High CourtsDivision Bench(2016) 03 AHC CK 0011

Krishna Singh vs State

Allahabad High Court · Decided on 14 March 2016

RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Criminal Appeal No. 2390 of 1986

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

31 paragraphs · 3,008 words

Arvind Kumar Tripathi, J.—1. Mr. Umesh Vats, learned Advocate, appeared on behalf of appellant and Mr. Mahendra Singh Yadav, learned AGA appeared on behalf of State.

2.

We have heard learned counsel for the parties and judgment was reserved on 10.2.2016.

3.

The instant criminal appeal has been preferred against the judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 2.9.1986 passed by IInd Additional Sessions Judge, Deoria, in S.T. No. 307 of 1983, arising out of case crime No. 66/83, State v. Vijai @ Vijai Pratap Singh S/o Shri Krishna Singh and Shri Krishna Singh S/o Madhu Singh both resident of Village Parari Banmali, P.S. Khukhundoo, District Deoria, convicting and sentencing for life imprisonment, under section 302 IPC, P.S. Bhatni, District Deoria.

4.

The prosecution case in brief is that first information report was lodged with the police station Bhatni, District Deoria on 29.8.1983 by the informant Haribansh Singh S/o Ram Jatan Singh R/o Village Padari Banmali, P.S. Khukhundoo, District Deoria. The date of occurrence is 29.8.1983. As per first information report on 29.8.1983 the informant along-with cousin Udai Pratap Singh and co-villagers Shyam Sunder Singh, Raj Nath Singh and Nagendra Singh R/o village Deekali Jai Ram, P.S. Madanpur, District Deoria, was returning to home from Bhatni Bazar after purchasing certain goods at about 7.15 P.M. as soon as he reached near the village Sahopar Tola, Lehtoli accused Shri Krishna Singh S/o Madhu Singh and his son Vijai Singh, who were present in ambush and due to old enmity to take revenge with regard to the land at the instigation of accused Vijai Singh, Shri Krishna Singh, who was armed with gun, shot fire, at his cousin Udai Pratap Singh and he died on the spot. They raised alarm on which several persons from nearby places rushed to the place of occurrence and they saw and identified the assailants but due to fear none of them chased them. Leaving the dead body on the spot the informant went at the police station and submitted written report Exhibit Ka-1, on which basis chick FIR Exhibit Ka-7 was prepared and registered at case crime No. 66/83, under section 302 IPC at police station Bhatni and its corresponding, G.D. Entry was also made. The FIR was registered on the same day i.e. 29.8.1983 at 19.45 under section 302 IPC. The Sub Inspector Shamsher Singh, P.W. 3, who was present at police station at the time of lodging of the first information report took investigation and started investigation of the case. He reached on the spot along-with necessary police force and relevant papers on a bicycle. The distance in between the place of incident and police station was about 2 km. He found the dead body of Udai Pratap Singh on the pool of blood, on the road, going from Bhatni Bazar to Pharathua crossing and thereafter to Deoria Salempur road. The number of persons were present on the spot. After he got lantern panchayatnama was got prepared and the dead body was sealed and necessary papers were prepared, which are Exhibit Ka-9 to Exhibit Ka-16. Thereafter sealed corpse was handed over to Constable Chhabinath Gupta and Sarvadanand Pandey to handover for postmortem examination and the same was taken in a Riksha. The necessary papers were sent with the dead body. On spot he found two pieces of towel on the dead body and after taking them into custody he prepared recovery memo Exhibit Ka-3. He also found five empty cartridges of 12 bore on the spot near the dead body at a distance of about 3 steps. He took the cartridges into custody, prepared recovery memo Exhibit Ka-4, thereafter, he recorded the statement of witnesses Haribansh Singh, Rajnath Singh claiming to be eye witness, Bal Kishun, Ramayan, Ram Briksh, Ram Shanker and Ram Nagina witnesses of inquest. The Investigating Officer also inspected the torch of the informant Haribansh, which was in working order. After preparing the recovery memo the same was handed over to witness Haribansh. The torch is material Ext.-I. On the next day after recording statement and completing necessary formalities since it was 23.45 hours in the night finished the investigation and closed the parcha. On the next day he inspected the site in presence of informant and other witnesses and prepared the site plan at about 6.15 A.M. He collected sample of blood stained and plain soil, prepared memo Ext. Ka-5 and sealed the same in two separate containers, material Exts. 4th and 5th. Recorded the statement of two eye witnesses namely Nagendra Singh and Shyam Sunder Singh. He also inspected the torch of witnesses Shyam Sunder and after preparing recovery memo Ext. Ka-6 he returned the same to him.

