AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
P. Murgesen, J.—This Criminal Appeal is directed against the judgment dated 15.10.2008 made in S.C. No. 167/2007 on the file of the Principal Sessions Judge, Thoothukudi.
The appellant is the accused and the respondent is the complainant.
The case of the prosecution is as under:
P.W.1-Paulraj is the husband of the deceased Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi and father of the deceased Santhanamari. P.W.2-Pappukani is the relative of P.W.1 and wife of P.W.3-Thangasami. P.W.3 is the husband of P.W.2. P.W.4-Selvakumar and P.W.7-Ponselvi are the son and daughter of the deceased Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi. About three years prior to the occurrence, a complaint was lodged by the deceased Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi against the appellant/accused with regard to theft of jewels in her house. P.W.17, who was the Inspector of Police in the Thattaparai Police Station, on 22.11.2005, received the said complaint and registered the same in Crime No. 712 of 2005 under Sections 454 and 380 IPC. Initially, the appellant/accused herein was suspected for the offence, but after coming to know that he had not committed theft, he was left out. Then, after a period of about one year, P.W.17 arrested one Perumal belonging to Ganesapuram on 23.01.2006 and filed final report. After recovery of the jewels, there was enmity between the accused and P.W.1''s family.
On the fateful day, i.e. on 29.09.2006 at 01.30 p.m., the deceased Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi was attacked by the accused with aruval and due to the attack, she sustained grievous injuries and died on the spot. The daughter of the deceased Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi, by name Santhanamari was also attacked by the accused, due to which she sustained grievous injuries. On hearing the incident, P.Ws.1, 2 and 3 went to the scene of occurrence and thereafter, Santhanamari was taken to the Government Medical College and Hospital, Thoothukudi. There, she was treated by P.W.10-Dr.Somasundaram. On 29.09.2006 at 03.20 p.m., P.W.10 examined Santhanamari and found the following injuries:
1) Cut injury of scalp 10 cm x 1 cm.
2) Cut injury of back 10 cm x 1 cm.
3) Cut injury of right arm 10 cm x 1 cm.
4) Lacerated injury of right forearm.
5) Cut injury of right side of the abdomen 10 cm x 1 cm.
6) Cut injury of right upper arm.
7) Cut injury of upper chest.
8) Cut injury of size 6 x 2 cm in right thigh.
9) Cut injury of right foot 2 x 1 cm.
10) Cut injury of size 4 x 1 cm in right breast.
11) Cut injury in right upper abdomen of size 4 x 1 cm.
Ex.P8 is the Accident Register copy of Santhanamari.
Thereafter, P.W.10 sent an intimation to the Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Thoothukudi under Ex.P6 to record the dying declaration of Santhanamari. P.W.9- Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Thoothukudi received Ex.P6 on 29.09.2006 at 03.55 p.m. and immediately he went to the hospital at 4.00 p.m. to record the dying declaration. Before recording the dying declaration, the Doctor certified that Santhanamari was in a fit state of mind to give dying declaration. After recording the dying declaration, P.W.9 read the contents of the dying declaration to Santhanamari and obtained the left thumb impression of Santhanamari over it. Ex.P7 is the dying declaration of Santhanamari.
On the same day at 03.45 p.m., the deceased Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi was brought to the hospital and P.W.10 examined her and found her
dead. Ex.P11 is the Accident Register copy of the deceased Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi. In Ex.P11 it is stated that the patient was brought dead (alleged to have assaulted) and the body was sent to mortuary.
P.W.16-Pitchaiya was working as Head Constable in the Outpost Police Station of the Government Medical College and Hospital, Thoothukudi. On 29.09.2006, he received the death intimation of the deceased Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi and the intimation with regard to injuries sustained by Santhanamari and he informed the same to the Thattaparai Police Station. P.W.18 was the Sub- Inspector of Police In-charge of the Thattaparai Police Station at that time. On 29.09.2006, at 16.00 hours, on receipt of the information from the hospital about the death of the deceased Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi and the injuries sustained by Santhanamari, he went to the hospital and received the statement of Santhanamari.
Thereafter he came to the Thattaparai Police Station and registered the complaint in Crime No. 149 of 2006 under Sections 447, 307 and 302 IPC and prepared Ex.P23-First Information Report.
