Tribunals and CommissionsFull Bench(2024) 08 NCLAT CK 1407

Krishna Infosolutions Pvt. Ltd vs Anil Anchalia & Ors.

National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi · Decided on 22 August 2024

CASE NUMBER
Comp. App. (AT) (Ins) No. 279 of 2024

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

32 paragraphs · 2,418 words

Per: Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain

The Appellant filed an application under Section 60(5) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (in short ‘Code’) bearing I.A. No. 288 of 2022 before the Adjudicating Authority (National Company Law Tribunal, Kolkata Bench – II) in which the following prayers were made:-

“a. Direct the Respondent No. 1/Erstwhile Resolution Professional to hand over the entire business and all assets along with the management and control of the Corporate Debtor to the Successful Resolution Applicant including allowing the Successful Resolution Applicant to operate all the bank accounts of the Corporate Debtor independently;

b. Restrain the Respondents to make such undue alleged demand of Rs. 25.96 Lakh i.e., difference in amount payable and paid to the UCO Bank (dissenting financial creditor) at the time of upfront payment made by the Applicant/ SRA on 15/12/2021;

c. Compensate the Applicant for all legal expenses incurred on account of persuading this present application seeking direction/ intervention from this Adjudicating Authority for the smooth implementation of the approved resolution plan; and

d. Any other direction may deem fit and proper.”

2.

The Appellant is aggrieved against the order dated 20.12.2023 passed by the Adjudicating Authority in respect of prayer (b) which read as under:-

“In regard to the surplus amount of Rs. 25.96 lakh, the CoC of the CD shall address the issue pragmatically before its table and shall take a holistic view in accordance with law.”

3.

Briefly put, the resolution plan of the Appellant was approved by the CoC on 23.02.2021 with 81.14% voting share and was dissented by UCO Bank with 18.86% voting share.

4.

Clause 8.3 of the resolution plan lays down the proposal of the payment to the creditors. Clause 8.3 is reproduced as under:-

8.3

The Resolution Applicant proposes to pay to all the creditors of the CD (Operational Creditors including statutory Dues and Financial Creditors including dissenting financial creditors, if any. The RA proposes to pay an amount of Rs 515.00 lakhs to the different creditors of the CD in the following manner:

a. The Insolvency Resolution Process Cost of Rs 65.00 lakhs will be paid upfront in priority to any other creditor of the Corporate Debtor. Further, as agreed by the COC, the same shall be met with the internal accrual of the CD and PRA shall not infuse any fund for the same.

b. The Financial Creditor including dissenting financial creditors, if any, and other creditors are proposed to be resolved in the following manner:

i.

Entire admitted dues of Allahabad Bank (now known as Indian Bank) for Rs. 70,05,23,413/- (Rupees Seventy Crores Five Lakhs Twenty Three Thousands Four Hundred Thirteen only) will be settled on full and final basis by payment of Rs. 20131166/- (Rupees Two Crore One Lakh Thirtyone Thousand One Hundred and Sixtysix only) (settlement amount) and the same will be paid in a spread over period of 6 months from the Effective date, with the initial payment of Rs. 4026233/- (Forty Lakhs Twenty six thousands two hundred thirty three Only) to be paid with in 30 days from the Effective date; Rs. 60,39,350/- (Rupees Sixty lakhs Thirty nine thousands three hundred fifty Only) within 90 days from the Effective Date and balance of Rs. 10065583/- (One Crores Sixty five Thousands Five Hundred Eighty three Only) shall be paid in within 6 months from the Effective Date, as more particularly described in the Annexure A. The payments contemplated here shall be in full and final settlement and satisfaction of all claims of Allahabad Bank (Presently Indian Bank) against its dues towards the CD. On receipt of the settlement amount, the Allahabad Bank (now known as Indian Bank) shall completely discharge and release the CD from all its liabilities and also issue "No Dues Certificate" to the CD.

ii.

