Madhav in his written statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. (Paper No. 57) and supported by DW-1 Shiv Bhagwan. However, the Investigating Officer (PW-9) found no stick or weapon associated with the complainant party at the scene. The omission to confront the prosecution eye-witnesses with this fundamental factual assertion during cross-examination confirms that the danda narrative was introduced at a later stage as an afterthought.

58.

While a citizen is entitled to protect person and property, the right of private defence is governed by the principles of proportionality and necessity under Sections 96 to 106 IPC. Even assuming a dispute existed regarding the uprooting of some tomato plants, causing death by stabbing an unarmed woman in the chest with a knife cannot be justified as an exercise of private defence. The plea that the deceased was the aggressor and that appellant Madhav acted in the right of private defence is therefore untenable and was rightly rejected by the trial court.

Point No. (iv): Plea of Grave and Sudden Provocation (Exception 1

to Section 300 IPC)

59.

Learned counsel appearing for the appellants vehemently contended that the act of appellant Madhav was devoid of any premeditation or murderous intent and was committed whilst he was deprived of the power of self-control on account of grave and sudden provocation. It is submitted that when the parties assembled to negotiate an amicable settlement regarding the tomato crops, the deceased Smt. Malho abruptly began uprooting the fruit-bearing tomato plants and assaulted Madhav with a stick (danda), which triggered an instantaneous loss of self-control, leading to the unfortunate incident. In support of his contention that an act committed under grave and sudden provocation excludes the offence of murder, learned counsel placed reliance upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Muthu v. State by Inspector of Police, T.N., (2009) 17 SCC 433, wherein it was observed:

“10.

... we are satisfied that the accused was deprived of the power of self-control by grave and sudden provocation which led him to commit the offence. If rubbish is thrown into one's house/shop, one would naturally get very upset. It is evident that the accused had no motive to cause the death of the deceased since the accused was not carrying the knife from before and only picked it up during the scuffle with the deceased... In our opinion, throwing rubbish/waste inside the house/shop of somebody is certainly a grave and sudden provocation. Everyone wishes to keep his premises neat and clean and is likely to lose his self-control in such a situation. The incident in question occurred in a sudden fight in the heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel without the appellant having taken any undue advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner."

56.

Learned counsel further placed reliance upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Buddhi Singh v. State of H.P., (2012) 13 SCC 663, wherein the doctrine of grave and sudden provocation was expounded in the following terms:

“18.

The doctrine of grave and sudden provocation is incapable of rigid construction leading to or stating any principle of universal application. This will always have to depend on the facts of a given case. While applying this principle, the primary obligation of the court is to examine from the point of view of a person of reasonable prudence if there was such grave and sudden provocation so as to reasonably conclude that it was possible to commit the offence of culpable homicide and as per the facts, was not a culpable homicide amounting to murder. An offence resulting from grave and sudden provocation would normally mean that a person placed in such circumstances could lose self-control but only temporarily and that too, in proximity to the time of provocation. The provocation could be an act or series of acts done by the deceased to the accused resulting in inflicting of injury."

57.

Per contra, learned A.G.A. countered that the parties were embroiled in a dispute regarding the discharge of water from the parnala (spout) and the tomato plants sown over the adjacent land. In the ensuing scuffle, appellant Madhav, who was already armed with a deadly knife, launched a murderous assault on the informant Lachhmi Narain (PW-1). When the deceased Smt. Malho rushed in unarmed to shield her husband, Madhav inflicted a fatal stab wound deep into her chest cavity and when their young daughter intervened, she too was inflicted knife injuries. Learned A.G.A. urged that the victims were completely unarmed and defenseless, ruling out any apprehension of injury or death to the accused party. The severity and anatomical site of the fatal wound —puncturing the ascending aorta—clearly manifest an intentional and deliberate homicide, completely negating the plea of sudden provocation.

58.

We have given our thoughtful consideration to the rival submissions and perused the statutory provisions. Exception 1 to Section 300 of the Indian Penal Code mandates:

“Exception 1.—When culpable homicide is not murder.—

Culpable homicide is not murder if the offender, whilst deprived of the power of self-control by grave and sudden provocation, causes the death of the person who gave the provocation or causes the death of any other person by mistake or accident.

The above exception is subject to the following provisos:—

(First)—That the provocation is not sought or voluntarily provoked by the offender as an excuse for killing or doing harm to any person.

(Secondly)—That the provocation is not given by anything done in obedience to the law, or by a public servant in the lawful exercise of the powers of such public servant.

