AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
S. Jagadeesan, J
The appeal is against the order of the Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks dated 18.1.96 rejecting the opposition No. MAS-1246 of the appellant and directing the registration of the first respondent's trade mark subject to disclaimer of the device of 12 zodiac signs and the words "Sarva Muhoortha Panchangam". The first respondent Mr. Balakrishnan is trading in publication under the name B. Rathina Nayagar and Sons and also under the name and style of Thirumagal Vilasam Press. The first respondent filed an application No. 314886 dated 15.5.1976 in class 16 for registration of a label mark consisting of a device of Lord Rama, Sita, Lakshmanan and Hanuman alongwith 12 zodiac signs and the words "Arcot Sri Seetharama Sarvamuhoortha Panchangam" in Tamil, in respect of Almanacs in class 16. After compliance of certain objections the application was ordered to be advertised and the same was accordingly advertised in Trade Mark Journal No. 702 dated 1.9.78 with the goods amended to read as Almanacs for sale in the State of Tamil Nadu. The second and third respondent herein K.S. Pattammal and Shri Kuppusamy alongwith one K.S.
Nagammal filed a notice of opposition on 29.12.78 opposing the registration of the impugned trade mark of the first respondent. Their claim is that they are trading in Almanacs of "Arcot K.V. Sitarama Iyer Sarva Muhoortha Panchangam" and their predecessor Shri K.V. Sitarama Iyer was a reputed and well known astrologer and had brought out an Almanac under the title "Vakkiya Nethira Jeevathi Sarvamuhoortha Panchangam" in the year 1900- 01 which was published by one Chinnaya Nadar Press, Chennai. It is their case that subsequently in 1902, the title of the Almanac was changed to Sandira Sowramana Nethira Jeevathi Arcot Sarvamuhoortha Panchangam"" and the same was published by one Ka. Narahari Naidu of Sri Hari
Press. In 1906, the said K.V. Sitarama Iyer adopted for his Almanac, the trade mark comprising the portrait of Lord Rama with Sita and Hanuman, surrounded by the 12 signs of Zodiac and the same was continued to be published till 1909-1910. After the death of Shri Sitarama Iyer, his younger brother Shri K.V. Venkatarama Iyer continued the preparation of the Almanac and published under the same name and trade mark. In the year 1924, the said Venkatrama Iyer died. Thereafter the preparation of the Almanac was taken over by K.V.S. Subbarama Iyer, son of Shri K.V. Sitarama Iyer, who retained the title of the Almanac as "Sandira Sowramana Nethira Jeevathi Arcot Sarvamuhoortha Panchangam". However, he altered the trade mark in the year 1926 by including Lakshmana in the picture and re-arranged the order of the portrait. During 1932-34 the publication of Almanac was entrusted to one Mr. Deiva Sigamani Mudaliar of Ananda Gajalakshmi Press and a minor alteration was effected in the trade mark by altering the position of Lord Rama's face. During 1934 to 1938 the publication was entrusted with the first respondent. In 1938-39 Shri Subbarama Iyer altered the name and title of the almanac in memory of his father late Shri K.V. Sitarama Iyer and name the same as "Arcot K.V. Sitarama Iyer Sarvamuhoortha Panchangam" which continued to be published by the first respondent up to 1974-75. In the meanwhile K.V. Subbarama Iyer died in 1970 leaving behind 2 wives and one son, who are the opponents in the proceedings. After the death of K.V. Subbarama Iyer, the present appellant took over the preparation of the almanac on behalf of the opponents. In 1975, the first respondent claimed the proprietorship of the impugned trade mark which resulted in the litigation. The High Court of Madras sorted out a work arrangement between the parties till the rights of the parties are decided by the Trade Marks Registry. The opponents submitted that the registration of the impugned trade mark would contravene section 11(a), 11(b) and 11(e) of the Trade and Merchandise Mark Act, 1958. As the first respondent is not a user of the trade mark they are not entitled for the benefit of section 12(3) of the said Act. Further, as the first respondent is not the proprietor of the impugned trade mark, he is not entitled for the registration under section 18(1) also.
