AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
This is a complaint filed in Form M by M/s. Spiral Impex Pvt. Ltd. against M/s Parsvnath Developer Ltd. and Others seeking a refund of an amount of Rs.1,03,72,222/- (Rupees one crore three lakh seventy-two thousand two hundred and twenty two only) along with interest calculated at 24% per annum from the date of payment of each amount until 21 November 2016 and at the rate of MCLR plus 2% after that date; to direct the Respondents to offer the apartment to the Complainant at the original agreed price on completion of the project; to direct the Respondents to pay a compensation equal to the interest paid by the Complainant on the home loan; to direct the Respondents to pay an amount of Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh only) towards litigation cost and another amount of Rs.10,00,000/- (Rupees ten lakh only) for mental harassment, agony and pain.
The brief facts of the case are that in March 2008 the Complainant M/s. Spiral Impex Pvt. Ltd. booked an apartment admeasuring 1942 sq. ft. in Parsvnath Paramount Project located in Subhash Nagar, Delhi (the Project) by paying a booking amount of Rs.14,56,500/- (Rupees fourteen lakh fifty six thousand and five hundred only); the Complainant was initially allotted flat No. T1/501 in Tower number T1 and a Builder Buyer Agreement was signed between M/s. Parsvnath Developers Ltd. (Respondent no. 1) and the Complainant on 11 April 2008; that the total basic cost payable for the flat was fixed at Rs.1,16,52,000 (Rupees one crore sixteen lakh and fifty two thousand only) calculated at the rate of Rs.6000 per square foot; and that vide letter dated 7 April 2011 the Complainant was informed that the earlier allotted flat was changed to T2/601. The Complainant has submitted that in accordance with clause 11A of the Builder Buyer Agreement, the construction of apartment was to be completed within a period of thirty months of commencement of construction of the building tower and counting from the date of Bhoomipujan held on 31 October 2008, the construction should have been completed by April 2011 but not only has there been an inordinate delay of several years, but also that there is no possibility of the construction getting completed in foreseeable future as the project site has been sealed under the orders of South DMC for the last several years owing to acts of omission and commission committed by the Respondent in violation of the law and the directions of the sanctioning authorities. In view of the stated circumstances, the Complainant has filed the present complaint against the Respondents and has sought reliefs as enumerated in paragraph above.
After hearing the Complainant, notices were issued to the Respondents, and the Respondents filed a detailed reply through Authorized Representative Shri Madan Dogra on 26 February 2019. In their reply, the Respondents submitted a chronology of events starting with 7 March 2003 when the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) allotted certain lands in Subhash Nagar, New Delhi to the Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC); grant of permission to DMRC by DDA/ MoUD in July 2003 to undertake property development; invitation of bids by DMRC in October 2005; adjudgment of the Respondent No.1 as the successful bidder in the auction; execution of a long-term lease agreement (ninety years) between the DMRC and Respondent No.1 in July 2006; submission of lay out plans and building plans by the Respondent No.1, with the requisite approval of DMRC, for consideration of the South Delhi Municipal Corporation (South DMC); the Respondent No.1 receiving the information that the allotted plan had been approved by the Standing Committee of the South DMC subject to issuance of a ‘No Objection Certificate’ (NOC) by DDA; issuance of a clarificatory order by the Ministry of Urban Development that the NOC for property development may not be insisted upon; issuance of a NOC by DDA in March 2009; release of the sanctioned building plans by South DMC in July 2010; consideration by South DMC to the revised building plans submitted by the Respondents and directions issued by South DMC in October 2011 to the Respondent No.1 asking it to comply with all balance compliances; sealing of the project by South DMC on 3 November 2011; de-sealing of the property on 23 December 2011 based on a representation made by the Respondents against the sealing order and assurances for timely compliance of the balance compliances; details of the correspondence made by the Respondent No.1 with DMRC, DDA, Ministry of Urban Development and South DMC between December 2011 and 21.08.2014 when the South DMC rejected the revised building plans; issuance of a Show Cause Notice by South DMC in December 2014 asking the Respondent No.1 to show cause why the property should not be sealed; reply to the Respondent No.1 to the Show Cause Notice and its consideration by South DMC and the eventual sealing of the subject property by South DMC on 23 January 2015 which sealing continues to operate as on date.
