AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
A.D. Jagadish Chandira, J.
The instant criminal appeal is filed by the accused (hereinafter referred to as “the appellant”) seeking to set aside the judgment of conviction and sentence dated 06.12.2017 passed in Spl.S.C. No.10 of 2016 (hereinafter referred to as “the impugned judgment”) by the learned Sessions Judge, Mahila Court, Tiruchirappalli (hereinafter referred to as “the Trial Court”).
Vide the impugned judgment, the Trial Court convicted and sentenced the appellant as tabulated below:-
| Penal Provision | Imprisonment | Fine Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Section 5(j)(ii) r/w Section 6 of the POCSO Act, 2012 | Life imprisonment | Rs.1,000/- in default to undergo one year simple imprisonment |
| Section 5(l) r/w Section 6 of the POCSO Act, 2012 | Life imprisonment | Rs.1,000/- in default to undergo one year simple imprisonment |
| Section 5(n) r/w Section 6 of the POCSO Act, 2012 | Life imprisonment | Rs.1,000/- in default to undergo one year simple imprisonment |
| Section 506(i) IPC | One year rigorous imprisonment | Rs.500/- in default to undergo six months simple imprisonment |
The period of detention already undergone by the appellant was ordered to be set off and the sentences were ordered to run consecutively.
The case of the prosecution, in a nutshell, is as follows:
The de facto complainant/victim (P.W.1) was aged about 14 years and the appellant is her biological father. During July 2013, the victim (P.W.1) was at home as she had attained puberty. When Palaniammal (P.W.2), mother of the victim (P.W.1), went for coolie work, the victim (P.W.1) was subjected to sexual assault by the appellant and the appellant threatened to kill the victim (P.W.1) if she disclosed the incident to anybody. Later, the appellant sexually assaulted the victim (P.W.1) several times and made her pregnant. When Shanthi (P.W.3), who is working as a nurse in Arasangudi Primary Health Centre, went for a field visit on 26.12.2014, the villagers informed her that the victim (P.W.1) had missed her periods for 2-3 months. Shanthi (P.W.3), in turn, informed the same to Uma Gandhi (P.W.4), a nurse at Vengoor Health Centre. Shanthi (P.W.3) and Uma Gandhi (P.W.4) took the victim (P.W.1) to the Primary Health Centre, Arasangudi. On 30.12.2014, Dr. Neelaveni (P.W.29) at Primary Health Centre examined the victim (P.W.1), took scan and confirmed that the victim (P.W.1) was 32-33 weeks pregnant. When Shanthi (P.W.3) and Uma Gandhi(P.W.4) enquired the victim (P.W.1), she informed them that her father i.e the appellant herein, is the cause for her pregnancy. Uma Gandhi (P.W.4) informed Palaniammal (P.W.2) that the victim (P.W.1) was subjected to sexual assault by the appellant and she is pregnant. When Palaniammal (P.W.2) enquired about the same with the appellant, he picked up a quarrel with her and said that she could do whatever she could. Thereafter, on 31.12.2014, the victim (P.W.1) lodged a complaint (Ex.P.1) with the respondent police.
Based on the complaint (Ex.P.1), Cauveriammal (P.W.41), Inspector of Police, registered an FIR (Ex.P.33) in Crime No.24 of 2014 for the offences under Section 4 of the POCSO Act and Sections 294(b) and 506(i) of IPC and sent the victim (P.W.1) to Trichy Government Hospital for examination through Arokica Amudha (P.W.14), Grade I Constable, by a Medical Memo. Upon examination, Dr.Karpagam (P.W.31) issued an accident register (Ex.P.23) mentioning that the victim (P.W.1) was 30-32 weeks pregnant.
Thereafter, Cauveriammal (P.W.41) went to the scene of occurrence and prepared rough sketch (Ex.P.34) and observation mahazar (Ex.P.35) in the presence of independent witnesses Balamuthu (P.W.11) and Rajendran (P.W.12). She examined Palaniammal (P.W.2), Shanthi (P.W.3), Uma Gandhi (P.W.4), Devaki (P.W.5), Vimaladevi (P.W.6), Senthamarai Selvi (P.W.7), Balamuthu (P.W.11) and Rajendran (P.W.12) and recorded their statements.
On the very same day, based on secret information, she arrested the appellant who was standing in Vengoor bus stop at 4.00 p.m. and recorded his confession statement in the presence of independent witnesses Rajesh (P.W.39) and Abiyullah (P.W.13) and sent the appellant for remand. She also examined and recorded the statements of those two independent witnesses. Thereafter, Cauveriammal (P.W.41) went to Trichy Government Hospital and recorded the statement of the victim (P.W.1).
On 02.01.2015, Cauveriammal (P.W.41) examined Kadalmani (P.W.8), Paulraj (P.W.9), Vadivel (P.W.10) and Dharmaraj (not examined) and recorded their statements.
On 03.01.2015, Cauveriammal (P.W.41) examined Dr.Neelaveni (P.W.29), Dr.Karpagam (P.W.31) and Arokica Amudha (P.W.14) and recorded their statements.
On 06.01.2015, Cauveriammal (P.W.41) gave a request to the Government Higher Secondary School, Arasangudi, where, the victim (P.W.1) was studying and obtained the bona fide certificate (Ex.P.22) from Rani, Headmistress (P.W.30) and also examined her and recorded her statement.
