AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
ORDER
Oral Judgment : Justice Sharad Kumar Sharma, Member (Judicial):
The Appellant claims itself to be a Partnership Firm consisting of 3 Partners and are said to have been engaged in the business of consultancy.
It is contended that, the Respondent No. 1 is the Bankruptcy Trustee of Respondent No. 2, who was admitted into the Bankruptcy, by the orders of the Ld. Adjudicating Authority as it was passed on 28.05.2024 in CP (IB) No. 389 / 121 / HDB / 2022, which was filed by the PTC India Financial Services Limited.
It is stated that during March 2006, Respondent No. 2 i.e. Mahendra Kumar Agarwal, the Bankrupt, had approached the Appellant herein to avail an unsecured loan facility and the Appellant in lieu thereof, had advanced an amount of Rs.2 Crores and subsequent to this, at the request of Respondent No. 2, had advanced more amount and the total amount thus advanced by the Appellant stood at Rs.30,51,44,225/- as it was payable on 31.03.2024, which was inclusive of the interest too.
Its owing to the aforesaid loan liability, the Respondent No. 2 i.e. the Bankrupt, offered to sell the properties and accordingly certain agreements for sale was entered into between Respondent No. 2 and the Appellant.
In the agreement for sale executed on 29.12.2017 in favour of the Applicant / Appellant, a certain piece of property Bearing No. C-6, admeasuring 1342 sq. yards situated at `Mediciti Enclave’ in Survey No. 90/P, Ghanpur Village, Medchal Mandal, Rangareddy District, Andhra Pradesh, was agreed to be sold as against the total debt of Rs.13,75,25,795/-.
Another agreement for sale dated 16.06.2017 was said to have been executed in favour of the Applicant / Appellant for sale of 21,002 equity shares of M/s. TCI Industries Limited, at the agreed rate of Rs.1,660/- per share, as an adjustment of Rs.10,95,63,320/- as against the total debt of Rs.13,75,25,795/-.
The Applicant / Appellant, in this Application, thus preferred by the Appellant was, by invoking the provisions contained under Section 60(5) of I & B Code, 2016, and had filed an Interlocutory Application before the Ld. Adjudicating Authority i.e. National Company Law Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench, which was numbered as IA (IBC) No. 936 / 2025, which was preferred in pending CP (IB) No. 389 / 121 / HDB / 2022.
In the said application thus preferred, the Appellant has prayed for grant of relief as extracted under:-
``To direct the Respondent No. 1 to exclude the property and shares as detailed in Para 9 of the said application out of the bankruptcy estate and the bankruptcy process of Respondent No. 2’’.
When this application was taken up for consideration by the Ld. Adjudicating Authority, it came to light that, the said property, which was subject matter of the agreement for sale dated 29.12.2017, has been included in the disputed property as an asset of Bankrupt, and the shares held by Respondent No. 2 as covered by Agreement dated 16.06.2017 was too included in the Bankruptcy proceedings drawn against Respondent No. 2, which is alleged to have caused hardship to the Applicant / Appellant and prejudice too, because the Appellant claimed a right over the property and the shares as covered by the agreements for sale dated 29.12.2017 and 16.06.2017, besides also the right over the equity shares which was agreed to be sold by the so called agreement for sale dated 16.06.2017.
The application was contested. The Respondent had contested the application on the ground that, an unregistered agreement for sale, does not confer any valid title on the Applicant / Appellant and besides that, as per Section 155 of I & B Codes, 2016, the estates of the Bankrupt includes all the properties, which belong to the Bankrupt person, which is to be reflected at the stage of commencement of the Bankruptcy proceedings and owing to the fact that, in the list of estate of the Bankrupt i.e. the Respondent No. 2 herein, to the application before Ld. NCLT, the property which are alleged to be covered by the Agreement for Sale dated 29.12.2017 was also then shown to be standing in the name of Respondent No. 2 , the bankrupt, the same could not be excluded from the estates of the bankrupt.
It was contended that, since there was no valid transfer of title in pursuance to the so called agreement for sale, no claim to the contrary can be raised by the Applicant over those properties of the bankrupt and also because of the fact that, with respect to the shares which was alleged to have been covered by the agreement for sale dated 16.06.2017, IFCI Venture Capital Limited, was already having a pledge over those shares of the Bankruptcy and the same was well within the knowledge of the Applicant / Appellant as it could find reference from Para 15 of the agreement for sale dated 16.06.2017.