Thereafter the investigation was taken up by P.W.20-Inspector of Police. On 29.09.2006 he received the F.I.R. prepared by P.W.18 and at 20.00 hours, he went to the scene of occurrence and prepared Ex.P2-Observation Mahazar and Ex.P24-Rough Sketch. Thereafter he recovered M.O.4-Blood-stained cement scratches and M.O.5-Plain cement scratches under the cover of Ex.P3-Seizure Mahazar. On that day, at 10.00 p.m., he went to the Mortuary where the body of the deceased Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi was kept, and conducted inquest over the body of the deceased in the presence of Panchayatars and prepared Ex.P25-Inquest Report. Then the body was sent through P.W.14-Head Constable for conducting post mortem. The post mortem of the body of the deceased Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi was conducted by P.W.11-Dr. Selvamurugan on
30.09.2006. After conducting the post mortem, he issued Ex.P13-Post Mortem Certificate for Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi. In the Post Mortem Report, it is stated as under:
APPEARANCE FOUND AT THE POST MORTEM:
External appearance:
Well nourished body of a female, finger and toe nails - pale.
The following ante mortem injuries were noted:
A cut injury of size 2 x 1 x 1cm seen near left eye.
A horizontal gapping heavy cutting injury of size 10 x 2 cm x bone depth seen over occipital region, underlying occipital bone partly cut.
A horizontal gapping heavy cutting injury of size 5 x 1 x 1cm seen over left side of neck and lies 5cm below injury No. 2.
A oblique gapping heavy cutting injury of size 5 x 1 x 1cm seen over left side of neck and lies 5cm below injury No. 2.
A horizontal gapping heavy cutting injury of size 4 x 3 x 2cm seen over top of right shoulder, underlying muscles, tendons and right humerous found cut.
A cut injury of size 2 x 1 x 1cm seen over back of right elbow.
A horizontal gapping heavy cutting injury of size 11 x 3 x 4cm seen over right forearm, it cuts the underlying muscles, tendons, vessels and
bones. Right hand found hanging with a tag of skin.
A horizontal gapping heavy cutting injury of size 10 x 1 x 2cm seen over inner aspect of right palm, it cuts the right thumb from its pedicle and it hangs with a tag of skin.
A horizontal gapping heavy cutting injury of size 9 x 2 x 2cm seen over right palm, it cuts the underlying tendons, arteries and nerves.
A horizontal gapping cut injury of size 9 x 1 x 1cm seen over right 3rd finger.
An oblique gapping heavy cutting injury of size 8 x 2 x 2cm seen over right side of chest, it lies 2cm lateral to midline and 20 cms below right clavicle.
A horizontal gapping heavy cutting injury of size 5 x 3 x 1cm seen over outer aspect of upper part of right thigh.
An oblique gapping heavy cutting injury of size 13 x 3 x 4cm seen over left arm, it cuts the underlying muscles.
A cut injury of size 2 x 1 x 1cm seen in front of left shoulder.
A horizontal gapping heavy cutting injury of size 11 x 4cm x bone depth seen over left forearm, it cuts the underlying both bones with surrounding contusion. It lies 15cms below left elbow joint.
A horizontal gapping heavy cutting injury of size 7 x 4 x 4cm seen over left forearm, it lies 5cm below injury No. 15, it cuts the underlying muscles, tendons and bones.
A horizontal gapping heavy cutting injury of size 6 x 1 x 1cm seen over left side of back near left axilla.
A horizontal gapping heavy cutting injury of size 4 x 1 x 1cm seen over left side of back near midline.
A horizontal gapping heavy cutting injury of size 7 x 2 x 4cm seen over the middle of the back, it lies 15cms below root of the neck, it partly cuts the underlying thoracic vertebra.
A horizontal gapping heavy cutting injury of size 17 x 4 x 7cm seen over the middle of lower back, it lies 7cm below injury No. 19, it cuts the underlying muscles, lumbar vertebra, spinal cord, ribs, posterior attachment of diaphragm and spleen (7 x 2 x 1cm size). Through the rent in the diaphragm a part of stomach enters in to the left pleural cavity.