Based on the requisition letter (Ex.P.37) by Cauveriammal (P.W.41) for medical examination, on 08.01.2015, the appellant was sent for medical examination through Packianathan (P.W.16), Grade II Constable. Upon examination of the appellant, Dr. Sarvanan (P.W.34) issued potency certificate (Ex.P.25) and opined that there was nothing to suggest that it could be conclusively said that the appellant was either impotent or was incapable of having sexual intercourse. After the medical examination, the appellant was sent back to remand.
On 22.01.2015, the statement of the victim (P.W.1) under Section 164 Cr.P.C (Ex.P.2) was recorded by the Judicial Magistrate No.5, Trichy (P.W.40). Subsequently, on 08.06.2015, the statement of Palaniammal (P.W.2) under Section 164 Cr.P.C. (Ex.P.3) was recorded by the Judicial Magistrate No.1, Trichy (P.W.38).
From 30.01.2015, the victim (P.W.1) was kept under the care of the Child Welfare Committee, Trichy. Based on the proceedings of the Child Welfare Committee dated 24.02.2015 (Ex.P.13), the victim (P.W.1) was sent to Kasthirubha Hospital for child birth.
On 05.03.2015, the victim (P.W.1) gave birth to a female baby at 8.52 a.m. On 11.03.2015, the victim (P.W.1) and Palaniammal (P.W.2) expressed their willingness to give the child in adoption and sworn to an affidavit (Ex.P.14) and gave the child to Kasthuribha Hospital, Gandhigramam, in the presence of the Child Welfare Committee, Dindugul.
On 13.03.2015, the victim (P.W.1) was sent back to the Child Welfare Committee, Trichy. Later, as neither the victim (P.W.1) nor Palaniammal (P.W.2) claimed custody of the child, the Child Welfare Committee, Dindugul issued a ‘No objection certificate’ 19.05.2015 granting permission to Kasthuribha Hospital,to give the child born to the victim (P.W.1) in adoption to third parties. The child fell ill on 05.06.2015 and was given treatment in the Kasthuribha Hospital till 11.06.2015. As the condition of the child got worsened, she was shifted to Rajaji Hospital, Madurai. However, the child died on 26.06.2015 and it was informed to Bhuvaneshwari (P.W.21), social worker in Kasthuribha Hospital. The body of child was brought back to Kasthuribha Hospital and laid to rest in the burial ground belonging to Kasthuribha Hospital by Chinnamani (P.W.19) and Veeraiyan (P.W.20), Sanitary Workers in Kasthuribha Hospital. From Kasturibha Hospital, the death of the child was intimated to the Child Welfare Committee, Trichy by letter dated 24.07.2015 (Ex.P.17) and to the Department of Social Welfare, Chennai by letter dated 27.06.2015 (Ex.P.19). The death certificate of the child was marked as Ex.P.20.
Due to transfer, Cauveriammal (P.W.41) handed over the case to Mumtaz Begum (P.W.42), Inspector of Police. Mumtaz Begum (P.W.42) made a request to Sivakumar (P.W.23), Tashildar to unearth the body of the child for drawing samples to conduct DNA analysis. Thangaraj (P.W.18) identified the place in which the body of the child was buried. Mumtaz Begum (P.W.42) prepared rough sketch (Ex.P.42) and observation mahazar (Ex.P.43) in the presence of Chinnamani (P.W.19) and Thangaraj (P.W.18).
On 15.10.2015, Chinnamani (P.W.19) and Veeraiyan (P.W.20) unearthed the body of the child wrapped in green colour rubber sheet (M.O.1) in the presence of Bhuvaneshwari (P.W.21), Sivakumar (P.W.23), Vijayalaksmi (P.W.25), Muthumari (P.W.26), Rameshwari (P.W.27), Rajavel (P.W.33) and Mumtaz Begum (P.W.42). The photos taken while unearthing the body of the child are marked as Ex.P.9 series.
Dr. Rajavel (P.W.33) recovered a part of skull and thigh bone and issued post-mortem certificate (Ex.P.11) and exhumation certificate (Ex.P.12) and the bones were sent to Trichy Mahila Court by Mumtaz Begum (P.W.42) through Muthumari (P.W.26), Grade II constable. Mumtaz Begum (P.W.42) examined Bhuvaneshwari (P.W.21), Sivakumar (P.W.23), Vijayalaksmi (P.W.25), Muthumari (P.W.26), Rameshwari (P.W.27), Rajavel (P.W.33) and the President of the Child Welfare Committee and recorded their statements.
On the same day, Panchavarnam (P.W.15), Grade II Constable, took the victim (P.W.1) from Annai Home to hospital for drawing blood samples for DNA analysis and Raja (P.W.17), Grade II Constable, took the appellant from Trichy Central Prison to hospital for the same purpose. The blood samples of the victim (P.W.1) and appellant were drawn by Dr. Saravanan (P.W.34) in FTA cards (Ex.P.26). Mumtaz Begum (P.W.42) examined Panchavarnam (P.W.15), Raja (P.W.17) and Dr. Saravanan (P.W.34) and recorded their statements.
On 16.10.2015, Mumtaz Begum (P.W.42) sent the FTA cards in a sealed cover to the court. Thereafter, on 25.10.2015, she forwarded the green colour rubber sheet (M.O.1), a part of dhoti with blue border (M.O.2) and blue turkey towel (M.O.3) to the Trial Court through Form 91 (Ex.P.44).
On 27.10.2015, Mumtaz Begum (P.W.42) handed over the sealed cover containing the blood samples of the victim (P.W.1) and the appellant and the bones of the child to Forensic Science Laboratory, Chennai through Poulin Mary (P.W.28), Grade II Constable.