Entire admitted dues of Oriental Bank of Commerce (now known as Punjab National Bank) for Rs. 54,18,43,117/- (Rupees Fifty Four Crores Eighteen Lakhs Forty Three Thousands One Hundred Seventeen only) will be settled on full and final basis by payment of Rs. 15571120/- (Rupees One Crores Fifty five Lakhs Seventy one Thousand One Hundred Twenty Only) (settlement amount) and the same will be paid in a spread over period of 6 months from the Effective date, with the initial payment of Rs. 3114224/- (Rupees Thirty one Lakhs Fourteen Thousands Two Hundred Twenty four only) to be paid with in 30 days of the Effective

iii.

date; Rs 4671336 (Rupees Forty Six Lakhs Seventy One Thousands Three Hundred Thirty Six Only) within 90 days from the Effective Date and balance of Rs. 7785560/- (Rupees Seventy Seven Lakhs Eighty Five Thousands Five Hundred Sixty Only) shall be paid within 6 months from the Effective Date, as more particularly described in the Annexure A. The payments contemplated here shall be in full and final settlement and satisfaction of all claims of Oriental Bank of Commerce (Presently Punjab National Bank) against its dues towards the CD. On receipt of the settlement amount, the Oriental Bank of Commerce (now known as Punjab National Bank) shall completely discharge and release the CD from all its liabilities and also issue "No Dues Certificate" to the CD.

Entire admitted dues of UCO Bank for Rs. 28,87,43,488/- (Rupees Twenty Eight Crores Eighty Seven Lakhs Forty Three Thousand Four Hundred Eighty Eight) will be settled on full and final basis by payment of Rs. 8297714/- (Rupees Eighty Two Lakhs Ninety Seven Thousand Seven Hundred Fourteen Only) and the same will be paid in a spread over period of 6 months from the Effective date, with the initial payment of Rs. 1659543/- (Rupees Sixteen Lakhs Fifty-nine Thousands Five Hundred Forty Three Only) to be paid with 30 days of the Effective date; Rs 2489314 (Rupees Twenty Four Lakhs Eighty Nine Thousand, and Three Hundred Fourteen Only) within 90 days from the Effective Date and balance of Rs. 4148857/- (Rupees Forty One Lakh Forty Eight Thousand Eight Hundred Fifty Seven Only) shall be paid within 6 months from the Effective Date, as more particularly described in the Annexure A. The payments contemplated here shall be in full and final settlement and satisfaction of all claims of UCO Bank against its dues towards the CD. On receipt of the settlement amount, the Uco shall completely discharge and release the CD from all its liabilities and also issue "No Dues Certificate" to the CD.

iv.

It is hereby clarified that the Resolution Applicant is neither seeking release of any Personal Guarantee nor third party security given by the Corporate Debtor to the Financial Creditors to secure the debt of the CD.

v.

It is clarified that notwithstanding the foregoing, dissenting financial creditors shall be paid liquidation value proportionate to their admitted claim in accordance with section 30(2) of the IBC,2016 i.e that such payment shall be made in priority to Financial Creditors who vote in favour of the plan.

5.

As per the aforesaid proposal, Indian Bank was to be paid Rs. 20131166/-against the entire admitted dues of Rs. 70,05,23,413/-, PNB was to be paid 15571120/- against the entire admitted dues of Rs. 54,18,43,117/- and UCO Bank was to be paid Rs. 8297714/- against the entire admitted dues of Rs. 28,87,43,488/- in full and final settlement. However, it was clarified in clause 8.3(b)(v) that the dissenting financial creditors shall be paid liquidation value proportionate to their admitted claim in accordance with section 30(2) of the Code.

6.

The synopsis of financial proposal made by the Appellant is also reproduced as under:-

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
7.

The dissenting financial creditor (UCO Bank) was paid 57.02 lakh as against 82.98 Lakh on the basis of the liquidation value in terms of Section 30(2) of the Code. In this regard, UCO Bank filed an application I.A. No. 355 of 2022 alleging that it ought to have received Rs. 82.98 Lakh as entitled under the approved resolution plan whereas it has been paid 57.02 lakh, therefore, it was prayed in the application that ‘an order be passed directing the SRA to forthwith pay the applicant its balance share of Rs. 25,95,533/- as provided for in the approved resolution plan’.

8.

The application bearing I.A No. 355 of 2022 was dismissed by the AA and hence, the claim made by the UCO Bank was closed, however, in the application filed by the Appellant bearing 288 of 2022, while dealing with prayer (b) of the application, it was held that since the amount of Rs. 25.96 Lakh is surplus in the hands of SRA, therefore, the CoC of the CD shall address the issue pragmatically before its table and shall take a holistic view in accordance with law.

9.

Grievance of the Appellant is only in regard to this part of the impugned order about which it is argued that once the plan has been approved, it cannot be changed. In this regard, he has relied upon a decision of this Court rendered in the case of Hem Singh Bharana Vs. M/s Pawan Doot Estate Pvt. Ltd., CA (AT) (Ins) No. 1481 of 2022 decided on 05.01.2023.