A vertical gapping heavy cutting injury of size 7 x2cm x cavity depth seen over lateral aspect of right side of chest, it cuts the underlying right 9th and 10th ribs at mid axillary line.
Internal appearance :
Heart : normal, coronaries - patent.
Lungs : right - collapsed, left - normal, c/s pale.
Hyoid bone : intact Stomach : contains 100 grams of partly digested cooked rice particles, nil specific smell, mucosa - pale.
Liver : normal, c/s - pale.
Spleen : cut injury present, c/s - pale.
Kidneys : normal, c/s - pale.
Small intestine : contains 50 grams of partly digested cooked rice particles, nil specific smell, mucosa - pale.
Bladder : empty.
Uterus : normal, laproscopic sterilization rings seen in both tubes.
Brain : normal, c/s - pale.
Death would have occurred 12 to 24 hours prior to autopsy.
OPINION:
The deceased would appear to have died of shock and haemorrhage due to heavy cutting injury to the back. Injury No. 20 is fatal in nature.
On 02.10.2006 at about 11.00 a.m., P.W.20 arrested the accused near the School for the Handicapped, situated at Pandarampatti Vilakku at Meelavittan Village in the presence of witnesses Chokkalingam and Murugan. The accused gave confession statement. Ex.P4 is the admissible portion of the confession statement of the accused. On the basis of the confession statement, P.W.20 recovered the M.Os.1 to 3-blood-stained bill hook, blood-stained full hand shirt and blood-stained lungi in the presence of same witnesses under the cover of Ex.P5-Seizure Mahazar. Then, he sent the accused and the material objects for judicial custody.
On 04.10.2006, at about 3.50 a.m., P.W.20 received the death intimation of Santhanamari from the hospital, under Ex.P22. P.W.20 went to the hospital and conducted inquest over the body of the deceased Santhanamari in the presence of Panchayatars and prepared Ex.P26-Inquest Report. Then he sent the body of the deceased Santhanamari through P.W.15-Head Constable Murugaiah through Ex.P27-Passport.
The post mortem of the body of Santhanamari was also conducted by P.W.11-Dr.Selvamurugan on 04.10.2006. After conducting the post mortem, he issued Ex.P15-Post Mortem Certificate for Santhanamari. In the Post Mortem Report, it is stated as under:
POST MORTEM APPEARANCE:
External appearance:
Well nourished body of a female. Finger and toe nails pale. Hospital bandage seen over right arm, forearm, right side of chest and abdomen and in
back. On removal of bandage sutured wounds seen in those areas.
The following ante mortem injuries are noted:
A horizontal sutured gapping heavy cutting injury of size 10 x 2cm x bone depth seen over frontal region, it partly cuts the underlying bone.
An oblique sutured gapping heavy cutting injury of size 8 x 2cm x bone depth seen over the outer aspect of right arm, underlying right humerous bone fractured with surrounding contusion.
An oblique sutured gapping heavy cutting injury of size 10 x 3 x 2cm seen over medial aspect of right arm 3cms below injury No. 2, it cuts the underlying muscles.
An oblique sutured gapping heavy cutting injury of size 11 x 3cm x bone depth seen over outer aspect of middle of right forearm, it cuts the underlying muscles and radius bone with surrounding contusion, intra medullary nailing present.
An oblique sutured gapping heavy cutting injury of size 4 x 2 x 2cm seen over right forearm, it lies 1 cm above injury No. 4.
An oblique sutured gapping heavy cutting injury of size 14 x 3 x 3cm seen over lower part of right forearm and right palm, it cuts the underlying muscles.
A vertical sutured gapping heavy cutting injury of size 6 x 2 x 1cm seen over inner aspect of lower part of right forearm.
An oblique sutured gapping heavy cutting injury of size 11 x 3 x 3cm seen over right breast.
An oblique sutured gapping heavy cutting injury of size 7 x 3 x 2cm seen over front of right side of chest 2cm lateral to midline and 16cm below supra sternal notch.
An oblique sutured gapping heavy cutting injury of size 8 x 3 x 3cm seen over right costal margin, it lies 11cm right lateral to midline.
A horizontal sutured gapping heavy cutting injury of size 16 x 4cm x cavity depth over right lower abdomen.