Vimali Thiyagarajan (P.W.36), Assistant Chemical Examiner, opined in her DNA report (Ex.P.27) that the appellant is the biological father and the victim (P.W.1) is the mother of the deceased child.
The case was taken up by Selvi (P.W.43), Inspector of Police, for further investigation. On 15.06.2016, Selvi (P.W.43) re-examined the victim (P.W.1) and recorded her statement. On the same day, Selvi (P.W.43) examined Vimali Thiyagarajan (P.W.36) and recorded her statement. On 17.06.2016, Selvi (P.W.43) made ready the alteration report (Ex.P.46) altering the case to one under Sections 5(j)(ii), 5(l) and 5(n) read with Section 6 of the POCSO Act and Section 506(i) IPC and thus, after completing the investigation, she filed a final report for the said offences before the Trial Court.
On the appearance of the appellant and on compliance of the provisions under Section 207 Cr.P.C., the Trial Court framed charges against the appellant under Sections 5(j)(ii) r/w section 6, section 5(l) r/w section 6 and 5(n) r/w read with Section 6 of the POCSO Act and Section 506(i) IPC and when questioned, he pleaded not guilty and sought to be tried.
In order to prove the case, the prosecution examined 45 witnesses and marked 49 exhibits and 3 material objects.
After examination of the prosecution witnesses, when the appellant was questioned under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. on the incriminating circumstances appearing against him, he denied the same as false without offering any explanation whatsoever and did not examine any witness or mark any document on his side.
The Trial Court, after hearing the arguments on both sides, found the appellant guilty and convicted and sentenced him as tabulated at paragraph 2, supra, vide the impugned judgment and challenging the conviction and sentence, the instant criminal appeal has been filed by the accused i.e. the appellant.
The learned counsel for the appellant advanced the following submissions:
The appellant has been falsely implicated.
The Trial Court failed to take into consideration the inordinate delay in giving the complaint, i.e., the complaint (Ex.P.1) was given only when the victim (P.W.1) was 7 months pregnant.
The victim (P.W.1) being a tutored witness, her evidence cannot be relied upon.
Only 4 months after the death of the child, its dead body was exhumed for forensic analysis and hence, it creates a serious doubt as to whether the exhumed body is that of the child of the appellant and the victim (P.W.1).
Based on the above submissions, it is the stance of the defence that the prosecution has failed to establish the foundational facts beyond reasonable doubt to entitle them to the benefit of the statutory presumption under Sections 29 and 30 of the POCSO Act, 2012 and that in the absence of the statutory presumption, the prosecution is required to establish its case beyond all reasonable doubt, which has not been done in the present case. Hence, the learned counsel for the appellant prayed for allowing the present criminal appeal by setting aside the impugned judgment of conviction and sentence of the appellant.
Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent State contended as follows:
The appellant, being the father of the victim (P.W.1), had subjected her to repeated penetrative sexual assault, which resulted in her pregnancy. Hence, the offence committed by the appellant is that of aggravated penetrative sexual assault under Sections 5(j)(ii), 5(l) and 5(n) of the POCSO Act, 2012, punishable under Section 6, ibid.
The evidence of the victim (P.W.1) is clear and cogent, which is sufficient to convict the appellant. Furthermore, the testimony of the victim (P.W.1) stands corroborated by the medical evidence as well as the scientific evidence, more specifically the DNA report (Ex.P.27).
The prosecution has hence sufficiently established the foundational facts to invoke the statutory presumption under Sections 29 and 30 of the POCSO Act. However, the accused has failed to rebut such presumption either by adducing evidence on his side to probablise his defence or by cross examining the prosecution witnesses to improbablise the foundational facts. Hence, the trial Court was right in convicting and sentencing the appellant as tabulated at paragraph 2, supra. Based on the aforesaid submissions, the learned counsel for the respondent/State sought setting aside of the impugned judgment and consequential dismissal of this appeal.
Now, what is to be seen is whether the prosecution has established the foundational facts forming the charges under Section5(j)(ii), 5(l) and 5(n) read with Section 6 of the POCSO Act and Section 506(I) IPC against the appellant to entitle it to the statutory presumption under Sections 29 and 30 of the POCSO Act and whether the appellant has rebutted the same. Hence, ultimately what is to be seen is whether the trial Court is right in extending the benefit of the statutory presumption to the prosecution whilst finding the appellant guilty and convicting him for the offences he stood charged.
This is a case of incestuous sexual assault in which the appellant has been charged and tried for offences under Section5(j)(ii), 5(l) and 5(n) read with Section 6 of the POCSO Act and Section 506(I) IPC. For better appreciation, the relevant provisions, viz., Section 5(j)(ii), 5(l) and 5(n) of the POCSO Act are extracted hereunder:
“5. Aggravated penetrative sexual assault:
…….
(j)whoever commits penetrative sexual assault on a child, which—
(ii)in the case of female child, makes the child pregnant as a consequence of sexual assault;
(l)whoever commits penetrative sexual assault on the child more than once or repeatedly;
(n)whoever being a relative of the child through blood or adoption or marriage or guardianship or in foster care or having a domestic relationship with a parent of the child or who is living in the same or shared household with the child, commits penetrative sexual assault on such child;
……
is said to commit aggravated penetrative sexual assault.”
(emphasis supplied by this Court)
To bring an offence under the ambit of Section 5(j)(ii), 5(l) and 5(n) read with Section 6, ibid., the prosecution must first prove that the victim is a child as defined under section 2(1)(d), ibid., and that an offence of penetrative sexual assault under Section 3, ibid., has been committed on her and it has so been committed repetitively by a person being a relative of the child through blood or adoption or marriage or guardianship or in foster care or having a domestic relationship with a parent of the child or who is living in the same or shared household with the child.