5.

The postmortem examination was conducted on 30.8.1983 at 12.30 P.M. by doctor R.P. Singh, the then Medical Officer, T.B. Clinic, District Hospital Deoria and he noted following anti mortem injuries

"(I) Gun shot lacerated wound of entry 8 cm x 7 cm x cavity deep over left side of head including forehead. Left eye absent. Part of left frontal and parietal bone blown off. Blackening and scorching present around the wound.

(II) Multiple gun shot wounds of entry in an area of 28 cms x 27 cms x skin deep on the anterior, medial and lateral aspects of left thigh. No blackening or scorching.

(III) Multiple gun shot lacerated wounds of entry in an area of 29 cms x 20 cms x skin deep on the anterior and medial aspects of right thigh. No blackening or scorching.

(IV) Lacerated gun shot wound of entry 8 cm x 5 cm x bone deep on the dorsum of right hand. Blackening and scorching present.

(V) Gun shot lacerated wound of entry 6 cms x 5 cms x cavity deep on the left upper gluteal region 5 cms behind the anterior superior illiac spine. Blackening present.

(VI) Gun shot lacerated wound of exit 7 cms x 6.5. cms x cavity deep on the right lateral abdomen 25 cms below the right nipple. No scorching.

(VII) Lacerated wound 7 cms x 3 cms x bone deep on the right parietal region, 6 cms above tragus of right ear.

On internal examination it was found that-

Head: Part of frontal bone on the left side blown off with fracture of parietal bone

Membrances: lacerated and congested

Brain: Congested and lacerated-- 11 metallic pellets and 1 wad recovered from the brain tissue.

Abdomen: Perineum congested and lacerated; in the cavity there was 300 ml. of free and clotted blood.

Stomach: contained semi digested food about 200 gms. Food particles could not be deciphered."

According to opinion of the doctor the cause of death was due to shock and haemorrhage as a result of ante-mortem injuries.

6.

The accused Vijay Singh was arrested, however, accused Shri Krishna Singh surrendered himself in the court on 6.9.1983 after proceeding was initiated under section 82/83 Cr.P.C. After completing necessary formalities charge-sheet was submitted. Charges were framed on 11.10.1984 under section 302 IPC and the charge was read over and explained. Accused appellant denied the charge and pleaded to be tried.

7.

The prosecution in support of its case examined as many as 13 witnesses P.W. 1 Haribansh Singh, informant, eye witness P.W. 2 Rajnath Singh, P.W. 3 Sham Sher Singh (Investigating Officer), P.W. 4 R.P. Singh, who conducted postmortem examination, P.W. 5 Constable Sarvada Nath Pandey, who carried the dead body to mortuary for postmortem, P.W. 6 Head Constable Birjoo Singh, who deposited gun in Malkhana, P.W. 7 Constable Chhiteshwar Rai, who took gun from malkhana to handover the same to ballistic expert, P.W. 8 Mr. Om Prakash Mani Tripathi ballistic expert, U.P. Govt., Lucknow, P.W. 9 Head Constable Raj Narain Singh, who prepared chick FIR and made G.D. entry, P.W. 10 Constable Deen Bandhoo, who carried S.B.B.L. gun from Police Station Salempur Malkhana to Sadar Malkhana and deposited in Sadar Malkhana, P.W. 11 Ram Lagan Dubey, S. I., who went for search of accused on direction of Station Officer and went on 30.8.1983 for collecting sample of blood stained, soil (earth), recovered five empty cartridges of 12 bore, blood stained "Gamachha" in presence of Station Officer, P.W. 12 Constable Ram Surat Pandey, who took total 7 bundle in all of this case from police station Bhatni to Sadar Malkhana, P.W. 13 Sheo Murti Singh, Station House Officer, who arrested accused Vijay in the night of 29/30.8.1983 and from his possession recovered S.B.B.L. gun and one empty cartridges in the barrel and two live cartridges.

