AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
The present complaint has been filed in Form-M under Section 31 of the Real Estate (Regulation & Development) Act, 2016 read with Rule 33 (1) of the NCT of Delhi of Real Estate (Regulation & Development) (General) Rules, 2016 by Sh. Krishna Moorthy Madhur, (hereinafter called as ‘complainant’) against M/s A.J.N. Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. (hereinafter called as ‘respondent’) with the allegation that the complainant was falsely informed by the respondent about the Land Pooling Policy and the project therein and respondent has obtained the booking amount by misrepresentation. The complainant prayed for refund of the amount deposited by him with interest with respondent.
The brief facts of the case are that in the year 2015, the respondent had launched a Project, namely, Urban Greek – a project of Antriksh Engicon Pvt. Limited (hereinafter referred as a Project) alleged to be located in L-Zone, Dwarka, New Delhi. It is mentioned in the complaint that the Complainant had booked four residential units – E-501, E-502, E-601 & E-602 and paid a sum of Rs.69,54,228/- for the above said bookings. It is alleged that a dispute arises due to non-execution of the Project by the respondent and after persuasion, the amount related to two flats of By Back Scheme were settled and the present complaint he has filed only for refund of the amount paid to the booking of Construction Linked Plan (CLP) as the respondents are not refunding the amount despite the fact that the Land Pooling Policy (LPP) scheme of the DDA has not been commenced yet and, therefore, there is no chance of getting the flat in near future.
Notices were issued to the Respondent on 13.11.2019 and a reply was filed by the respondent on 03.03.2020. The complainant also filed rejoinder dated 26.08.2020. The respondent denying the allegation stated that since the Project was launched before the commencement of the Real Estate (Regulation & Development) Act, 2016 and, therefore, the Act is not operative for registration of the Project and further submitted that the complainant is ill inspired and trying to extort money from the respondents. It was submitted by the respondent that they intended to develop the Project but could not get the land transfer certificate which is a pre-requisite for developing the Project and, hence, he has given option to the investors (Complainant) to either await the clearance or opt for the refund. It is further submitted in the reply that out of Rs.69,54,228/- deposited by the complainant at the time of booking of four flats, a sum of Rs.52,34,496/- has been refunded to him and only a balance of Rs.17,19,732/- is pending with the respondent and which he is willing to refund. The respondents in their reply dated 03.03.2020 which is duly supported with an affidavit of Sh. Rahul Prashar, Authorized Representative of the Company further stated in paragraph (f) at page-7 (internal page of their reply) while denying the allegations of the depositing the amount with the respondents submitted that a total amount paid by the complainant is Rs.33,44,000/- (inclusive of Service Tax). Therefore, it is clearly admitted by the respondents that a sum of Rs.33,44,000/- is pending with the respondents. In the rejoinder filed by the respondent, it is confirmed that a sum of Rs.33,44,000/- is only pending under Construction Linked Plan (CLP). The complainant also relied upon letter dated 15.12.2017 where the respondent mentioned that if the complainant is interested to withdraw from the CLP any time within three years of booking, he can withdraw and he will be paid interest of 6.99% per annum from the date of booking. In the pleadings, nowhere the respondent has denied the fact that they have not received amount. Moreover, they have admitted that they are willing to refund the balance amount.
Respondents also submitted that a negotiation took place between the parties and as per negotiation Rs.52,34,000/- was refunded to the complainant. However, no details regarding the balance amount has been mentioned.
The Authority while hearing the case on 01.09.2020 due to confusion arises regarding the payment and the balance amount directed the parties to provide complete/full information regarding the details of the amount paid and the amount of refund was sought. However, in pursuance to the directions, the complaint filed submissions dated 21.11.2020 and while giving the details regarding particulars of Buy-Back scheme and Construction Linked Plan in paragraph-8 submitted that in the present complaint he is seeking only refund of the amount of the Construction Linked Plan for the two flats and mentioned that an outstanding amount of Rs.33,44,000/- is only payable by the respondents as the flats were not delivered to him. The complainant also annexed the details of Flat No. E-502 and Flat No. E-602 of CLP plan and also details of payment of Rs.33,44,000/-.
Considering the above submissions of the parties, a short issued involved for consideration is regarding the refund claimed under the Construction Linked Plan only as the issues regarding BB flat scheme has been settled by them self.