In their reply, the Respondents admitted that the Complainant had booked an apartment bearing No. T1-501 ad-measuring 1942 sq. feet in their project named Parsvnath Paramount Subhash Nagar, New Delhi, in February 2008 and has paid a total of Rs.1,03,72,222/- (Rupees one crore three lakh seventy two thousand two hundred and twenty two only); that a Builder Buyer agreement has been executed between the two sides in April 2008 and claimed that the super structure of the Tower in which the Complainant’s apartment was located was already complete and that further construction could not be taken up by the Respondent due to reasons mentioned by it in the preceding paragraph which reasons cannot be attributed to the Respondents. The Respondents submitted that being a private limited company the Complainant was an investor, but did not provide any information regarding the possible date of completion of the project despite acknowledging that more than eleven years had elapsed since the booking of the apartment by the Complainant and payment of almost 95% of the agreed cost of the apartment.
Both sides were heard on successive dates of hearings during the course of which the Counsel for the Complainant, on 19.6.2019 withdrew on instructions, all reliefs sought by the Complainant except those relating to the refund and interest thereon. Subsequently, the Complainant was directed to file a calculation sheet duly supported with a statement about loans taken from the bank, which it did on 27 June 2019. The Respondent did not raise any dispute on the statement of payments made and the calculation sheet filed by the Complainant. Instead, the Respondent raised an unsubstantiated issue of maintainability of the complaint before this Authority. The Respondent was granted a period of two weeks to submit relevant documents, if any, and the matter was reserved for orders.
The Respondent did not file any documentation relating to maintainability within the permitted period of two weeks provided to him on 31 July 2019, which plea of maintainability had been made by the Respondent, interestingly, after eight hearings in the case were already over. However, on 26 August 2019, the Respondents filed an application under section 71(1) of the Act claiming that they had “come to know” that the Complainant was a member of the Paramount Subhash Nagar Resident Welfare Association (RWA), who had filed a complaint bearing No.353-2014 before the Hon’ble NCDRC on 30 August 2014, and that case is next listed for hearing on 14 May 2020. Oddly, neither of the parties had mentioned about such a parallel litigation in another forum during the entire pendency of the case before this Authority over the past several months and the Complainant had even furnished a declaration that no other case on the same subject was pending before any other forum and the Respondent had chosen not to contest this declaration. In filing the complaint under section 71(1) of the Act on 26 August 2019, the Respondent did not explain as to how it suddenly “came to know” of the existence of the case which had been going on for more than five years nor provided any evidence that the Complainant is indeed a part of that litigation. However, since such a claim had been made by the Respondent, though not within the time period provided for it, the Authority considered the matter and noted that natural justice would demand that the application made by the Respondent be heard by the Authority even at this late stage.
Accordingly, hearing notices were issued to both sides and the matter was listed for hearing on several successive dates. On 8 January 2020, the Counsel for the Respondent requested for permission to withdraw his application filed on 26 August 2019 under Section 71 of the Act and further requested for permission to file another miscellaneous application under Section 37 and Section 35(2) of the Act read with Section 151 CPC. The Respondent sought this permission to modify its application on the plea that the fact of a parallel litigation between the two sides needed to be considered not under Section 71 of the Act but under the provisions of Sections 35(2) and 37 read with Section 151 of CPC. This was found acceptable by the Authority and permission was accordingly granted to treat the application under Section 71 as withdrawn and by taking on record the new miscellaneous application under Section 37 read with Section 35(2) of the Act of 2016 read with Section 151 of CPC.
While the Counsel for the Complainant did object strongly to the maintainability of the fresh application, he did admit on instructions from the Complainant, that the Complainant was well aware of the pendency of a complaint filed by the RWA before Hon’ble NCDRC at the time of filing his complaint before this Authority. Such an admission of full knowledge of pendency of the case filed by the RWA before Hon’ble NCDRC clearly indicates that the complaint filed by the Complainant in December 2018 before this Authority was not in accordance with the provisions of law and that, even if the Complainant wished to withdraw itself from the litigation pending before the Hon’ble NCDRC, the complaint before this Authority was premature.
This Authority is of the considered view that the issue relating to maintainability of the complaint as on the date of filing of the complaint needs to be decided first, without going into the merits of the complaints and/or applicability of the provisions of CPC to these proceedings. Since the Complainant has already admitted that it was well aware of the pendency of a complaint filed by Paramount Subhash Nagar Resident Welfare Association (RWA) (of which it is a member) before Hon’ble NCDRC, and the Complainant still went ahead with filing the present complaint in Form ‘M’ before this Authority seeking reliefs that bore substantial commonality with the reliefs sought by RWA before Hon’ble NCDRC, the present complaint suffers from a fatal infirmity and is liable to be rejected forthwith. The Complainant is however, at liberty to approach this Authority after it has disassociated itself from the litigation pending before Hon’ble NCDRC, should it so wish.
Ordered accordingly.
No orders as to cost.