8.

After evidence was closed by the prosecution the statement of accused appellant was recorded under section 313 Cr.P.C. Both of the accused pleaded not guilty and stated that they were falsely implicated due to enmity. Accused Shri Krishna Singh further stated that at the time of occurrence he was on duty in Bhatpar in connection with petroleum duty. His petroleum duty was in Hydle department and was living along-with family in rented house in Salempur and in his absence Station Officer of Police Station Bhatni had taken into custody the licensed gun along-with the license from his quarter and arrested his son Vijay. The accused appellant stated that the gun was taken from the house of Vyas Lohar. He was sleeping with Vyas Ji, who was landlord. After arresting him police beaten him and forcibly entered into his house and taken away gun, some money and other households items.

9.

In defence one witness Gauri Shanker Pandey was examined as D.W. 1. He stated on oath that his house was situated in village Ichauna bazar. He fully knows Vyas Lohar, whose house was situated at a distance of 10 yards from his house and Salempur Railway Station. The railway godown was situated at distance of 50 yards from the house of Vyas Lohar. According to him accused was also well known to him. Shri Krishna Singh was posted at the electricity department and accused Vijay was tenant in the house of Vyas Lohar. Further according to him three years ago some police officials raided the house of Vyas Lohar and taken out the gun of Shri Krishna Singh. The accused Vijay Singh, who was sleeping in the house was also arrested and he was also taken with him to police station. Some documentary evidence Ext. Kha-1 to 13 were also filed.

10.

Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that there is no motive for committing the offence and even if there was any motive there that was weak motive. Since there was a litigation hence he was falsely implicated. The witnesses are partisan and interested witnesses and there is no independent witness to support the prosecution story. No independent witness of the vicinity were examined. The gun was returned by the ballistic expert as there was no proper seal and thereafter it was sent again after one month and presence of witnesses is doubtful. There were allegation of five fire but recovery of only 15 pellets from the body shows that there might have been only 2-3 fires hence no one has seen the incident. He further submitted that on the same evidence co-accused Vijay son of the appellant was acquitted.

11.

Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that in view of the fact it is clear that prosecution failed to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt. Since prosecution story is doubtful and prosecution failed to prove guilty beyond doubt and as such impugned judgment of conviction and sentence is liable to be set aside.

12.

Learned AGA vehemently opposed the prayer and submitted that even if the witnesses are relative or interested it is well settled that they have not to be disbelieved rather their statement has to be examined cautiously and further there is no reason to spare real culprit and implicate appellant or any innocent person. As far as the return of the gun is concerned, there is no evidence to show that there was any tempering with the gun rather it was not properly sealed though from the sealed it could have not been taken out but only on technical ground it was returned and subsequently after proper sealed, the same was again sent to the ballistic expert. The presence of witnesses is not doubtful and their presence are natural. Statement of both the witnesses are intact. There are no material contradiction to disbelieve their statement. If the benefit of doubt has gone to co-accused Vijay it cannot be said that the trial court disbelieved the statement of witnesses because the role of exhortation was assigned to co-accused Vijay Singh son of appellant Shri Krishna but specific role of firing has been assigned to Shri Krishna Singh, who shot five fires at deceased Udai Pratap Singh 15 pillets were recovered from the body. Since there is no scanning and x-ray of entire body and as such their might have been possibility of more pellets in the body of the deceased. There was no reason of false implication. There is a prompt FIR. The incident took place at 7.15 P.M. and FIR was lodged and registered at 7.45 P.M. The distance of police station was about 2 km. from the place of occurrence. The first information report was lodged by Haribansh Singh, who is eye witness account. Hence in view of the fact, since prosecution proved the case beyond reasonable doubt and as such present appeal being devoid of merit is liable to be dismissed.

