AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Per Satbeer Singh Godara, Judicial Member:
These assessee’s three appeals in ITA Nos. 832, 833 & 834/Del/2025 for Assessme nt Years 2018-19, 2019-20 & 2020-21 arise against the C IT( A)-30, New Delhi’s DIN & order No. ITBA/APL/M/250/2024-25/1071341134(1), 1071341700(1) & 1071341990(1) all dated 18.12.2024, in proceedings u/s 153C r.w.s. 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short “the Act”), respectively.
Heard both the p arties at length. Case files peruse d.
It emerges during the course of hearing that the assessee’s instant three appeals raise an identical issue of disallowance of bogus purchases made by both the learned lower authorities; involving varying sums, in their respective assessments as upheld in the lower appellate discussion.
That being the case, both the parties hereby invite the tribunal’s attention to the lear ned co-ordinate bench recent order dated 29.07.2025 in assessme nt year 20 21-22 in it’s appeal ITA No. 719/Del/2025 partly accepting the issue against the department as under:
2.T he grounds of appeal are not well drafted. H owever , sol e iss ue raised by the ass essee emerged the refr om is tha t whet her t he L d. CIT(A ) is justified i n applyi ng Gr oss Pro fit (‘G P’) @ 2 0% of t he said bogus purchases of Rs.43,16,444/-.
3.The relevant facts giving rise to thi s appeal are that the as sesseeappell ant filed its Income Tax Return (‘ITR’) of t he r el evant year on 05.03.2022 declari ng incom e of Rs.85,26,280/-. Search and s eizur e ope rati ons under section 132 of t he Inc ome Tax Act, 1961 (‘Act’) c arri ed, on 26.10.2020, on Sanj ay Jain & Meht a G roup of cases rev eal ed that the assessee had taken accommodation entri es of Rs.43,1 6,444/- in the garb of purchases during the rel eva nt yea r. H ence , the Assessi ng Officer (‘AO’), with de tai led reasoni ng mentioned in the ass es sme nt order disallowe d the entire bogus purchas es of Rs.43,16,444/- a nd taxed the s ame in the hands of t he assessee. A ggri eved, the assessee fi led appeal before the Ld. C IT(A), who restricted the disallo wance /addition at Rs.8,63,289/-; i. e. @ 20% of t he bogus purchases of Rs.43,16,444/- as under: -
“8 . T he evidenc e, incl udi ng s ta tements of S anjay Jai n and Ni khil Sachar , and the seized T ally data, unequivocall y es tabli shes t hat the p urchases were accommodation entries. The abs ence of co rrespondi ng deliv ery c hallans or transport records furt her corrobo rates this conclusi on. While the purchases are dee med bo gus, t he fact that the correspondi ng sales and consumptio n are undisput ed indicates t hat the mat erials were obtai ned through back channels. The appellant's ar gument that only the profi t eleme nt shoul d be taxed is valid. Consideri ng the nat ure o f the industry and the high GS T rate of 28% on c ement, it is reasonable to assume that bac k-channel operations woul d involve additional costs, such as commissi ons and logistics . A GP addition of 20% on t he bogus purc has es ade quately refl ects the profit embedded i n such transactio ns, acc ounti ng for industry nor ms and the speci fic ci rcumstances of this cas e. In C IT vs. Simit P. S het h, the c ourt upheld a 1 2.5% GP additio n. Ho wever, given the hi gher GST rate and the inhere nt costs i n acc ommodation entr y operations fo r cement, a GP addi tion of 20 % is more appropr iate. This approach aligns with the pri ncipl e that the addition must reflec t a fair estimat e of the pr ofit element. In light of t he above fi ndi ngs, the a ppeal is par tially allowed . The additi on of ₹43,1 6,444/- is modified, and 20% of t he disputed purchases , amounti ng t o ₹8,63,289/-, is sustai ned as ta xable i nc ome. ”
4.The R evenue i s not i n app eal before us.
5.At the outs et , the Ld. Counsel contended that t he purc has es of R s.43,16,444/- was ge nui ne as t he pay ments had been made through the banki ng channel and the AO had not disput ed the consumption of material purc has ed for Rs.43,16,444/-. Alt ernatively, he submitt ed that the GP ra te of 12.5% mi ght be applied i n this case i nstead of 20% a pplied by the Ld. C IT(A ).
6.On the other hand, the Ld. C ommissioner of Inco me Tax - Depar tmental Representa tive (‘CIT-D R’) conte nded tha t the average G.P. rate of the assess ee had been applied as t he GST on the p urcha ses of cement was 2 8%. He contended that the Ld. Couns el had not contradicted the fi ndi ng of the Ld. CIT(A). He prayed for dismissal of the appeal.
7.We hav e heard both parti es a nd have consider ed the mat erial availabl e on recor d. The L d. CIT(A ) has a ppli ed the ra te of 20% k eepi ng i n vi ew t he entire facts of the case, GST rate and the cost of ac commodatio n entr ies. Ho wever, the Ld. CI T(A) has not gi ven details in t his in the impugned orde r. Keepi ng i n vi ew the facts in totality, mat erial availabl e on the record and in the i nterest of justice, we are of t he c onsidered opi ni on that t he GP rat e of 18% wi ll be suffi cient as t he assess ee had t o give pay ment for ac commodati on entri es aft er deri vi ng i nco me from the above bogus purchas es . Accordi ngly, we restri ct the disallowance/additi on to 18%. The appellant gets consequential relief. ”
Bo th the parties could hardly dispute in this factual backdrop that the instant issue of disallowance of the assessee’s bogus purchases is very much an identical one in all the se assessme nt years. We thus adopt the learned co-ordinate bench above detailed discussion mutatis mutandis to restrict the impug ned bogus purchases disallowance to that @18 % in very terms. Nece ssary computation shall follow as per law.
No other ground or argument has been pressed before us.
These assessee’s three appeals ITA Nos. 832, 833 & 834/Del/2025 are partly allowed in above terms. A copy of this common order be placed in the respective case files.
