AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Rakesh Mohan Pandey, J
The appellant/claimant has filed this appeal for enhancement of compensation assailing award passed by the learned 1st Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Jagdalpur, District Bastar in Claim Case No. 238/2019 dated 28.08.2021, whereby the learned Tribunal has passed an award to the tune of Rs. 56,232/- with interest at the rate of 9% per anum on account of injuries sustained by the appellant/claimant.
The facts in brief are that on 16.01.2016 at about 11: 00 am while claimant was returning from Police Line, Jagdalpur to his home, the driver of the offending car bearing registration No. CG 17 KH 7837 by driving it rashly and negligently dashed him, consequently, he sustained injuries including fracture of left femur bone and and hip bone. The claimant underwent surgery and remained hospitalized for considerable period. The claimant also suffered permanent disability to the extent of 53%, but the learned Tribunal assessed functional disability 17%-18%. Respondent No. 1 as well as Insurance Company filed reply to claim petition and denied averments. The learned Tribunal framed issues; parties led evidence, and thereafter, award was passed.
Mr. Ramsajiwan, Advocate would argue that the learned Tribunal has not granted compensation for loss of income. He would further contend that on conventional heads, the learned Tribunal has awarded meager amount. It is also contended that on the head of conveyance, loss of amenities and future medical expenses, the learned Tribunal has not awarded compensation. He would pray to enhance the compensation.
On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for the respondents would oppose. They would submit that at the time of accident, claimant was working to the post of Constable, and thereafter, he was promoted to the post of Hawaldar, and thus, there was no loss of income. With regard to grant of compensation on conventional heads, they would submit that the learned Tribunal has granted just and proper compensation and appeal deserves to be dismissed.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record with utmost circumspection.
Admittedly, at the time of accident, claimant was working to the post of Constable in the Police department, and thereafter, he was promoted to the post of Hawaldar, thus, the finding recorded by the learned Tribunal that there was no loss of income appears to be proper. The learned Tribunal has granted a sum of Rs. 16,232/- against the medical bills submitted by the claimant and there is no reason to interfere with such finding. The learned Tribunal has awarded a total sum of Rs. 40,000/- for pain & suffering, attendant and special diet and said figure is not proper in opinion of this Court. Further, the learned Tribunal has not awarded compensation for loss of amenities, future medical expenses and conveyance. Thus, the compensation requires reconsideration.
According to disability certificate Ex. P/38, there was fracture of hip bone and extent of disability was 53% according to the medical board. Dr. Lakhan Thakur(AW/2) has proved the disability certificate. The learned Tribunal assessed functional disability 17%-18% as there was fracture of hip bone. Certainly the claimant would have suffered pain for considerable period and the amount awarded by the learned Tribunal on that head requires modification. According to the medical documents placed on record by the claimant, after surgery he remained hospitalized from 16.01.2016 to 24.02.2016, and thereafter, from 01.05.2016 to 16.05.2016 and he would have rested for 1-2 months; therefore, the compensation granted by the learned Tribunal for special diet and attendant also requires reconsideration.
Taking into consideration the above discussed facts, compensation is being revisited herein-below:-
Sr.
Heads
Compensation
Compensation
No.
awarded by Tribunal
awarded by this
Court
1.
Medical Bills
Rs. 16,232/-
Rs. 16,232/-
2.
Pain and suffering
Rs. 30,000/-
Rs. 40,000/-
3.
Attendant
Rs. 30,000/-
4.
Special Diet
Rs. 10,000/-
5.
Conveyance
NIL
Rs. 10,000/-
6.
Loss of amenities
NIL
Rs. 20,000/-
7.
Future
Medical
NIL
Rs. 20,000/-
expenses
TOTAL
Rs. 56,232/-
Rs. 1,36,232/-
For the forgoing reasons, the appeal is allowed in part. The amount of compensation of Rs. 56,232/- awarded by the tribunal is enhanced to Rs. 1,36,232/-. Hence, after deducting the amount of Rs. 56,232/-, the appellant/claimant is held entitled for an additional amount of Rs. 80,000/- with interest at the rate of 9%. The Insurance Company is directed to deposit the amount of compensation as enhanced by this Court within a period of 60 days from the date of receipt of copy of this order. Rest of the conditions of impugned award shall remain intact.
Accordingly, the instant appeal is hereby partly allowed.