The first respondent filed a counter-statement on 16.4.79 denying all the averments made by the respondents 2 and 3 in their opposition. He claimed the proprietorship of the impugned trade mark on the ground that his firm has been using the said impugned trade mark uninterruptedly from the year 1934-35. Shri K.V. Sitarama Iyer and K.V. Subbarama Iyer were associated with the first respondent only in their capacity as astrologers, who were responsible for preparation of the almanacs from time to time for which they were paid remuneration by the first respondent.
The respondents 2 & 3 filed evidence by way of affidavit of Smt. K.S. Nagammal alongwith the copies of some of the front covers of almanacs published during the years 1901-78 in the form of Exhibit A series. The first respondent also filed evidence by way of affidavit of Shri T.R.
Balakrishnan alongwith some of the copies of front cover pages of the almanacs published by the first respondent during the period between 1936 to 1977-78, copies of cash receipts issued by the two astrologers K.S.V. Subba Rama Iyer and K.N. Narayana Moorthy, the appellant herein were also attached as Exhibit B series. The Assistant Registrar Trade Marks, heard the counsel for both side and finally passed the impugned order under appeal. The appellant herein claiming assignment of the right over the impugned trade mark from the legal representatives of K.V. Sitarama Iyer filed the appeal seeking leave of the High Court of Madras on the ground that he being the assignee of the rights of the original owners he is entitled to challenge the order of the Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks. The High Court of Madras granted leave and ultimately the appeal was taken on file as TMA 1 of 1998. In view of section 100 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 the appeal stand transferred to the Appellate Board. We heard Mr. S.D.N.
Vimalanathan on behalf of the appellant and Smt. Usha on behalf of the respondent and perused the records.
The learned counsel for the appellant contended that originally K.V. Sitarama Iyer prepared the almanac and subsequently after his death his brother Venkatarama Iyer and after his death Sitarama Iyer's son K.S.V. Subbarama Iyer continued the preparation. After the death of the said Subbarama Iyer, the appellant was preparing the almanac and the same was published by the first respondent under the name and style of "Arcot Shri Sitarama Iyer Sarvamuhoortha Panchangam" having the label mark Lord Rama with Sita, Hanuman and Lakshmanan. The first respondent being only a publisher, he cannot claim any proprietorship over the label mark and seek for the registration of the same as the trade mark. The ownership of the mark can be attributed only to the individual who prepares the calculation and set the almanac. In fact the label mark goes alongwith the almanac. The predecessors and after them the appellant being the person who prepares the calculation, the impugned trade mark will belong to the appellant alone.
Hence the registration in favour of the first respondent cannot be sustained. Further, he contended that the first respondent obtained a deed of agreement from the appellant in respect of the disputed trade mark and as such the first respondent is estopped from claiming any exclusive ownership or proprietorship in respect of the impugned trade mark. He also contended that the almanac belongs to the appellant and consequently the label mark printed on the cover page of the almanac would also belong to the appellant. Moreover, the appellant is entitled for the copyright of the
same. Apart from that, it is also the case of the appellant that the trade mark consist of the figures of Lord Rama with Sita and Lakshmanan encircled by the 12 zodiac sings was registered as early as 1937 with the Southern India Chamber of Commerce with the words Arcot Jothisham K.V. Sitaram Iyer Sarvamuhoortha Panchangam. This would establish the registered ownership of the appellants predecessor Sitarama Iyer in respect of the almanac as well as the impugned trade mark and consequently even though no steps had been taken to register the trade mark by the successors of K.V. Sitarama Iyer, still the predecessor of the appellant are deemed to be the registered proprietor of the impugned trade mark. Consequently the first respondent cannot have any independent claim over the same.