Relevant para 15 of the Agreement for Sale dated 16.06.2017 is extracted hereunder:-
``15. That the Vendor agrees that till the IFCI ventures Capital releases the shares, the Vendee shall have the sole right to acquire the 21,002 Shares out of the aforesaid Shares once the Demat account of the Vendor is unfreezed and the balance Shares out of the aforesaid Shares once the pledge upon the same is released by IFCI Venture Capital Funds Ltd (IFCI). The Vendor has further assured the Vendee that the Vendor shall inform the Vendee once the Demat account of the Vendor is unfreezed as well as the pledge upon 45,000 shares out of the aforesaid Shares is released by IFCI Venture Capital Funds Ltd (IFCI).’’
It was further the case before the Ld. Adjudicating Authority, as it was drawn by the Respondent, that owing to the provisions contained under Section 156 of the I & B Code, 2016, which is extracted hereunder:
``156. Delivery of property and documents to bankruptcy
trustee.— The bankrupt, his banker or agent or any other person having possession of any property, books, papers or other records which bankruptcy trustee is required to take possession for the purposes of the bankruptcy process shall deliver the said property and documents to the bankruptcy trustee.’’
From the above provisions it could be made out, that a Bankrupt as against whom the Bankruptcy proceedings, had been drawn, it becomes mandatory on part of the bankrupt to ensure the delivery of the properties to the Bankruptcy Trustee for the purposes to effectively carry the proceedings of the Bankruptcy and hence, the disputed property as covered by the agreement for sale dated 29.12.2017 and the shares which were subject matter of agreement for sale dated 16.06.2017, they would automatically by implications of law, would fall to be the estate of the Bankrupt, and the possession of them shall be deemed to be with the Bankruptcy Trustee for control under its administration.
However, the Appellant / Applicant is said to have raised a belated claim in response to the public notice dated 13.06.2024, that was circulated in relation to the disputed property, which was the subject matter of two agreements for sale, which for all legal purposes cannot be treated to be the documents which had conferred a valid title, which could be treated to be a Deed of Conveyance in the eyes of law.
After exchange of the pleadings the matter was put to contest and the question that was formulated by the Ld. Tribunal, was as to whether at all, the property and shares, which form to be the subject matter of respective agreements for sale dated 29.12.2017 and 16.06.2017, at all could be included in the Bankruptcy estate and can it to be treated as to be under the management of the Bankruptcy Trustee, which could be put for an Auction Sale which was scheduled to be held on 25.10.2025.
The Appellant’s claim that, they had entered into a bona fide agreement for sale, of the property, and the fact of execution of the agreement for sale is not in dispute, because, the Bankrupt i.e. Respondent No. 2, has confirmed the same to Respondent No. 1 and further because it had also been admitted by Respondent No. 2 that, he has no right over the disputed property owing to the fact that, the bankrupt himself has disowned his rights over the property and the shares, which were the subject matter of agreement for sale which forms as the basis of the claim by the Appellant / Applicant. On the basis of the above, the Appellant claims an exemption for the said properties from being brought within the estate of the Bankrupt to be kept under the management of the Bankruptcy Trustee and from the Auction proceedings, which was to be held on 25.10.2025.
The Ld. Tribunal considered the rival contentions in context of the application preferred by the Appellant praying for exclusion of the property and shares covered by the agreement for sale to be excluded from the Bankruptcy Estate, and came to a conclusion that:-
a. The Bankrupt admits the fact that he does not own the property and the shares covered by the two Agreements for Sale.
b. The existence of these two Agreements for Sale is not a fact in dispute.
c. Admittedly, these two Agreements for Sale, in relation to the immovable property and the shares respectively, which too would be a property, are not a registered document, which is mandatory, as per the provisions contained under Section 17 of the Registration Act.
What is more important is, that if we go through the terms and conditions of the agreements for sale that was executed on 29.12.2017, Clause 20 of the said Agreement for Sale becomes relevant for consideration.
Clause 20 of the agreement for sale dt. 29.12.2017, it reads as under:-
``That in case any of the Parties hereto infringes any of the terms and conditions of this Agreement, then the other Party shall be entitled to get this transaction enforced through the Court of law by Specific Performance of the Contract, at the cost and expenses of the defaulting Party.’’
Thus Clause 20 of the Agreement for Sale dated 29.12.2017, prescribes for that, if any of the covenants of agreement for sale of the immovable property as covered by the agreement for sale dated 29.12.2017, is infringed, then it will be incumbent upon the ``Vendee’’, to file a Suit for a specific performance of contract.
There is nothing on record and rather admitted too by the Appellant that, ever since 29.12.2017, no Sale Deed has been executed nor, there happens to be any Suit instituted before Competent Court for grant of decree of specific performance, filed by the Appellant.