A surgical cut injury of size 2 x 1 x 1cm seen 2cm above injury No. 11, with flank drain insitu.
An oblique sutured gapping heavy cutting injury of size 9 x 3 x 2cm seen over back of middle of right thigh.
A cut injury of size 3 x 1 x 1cm seen over right foot.
15.A horizontal sutured gapping heavy cutting injury of size 16 x 2 x 2cm seen over upper part of middle of back.
A vertical surgical right para median sutured wound seen over the abdomen of length 24 cms. On removal of the sutures the peritoneal cavity contains about 300ml of yellow colour fowl smelling fluid and a suture of length 8cm seen over ceacum which is in line with injury No. 11.
Internal appearance:
Heart : normal, coronaries - patent.
Lungs : basal consolidation present in both lungs, c/s pale and edematous.
Hyoid bone : intact.
Stomach : contains 30ml of mucosal fluid, nil specific smell, mucosa - pale.
Liver, spleen, kidneys and brain: normal, c/s - pale.
Small intestine : contains 50ml of mucosal fluid, nil specific smell, mucosa - pale.
Bladder : empty.
Uterus : normal, c/s - empty.
OPINION:
THE DECEASED WOULD APPEAR TO HAVE DIED OF SHOCK DUE TO COMPLICATIONS OF
INJURY.
Injury No. 11 is fatal in nature.
Death would have occurred 6 to 12 hours prior to autopsy.
Thereafter, P.W.20 recorded the statements of witnesses, completed the investigation and filed charge sheet against the accused on 20.11.2006 under Sections 449 and 302 (2 counts) IPC.
Before the Trial Court, P.Ws.1 to 20 were examined and Exs.P1 to P28 and M.Os.1 to 8 were marked. On consideration of the evidence on record, the Trial Court convicted the accused u/s 449 IPC and sentenced to undergo 5 years R.I. and to pay a fine of Rs. 2,000/- in default to undergo 6 months R.I.; convicted the accused u/s 302 (2 counts) IPC and sentenced to undergo life imprisonment for each count and to pay a fine of Rs. 5,000/- for each count, in default to undergo 6 months R.I. for each count. The sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
Challenging the conviction and sentences imposed by the Trial Court, the present Criminal Appeal has been filed by the appellant/accused.
P.W.1 is the husband of the first victim Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi. P.Ws.4 and 7 are the son and daughter of the first victim. P.Ws.2 and 3 are relatives. The motive as projected and portrayed on the side of the prosecution is that there was a previous enmity between the accused and the family of the victims. About three years prior to the occurrence, a complaint was lodged by the first victim Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi against the appellant/accused with regard to theft of jewels in her house. P.W.17, who was the Inspector of Police in the Thattaparai Police Station registered the said complaint in Crime No. 712 of 2005 under Sections 454 and 380 IPC. Initially, the appellant/accused herein was suspected for the offence, but after coming to know that he had not committed theft, he was left out. So, due to the complaint lodged by the first victim against the accused, he had a grudge over her.
Another ground put forth on the side of the prosecution is that, on the fateful day, the accused was travelling in a bus along with the first victim and when the accused went to see his son in the hospital, she teased him. So, he became angry over that incident. To prove this, P.W.6-Rajathi, who knew both the first victim as well as the accused, has been examined. She turned hostile. She did not support the case of the prosecution.
Even the relatives of the deceased turned hostile. Evidence of P.Ws.1, 4 and 7 would show that the accused had a grievance against the first victim Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi. Therefore, it is clear that the accused had a motive to commit the offence of murder.
