Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2026) 11 ITAT CK 1650

M/s KKH Infrastructure Private Limited vs ACIT, Central Circle-27

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi · Decided on 11 November 2026

CASE NUMBER
ITA 3031/DEL/2026 & ITA 3032/DEL/2026

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

8 paragraphs · 884 words

PER SATBEER SINGH GODARA, JUDICIAL MEMBER:

These twin assessees namely M/s KKH Infrastructure Private Limited and M/s My Choice Agencies Private Limited have instituted their instant as many appeals ITA Nos. 3031 & 3032/Del/2026; for assessment year 2013-14, against the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-29 (for short, “CIT(A)”), New Delhi’s separate Order Nos. 10142/2012-13 & 10141/2012-13) dated 13.01.2026, involving proceedings u/s 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961; hereinafter referred to as, “the Act”; respectively.

Heard both the assessees and the departments at length. Case files perused.

2.

It transpires during the course of hearing that the learned counsel representing both the assessees raises his first and foremost legal ground challenging validity of the impugned reopening itself. That being the case, our attention is invited to the latter assessee M/s My Choice Agencies Private Limited, reopening reasons recorded by the learned Assessing Officer inter alia indicating that it had acquired 50% shareholding in M/s PSS Agro & Investments Private Limited after allegedly availing funds/accommodation entries from three entry providers M/s Real Vyapaar Private Limited, M/s Shubhshree High Rise Private Limited and Careful Engineering Private Limited to the tune of Rs. 1.8 crores, Rs. 0.7 Crores and Rs. 1 Crores; respectively, totaling to Rs. 3.5 Crores in question. We wish to emphasize here that the other investor to the extent of 50% in M/s PSS Agro & Investments Private Limited herein happens to be Obedient Tradelink Private Limited who advanced loan of Rs. 1.75 crores to the former assessee M/s KKH Infrastructure Private Limited. We further wish to clarify that the learned departmental authorities invoked the very section 148 reopening mechanism against this former assessee as well alleging M/s Obedient Tradelink Private Limited as an accommodation entry provider as per the search statement recorded from the party concerned. There is further no quarrel between the parties that the learner Assessing Officer’s reopening reasons in M/s My Choice Agencies Private Limited extract the search statement of one Mr. Praveen Agarwal, that he had admitted the above said three entities as providing accommodation entries only. The factual position is hardly any different in case of M/s KKH Infrastructure Private Limited herein as similar search statement admission is attributed to Shri Manpreet Piplani’s specific reply to the learned departmental authorities’ questionnaire duly reproduced in the reopening reasons. It is in this factual backdrop that the assessee is on the one hand submit that we ought to quash the impugned reopening since based on incorrect assumption of facts whereas the Revenue strongly supports the same for the reason that the learned Assessing Officer(s) in both these cases recorded the same going by the concerned entry operator's statement, duly admitting all the four parties herein (supra) as providing loan entries and engaged in accommodation entry business. The Revenue accordingly submits that the learned Assessing Officer had added Rs. 3.50 and Rs. 1.75 (crores) as unexplained/credits as well as the alleged commission component embedded therein as these twin assessees’ respective incomes.

3.

We have given our thoughtful consideration to the assessees’ and the Revenue’s respective stands against and in support of validity of the impugned twin re-openings. We find no reason to sustain the same. We wish to clarify here at the cost of repetition that all what learned Assessing Officer(s) had done in both these assessee's cases is to refer to the concerned entry operator's statements that all the above four entities are merely accommodation entry providers. The assessee at this stage takes us to the learned Assessing Officer’s reopening reasons in case of M/s My Choice Agencies Private Limited at page 7 wherein the concerned entry operator had nowhere admitted that M/s Real Vyapaar Private Limited, M/s Shubhshree High Rise Private Limited and Careful Engineering Private Limited as accommodation entry providers as the entities named in the said statement read different names. The factual position is hardly any different in reopening reasons recorded for KKH Infrastructure Private Limited wherein Mr. Piplani had nowhere made it clear that M/s Obedient Trademark Private Limited is an entry providing accommodation entity only. It would indeed apt in our opinion to refer to the CBDT’s landmark circular issued way back on 10.3.2003 that mere recording of such search statements; in absence of any supportive evidence, does not carry any significance under the provisions of the Act. This is indeed coupled with the fact that M/s Obedient Trademark Private Limited has nowhere been questioned as an accommodation entry provider entity in case of this latter assessee M/s My Choice Agencies Private Limited despite the fact that it acquired 50% of the stake in M/s PSS Agro & Investments Private Limited(supra).

4.

It is in this factual backdrop that we hereby quote CIT versus Renee Singh (2011) 11 taxmann.com, 310 (Delhi) that assumption of such section 148/147 reopening jurisdiction on incorrect facts couldn’t be concurred with both in law as well as on facts. We thus quash both these re-opening(s) as initiated in these two assessees’ respective cases in very terms. Ordered accordingly.

All other remaining pleadings on merits between both these assessees on the one hand and the department, on the other hand are hereby rendered infructuous.

5.

These twin assessees’ as many cases ITA No. 3031 & 3032/Del/2026 are allowed. A copy of this common order be placed in the respective case files.