High CourtsDivision Bench(2026) 11 KL CK 1536

M. Nakulan & Ors. vs Raghavan

High Court Of Kerala, Ernakulam · Decided on 12 November 2026

RESULT
Allowed
CASE NUMBER
R.C.REV. NO. 234 OF 2025

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

19 paragraphs · 1,226 words

Sathish Ninan, J.

The order of eviction passed under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, (for short “the Act”) by the Rent Control Court, was reversed by the Appellate Authority on the appeal by the tenant. The landlord is in Revision.

2.

The Rent Control Petition was filed in the year 2016 by one Nakulan who is the predecessor-in-interest of the present petitioners. Eviction was sought for his need of conducting business in Ayurvedic Medicines and Drugs. The Rent Control Court, as per order dated 30.11.2017, ordered eviction. Pending the appeal by the tenant as RCA 20/2018, the landlord-Nakulan passed away. The legal heirs of Nakulan got themselves impleaded in the proceedings and sought to amend the Rent Control Petition claiming eviction for the bonafide need of Nakulan's daughter-in-law, to start a textile business. The amendment was declined by the Appellate Authority and the Rent Control Petition was dismissed. Challenging the same, the landlords approached this Court in Rent Control Revision No.172/2020. This Court held that amendment can be permitted, and remanded the matter to the Rent Control Court.

3.

After remand, the Rent Control petition was amended seeking eviction, however not for the daughter-in-law but for the son of the second petitioner to start an air conditioning and refrigerator service centre.

4.

The Rent Control Court upheld the bonafide need. It further noted that the tenant conceded of not claiming the benefits under the first and second proviso to Section 11(3) of the Act. Accordingly eviction was ordered.

5.

On appeal by the tenant, the Appellate Authority interfered with the finding of bonafide need stating that the need projected before this Court and the need incorporated by way of amendment were different. It also held that petitioners failed to plead and prove the “dependency” of the second petitioner's son. Accordingly, the Rent Control Petition was dismissed.

6.

We have heard learned counsel on either side.

7.

As per the amended Rent Control petition, the requirement is for the second petitioner's son to do business in air conditioning and refrigerator services. To hold against the bonafide need all that the appellate authority relied on was that, when this Court had in the earlier round of litigation allowed amendment of the Rent Control Petition, the need projected was for the purpose of Nakulan's(the original landlord-Petitioner) daughter-in-law to start textiles business. But the amendment effected was, seeking eviction for the second petitioner's son and not for Nakulan's daughter-in-law. This was taken note of by the Appellate Authority adversely and held that the different cases being set up is only a pretext for eviction.

8.

What is required to be considered is, whether the need urged is bonafide or not. PW1 had deposed that Nakulan's daughter-in-law had shifted to Bangalore and that the second petitioner's son who is aged 30 years and who holds a diploma in air conditioning and refrigerator servicing, wants to start a refrigerator service centre in the room. It is the bonafides of the said need which is relevant. The mere fact that the need projected earlier was different, is not determinative to find that the present need and purpose pleaded lacks bonafides. The circumstances as to why there has been a change in the requirement has been explained by PW1. The second petitioner's son is aged 30 years. He holds a diploma in air conditioning and refrigerator. Presently he is employed elsewhere. He is unmarried. He intends to start an air conditioning and refrigerator service centre in the petition scheduled room. The son of the second petitioner is examined as PW1. The above sufficiently establishes the genuineness of the need. The Appellate Authority failed to appreciate the above materials on record while interfering with the finding of the Rent Control Court with regard to the bonafide need. The finding of the Appellate Authority is liable to be set aside and we do so. We find the bona fide need pleaded has been sufficiently established.

9.

Yet another reason on which the Appellate Authority interfered with the order of the Rent Control Court is, on the alleged failure of the petitioners to plead and prove the “dependency” of the second petitioner's son on the petitioners. The Appellate Authority has relied on the judgments in Albert Mendez v. Rema Chandran and others (2007 (3) KLT 23), Antony P.V. v. M/s Swastik Sweet House and Others (2017(2) KHC 951), Prathapan v. Rama Warrier (2004 (2) KLT 559).

10.

Paragraph 11A of the amended Rent Control petition reads thus :-

“11A The Petition Schedule Shop room has devolved on Petitioners 2 to 7. The 2 Petitioner's son Adarsh is 30 years old and he holds a diploma from Jaganath ITI. Thalassery in Air conditioning and Refrigeration. Presently he is working at the Whirlpool Service Centre. Vatakara for a meagre salary. He is unmarried. He has the bona-fide need to start an AC and Refrigerators Service Centre from the Petition Schedule Shop room independently, so that he can contemplate marriage. All the petitioners are agreeable for the same and they shall provide funds. The petition schedule shop room has sufficient space and suitable for the proposed venture.”

PW1 in his proof affidavit at paragraph 5 has sworn to thus:-

“5.

I hold a diploma from Jananath ITI, Thalassery in Air Conditioning and Refrigeration. Presently I am working at the Whirlpool Service Centre, Vatakara for a meagre salary. I am unmarried. I have the bona-fide need to start an AC and Refrigerators service centre from the Petition Schedule shop room independently. All the Petitioners are agreeable for the same and they shall provide funds. The Petition schedule shop room has sufficient space and suitable for the proposed venture. I am dependent on the Petitioners for accommodation. ”

Evidently the ingredient of “dependency” has been sufficiently brought out. It is also seen that he was cross-examined regarding the issue of “dependency”, thus :-

“ഞ ഞാൻ ഉദദ്ദേ ശ ശികക്കുന്ന ദജഞാലശി ചചെയ ഞാൻ ഈ മക്കു റശി ആ വ ശശ്യ മശില്ല എന്നക്കു പറഞ ഞാൽ ശ രശിയല്ല ....... ഹ രജശിപ്പ ടശിക പപീടശിക മക്കു റശികക്ക് ദവ ണ ശി ഞ ഞാൻ ഹ രജശിക ഞാചര ആ ശശ ശിയ ശികക്കുന്നക്കു ണക്ക് . ഞ ഞാൻ ഹ രജശിക ഞാചര ആ ശശ യ ശികക്കുന്ന ശില്ല ഞാ എന്നക്കുന്നും അങ്ങ ചനെയക്കു ള സ ഞാഹ ചെരശ്യന്നും എ നെശികക്ക് ഉണ ഞായ ശിടശില്ല എന്നക്കുന്നും പറഞ ഞാൽ ശ രശിയല്ല .”

While the term 'dependency” as such has not been mentioned in the petition, the averments in paragraph 11A of which is extracted above, coupled with the deposition of PW1 would leave no room for doubt that eviction was claimed for the occupation by her dependent-son. On the facts as noted above, there is no scope for a contention of any prejudice having resulted to the tenant for the absence of the word “dependent” in the Rent Control petition. The finding of the Appellate Authority to the contrary is liable to be set aside and we do so.

12.

As was noticed earlier, the tenant has not attempted to claim and prove the benefit of the proviso to Section 11(3) of the Act. The bonafide need having been upheld, the order of eviction passed by the Rent Control Court is liable to be restored.

In the result, the Rent Control Petition is allowed. Setting aside the judgment of the Appellate Authority, the order of eviction passed by the Rent Control Court is restored.