High CourtsDivision Bench(2026) 10 BOM CK 5436

Khushi Sanjay Pawar vs Scheduled Tribe Caste Scrutiny Committee

Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench · Decided on 19 October 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
Urmila Joshi Phalke, J · Raj D. Wakode, J
RESULT
Disposed Of
CASE NUMBER
Writ Petition No. 1049 of 2023 (with Writ Petition No. 5387 of 2022)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

17 paragraphs · 973 words

(Per Mrs. Urmila Joshi Phalke, J.)

1.

Heard learned counsel for the respective parties.

2.

Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Taken up for final disposal with the consent of learned counsel for the parties.

3.

The petitioners, in both petitions are sister and brother. The Sub-Divisional Officer, Ner had issued caste certificate of ‘Thakur’ Scheduled Tribe in favour of the petitioners. The caste certificates of the petitioners were forwarded to the respondent-Committee for the verification. This Court by order dated 30.08.2022 directed the respondent to take the decision on tribe claim of the petitioners within a period of 8 weeks from 07.9.2022. The respondent-committee had forwarded it for the police vigilance cell and called for the Vigilance Report. After receipt of the Vigilance Report, the explanation from petitioners were called. On 13.9.2022 the petitioners had furnished the replies to the report of the police vigilance cell. The respondent-Committee invalidated the caste claim by order dated 07.12.2021 in WP No.5387/2022 and on 09.12.2022 in WP No.1049/2023. Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the said, the petitioners have approached to this Court.

4.

Heard learned counsel for the petitioners, Mr. Anup Gilda, who submitted that the main reason for the invalidation of the caste claim of the present petitioners is that the caste claim of their father Sanjay Shankarrao Pawar was invalidated by the Committee. Now, in Writ Petition No. 9616/2007 this Court at Principal seat has already granted the validity by passing a judgment on 24.09.2026. He further submitted that other family members of the present petitioners namely Prakash Awadhut Pawar and Sunil Avdhut Pawar are already granted with the validity. Thus, there are validities in the family on the basis of the pre-constitutional documents. He also invited our attention towards the various documents which state that the fore-fathers of the present petitioners, specifically, the grandfather of the present petitioner Shankar Ramji was recorded as ‘Thakur’ in 1934. His school admission extracts, which is produced on record, show that he was admitted in school and while admitting him at the school, he was recorded as ‘Thakur’. The great grandfather of the present petitioner namely Ramasakharam Thakur was also recorded as ‘Thakur’ on 01.10.1921. He submitted that, thus, despite there are validities in the family, the Committee has not considered this. The Committee has also not considered the decision of this Court in the case of Apoorva Vinay Nichale versus Division Caste Certificate Scrutiny Committee reported in (2010) 6 MH.LJ. 401 and swayed away by the fact that the petitioners could not prove their affinity with ‘Thakur’ Scheduled Tribe. He submitted that now it is settled law that the affinity is not a litmus test. For all above these grounds, he prayed for quashing of the impugned orders passed on 7.12.2021 and 9.12.2022.

5.

Per contra learned APP strongly opposed the said contentions and submitted that the petitioners cannot prove the affinity with the ‘Thakur’ Scheduled Tribe and therefore the orders passed by scrutiny committee are proper one.

6.

We have heard the learned counsel for the petitioners who pointed out that now the father of the petitioners has already granted with the validity as well as the other family members Prakash Avdhut and Sunil Avdhut, who are the blood relatives of the petitioners, have already granted with the validity. In view of the decision of this Court in Apoorva Vinay Nichale versus Division Caste Certificate Scrutiny Committee, referred above, the petitioners would be entitled for the benefit of the same. In addition to that, there are various pre-constitutional documents which show that the fore-fathers of the petitioners during the pre-constitutional era were recorded as ‘Thakur’ Scheduled Tribe. The said documents are having highest probative value which are ignored by the Scrutiny Committee. On this ground also the petitions deserve to be allowed.

7.

As far as the affinity test is concerned, the issue is now well settled in the judgment of Anand vs. Committee and Verification of Tribe Claims and others, reported in 2012(1) SCC 113 wherein it is observed that, “while applying the affinity test, which focuses on the ethnological connections with the scheduled tribe, a cautious approach has to be adopted. A few decades ago, when the tribes were somewhat immune to the cultural development happening around them, the affinity test could serve as a determinative factor. However, with the migrations, modernisation and contact with other communities, these communities tend to develop and adopt new traits which may not essentially match with the traditional characteristics of the tribe. Hence, affinity test may not be regarded as a litmus test for establishing the link of the applicant with a Scheduled Tribe. Nevertheless, the claim by an applicant that he is a part of a scheduled tribe and is entitled to the benefit extended to that tribe, cannot per se be disregarded on the ground that they are not following the culture and they were following the other culture. Thus, the affinity test may be used to corroborate the documentary evidence and should not be the sole criteria to reject a claim.”

8.

In view of the above referred facts, law laid down and the reasons recorded, we allow, these petitions. Hence, we proceed to pass the following order:-

ORDER

(i)

The Writ Petitions are allowed.

(ii)

The orders dated 9.12.2022 and 07.12.2021 passed by the Respondent-Scheduled Tribe Certificate Scrutiny Committee, Yavatmal and Amravati in WP Nos.1049/2023 and 5387/2022 invalidating the tribe claim of the petitioners as “Thakur” Scheduled Tribe are hereby quashed and set aside.

(iii)

It is declared that, the petitioners belong to “Thakur” Scheduled Tribe.

(iv)

The respondent- Scrutiny Committees are directed to issue the validity certificate to the petitioners within two weeks.

9.

With the above directions both petitions are disposed of.

10.

Rule is made absolute in the aforesaid terms.

11.

Pending application/s, if any, shall stand disposed of accordingly.