Section 3, ibid., reads as follows:
“3. Penetrative sexual assault
A person is said to commit “penetrative sexual assault” if—
(a)he penetrates his penis, to any extent, into the vagina, mouth, urethra or anus of a child or makes the child to do so with him or any other person; or
(b)he inserts, to any extent, any object or a part of the body, not being the penis, into the vagina, the urethra or anus of the child or makes the child to do so with him or any other person; or
(c)he manipulates any part of the body of the child so as to cause penetration into the vagina, urethra, anus or any part of body of the child or makes the child to do so with him or any other person; or
(d)he applies his mouth to the penis, vagina, anus, urethra of the child or makes the child to do so to such person or any other person.”
Now, this Court proceeds to analyse the relevant portions of the deposition of the key prosecution witnesses which are germane for deciding this criminal appeal.
The victim (P.W.1) deposed that she attained puberty in July 2011 and one week thereafter, when her mother went for coolie work and when she was alone at home, her father forcefully penetrated his penis into her vagina and threatened to kill her and her mother Palaniammal (P.W.2), if she discloses about the occurrence to anybody. Hence, she did not disclose anything to her mother. Later, she resumed her schooling. Her father came to school during lunch recess and took her home to serve lunch for him. When she denied, he took her on compulsion 4-5 times. Everytime, he raped her and asked her to go back to school. A nurse came for routine health check up in the village and she informed the nurse that she suffers from drowsiness often. The nurse took her to the Primary Health Centre at Mela Vilankulam and after examination, she was informed that she was pregnant. The same was intimated to the Child Welfare Committee. Another nurse named Uma Gandhi (P.W.4) informed her mother (P.W.2). When her mother (P.W.2) inquired her father, he scolded her mother (P.W.2) and said that he will do like that only and that her mother (P.W.2) can do whatever she can. Thereafter, on 31.12.2014, she along with her mother (P.W.2), Shanthi (P.W.3) and Uma Gandhi (P.W.4), went to Thiruverumbur All Women Police Station and preferred the complaint (Ex.P.1). She was sent to Trichy Government Hospital for medical examination. Thereafter, she was sent to the Observation Home.
Palaniammal (P.W.2), mother of the victim (P.W.1), deposed that she came to know about the pregnancy of the victim (P.W.1) through Shanthi (P.W.3). Shanthi (P.W.3) and Uma Gandhi (P.W.4) took the victim (P.W.1) to the police station and she also accompanied them. The victim (P.W.1) gave a complaint that the appellant raped her. Palaniammal (P.W.2) stated that the appellant was convicted in a murder case and was sentenced to life imprisonment. After release of the appellant, they gave birth to the victim (P.W.1) and a male child. After attaining puberty, the victim (P.W.1) stayed at home for 16 days and she stayed along with the victim (P.W.1) for one week only and thereafter, went for work. She used to leave home at 7.00 a.m. and return only at 7.00 p.m. The victim (P.W.1) informed the police that the appellant raped her when she (P.W.2) was out for work. The victim (P.W.1) did not inform her that the appellant used to bring her from school and abuse her. When she enquired the victim (P.W.1) about her monthly menstruation, the victim (P.W.1) replied positively. She did not check whether the victim (P.W.1) had her menstruation regularly. Her statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C. was marked as Ex.P.3. She (P.W.2) was treated partially hostile and was cross-examined by the prosecution.
Shanthi (P.W.3), Nurse at Arasangudi Primary Health Centre, deposed that on 26.12.2014,when she went for supervision in Mela Vilankulam village, the villagers informed her that the victim (P.W.1) had missed her periods for 2-3 months. On 30.12.2014, she and Uma Gandhi (P.W.4) took the victim (P.W.1) to the Primary Health Centre, Arasangudi where Dr.Neelaveni (P.W.29) examined the victim (P.W.1) and found her to be pregnant. The scan report showed that the victim (P.W.1) was 32-33 weeks pregnant. When she (P.W.3) and Uma Gandhi (P.W.4) enquired the victim (P.W.1), she stated that her father had raped her at knife point. The villagers told her that the appellant had threatened them. She already knew the appellant as he was residing near her workplace. The termination of pregnancy was not possible as the victim (P.W.1) was already 7 months pregnant. Hence, the doctor sent the victim (P.W.1) to Trichy Government Hospital for treatment. The victim (P.W.1) expressed her willingness to file a complaint. She and Uma Gandhi (P.W.4), along with other nurses, viz., Devaki (P.W.5), Vimaladevi (P.W.6) and Senthamarai Selvi (P.W.7), had a discussion at the block meeting held at 30.12.2014. On 31.12.2014, Shanthi (P.W.3), Uma Gandhi (P.W.4), Devaki (P.W.5), Vimaladevi (P.W.6) and Senthamarai Selvi (P.W.7) accompanied the victim (P.W.1) and her mother Palaniammal (P.W.2) to the police station. The victim (P.W.1) made a complaint (Ex.P.1) with the respondent police.
