AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Heard learned counsel for the Appellant as well as learned counsel appearing for the Respondent. This Appeal has been filed against order dated 17.09.2020 passed by the Adjudicating Authority (National Company Law Tribunal), Ahmedabad Bench, Ahmedabad, Court No. 2 by which the Application filed by the Appellant under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Code’) has been dismissed as not maintainable.
A notice dated 05.01.2019 in Form IV under Section 8 was issued by the Appellant which was signed by one Shri Kailash Shukla who was the Managing Director of the Appellant. Reply to the said notice was given by the Respondent – Corporate Debtor on 22.02.2019 which has been placed on record at page 284 of the Appeal. The Reply was addressed to “M/s Kailash Devbuild (India) Private Limited Through: Mr. Kailash Shukla, Managing Director, 817, Hatilal, Jabalpur – 482001, Madhya Pradesh”. It is after the Reply to the notice, Application under Section 9 was filed by the Appellant which came to be rejected by the impugned order for reasons recorded in para 8 of the judgment, which is to the following effect:
“On perusal of the record it is found that the demand
notice dated 05.01.2019 (page 257-267), which is a
pre-requisite under section 8 of the Insolvency &
Bankruptcy Code, 2016 for filing the petition under
section 9, is signed and issued by one Mr. Kailash
Shukla, said to be Director of the applicant company
whereas the Board Resolution authorising Mr.
Kailash Shukla is of 14.02.2019. That means, at the
time of issuing the demand notice dated 05.01.2019,
Mr. Kailash Shukla had no authority to sign and issue
such notice. Moreover, the Board Resolution also do
not specifically empower Mr. Bhanu Shukla to initiate
CIRP against the corporate debtor. Admittedly,
Director of a company can issue the notice on behalf
of the client but due authorisation is required by
passing resolution in duly convened Board Meeting
and in the instant case the demand notice was issued
prior to passing the Board Resolution.”
Learned counsel for the Appellant submits that Shri Kailash Shukla, who has signed the demand notice dated 05.01.2019 was the Managing Director of the Appellant and was fully competent to issue the notice under Section 8. It is submitted that Board Resolution dated 14.02.2019 which has been referred to in the impugned order was for filing application under Section 9 in which one Mr. Bhanu Shukla was authorised. The Board Resolution is referred to is at page 283 of the Appeal which provides that Mr. Bhanu Shukla is authorised to execute and deliver such letters of appointment, powers of attorney and such other documents of the company as may be appropriate to carrying out the intent of the resolutions.
Learned counsel for the Respondent submits that the Board Resolution was issued on 14.02.2019 whereas notice was issued under Section 8 on 05.01.2019 signed by Mr. Kailash Shukla.
We have considered submissions of learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
The Section 8 notice which has been brought on record was signed by Mr. Kailash Shukla who was the Managing Director of the Appellant Company with regard to this there is no dispute since Reply to the demand notice was sent to the Appellant through ‘Mr. Kailash Shukla, Managing Director’ as noted above. The application under Section 9 is filed by Mr. Bhanu Shukla who was authorised by Board Resolution dated 14.02.2019.
Learned Adjudicating Authority has observed that at the time of issuing the demand notice on 05.01.2019, Mr. Kailash Shukla has no authority to sign and issue such notice. The above observation cannot be approved. The Managing Director of the Applicant was fully authorised to issue demand notice under Section 8. We, thus, do not approve the reason given for rejecting application under Section 9 as there is no dispute that notice under Section 8 was signed by Mr. Kailash Shukla who was Managing Director of the Applicant. Moreso, when application under Section 9 was filed by the person who was authorised by Board Resolution dated 14.02.2019, there was no occasion for the Adjudicating Authority to reject the application on aforesaid grounds.
We, thus, are of the view that impugned order dated 17.09.2020 deserves to be set aside and is hereby set aside. In result, impugned order is set aside and application under Section 9 is revived before the Adjudicating Authority, which may now be considered and decided by the Adjudicating Authority in accordance with law.
We make it clear that we have not entered into the merits of the case and we have not expressed any opinion on the merits. It is for the Adjudicating Authority to consider all questions in accordance with law. In view of the fact that application is of the year 2019, the Adjudicating Authority shall make all endeavours to dispose of the matter as early as possible. The Appeal is allowed.