10.

On the other hand, Counsel appearing on behalf of the Respondent has submitted that the Appellant was to pay Rs. 440 lakh to the assenting financial creditors who have been paid only 201.35 Lakh (Indian Bank) and 155.72 Lakh (PNB), total amounting to Rs. 357.02 Lakh. It is further submitted that the amount in question cannot be retained by the Appellant being SRA as it has to go to the kitty of the financial creditors. In this regard, he has also relied upon a decision of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Tata Steel BSL Limited Vs. Venus Recruiter Pvt. Ltd., 2023 SCC OnLine Del 155. He has argued that though this decision is not squarely on the issue involved but in that case the money which became available after the resolution plan, on the adjudication of the avoidance application, will not go to the pocket of the SRA but it shall be distributed amongst the CoC. In this regard, he has pressed para 80 and 90 of the said decision which are reproduced as under:-

“80.

The Ld. Single Judge operates on the assumption that the sum or property acquired upon adjudication of the avoidance application will be appropriated by the corporate debtor in its new avatar. As laid down above, the provisions pertaining to avoidable transactions is to primarily benefit creditors. While the Corporate Debtor ceases to exist in its erstwhile avatar, in cases where the Resolution Plan is silent on the treatment of any pending applications because such information could not be made available to the applicant, the creditors of the corporate debtor can still be the beneficiaries of the sum or properties that may be recovered from adjudication of an avoidance application. The same is consistent with the scheme of the Code and in line with object sought to be achieved by it which inter-alia includes, increasing the availability of credit within the economy.

(d)

RP will pursue the avoidance applications since he is only functus officio vis-à-vis CIRP and not avoidance applications.

90.

The amount that is available after the transactions are avoided cannot Neutral Citation Number: 2023/DHC/000257 go to the kitty of the resolution applicant, in this case the Appellant in LPA No. 37/2021. For the resolution applicant, it was purely a commercial contract, a commercial decision whereunder the resolution applicant knew the ground reality, the assets and the liabilities. The benefit arising out of the adjudication of avoidance applications is not for the corporate debtor in its new avatar since it does not continue as a debtor and has gone through the process of resolution. The expectation that some more amount could come to the kitty was not present when the commercial decision was taken by the resolution applicant while agreeing to take over the corporate debtor. The purpose of the avoidance application as stated above is to enhance the asset pool available for the decision of creditors who are primarily financial institutions and have taken the haircut in agreeing to accept a much lesser amount than what was due and payable to them. This is public money, and, therefore, the amount that is received if and when transactions are avoided and receive the imprimatur of adjudicating authority must be distributed amongst the committee of creditors in a manner determined by the adjudicating authority.

11.

Counsel appearing on behalf of the Indian Bank has also supported the case of the PNB.

12.

We have heard Counsel for the parties and perused the record with their able assistance.

13.

In so far as the decision, relied upon by the Appellant, in the case of Hem Singh (Supra) is concerned, it was a case where an appeal was filed by the ex-promoter of the CD who had been unsuccessful before the AA in its application to keep in abeyance of the decision on the application filed by the RP for approval of the resolution plan. There was an issue of revised settlement proposal made under Section 12A and the question was framed that ‘whether after approval of the resolution plan by CoC under Section 30, sub-section (4) and filing an application before the AA for its approval, any settlement proposal under Section 12A (filed by ex-promoter) can be entertained deferring consideration of approval of resolution plan by the AA?’ This question has been decided against the Appellant in the said appeal, therefore, judgment in the case of Hem Singh (Supra) is not applicable to the facts of the present case. On the contrary, in the case of Tata Steel BSL Limited (Supra), the Hon’ble Delhi High Court has held that the amount accruing on the adjudication of the avoidance application will go to the financial creditors which shall be decided by the CoC. In the present case, the AA has not tinkered with the resolution plan because it has already been decided that the Appellant would pay 440 Lakh to the assenting financial creditors to whom only 351 lakh has been paid, therefore, the amount in question i.e. 25.96 Lakh belongs to the kitty of the assenting financial creditors for which the AA has rightly passed the order that it is for the CoC to address the issue to take a holistic view in accordance with law and in our considered opinion, it does not requires any interference.

14.

In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, we do not find any merit in the present appeal and the same is hereby dismissed. Not costs.