Uma Gandhi (P.W.4), Nurse at Vengoor Health Centre, deposed that she already knew the appellant as he was residing near her workplace. Shanthi (P.W.3) told her that that when she had gone on a field visit on 26.12.2014 to ascertain who are pregnant in the village, the villagers informed her that the victim (P.W.1) had missed her periods for 2-3 months. Hence, she, along with Shanthi (P.W.3), went to the house of victim (P.W.1) and enquired her. She already knew the victim (P.W1) as they have already gone to the school where the victim (P.W.1) was studying to take class on health schemes. Victim (P.W.1) informed them she might be pregnant as she had missed her periods. They took the victim (P.W.1) to the Primary Health Centre, Arasangudi. After examination, the doctor informed them that victim (P.W.1) was 7 months pregnant. After taking scan, the pregnancy of victim (P.W.1) was confirmed. On enquiry, the victim (P.W.1) informed them that the appellant had raped her. Thereafter, on 31.12.2014, Shanthi (P.W.3), Uma Gandhi (P.W.4), Devaki (P.W.5), Vimaladevi (P.W.6) and Senthamarai Selvi (P.W.7) accompanied the victim (P.W.1) and her mother Palaniammal (P.W.2) to the police station and the victim (P.W.1) made a complaint (Ex.P.1) with the respondent police.
Devaki (P.W.5), Vimaladevi (P.W.6) and Senthamarai Selvi (P.W.7) are the witnesses who deposed about having accompanied the victim (P.W.1) and Palaniammal (P.W.2) to the police station. Kadalmani (P.W.8), President Mela VilankulamVillage, deposed that he had witnessed the appellant bringing the victim (P.W.1) from school often. Paulraj (P.W.9) and Vadivel (P.W.10), residents of Mela VilankulamVillage, deposed that school children had told them that the appellant would bring the victim (P.W.1) from school often. The accused had already undergone imprisonment. Later, they came to know through Shanthi (P.W.3) that the victim (P.W.1) is pregnant and that it is the appellant who impregnated her.
Balamuthu (P.W.11) and Rajendran (P.W.12) are the witnesses to the observation mahazar (Ex.P.35). Their signatures in the observation mahazar(Ex.P.35) are marked as Ex.P.4 and Ex.P.5 respectively. Abiyulla (P.W.13) and Rajesh (P.W.39) are witnesses to the confession statement (Ex.P.36).
Arokica Amudha (P.W.14) and Panchavarnam (P.W.15), the Police Constables, who assisted the investigating officer, deposed about taking the victim (P.W.1) to Trichy Government hospital, admitting her as in-patient and thereafter, taking her for drawing blood samples for the purpose of conducting DNA analysis, respectively. Whereas, Packiyanathan (P.W.16) and Raja (P.W.17), the Police Constables who also assisted the investigating officer, deposed about taking the appellant from Trichy Central Prison to the hospital for medical examination and for DNA test, respectively.
Thangaraj (P.W.18), Sanitary Worker in Kasthuribha Hospital, deposed about having identified the graveyard and the place where the child was buried. Chinnamani (P.W.19) and Veeraiyan (P.W.20) who are also sanitary workers in Kasthuribha Hospital deposed about having buried the body of the female child on the directions of the hospital authorities and about the exhumation of the body of the female child wrapped in green colour rubber sheet (M.O.1) and blue colour turkey towel (M.O.3).
Bhuvaneshwari (P.W.21), social worker deposed about (i) admission of the victim (P.W.1) in Kasthuribha Hospital on 25.02.2015 and about she giving birth to a female child on 05.03.2015; (ii) The reluctance of the victim (P.W.1) and Palaniammal (P.W.2) to take the child home since it was born through an incestuous relationship and handing over of the baby to the President of the Child Welfare Committee to be given in adoption to third parties; (iii)Execution of an affidavit (Ex.P.14) qua giving the female child in adoption (iv) Issuance of No Objection Certificate dated 19.05.2015 by the Child Welfare Committee for giving the female child in adoption to third parties; (v) The female child falling ill and eventually, dying later; (vi) Burying of the body of the female child on the directions of the hospital authorities; and (vii) Exhumation of the body of the female child.
Indira Gandhi (P.W.22), a practising Advocate, who at the relevant point of time was the President of Child Welfare Committee, Trichy, deposed about (i) the Inspector of Police, Thiruverumbur All Women Police Station handing over the victim (P.W.1) to be kept at the welfare home; (ii) the victim (P.W.1) being pregnant and hence, being sent to Kasthuribha Hospital for child birth; (iii) the birth of a female child to the victim (P.W.1); (iv) the female child being given in adoption as per the desire of the victim (P.W.1) and Palaniammal (P.W.2);(v) the victim (P.W.1) thereafter having been sent to Annai Home and taken care thereof; and (vi) the female child of the victim (P.W.1) having died and its body having been buried and exhumed for DNA analysis.
Shivakumar (P.W.23), Tashildar, deposed about the Inspector of Police, Thiruverumbur All Women Police Station, having requested him to be a witness for exhuming the body of a female baby for the purpose of forensic analysis and as to the exhumation and post-mortem thereof. Pathimuthu (P.W.24), Supervisor at Kasthuriba Hospital, spoke about the admission of the victim (P.W.1) for child birth, birth and adoption of the female baby, its death and burial of its body in the land belonging to Kasthuribha Hospital and about exhumation of its body for the purpose of forensic analysis.
Rameshwari (P.W.27) and Muthumari (P.W.26), Police Constables who also assisted the investigating officer deposed about taking pictures when the body of female child was exhumed and about submitting the bones, green colour rubber sheet, a part of dhothi with blue border and blue turkey towel in a sealed cover to the Mahila Court, respectively. Rameshwari (P.W.27) also deposed as to the presence of the Tashildar (P.W.23), VAO (P.W.25), Inspector of Police (P.W.42) and Forensic Science Department at the exhumation.