We heard Counsel for the parties on 01.04.2021 and reserved the orders. The parties were given liberty to file written arguments within a period of one week but the record shows that nothing has been filed by the parties.
We have considered the submission made by the Counsel for the parties and gone through the pleadings filed in this case.
The contention of respondent that the project was launched before commencement of the Real Estate (regulation & Development) Act, 2016 and therefore it does not required registration is rejected as firstly the issue of registration is not under consideration in this complaint and even if it is considered the respondent has not filed any completion certificate of the project and the project could not be started yet as per their pleadings.
Now, a very short question for consideration is the refund of the amount paid to the respondents for the Construction Linked Plan. It is an admitted case of the respondents that the complainant has paid the amount of Rs.33,44,000/-. The relevant paragraph of the reply of respondent dated 03.03.2020 is as under:
“(s)That the contents of the paragraph (s) are false and hence denied. It is submitted that the total amount paid by the complainant is Rs.33,44,000/-(inclusive of Service Tax).This clearly shows the malafide intention of the complainant and misleading the Hon’ble Tribunal thereby causing of prejudice against the respondent for personal benefit and to extort money. That the contents of para under reply are nothing more and fragments of complainant’s fertile imagination and the devoid of all the merits and do not inspire any confidence.”
On the other hand, the complainant has also admitted the same amount. In his submission dated 21.11.2020, the relevant paragraph of the submission is as under :
“(8)That it is submitted that complainant had made payments for two flats in B.B. scheme and two flats in CLP scheme, out of which present complaint related only to CLP. Complainant has despite his financial loss of interest income of one year settled the issue and seek remedy in case of booking under CLP, in which the respondents owes the complainant an outstanding sum of Rs.33,44,000/- only alongwith a rate of interest 6.99% p.a. from the date of booking assured by respondent vide their letter dt.15.10.2017 (Annexure-4) and against which neither delivered the flat nor refund along with lawful interest was made till date. It is further submitted that respondents are well aware of this fact that yet they are repeatedly trying to force above stated ground in order to create confusion just like they did in case of Land Pooling Policy, which despite their several claims was not in operation till the time (Annexure-5).
The averments made in the above pleadings shows the admitted amount.
Section 12 of the Real Estate (Regulation & Development) Act, 2016 is as under:
-“12. Obligations of promoter regarding veracity of the advertisement or prospectus.—
Where any person makes an advance or a deposit on the basis of the information contained in the notice, advertisement or prospectus, or on the basis of any model apartment, plot or building, as the case may be, and sustains any loss or damage by reason of any incorrect, false statement included therein, he shall be compensated by the promoter in the manner as provided under this Act:
Provided that if the person affected by such incorrect, false statement contained in the notice, advertisement or prospectus, or the model apartment, plot or building as the case may be, intends to withdraw from the proposed project, he shall be returned his entire investment along with interest at such rate as may be prescribed and the compensation in the manner provided under this Act.”
The above section very well clarify that any person who make an advance or a deposit on the basis of information sustain any loss, he shall be compensated. The proviso to the Section specifically says that a person who is affected by such false statement or advertisement and intend to withdraw from the Project shall be returned with his entire investment along with interest. In the above proviso the word ‘investment’ has been used which means an amount even if it is not a booking amount shall be liable to be refunded on the discretion of the person who has invested money in the proposed Project if the project is not started.
In view of the facts that above amounts are paid by the complainant to the respondents in view of the Construction Linked Plan and the Project could not be commenced. The respondents are duty bound to return the invested amount of the complainant deposited for a Project completely in the dreams only. The Real Estate (Regulation & Development) Act, 2016 which has been promulgated to watch the interest of the allottees and Section 12 of the Act also give provisions that where a person has deposited the amount with any promoter in view of any advertisement or the promise made for any real estate project, the promoter is duty bound to return the deposited amount to the allottees. Since it is admitted case of the parties and even the respondent has shown their willingness to refund the amount, we have no hesitation in holding that the amount should be returned by the promoter to the complainant.
In view of the above, we direct that a sum of Rs.33,44,000/- (Rupees Thirty Three Lac Forty Four Thousand only) admitted amount between the parties should be returned by the respondents to the complainant within a period of 45 days from the date of this order with an interest of 9.3% (7.3 % MCLR + 2%) as applicable under the provisions of the Real Estate (Regulation & Development) Act, 2016.
Ordered accordingly.