In that eventuality, by operation of law, no valid transfer has fructified so far, and the title of the property will still continue to be vested with the Bankrupt who has executed the agreement for sale and it would be treated as to be part of the estate of the Bankrupt to be included in the Auction proceedings to be carried by the Bankruptcy Trustee as scheduled to be held on 25.10.2025.
If we could look at the controversy from yet another perspective, it is an unbelievable proposition under law that an agreement for sale, which was executed between the parties as back as on 29.12.2017 and 16.06.2017 respectively, was kept unexecuted without seeking execution of Deed, for such a long time and no effort whatsoever has been made or is even shown to have been made by the Appellant by bringing on documents on record to show any effort made by the Appellant to get the Deed executed in compliance of Clause 20 of the agreement for sale.
In that eventuality, the logical conclusion, which could be drawn is, that in the absence of the Sale Deed having been executed within time on the basis of the two Agreements for Sale, in relation to the immovable property and the shares covered by it, the deemed presumption would be that, the valid title of the said Assets continues to be with the Bankrupt i.e. Respondent No. 2 and it would be treated as to be the property of the Bankrupt which is to be included in the assets to be auctioned by the Bankruptcy Trustee / Respondent No. 1.
It is settled principle of law which needs no detailed and specific reference, that in the light of the provisions contained under Section 17, to be read with Section 49 of the Registration Act, an unregistered document in Comp. App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No.567/2025 Page 9 of 12 relation to an immovable property, the registration of which has been made mandatory under law, will not be conferring any valid title on the Appellant, and furthermore, it cannot be even read in evidence for any purposes whatsoever in any judicial proceedings as there is no fructified transfer of title of the subject asset to the Appellant, who is only a holder of an Agreement for Sale which is only a proposal or a settlement between the two contracting the parties and that too having being executed in 2017, for which, the Sale Deed has not yet been executed. Hence, the presumption under law would be that the said Asset property still continues to be the property of the Bankrupt, as there has been no valid conveyance.
A very illogical argument has been raised by the Ld. Counsel for the Appellant / Applicant, qua the aspect of filing of a Suit for specific performance that Clause 20 of the Agreement for Sale dated 29.12.2017, will have a binding effect, as agreed to resolve the aspect of rights as per the terms of agreement.
Under the law of limitation governing in relation to filing of a Suit for specific performance, the period which has been prescribed under law for institution of Suit for specific performance is 3 years as set down under Article 54 of Limitation Act.
Article 54 is extracted hereunder:
| Description of suit | Period of Limitation | Time from which period begins to run | |
| 54 | For specific performance of a contract | Three years | The date fixed for the performance, or, if no such date is fixed, when the plaintiff has notice that performance is refused. |
In the instant case, the said limitation period of 3 years have already lapsed.
An argument that has been attempted to be constructed by the Ld. Senior Counsel for the Appellant is that, in an agreement for sale where there is no specific date or period, which is fixed for performance of an act of execution of the Sale Deed, 3 years period has to be construed from the date, when a notice for performance of contract by execution of Deed is given and the same has been refused and that, since in this case, the Appellant is yet to give notice to the Bankrupt i.e. Respondent No. 2, to ensure to execute the Deed, under the Agreement, he is still within the limitation period to seek execution of the Deed.
We are of the view that, no exception could be carved out in the instant Appeal in the light of the Column 3 of Article 54 of the Limitation Act because, the period of limitation for filing of a Suit for specific performance cannot be permitted to be extended for an indefinite period owing to an in-action on part of the Appellant himself. Hence, in the light of the provisions contained under Comp. App (AT) (CH) (Ins) No.567/2025 Page 11 of 12 Section 27 of the Limitation Act, ``the in-action on part of the Appellant itself extinguishes his right over the property covered by the agreement for sale which has been sought to be excluded from the list of Bankruptcy Estate by filing of the Application being IA (IBC) No. 936 / 2025 which has been rejected by the Ld. Tribunal’’.
Owing to the fact, that on the basis of the alleged Agreement for Sale there is no valid right has been conferred and conveyed to the Appellant, and that, in the absence of a registered document having been executed in their favour within the prescribed period of limitation under law, the title of the property would be deemed to be continued to be vested with the Bankrupt for which, the proceedings of Bankruptcy has already been drawn, and at this stage, the same cannot be permitted to be excluded from the Bankruptcy Estate.
Consequently, the Company Appeal (AT) (CH) (INS) No. 567 / 2025 lacks merit and the same is accordingly dismissed. All Interlocutory Applications as contained therein, would stand rejected.