On the contrary, the learned counsel Smt. Usha for the first respondent contended that there is clear evidence to show that the predecessors of the appellant as well as the appellant were paid charges for the preparation of the almanac. The publication was made by the first respondent with the impugned label on the cover of the almanac. When the appellant and the predecessors were paid for the preparation of the almanac, they cannot claim any independent right or title over the published almanac itself. Having received the consideration for their labour of calculating the Almanac, the appellant as well as their predecessor cannot have any subsisting right thereafter. Once the publisher pays for the almanac prepared by the appellant and their predecessor, thereafter, the publisher gets every right for the publication of the same and whatever from the almanac was brought out, the publisher can have the claim in the absence of any agreement contra. Further, the appellant did not put forth any claim before the Assistant Registrar of the Trade Marks, even though he claims that he prepared the almanac for the years 1970 to 1975. The dispute was pending before the Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks from 1976 to 1996. The legal representatives of K.V. Sitarama Iyer alone put forth their claim and failed to establish that they have anything to do with the preparation of the almanac or in the impugned trade mark. The Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks carefully considered all these aspects and ultimately rejected the opposition of the respondents 2 & 3. Since the appellant did not establish his claim the appeal is liable to be dismissed in limine apart from the ground that the appellant had miserably failed to establish his claim that his predecessor had got any interest or right over the impugned trade mark.
Respondents 2 to 4 remained absent.
There is no doubt that K.V. Sitarama Iyer originally brought out the almanac in the year 1900-01 and continuously brought out the same till his death in 1920 through various publishers. In 1906, the almanac had the cover page with a label mark comprising the portrait of Lord Rama, Sita and Hanuman, surrounded by the 12 sings of zodiac. After the death of Shri Sitarama Iyer, his brother Venkatrama Iyer continued the work of preparing the almanac. He also died in 1924. Thereafter one Subbarama Iyer son of the original author, Shri Sitarama Iyer prepared the almanac. Periodically the name of the almanac was changed. In 1926, the label mark in the front cover page was also altered by including the figure of Lakshmanan alongwith the Lord Rama, Sita and Hanuman. From 1934, the first respondent herein i.e., Ratna Nayakar became the publishers of the almanac. After the death of Subbarama Iyer, the appellant herein prepared the almanac and thereby claims the proprietorship of the label mark contained in the front cover published by the first respondent. The appellant claims to be the nephew of Subbarama Iyer. While so, the first respondent herein filed an application No. 314886 for the registration of the label mark consisting of the device of Lord Rama, Sita, Lakshmanan and Hanuman alongwith 12 zodiac signs with the words ""Arcot Shri Sitarama Iyer Sarva Muhoortha Panchangam. The respondents 2 & 3 who are the legal heirs of Sitarama Iyer, the original author of the almanac filed opposition claiming proprietorship of the label mark alongwith the name of the Panchangam. Their claim is that Sita Rama Iyer was the proprietor of the almanac and the first respondent was entrusted with the work of the publication. The publisher cannot claim any right either in the almanac or in the details including the label mark contained in the cover pages. In support of their claim, the respondents 2 & 3 produced only the cover pages of the Panchangam, which consists of the disputed label with the name Arcot Ka. Ve. Subbarama Iyer Sarvamuhoortha Panchangam. Except the Xerox copies of the cover pages of the Panchangam the respondents 2 & 3 did not produce any material to establish the proprietorship of the label mark. The appellant herein was not in the picture before the Assistant Registrar of Trade Mark.
Apart from this, a relevant factor to be considered is that the respondents 2 & 3 alongwith one Nagammal claim to be the first wife of K.V.
Subbarama Iyer have stated to have filed an application No. 320955 for registration of the portrait of "Arcot Jodhidar Ka. Ve. Sitarama Iyer" meaning Arcot Astrologer K.V. Sitarama Iyer"". They have also stated to have filed application Nos. 321801, 321802, 321803 for registration of the mark ARCOT Ka. Ve. Sitarama Iyer and also the portrait of late K.S.V. Subbarama Iyer, the husband of the second respondent and Nagammal and the father of the first respondent herein with the word K.S.V. Subbarama Iyer (Jothida Vallunar) Arcot, the words "Jothida Vallunar" Arcot means Expert Astrologer, Arcot. However, the result of the said applications is not known and both the counsels are not in a position to inform the same to this Board. However, these applications have been filed later than the impugned application.