13.

Considered the submission of learned counsel for the parties and perused the records. According to counsel for the appellant there was no motive to commit offence but according to prosecution case there was a dispute in respect of land hence due to land dispute there was old enmity in between the parties. Apart from that when there are eye witnesses of the incident then motive is not so important. As far as the argument that there are no independent witnesses is concerned, there are eye witnesses and merely on the ground that they are interested and relative, their testimony has not to be discarded. It is well settled that the evidence of relative and interested witnesses are required to be examined carefully and cautiously and further there is no reason to spare the actual culprit and implicate the other person falsely because if the witnesses are related and interested, at least they will not spare real culprit. Hence statement of witnesses has not to be disbelieved merely on the ground that they are related witnesses. The only things is required that their statements has to be examined carefully and if eye witnesses account found trustworthy and reliable, then on the basis of their evidence conviction and sentence can be awarded and the accused can be convicted. In case of , 2006 (4) SCC 512 State of A.P. v. S. Rayappa and others it was held by the Hon'ble Apex Court "testimony of a witness otherwise inspiring confidence cannot be discarded on the ground that he being a relation of the deceased is an interested witness. A close relative who is a very natural witness cannot be termed as an interested witness. The term interested postulates that the person concerned must have some direct interest in seeing the accused person being convicted somehow or the other either because of animosity or some other reasons.

On the contrary it has now almost become a fashion that the public is reluctant to appear and depose before the Court especially in criminal case because of varied reasons."

14.

Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that gun was returned by the ballistic expert but it was returned only due to technical ground that it was not properly sealed and from evidence it is clear that without breaking the seal gun could not be taken out and no tempering was possible and after proper seal the same was sent again. It was found that fire was from the same gun. The allegation is of five fire. Whether all the pellets hit and entered in the body or not there is no such allegation or evidence, however, 15 pellets were recovered from the body of the deceased. Admittedly there was no scanning of the entire body so even otherwise possibility of some more pellets in the body cannot be ruled out. The scanning and x-ray of the entire body was not conducted. Further had there been any intention to falsely implicate then other son of appellant might have also been implicated in the present case along-with accused appellant. The accused appellant was absconding and proceeding was initiated under section 82/83 Cr.P.C. for attachment of the immovable property. There were five gun shot lacerated wound of entries, one gun shot lacerated wound of exist and lacerated wound 7 cm. x 3 cm bone deep on the right parietal region, 6 cm above tragus of right ear. Left eye was found absent and part of left and parietal bone blown off. The presence of witnesses are not doubtful. It is not unnatural that informant was going along-with deceased and P.W. 2 Rajnath Singh also accompanied them, who was returning from market after purchasing certain goods. P.W. 1, informant, and eye witness account P.W. 2 both have supported the prosecution case without any contradiction barring few minor contradictions. Hence prosecution succeeded to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt and this argument that witnesses were not present and no one has seen the incident is against the evidence on record.

15.

As far as the acquittal of co-accused Vijay @ Vijay Pratap Singh is concerned, the role of exhortation was assigned to him and trial court found that his involvement was doubtful hence appellant, who is a main shooter is not entitled to get the same benefit. Since appellant was rightly held guilty by the trial court and minimum punishment has been awarded under section 302 Cr.P.C. hence it is not a fit case for interference in the impugned judgment of conviction and sentence.

16.

In view of the above noted discussion, the appeal lacks merit, accordingly, the same is hereby dismissed.