(Thirdly)—That the provocation is not given by anything done in the lawful exercise of the right of private defence.

Explanation.—Whether the provocation was grave and sudden enough to prevent the offence from amounting to murder is a question of fact."

59.

On an anxious scrutiny of the record, we are unable to persuade ourselves to accept the submissions advanced on behalf of the appellants. The ocular testimony of the injured star witness PW-1 Lachhmi Narain clearly demonstrates the topography: the courtyard of Bhagwan Deen lies towards the east of the informant's house and below the wooden spout (parnala), the informant's land is situated where appellant Madhav had encroached by planting a tomato crop. When the mediator’s efforts failed and the informant turned to return home, appellant Madhav, armed with a knife, stabbed him in the lumbar back, while co-appellants Shiv Kumar, Sheo Ram and Munna physically restrained him. When the deceased rushed forward to cover her husband from further blows, Madhav thrust the knife into her chest.

60.

Crucially, during the extensive cross-examination of PW-1, not even a suggestion was thrown by the defence that the deceased was armed with a danda or that she had struck Madhav with it. PW-2 Jagannath Prasad Tiwari, an independent mediator present on the spot, categorically deposed that Lachhmi Narain held no danda or weapon in his hand. The victims being entirely unarmed, there existed no imminent peril to the person or property of the accused that could reasonably justify a loss of self-control in a person of ordinary prudence. The law is firmly settled that mere resentment cannot be permitted to masquerade as grave and sudden provocation; where an offender arms himself and takes undue advantage of unarmed persons to commit homicide, the beneficial umbrella of Exception 1 to Section 300 IPC is wholly inapplicable. Thus, the plea of grave and sudden provocation is sans merit and stands rejected.

Point No. (v): Credibility and Sterling Quality of Eye-Witnesses

(PW-1 & PW-2)

61.

It is next contended on behalf of the appellants that the prosecution case rests upon the testimonies of PW-1 and PW-2, who do not meet the test of witnesses of sterling quality and that the deposition of PW-1, being an interested relative, lacks independent corroboration. It is argued that PW-2 Jagannath Prasad Tiwari did not support the complicity of the remaining co-accused persons, rendering their presence and active participation highly doubtful.

Point No. (vi): Evaluation of Defence Evidence (DW-1)

62.

Learned counsel for the appellants urged that the learned trial court fell into error by summarily discarding the deposition of defence witness DW-1 Shiv Bhagwan, who was an independent neighbor residing across the courtyard.

63.

We have scrutinized the testimony of DW-1 Shiv Bhagwan in the light of the record. Through DW-1, the defence attempted to set up a narrative that the deceased was armed with a danda and was the aggressor and that Madhav wielded a vegetable knife solely in private defence while his three brothers were absent, however, this version stands completely belied by the contemporary investigative record. As observed hereinabove, neither was any suggestion regarding a danda put to the injured witness PW-1 during cross-examination, nor was any stick recovered from the spot by the Investigating Officer (PW-9). DW-1 was introduced as an afterthought after a considerable lapse of time to fabricate a defence of right of private defence. In the face of the consistent and unimpeached testimony of the injured eye-witness, the learned trial court committed no illegality in rejecting the testimony of DW-1 as untrustworthy and partisan.

Point No. (vii): Claim of Juvenility of Appellants No. 2 & 3 (Shiv

Kumar & Sheo Ram)

64.

So far as the plea of juvenility raised on behalf of appellant No. 2 (Shiv Kumar) and appellant No. 3 (Sheo Ram) is concerned, it is relevant to note that although an argument regarding their minority was advanced before the trial court at the stage of sentencing, the same was turned down and substantive sentences were awarded. However, during the pendency of this appeal, pursuant to applications filed by them, this Court through successive orders—including order dated 10.02.2021 noticing their recorded age under Section 313 Cr.P.C., order dated 23.03.2021 regarding Notification under Section 60(2) of the U.P. Children Act, 1951 and orders dated 25.08.2021 and 30.09.2021 confirming the enforcement of the said Act in District Sitapur vide Notification dated 18.11.1977—referred the matter vide order dated 09.11.2021 to the Juvenile Justice Board, Sitapur for conducting an inquiry. The Juvenile Justice Board, Sitapur, in Misc. Case No. 70 of 2021 and Misc. Case No. 40 of 2022, vide comprehensive orders dated 25.02.2022 and 02.05.2022 respectively, categorically declared both appellant No. 2 and appellant No. 3 to be juveniles on the date of commission of the alleged offence (19.04.1983); and crucially, this Court vide its most relevant order dated 06.04.2023 passed by a Division Bench comprising Hon'ble Attau Rahman Masoodi, J. and Hon'ble Mrs. Saroj Yadav, J., explicitly recorded that since the aforesaid declarations of juvenility remained unassailed by the State or the complainant, the legal consequence thereof is that while their conviction would stand, the substantive sentence awarded to the said juvenile appellants stands eclipsed. Hence, in view of the uncontroverted declarations of juvenility by the competent Board and the binding order of this Court dated 06.04.2023, while we proceed to uphold their conviction on merits along with the other co-appellants, the substantive sentence of imprisonment awarded to appellant No. 2 (Shiv Kumar) and appellant No. 3 (Sheo Ram) stands eclipsed and cannot be given effect to, requiring their case to be remitted to the Board for passing appropriate orders in accordance with the statutory provisions.