Only after the disposal of the matter by the Assistant Registrar, Trade Mark the appellant came into picture. The short question for consideration before this Board is as to whether the appellant has any right to maintain this appeal and also whether factually he has got any right in the impugned trade mark?
The first respondent by way of evidence produced 5 receipts for the payment of the charges for preparation of the almanac. One receipt is dated 1.2.69 signed by Subbarama Iyer. The other one is also by him dated 5.2.70. The receipt dated 22.2.71, 18.2.74 and 27.2.75 are signed by the appellant herein. In the receipt dated 1.2.69 Subbarama Iyer clearly mentioned that he agreed to receive a sum of Rs. 400/- towards charges for preparing the calculations of the Panchangam and he received Rs. 102/- as advance on 15.10.68 and he also received the balance of Rs. 298 under the said receipt. Similarly, in the receipt dated 5.2.70 the said Subbarama Iyer mentioned that the agreed charges for calculation of Panchangam for the year 1970-71 is Rs. 600/- and he received a sum of Rs. 102/- by way of advance by MO and the balance of Rs. 498/- was received under the receipt. The appellant also signed the receipt dated 22.2.71 for a sum of Rs. 600/- towards the charges for the calculation of the Panchangam. Under the receipt dated 18.2.74 he acknowledged receipt of a sum of Rs. 2000/- towards the charges for the preparation of the calculation of the Panchangam for 1974-75 and in the receipt dated 27.2.75 the appellant acknowledged the receipt of the sum of Rs. 2000/- for the preparation of the calculation in respect of the Panchangam for 1975-76.
A perusal of these receipts produced by the first respondent clearly establish that the astrologers were paid for the preparation of the calculation in respect of the Panchangam. When the astrologers were paid for their work done, thereafter they cannot have any right over the materials prepared and supplied by them, unless there is any agreement contra between the parties. The respondents 2 & 3 did not produce any agreement to establish their claim that the authors of the calculation have got any right over the publication. In view of the fact that, the publisher has paid the necessary charges to the astrologer for the work done by them and thereafter they published the Panchangam, they became the owner of the same especially in the absence of any agreement contrary to the same.
When the respondents 2 & 3 contested the matter before the Assistant Registrar and failed, the appellant claiming to be an assignee from them cannot have any independent right. When the assignor lost the claim, the assignee's right also comes to an end and thereby the appellant has no independent right to enforce. The respondents 2 & 3 remained ex-parte. Moreover, it is clear from the impugned order of the Assistant Registrar that the counsel for the Respondents 2 & 3 herein did not admit any assignment in favour of the appellant herein and claimed that the appellant was paid remuneration for his calculations and the appellant is not the owner of the trade mark.
Even if we consider the claim of the appellant there is absolutely no document to establish his claim that his predecessors are the owners of the trade mark. Even though he produced the registration certificate with the Chamber of Commerce prior to coming into force of the Trade Mark Act, admittedly his predecessors did not take any steps to keep the registration alive subsequent to the Trade and Merchandise Act, 1958 coming into
force. Hence, the document relied upon by the appellant is of no use. The learned counsel for appellant also relied upon a deed of agreement executed by him on 19th September, 1973 in favour of the first respondent and contended that the first respondent is estopped from denying the appellant's right.
We are unable to agree with the said contention. When the appellant has failed to establish his right in respect of the impugned trade mark, then he does not have any ownership in respect of the same. Factually he is not the owner of the trade mark on 19th September 1973. In such circumstances, a person who do not have any title or right or ownership or proprietorship in a trade mark cannot pass on the same to anyone. Even if a person who do not have any such right executes or transfers any alleged right under any document, such document will have no legal force and virtually it will be a worthless piece of paper. Hence, the contention of the counsel for the appellant that the first respondent is estopped from denying the right, title or proprietorship of the impugned trade mark of the appellant cannot be sustained. In view of the above finding, it is needless for us to traverse the use of the trade mark or any other incidental issues as the same becomes unnecessary. Accordingly, we confirm the impugned order of the Assistant Registrar of Trade Marks and dismiss the appeal. No costs.