Poulin Mary (P.W.28), the Grade II Constable deposed that on 27.10.2015, she got the blood samples of the victim (P.W.1) and the appellant and bones of the female child in a sealed cover from Mahila Court, Trichy and she submitted it to the Forensic Science Department, Chennai on 28.10.2015 for DNA analysis. Dr.Neelaveni (P.W.29) spoke about examining the victim (P.W.1) at the Primary Health Centre and identifying that the victim (P.W.1) was pregnant. The statement given by the victim (P.W.1) to her was marked as Ex.P.21. Rani (P.W.30), the Headmistress of the school in which the victim (P.W.1) was studying, deposed that after examining the school records, she issued the bona fide certificate (Ex.P.22) as proof of age of the victim (P.W.1).
Dr.Karpagam (P.W.31), in the accident register (Ex.P.23) issued by her, opined that the victim (P.W.1) is not virgin as her vagina admits 2 fingers and the victim (P.W.1) is 30-32 weeks pregnant. Dr.Karuppasamy (P.W.32) spoke about the treatment given to the female child at Rajaji Hospital. He confirmed the death of the female child on 26.06.2015. He stated that one Josepin Mary brought the female child to Rajaji Hospital and was present till its death. The body of the female child was handed over to Josepin Mary and her signature was also obtained in the discharge summary-Mortuary card (Ex.P.16).
Rajavel (P.W.33), Assistant Professor in Forensic Science Department deposed that on 12.10.2015, when the body of the female child was exhumed, a part of thigh and skull bones were found. No injuries were found on the bone. The age and sex of the body was not ascertained as the body was already in a decomposed state. He preserved the thigh bone to be sent for DNA analysis. He gave the postmortem certificate (Ex.P.11) and exhumation certificate (Ex.P.12).
Dr. Saravanan (P.W.34), who conducted potency test for the appellant on 08.01.2015 and issued the potency certificate (Ex.P.25) deposed that on 15.10.2015, he drew the blood samples of the victim (P.W.1) and the appellant for DNA analysis. Dr. Padmavathy (P.W.35) of Kasthuribha hospital, who assisted victim (P.W.1) for delivery deposed that the victim (P.W.1) gave birth to a female baby and at that time Palaniammal (P.W.2) was also present in the hospital to help the victim (P.W.1).
Vimali Thiyagarajan (P.W.36), who conducted DNA analysis, in her DNA report (Ex.P.27), confirmed that the appellant is the biological father of the victim’s (P.W.1’s) baby. Jaya (P.W.37) who was working in Forensic Science Department, Trichy, deposed that the blood sample of the appellant was received at the lab on 08.01.2015 and it was sent to Forensic Science Department, Chennai, for ascertaining the blood group.
Gopinath (P.W.38), Judicial Magistrate I, Trichy, deposed that on 08.06.2015, he recorded the statement of Palaniammal (P.W.2) under Section 164 Cr.P.C (Ex.P.3). Nargise Karim (P.W.40), Judicial Magistrate V, Trichy deposed that on 22.01.2015, after preliminary examination of the victim (P.W.1), she recorded the statement of the victim (P.W.1) under Section 164 Cr.P.C (Ex.P.2).
Cauveriammal (P.W.41), Mumtaz Begum (P.W.42) and Selvi (P.W43) and Saranya (P.W.44) spoke about registration of the case, investigation, recording of statement of witnesses, forensic examination, alteration of the offences and filing of the final report.
In the case on hand, as per bona fide certificate (Ex.P.22) issued by Headmistress of the school (P.W.30), the victim (P.W.1) was born on 10.01.2001 and during the occurrence, she was aged 14 years and thus, a child under S.2(1)(d) of the POCSO Act. Further, the accident register (Ex.P.23) dated 31.12.2014 shows that the victim (P.W.1) was 30-32 weeks pregnant. Therefore, there arises no doubt as to whether the victim (P.W.1) was a child at the time of the first and last occurrence.
Now, coming to the offence of penetrative sexual assault under Section 3 of the POCSO Act, the victim (P.W.1) has categorically deposed in her examination-in-chief that when she was alone at home after attaining puberty, the appellant penetrated his penis into her vagina. Not stopping with that, when the victim (P.W.1) went to school, the appellant would bring her back home under the guise of being served lunch by her and after lunch, would commit penetrative sexual assault on her and this has happened for four or five days. In her complaint (Ex.P.1) as well as her statement under Section 164 CrPC (Ex.P2), the victim (P.W.1) stated about the penetrative sexual assault committed on her by the appellant. Hence, the evidence of the victim (P.W.1) is corroborated by her initial statements. In this connection, it is very pertinent to note that nothing contrary to her statement in chief was elicited during her cross-examination. Therefore, we find that the testimony of the victim (P.W.1) is found credible, cogent, clear, trustworthy and exceptionally high in quality.
The evidence of Shanthi (P.W.3) and Uma Gandhi (P.W.4) is clear that the victim (P.W.1) told them that the appellant had committed penetrative sexual assault on her. Dr.Karpagam (P.W.31), who conducted medical examination and issued accident register (Ex.P.23) deposed that when she enquired the victim (P.W.1), she was told that the appellant had committed penetrative sexual assault on her. Most importantly, the DNA report (Ex.P.27) confirms that the appellant is the father of the deceased female child. Albeit Palaniammal (P.W.2), mother of the victim (P.W.1) has partially turned hostile, it will not in anyway, affect the case of the prosecution, especially when the evidence of the victim (P.W.1) is clear, cogent and uniform and further corroborated by the medical evidence (Ex.P.27), scientific evidence and her initial statements. Hence, there are sufficient materials on record to corroborate the testimony of the victim (P.W.1), and to substantiate the case of the prosecution.
