AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
[Per : URMILA JOSHI-PHALKE, J.]
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard finally by consent of the learned counsel for the parties.
The present petition challenges the order passed by the Scheduled Tribe Caste Certificate Scrutiny Committee, Yavatmal in validating the caste claim of the present petitioner by order dated 11.07.2025.
The petitioner claims to be the “Thakur” Scheduled Tribe which is recognized at Serial No.44 in the list of the Scheduled Tribe Notification. The Sub-Divisional Officer, Washim has issued the Caste Certificate to the present petitioner on 29.05.2023 of “Thakur” Scheduled Tribe. The petitioner is a student and belongs to the Scheduled Tribe category, therefore, for availing the benefits prescribed for reserved category candidate, petitioner herein had submitted a proposal along with necessary documents for verification of tribe claim to the respondent Caste Scrutiny Committee. It is contended that the petitioner relied upon the pre-constitutional documents, however, the Committee has not considered the same and on the basis of the Vigilance report invalidated the caste claim of the present petitioner. It is further contended that despite the validities are granted in the family, the Committee has not considered the same and invalidated the caste claim of the petitioner and, therefore, present petitioner approached to this Court.
Heard learned counsel Mr. Kalmegh for the petitioner. He reiterated the said contentions and submitted that the documents i.e. Kotwal book showing the name of Hiraman Thakur, who is the grandfather of the present petitioner recorded as “Thakur” during the pre-constitutional era. The said document is having highest probative value which was not considered by the Committee. The Committee has also not considered the earlier validities granted to the aunt of the present petitioner.
In view of the judgment of this Court, in Writ Petition No.4830/2019 [Akanksha Gajendra Nimke Vs. Schedule Tribe Caste Certificate Scrutiny Committee, Amravati dated 11.07.2019], wherein the aspect of area restriction is already considered by this Court, in view of the judgment of the Apex Court and granted validity. Despite the validity is granted in the family, the Committee has invalidated the caste claim only on the basis of the Vigilance report. He submitted that in Writ Petition No.4830/2019 (supra), this Court has specifically observed that in the case of Akanksha Nimke, who is the aunt of the present petitioner, the vigilance Cell has conducted the inquiry, verified the documents and Vigilance Cell found that the entries are correct. Despite this observation, the Vigilance Cell in the case of the present petitioner assigned the reason that the petitioner is resident of Shaha village and no document is produced in support of the same. Thus, for the above said reasons, the order passed by the Committee deserves to be quashed and set aside.
Per contra, learned AGP strongly opposed the said contention and submitted that the Vigilance Cell report specifically states that though petitioner claims to belong to the “Thakur” Scheduled Tribe and relied upon the entry of the year 1925 recorded in the name of Hiraman Thakur the great-grandfather of the present petitioner. But, the Vigilance inquiry specifically states that they are not resident of Shaha and therefore, the petitioner failed to establish the caste claim. She also submitted that the caste claim of the present petitioner is invalidated on area restriction also. In view of that, no interference is called for.
After hearing both sides and on perusal of the record, it reveals that petitioner is a student and pursuing his education. The family tree on which the petitioner relied upon shows that Hiraman is the great-grandfather of the present petitioner. Hiraman is having two sons, namely Pandurang and Madhukar. Madhukar is having son, namely Gagendra, who is having two children Ashutosh and Akanksha. Akanksha, who is the aunt of the present petitioner already granted with the validity whereas the present petitioner is the great grandson of Pandurang i.e. the brother of Madhukar.
We also perused the Vigilance report. During the Vigilance inquiry, the Vigilance Officer has observed that the petitioner has shown that his forefathers were residents of Mouza Shaha, Taluka Karanja, District Washim, however, no document is produced in support of the said contention and on the basis of the said observation, the Committee has invalidated the caste claim of the present petitioner.
Undisputedly, the present petitioner has produced before the Committee the documents including the document of the year 1925, which shows that the great-grandfather of the petitioner was recorded as “Thakur” and there are consistent entries after that against the names of the forefathers recorded as “Thakur”. The order passed by the Committee, nowhere shows that there are any contrary entries found during the Vigilance report. Thus, only Vigilance report shows that the present petitioner is not resident of village Shaha. The point regarding area restriction is already considered by this Court in Writ petition No.4830/2019 (supra), wherein it is observed that the point regarding area restriction is covered by the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Jaywant Dilip Pawar Vs. State of Maharashtra and Ors. reported in 2018 (5) All M R 975 (S.C.). The Apex Court has held that after the amendment to the second schedule by Second Schedule Act No.108 of 1976, the area restrictions are removed. It is further observed that it was the case for the claim of Thakur-Scheduled Tribe in the State of Maharashtra and the High Court confirmed the rejection by the Committee on the ground that the relatives of the appellant were not residents in the areas mentioned in the Presidential Order of 1956. The Apex Court allowed the appeal and quashed and set aside the decision of this Court. In view of this, the point is no longer open to challenge and the Committee fell in error in rejecting the claim of the petitioner on the ground of area restriction.
The reasoning given in the earlier writ petition while granting the validity to the aunt of the present petitioner, it is further observed by this Court that the Vigilance report in the case of Akanksha Nimke wherein the Vigilance inquiry was conducted and the documents were verified and Vigilance Cell found the said entries are correct. Thus, the Vigilance Cell, which was conducted in the case of Akanksha Nimke verifies the entries and found corrected, whereas, the Vigilance Cell which has acted in the case of the present petitioner gives the contrary report. The relationship of the petitioner with the person in whose documents verified by the Vigilance Cell is also not disputed.
As far as the document regarding pre-constitutioal era is concerned, now it is well settled law that the pre-constitutional document is having the highest probative value. Moreover, the affinity test is also not a litmus test and, therefore, the invalidation on the ground of the affinity test as well as area restriction is not sustainable in view of the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Anand vs. Committee for Scrutiny and Verification of Tribe Claims and ors, reported in 2011 (6) Mh.L.J. (S.C.) 919.
As already observed that the validity already granted to one of the family members with the detailed reason and therefore, the Committee ought to have consider the judgment of Apoorva d/o Vinay Nichale Vs. Divisional Caste Certificate Scrutiny Committee No.1 and others reported in 2010(6) Mh.L.J. 401, wherein it has been held that once a validity certificate has been issued to a close paternal blood relative after due scrutiny, the same constitutes a strong piece of evidence which cannot ordinarily be disregarded unless it is shown that such certificate was obtained by fraud or misrepresentation.
The Committee ignored the judgment of this Court and acted as an appellate Court despite there is clear observation of this Court in Writ Petition No. 4830/2019 (supra), such practice of the Committee requires to be deprecated.
In view of the above discussion, the order passed by the respondent Committee dated 11.07.2025, is hereby quashed and set aside.
The claim of the petitioner for ”Thakur” Scheduled Tribe which is an entry at Serial No.44 of the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order, 1950, held to be valid.
The petitioner is declared as a “Thakur” Scheduled Tribe.
The Committee is directed to issue the Caste Validity Certificate to the petitioner declaring he belongs to the “Thakur” Scheduled Tribe, within a period of eight weeks.
Rule is made absolute in above terms. No order as to costs.