The prosecution relied on the evidence of P.Ws.1 to 6 to prove the case of murder. P.W.1 cannot be the eye-witness to the occurrence, because, only on hearing the noise, he came to the scene of occurrence and saw the accused running with a weapon. P.W.2 turned hostile. Even though she is the relative of the victim, she did not support the case of the prosecution. P.W.3, who is the husband of P.W.2, took the second victim-Santhanamari to the hospital. He has no enmity towards the accused. The motive projected by the prosecution has been clearly established by the evidence of P.Ws.4 and 7, the son and daughter of the first victim. The second victim was examined by P.W.10 at the earliest possibility, i.e. at 3.20 p.m. The occurrence took place at 01.30 p.m. When she was admitted to the hospital, she said to P.W.10-Doctor that she was assaulted by the accused by name Lakshmanan. This was proved by the evidence of P.W.10. So, the first declaration was given by the second victim to P.W.10 that the accused Lakshmanan assaulted her. Thereafter, P.W.10 sent an intimation to the Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Thoothukudi under Ex.P6 to record the dying declaration of the second victimSanthanamari. P.W.9-Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Thoothukudi received Ex.P6 on 29.09.2006 at 03.55 p.m. and immediately he went to the hospital at 4.00 p.m. to record the dying declaration. The quarters of the Judicial Magistrate, Court and the residence are all situated adjacent to the building of the hospital. So, immediately when the Judicial Magistrate received the message at 03.55 p.m., he rushed to the hospital at 4.00 p.m. itself and recorded the dying declaration of the second victim. P.W.10 certified that she was in a fit state of mind to give dying declaration. The learned Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Thoothukudi observed all the formalities and recorded the dying declaration of the second victim. In the dying declaration, the second victim had categorically stated that the accused attacked her and her mother with an aruval. Evidence of P.W.10 along with the dying declaration would go to show that the accused committed two murders.
There was no delay on the part of the Doctor to send the intimation to the Judicial Magistrate. The Judicial Magistrate also rushed to the hospital immediately and recorded the dying declaration of the second victim- Santhanamari.
Learned Counsel for the appellant/accused has submitted that the second victim was tutored to depose against the accused, because of previous enmity and a suggestion was not put to the witnesses about this aspect. We have perused the evidence on record carefully and meticulously and we find absolutely there is no evidence to show that the second victim was tutored. The occurrence took place at 01.30 p.m. The second victim was treated by the Doctor at 03.20 p.m. and at 4''O clock, the dying declaration was recorded. In the mean time, there is no acceptable evidence on record to show that the second victim was tutored. She clearly stated in the dying declaration the accused attacked her and her mother. So, the act committed by the accused has been clearly established.
At this juncture, the learned Counsel for the appellant/accused raised a doubt about the First Information Report. According to him, the early report was suppressed and P.W.1 gave a complaint to the Police earlier. In this case, on receipt of a message from the hospital, P.W.18 went to the hospital and received the statement of the second victim under Ex.P1. In the complaint, the second victim first spoke about the occurrence.
P.W.1 is a man from village and he was examined in chief on 18.02.2008. He was cross-examined on 17.04.2008 due to the boycott of the Court by the Advocates. Probably, the deposition of P.W.1 that he gave the complaint, may be due to lapse of memory. After the occurrence, it was immediately informed to the Police and F.I.R. had been registered after getting the statement from the second victim. Hence, the submission of the learned Counsel for the appellant/accused that the early report was suppressed, falls to the ground.
Learned Counsel for the appellant/accused has argued that the questions regarding incriminating circumstances were not put to the accused.
According to the counsel for the appellant, the blood-stained lungi which was recovered from the accused contained "B" Group blood and that point was not put to him during questioning u/s 313 Cr.P.C. It is true that the question regarding the blood stained lungi was not put to the accused.
For this, the counsel relied on the following decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court:
1) Shaikh Masood v. State of Maharashtra (2009) 3 Scc (Cri) 82 and
2) Ranvir Yadav v. State of Bihar (2009) 3 Scc (Cri) 92.
The object of examination of the accused u/s 313 Cr.P.C. has been dealt with in the above two judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court. The word "generally" in Sub-section (1)(b) does not limit the nature of the questioning to one or more questions of a general nature relating to the case, but it means that the question should relate to the whole case generally and should also be limited to any particular part or parts of it. The question must be framed in such a way as to enable the accused to know what he is to explain, what are the circumstances which are against him and for which an explanation is needed. The whole object of the section is to afford the accused a fair and proper opportunity of explaining circumstances which appear against him.
In a Full Bench decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, in the case of Jai Dev Vs. The State of Punjab, , the nature of examination of accused, has been pointed out. The ultimate test in determining whether or not the accused has been fairly examined u/s 342 of Criminal P.C.