Now, this Court proceeds to examine the question as to whether the delay in lodging the complaint is fatal to the case of prosecution. This is a case where the occurrence came to light only when the victim (P.W.1) was found 30-32 weeks pregnant. Further, the delay was justified in the evidence of the victim (P.W.1) who deposed that the appellant intimidated to kill her and her mother if she discloses about his act to anyone. She further deposed that the appellant had already been convicted in a murder case and was in prison. In such circumstances, the delay in preferring the complaint cannot be termed to be unjustified. Moreso, if it were not for the identification of the pregnancy of the victim (P.W.1) by Shanthi (P.W.3) and Uma Gandhi (P.W.4), the occurrence may not have come to light leading to the complaint and subsequent FIR. Hence, this Court safely concludes that the delay in lodging the complaint is not fatal to the prosecution.
Further, the victim (P.W.1) child had given birth to a female child and later, it died and its body was buried. During the course of investigation, the child’s body was exhumed and a DNA analysis was conducted after drawing samples from the victim (P.W.1), the appellant and the female child. As per the accident register (Ex.P.23) the victim (P.W.1) was pregnant and as per the evidence of Vimali Thiyagarajan (P.W.36) as well as the DNA Report (Ex.P.27) the appellant was proved to be the biological father of the female child born to the victim (P.W.1).
Hence, this Court has no hesitation in holding that the prosecution has satisfactorily established the foundational facts that the appellant had subjected the victim (P.W.1) to penetrative sexual assault due to which the victim (P.W.1) had become pregnant and delivered a female baby. In such circumstances the prosecution is entitled to the benefit of statutory presumption under Sections 29 and 30 of the POCSO Act. When the prosecution is extended the benefit of presumption as aforesaid, what follows as a natural corollary is that the appellant has to rebut the said presumption by letting in cogent and convincing evidence satisfying the standard of preponderance of probabilities and not by pointing out immaterial and trivial lapses in the prosecution case. However, the appellant has failed to rebut the aforesaid statutory presumption by offering any plausible explanation or by letting any evidence.
Further, concededly, the appellant was a convict in a murder case and he has committed this ghastly offence of incest on his own daughter (P.W.1), not once, but on multiple occasions, to the extent of impregnating her and threatened her saying that if she spills the beans, he would eliminate her (P.W.1) and her mother (P.W.2). The victim (P.W.1) who became a prey for the appellant’s carnal pleasure, out of fear, did not divulge his act of aggravated penetrative sexual assault on her to anyone till it was found out by Shanthi (P.W.3) that she (P.W.1) was pregnant. Thus, the offence of Section 506(I) IPC also stands proved. Therefore, the conviction of the appellant for the offence under Section 506(I) IPC and the sentence therefor imposed by the Trial Court stand confirmed.
As discussed above, since the prosecution has satisfactorily established the foundational facts that the victim (P.W.1) was subjected to aggravated penetrative sexual assault by the appellant and since the appellant has miserably failed to rebut the statutory presumption under Section 29 of the POCSO Act, this Court concludes that the Trial Court is perfectly justified in finding the appellant guilty of the offence of aggravated penetrative sexual assault.
However, notwithstanding the abovesaid, what strikes this Court glaringly is that the trial Court has erred in convicting and sentencing the appellant on two fronts. Firstly, the Trial Court erred in framing charges separately under Section 5(j)(ii) r/w. 6, 5(l) r/w. 6 and 5(n) r/w. 6 of the POCSO Act. It can be seen from this error that the trial Court has failed to appreciate that the offence in the present case is that of penetrative sexual assault under Section 3, ibid. which becomes aggravated on account of three different circumstances under Section 5(j)(ii), 5(l) and 5(n) ibid., thus, the offence being punishable under only Section 6, ibid., rather than under Section 4, ibid. Owing to the aforesaid failure, not only has the charge been wrongly framed as though they are distinct offences but as a sequitur, the conviction and sentence have also been wrongly rendered and imposed respectively, as if they were separate offences forming a part of the same transaction. Hence, the appellant cannot be convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment thrice, but only once. Secondly, in any case, the Trial Court has also erred in ordering three life sentences to run consecutively in striking contrast to the ratio laid down by the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in the oft-quoted judgment in Muthuramalingam v. State [(2016) 8 SCC 313] followed in the very recent judgment in Raju Shantaram Koli v. State of Maharashtra [2026 SCC OnLine SC 2250]. Therefore, the conviction and sentence of the appellant for the offences under Sections 5(j)(ii) r/w. 6, 5(l) r/w. 6 and 5(n) r/w. 6 of the POCSO Act, imposed by the Trial Court, are modified to a conviction and sentence of imprisonment life for the offence under Section 5(j)(ii), 5(l) and 5(n) r/w. Section 6 of the POCSO Act .
