High CourtsSingle Bench(2026) 10 P&H CK 6029

Karandeep Kaur @ Karamdeep Kaur vs Bhupinder Singh & Anr.

Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · Decided on 12 October 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
Deepak Gupta, J
RESULT
Partly Allowed
CASE NUMBER
FAO-6983-2017

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

31 paragraphs · 1,404 words

Deepak Gupta, J.

The present appeal has been filed by the injured claimant seeking enhancement of compensation awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sirsa, vide award dated 06.05.2017, in a petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.

2.

The facts, in brief, are that on 16.09.2015, the appellant, aged about 23 years, was travelling as a pillion rider on a scooty, when it was hit by a car bearing registration No. HR-25C-1327, driven by respondent No.1. As a result of the accident, she sustained a fracture of the right tibia and underwent surgery involving nailing. She remained admitted in Sidhu Nursing Home, Sirsa, from 16.09.2015 to 19.09.2015.

3.

The Tribunal, upon appreciation of the evidence, held respondent No.1 responsible for the accident and awarded compensation of ₹1,06,500/-with interest at 9% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition till its final realization.

4.

Seeking enhancement, learned counsel for the appellant contends that the Tribunal has awarded an inadequate amount of ₹18,000/- towards permanent disability despite the disability certificate establishing 9% permanent disability pertaining to pain in the right ankle. It is further contended that the structured formula ought to have been applied for determining compensation; that no compensation has been awarded towards loss of marriage prospects; and that the amounts awarded under the other heads are also inadequate.

5.

Per contra, learned counsel for the insurance company submits that the appellant's assertion that she was earning ₹12,000/- per month as a Computer Teacher at a private computer centre is unsupported by reliable documentary evidence. It is argued that, in the absence of proof of income or evidence establishing any corresponding loss of earning capacity, the appellant is not entitled to any enhancement on the basis of the asserted income.

6.

I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

7.

The principles governing assessment of compensation in cases involving permanent disability stand settled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar, (2011) 1 SCC 343. The Court is required to distinguish between the percentage of physical disability and the consequent functional disability affecting earning capacity. A particular percentage of permanent physical disability does not, by itself, establish an equivalent percentage of loss of earning capacity. The nature and location of the injury, the occupation of the injured and the impact of the disability upon the ability to pursue that occupation are relevant considerations.

8.

In the present case, the disability certificate establishes 9% permanent disability pertaining to pain in the right ankle. The medical witness further stated that the disability was not likely to decrease with the passage of time or physiotherapy. The appellant had sustained a fracture of the right tibia, necessitating surgical intervention by way of nailing. The permanent nature of the impairment is, therefore, established. However, the percentage of physical disability, by itself, does not establish the extent of any consequential loss of earning capacity.

9.

The appellant asserted that she was working as a Computer Teacher at a private computer centre and earning ₹12,000/- per month. However, the record does not contain reliable documentary evidence establishing the asserted income, nor does the evidence establish that the permanent disability compelled her to leave her employment or resulted in a corresponding loss of earning capacity. Consequently, a multiplier-based award towards loss of future earnings cannot be granted merely by applying the percentage of physical disability to the asserted income. The contention of the insurance company, to this extent, merits acceptance. Nevertheless, the absence of proof of loss of earning capacity does not disentitle the appellant to compensation for the permanent physical impairment and its non-pecuniary consequences.

10.

The contention regarding application of the structured formula is misconceived. The claim petition was instituted under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, whereas the structured formula contemplated under Section 163-A operates within a distinct statutory framework. It cannot, therefore, be mechanically applied to the present claim. The compensation has to be determined in accordance with the evidence available on record and the principles governing the award of just compensation under Section 168 of the Act.

11.

The Tribunal awarded only ₹18,000/- towards permanent disability. Having regard to the appellant's young age at the time of the accident, the fracture requiring surgical intervention, the permanent residual pain and the lasting physical impairment, the amount awarded under this head is inadequate. The appellant will have to live with the consequences of the impairment throughout her life, irrespective of whether a corresponding loss of income has been established. The compensation under this head is accordingly enhanced from ₹18,000/- to ₹40,000/-.

12.

The appellant has further sought compensation towards loss of marriage prospects. It is not disputed before this Court that the appellant was unmarried at the time of the accident. The appellant was approximately 23 years of age when she sustained the injury. The question is whether, in the circumstances of the present case, the permanent physical impairment justifies an award under this head.

13.

Loss of marriage prospects is a recognised head of non-pecuniary compensation, wherever the nature and consequences of the injury warrant such an award. Its assessment must be based upon the age of the claimant, the nature and permanence of the injury and its likely consequences for the claimant's future life.

14.

In the present case, the appellant suffered a fracture of the right tibia requiring surgical intervention and continues to have permanent residual pain in the right ankle. Although the medical evidence does not establish that the disability has rendered her incapable of marriage, the assessment of compensation cannot be restricted to cases involving such an extreme consequence. Having regard to her young age at the time of the accident and the permanent impairment suffered by her, a modest sum of ₹25,000/- is considered appropriate towards loss of marriage prospects.

15.

The appellant is also entitled to adequate compensation for loss of amenities of life. Permanent physical impairment may affect the ease with which a person undertakes ordinary activities and enjoys life, even where no corresponding loss of income is established. The appellant was a young woman at the time of the accident, and the permanent residual pain in her right ankle is likely to remain a source of physical discomfort. The amount awarded under this head must, however, remain proportionate to the nature and extent of the disability established on record. Accordingly, a sum of ₹20,000/- is awarded towards loss of amenities of life.

16.

As regards pain and suffering, the Tribunal awarded ₹20,000/-. The appellant sustained a fracture of the right tibia, underwent surgical treatment and remained hospitalised from 16.09.2015 to 19.09.2015. The physical pain associated with the fracture, the surgical procedure and the period of recuperation, coupled with the permanent residual impairment, justify enhancement under this head. The amount of ₹20,000/- is accordingly enhanced to ₹30,000/-.

17.

The Tribunal awarded ₹38,500/- towards medical expenses on the basis of the hospital bill and the medical bills accepted by it. No sufficient ground has been made out to disturb the assessment under this head. Likewise, the amounts of ₹15,000/- each awarded towards loss of earnings during the convalescent period and special diet and allied expenses do not warrant further enhancement in the absence of additional evidence justifying a higher assessment. These amounts are accordingly maintained.

18.

In view of the foregoing discussion, the compensation payable to the appellant is reassessed as under:

Head of compensation Amount

Medical expenses ₹38,500/-

Permanent disability ₹40,000/-

Loss of earnings during treatment and recuperation ₹15,000/-

Pain and suffering ₹30,000/-

Special diet and allied expenses ₹15,000/-

Loss of amenities of life ₹20,000/-

Loss of marriage prospects ₹25,000/-

Total compensation ₹1,83,500/-

19.

Consequently, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is enhanced from ₹1,06,500/- to ₹1,83,500/-, resulting in an enhancement of ₹77,000/-. The enhanced amount shall carry interest at the rate of 7.5 % per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition till its final realization.

20.

Respondent No.2–insurance company shall deposit and satisfy the enhanced amount in accordance with law. The remaining findings and directions contained in the award, insofar as they are not inconsistent with the present order, shall remain unaltered.

21.

The appeal is accordingly partly allowed in the aforesaid terms. The award of the Tribunal stands modified to the extent indicated above. Ordered accordingly. Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.