(1898) would be to enquire whether, having regard to all the questions put to him, he did get an opportunity to say what he wanted to say in respect of prosecution case against him. As per this decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the accused must be in a position to explain about the questions put to him. In the present case, during the examination of the accused u/s 313 Cr.P.C., Question Nos. 4, 5 and 6 relates to the offence committed by the accused. In the fifth question, the accused was asked to reply as to the evidence of P.W.10-the Doctor, that the second victim informed the Doctor that she and her mother were cut by the accused. For this, the accused replied that it is a false evidence. Question No. 6 was put to the accused that on 29.09.2006, at about 4.00 p.m., the Judicial Magistrate recorded the dying declaration of the second victim- Santhanamari. For this, the accused replied that he was not aware of it. So, questions were put to the accused about the dying declaration, by the Judicial Magistrate. The Judicial Magistrate is a neutral person. He has no grievance against the accused. On receipt of the message from the hospital, he immediately rushed to the hospital to record the dying declaration within a few minutes. So, in the above view of the matter, it is clear that questions were put to the accused with regard to incriminating circumstances, for which he said that he was not aware it. So, it is clear that questions regarding incriminating circumstances were put to the accused, but he did not avail it.
In the case of Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra 1973 Scc (Cri) 1033, the Hon'ble Supreme Court had pointed out that it is trite law, nevertheless fundamental, that the prisoner's attention should be drawn to every inculpatory material so as to enable him to explain it. This is the basic fairness of a criminal trial and failures in this area may gravely imperil the validity of the trial itself, if consequential miscarriage of justice has flowed. However, where such an omission has occurred, it does not ipso facto vitiate the proceedings and prejudice occasioned by such defect must be established by the accused. In the event of evidentiary material not being put to the accused, the Court must ordinarily eschew such material from consideration. It is also open to the appellate Court to call upon the counsel for the accused to show what explanation the accused has as regards the circumstances established against him but not put to him and if the accused is unable to offer the appellate Court any plausible or reasonable explanation of such circumstances, the Court may assume that no acceptable answer exists and that even if the accused had been questioned at the proper time in the trial Court, he would not have been able to furnish any good ground to get out of the circumstances on which the trial Court had relied for its conviction.
In the present case, questions were put to the accused, but no satisfactory explanation was given by the accused. The accused himself expressed that he was not aware of the dying declaration. So, it cannot be said that prejudice has been caused to the accused.
At this juncture, the learned Counsel for the appellant/accused relied on a decision of this Court in the case of Mohd. Fazluddin v. State
(2007) 1 MLJ (Crl) 810, and argued that it is a case of sustained provocation and that the confession statement of the accused should be taken into consideration. He further submitted that on an earlier occasion, when the accused and the first victim were travelling in a bus, the first victim teased the accused when he went to see his son in the hospital and therefore, there was sustained provocation existed on the part of the accused.
Relying on the above decision of this Court, the counsel stated that the confession statement of the accused must be taken into consideration. Here, the important point that should be noted is regarding the attack of the accused on the second victim-Santhanamari, who is the daughter of the first victim-Gunaseeli @ Kamatchi. There is no sustained provocation as against the second victim. The attack of the accused on the second victim would go to show that he had intention to murder and therefore, he committed the offence of murder. It should also be taken into consideration that the first victim sustained 21 injuries and the second victim sustained 16 injuries. If it was a sustained provocation, there should be no reason for the accused to murder the second victim, but he murdered her in a brutal manner and the same has been proved by the injuries sustained by her.
So, there is no sustained provocation on the part of the accused and the theory of sustained provocation is not applicable to this case. Further, it is clear from the evidence on record that the accused had grudge over the victims and there is motive for committing the offence of murder. Further, it is clear from the evidence on record that he entered the house of the victims and murdered them.
In view of all the reasons stated supra and on a careful analysis, scanning and scrutiny of the evidence on record, this Court is of the considered opinion that the accused had committed the offence of murder and the prosecution has proved the case beyond reasonable doubt.
Under the circumstances, the conviction and sentences imposed on the accused are liable to be confirmed.
In the result, the conviction and sentences imposed on the accused by the Principal Sessions Judge, Thoothukudi vide judgment dated 15.10.2008 made in S.C. No. 167/2007, are confirmed and the Criminal Appeal stands dismissed.