With reference to reduction of sentence imposed on the appellant for the conviction of the offences under Section 5(j)(ii), 5(l) and 5(n) r/w. Section 6 of the POCSO Act, this Court finds it useful to turn to the following passage from Bhanei Prasad v. State of H.P. [2025 SCC OnLine SC 1636], in which it was held unequivocally that the accused in an incestuous sexual violence case does not deserve to be shown leniency in sentencing:
“13.When a father who is expected to be a shield, a guardian, a moral compass, becomes the source of the most severe violation of a child's bodily integrity and dignity, the betrayal is not only personal but institutional. The law does not, and cannot, condone such acts under the guise of rehabilitation or reform. Incestuous sexual violence committed by a parent is a distinct category of offence that tears through the foundational fabric of familial trust and must invite the severest condemnation in both language and sentence. The home, which should be a sanctuary, cannot be permitted to become a site of unspeakable trauma, and the courts must send a clear signal that such offences will be met with an equally unsparing judicial response. To entertain a plea for leniency in a case of this nature would not merely be misplaced, it would constitute a betrayal of the Court's own constitutional duty to protect the vulnerable. When a child is forced to suffer at the hands of her own father, the law must speak in a voice that is resolute and uncompromising. There can be no mitigation in sentencing for crimes that subvert the very notion of family as a space of security. (emphasis supplied by this Court)
From the above, this Court is inclined to give due weightage to the fact that the victim (P.W.1) had suffered repeated aggravated penetrative sexual assault from none other than her own father who was entrusted with the primary responsibility to protect her from perpetrators. Hence, this Court finds that as strongly emphasised by the Apex Court, incestuous sexual violence committed by a parent is a distinct category of offence and hence, is an exceptional circumstance that requires no leniency in sentencing. Accordingly, the life sentence imposed on the appellant requires no reduction.
Further, this Court notices that neither has any victim compensation been granted to the victim (P.W.1) nor has any reason been assigned by the Trial Court for declining to grant the same. In other words, to put it pithily, the aspect of grant of victim compensation was left untouched. This Court is of the opinion that the victim compensation is necessary to alleviate the physical and emotional injuries suffered by the victim (P.W.1) at the very hands of her own father. Having said thus, this Court, once again, turns to Bhanei Prasad, supra, wherein the Supreme Court had granted a compensation of Rs.10,50,000/- to the victim child who suffered incestuous aggravated penetrative sexual assault at the very hands of her very own father, as in the present case. Hence, since the present case also involves the very same exceptional circumstance, this Court deems it fit to grant compensation to the victim (P.W.1).
In the result, while confirming the guilt of the appellant qua his acts of aggravated penetrative sexual assault and criminal intimidation, this Court allows this criminal appeal in part to the limited extent of modifying the conviction and sentence as under:
| Penal Provision | Imprisonment | Fine Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Section 5(j)(ii), 5(l) and 5(n) r/w. Section 6 of the POCSO Act | Life imprisonment | Rs.1,000/- in default to undergo one year simple imprisonment |
| Section 506(I) IPC | One year rigorous imprisonment | Rs.500/- in default to undergo six months simple imprisonment |
| The aforesaid sentences shall run concurrently. | ||
Further, as per G.O.(Ms)No.33, Department of Social Welfare and Nutritious Meal Programme dated 03.10.2020 and G.O.(Ms)No.32, Department of Social Welfare and Women Empowerment dated 10.07.2021, the Commissioner/Director of Social Defence is consequently directed to disburse a compensation of Rs.10,00,000/-, to the victim (P.W.1), within a period of thirty (30) days from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. The District Legal Services Authority, Tiruchirappalli, District, is directed to ensure that the compensation amount is paid to the victim (P.W.1) within the aforesaid timeline.
Before bringing the curtains down, this Court expresses its deep sense of anguish and displeasure in the manner in which the victim (P.W.1) has been subjected to irrelevant and insensitive questions posed in the cross-examination by the learned counsel for the defence. It is to be noted that the Special Courts should not be mute spectators to such insensitive questioning by the defence and they should take strong exception to the same, thereby ensuring that the poor victim children are not subjected to embarrassment by being posed with irrelevant questions and that the object of the POCSO Act, more particularly, Section 33(6), ibid., is not rendered otiose. It must be highlighted here that years before the introduction of the POCSO Act and the codification of the safeguards to the victims of sexual offences thereof from being subjected to gruesome cross-examination, it is a pathetic plight that the criticism discussed at paragraph 22 of the judgement in State of Punjab v. Gurmit Singh [(1996) 2 SCC 384] remains unchanged till date. Paragraph 22 of Gurmit Singh, supra which is of utmost relevance, is as follows:
“22.There has been lately, lot of criticism of the treatment of the victims of sexual assault in the court during their cross-examination. The provisions of Evidence Act regarding relevancy of facts notwithstanding, some defence counsel adopt the strategy of continual questioning of the prosecutrix as to the details of the rape. The victim is required to repeat again and again the details of the rape incident not so much as to bring out the facts on record or to test her credibility but to test her story for inconsistencies with a view to attempt to twist the interpretation of events given by her so as to make them appear inconsistent with her allegations. The court, therefore, should not sit as a silent spectator while the victim of crime is being cross-examined by the defence. It must effectively control the recording of evidence in the court. While every latitude should be given to the accused to test the veracity of the prosecutrix and the credibility of her version through cross-examination, the court must also ensure that cross-examination is not made a means of harassment or causing humiliation to the victim of crime. A victim of rape, it must be remembered, has already undergone a traumatic experience and if she is made to repeat again and again, in unfamiliar surroundings what she had been subjected to, she may be too ashamed and even nervous or confused to speak and her silence or a confused stray sentence may be wrongly interpreted as “discrepancies and contradictions” in her evidence.” (emphasis supplied by this Court)
Having expressed our anguish and displeasure, we take this instance as an opportunity to remind the Courts dealing with the trial of sexual offences, of Section 33(6) of the POCSO Act and the observations made in Gurmit Singh, supra. The Courts dealing with the trial of sexual offences are hereby directed to have due regard to the aforesaid and avoid aggressive and irrelevant questioning or character assassination of the child and also ensure that the dignity of the victims is maintained throughout the trial.