Point No. (viii): Scrutiny of Findings, Allegation of Ante-Timed FIR and Patent Perversity

65.

Learned counsel for the appellants lastly contended that the First Information Report was ante-dated and fabricated after consultation with the police, relying upon the statement made by scribe PW-3 Bankey Lal during cross-examination that the Sub-Inspector had arrived in the village at 10:00 P.M. and corrected certain sentences in the complaint.

66.

On a meticulous examination of the chronological record, we find this argument to be wholly meritless. The informant PW-1 clearly deposed in his examination-in-chief that he dictated the written tehrir to Bankey Lal, which was read over and explained to him, whereupon he affixed his signature and proved the same as Exhibit Ka-1. Not a single suggestion was put to PW-1 that the report was tailored under police influence. As regards PW-3 Bankey Lal, his examination-in-chief was recorded on 09.03.1984, whereas his cross-examination was conducted after an unexplained hiatus of more than a month on 21.04.1984. While he stated that the Sub-Inspector corrected sentences that were not properly framed, he maintained that the report was scribed at the dictation of Lachhmi Narain.

67.

The incident occurred at sunset (around 06:30–07:00 P.M.) in a rural area devoid of vehicular transport. The village Chaukidar PW-4 Guru Sewak carried the written complaint on foot across a distance of 8 kilometers to Police Station Talgaon, where the Chick FIR (Exhibit Ka-5) was registered at 23:15 hours, followed by the immediate dispatch of the special report to higher authorities. The learned trial court thoroughly examined the sequence of events and recorded a categorical finding that the FIR was lodged with utmost promptitude and was neither delayed nor ante-timed. We find no perversity or infirmity in the said conclusion.

68.

Upon a holistic appreciation of the oral, documentary and forensic evidence in its entirety, we are of the considered opinion that the prosecution has successfully established the guilt of the appellants beyond all reasonable doubt and the findings recorded by the learned trial court suffer from no patent perversity or illegality warranting interference in appeal.

69.

In view of the discussion, analysis and findings recorded here-in-above, the instant Criminal Appeal is hereby dismissed and the conviction recorded by the learned trial court against all the appellants— namely, appellant No. 1 (Madhav) under Sections 302, 307 and 324 IPC and appellant No. 2 (Shiv Kumar), appellant No. 3 (Sheo Ram) and appellant No. 4 (Munna) under Sections 302/34, 307/34 and 324/34 IPC, is hereby affirmed.

70.

The substantive sentences of Imprisonment for Life, 7 years' R.I. and 1 year's R.I. awarded to appellant No. 1 (Madhav) and appellant No. 4 (Munna) are hereby confirmed. Their bail bonds are cancelled and their sureties are discharged. They shall be taken into custody forthwith to serve out their remaining sentences.

71.

In respect of appellant No. 2 (Shiv Kumar) and appellant No. 3 (Sheo Ram), in view of the orders dated 25.02.2022 and 02.05.2022 passed by the Juvenile Justice Board, Sitapur declaring them to be juveniles on the date of commission of the offence and the binding order of this Court dated 06.04.2023, the substantive sentences of imprisonment awarded to them stand eclipsed and are hereby set aside. Their bail bonds stand discharged. Their records shall be remitted to the Juvenile Justice Board, Sitapur, for passing appropriate orders in accordance with the provisions of the Juvenile Justice Act.

72.

Let the Trial Court Record along with a certified copy of this judgment and order be transmitted to the trial court concerned forthwith for information and necessary compliance.