AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Samvatsar, J.—On 28-7-1954 at 5-30 P.M., the Excise Officer Indore raided the house of the petitioners Khannu and his son Hiralal, which is in Raoji Bazar House No. 217, Juni Indore. The petitioners were absent but it is alleged by the prosecution that Rampyari W/O Hiralal was present in the house. In the search that followed the raid, the prosecution have alleged that they recovered country liquor in bottles and petrol tin. The liquor was seized and a Panchnama was drawn up which is produced at Ex. P/1 in this case.
The two petitioners along with Rampyari were prosecuted before the Additional City Magistrate, Indore for offence u/s 33 (a) of the Madhya Bharat Excise Act. The learned Magistrate found Rampyari not guilty and acquitted her. He however found the petitioners guilty and convicted and sentenced Khannu to pay a fine of Rs. 30/- and Hira to pay a fine of Rs. 20/-. Aggrieved by their conviction and sentence the two petitioners preferred a revision-application before the Sessions Judge, Indore. The learned Additional Sessions-Judge who heard the revision-application has preferred the matter to this Court u/s 438 Criminal Procedure Code, as he is of opinion that the conviction of the accused-petitioners cannot be upheld on the evidence on record.
Mr. Khanwilkar, the learned Advocate for the petitioners did not press any of the grounds mentioned by the Sessions Judge in support of his order. He however contended that there was no evidence to prove that the house No. 217 belonged to or was in the occupation of the accused persons on the material date. He further submitted that the house was admittedly searched in the absence of the accused persons and the evidence of the Panch witnesses is not sufficient to prove the recovery of objectionable material from the possession of the accused.
I do not find any substance in the first point raised by Mr. Khanwilkar. It has all along been the case of the prosecution that the accused were residing in House No. 217 Raoji Bazar, Indore which was searched on 28-7-1954; but it was never suggested by the accused that it was not so. In the question put to the accused it was specifically asked whether his residential house i.e. House No. 217 Raoji Bazar, Indore, was raided and searched by the Police. The accused in their reply did not contend that the said house was not their residential house. They replied that they did not know. The petitioner No. 2 Hiralal further added that he was not present in the house. P.W. 4 Rajendraprasad Jain has stated that he knew the accused No. 1, and he resided in Raoji Bazar Indore. This statement has not been challenged in cross-examination. It is further significant to note that the petitioners had not only not raised this contention before the Sessions Judge but in the petition for revision filed in that Court they stated that their house was occupied by six or eight other persons besides themselves; that they were absent from the house at the time of search; that the lower Court was therefore not right in holding that the liquor was seized from their possession. Under the circumstances the petitioners cannot be allowed to urge now that they are not residing in House No. 217 Raoji Bazar Indore and it was not proved that they occupied the house at the material time.
The next point to be considered is, whether it is proved by the prosecution that the liquor seized, vide Ex. P/1, was in the possession of the accused persons. The prosecution has led no evidence to prove who was in actual possession of the liquor. It has relied primarily on the fact that the accused persons were residing in that house. The accused have maintained that besides themselves there were eight or ten other persons living in House No. 217 Raoji Bazar, Indore. The accused have examined one Chiranjilal as defence-witness and he has also supported the case of the defence on this point. Chiranjilal's statement is not challenged in cross-examination and it cannot therefore be lightly brushed aside. It is therefore not satisfactorily proved that the liquor was seized from the possession of the accused persons.
To constitute an offence under S. 33 (a), it must be established that the possession of the accused over the objectionable material was exclusive. Section 48 of the Madhya Bharat Excise Act does not lay down anything to the contrary. It only provides that in a prosecution u/s 33, 34 and 35, it shall be presumed until the contrary is proved that the accused person has committed an offence punishable under that section in respect of (a) any intoxicant, (b)......... (c).........for the possession of which he is unable to account satisfactorily. It is therefore necessary for the prosecution to prove that the intoxicant or other articles specified in Clauses (a) to (c) of this section, were in the exclusive possession of the accused person. If then the accused is unable to explain his possession, it will be presumed that he is guilty and will be liable to be convicted.
As in the present case there is no evidence to prove that the intoxicant or even the premises from which it was recovered were in the exclusive possession of the accused persons, neither any presumption of guilt u/s 48 can be drawn, nor are the ingredients required to make out a case u/s 33 of the Madhya Bharat Excise Act established. The conviction of the accused persons u/s 33 cannot therefore be upheld.
I accept the reference, set aside the conviction of the accused and acquit both of them. Fine if paid shall be refunded.
