AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Mr. Praveen Dhurandhar, learned counsel, appearing for the appellant.
Mr. Punit Ruparel, learned counsel, appearing for the respondent Nos. 1 to 3.
Mr. Swapnil Thawani, on behalf of Mr. P.R. Patankar, learned counsel, appearing for the respondent No. 4.
Heard on admission.
This appeal is admitted on the following substantial question of law:
“Whether the learned Commissioner was justified in imposing a penalty to the extent of 50% against the appellant without affording him an opportunity of hearing?”
Issue notice to the respondents.
Mr. Punit Ruparel and Mr. Swapnil Tawani, learned counsel, accept notice on behalf of the respective respondents.
With the consent of the parties, the appeal is heard finally.
This appeal under Section 30 of the Employees’ Compensation Act, 1923 (for short, “the Act of 1923”), has been filed by the appellant/employer, assailing the judgment dated 11.01.2024 passed by the Commissioner, Employees’ Compensation-cum-Labour Court, Bastar, Place Jagdalpur, (C.G.), in Compensation Case No. 10/2022/E.C.Act/F, whereby compensation of Rs.16,01,775/- was awarded in favour of respondent Nos. 1 to 3 and, simultaneously, a penalty of 50% of the said amount, i.e., Rs. 8,00,888/-, was also imposed upon the appellant/employer.
The parties shall hereinafter be referred to as the claimants, employer and insurance company, respectively.
A claim application under Section 22 of the Act of 1923 was filed by the claimants, seeking compensation of Rs.17,35,280/- on account of the death of Samir Soni in an accident that occurred on 02.04.2022, resulting in his death during the course of and arising out of his employment with the employer.
The claim application was resisted by the respondents on various grounds.
The learned Commissioner, after framing the issues and recording the evidence of the parties, decided the same and awarded the aforesaid compensation along with penalty.
Being aggrieved by the imposition of penalty, the appellant/employer has preferred the present appeal.
Learned counsel for the appellant/employer submits that the learned Commissioner erred in imposing the aforesaid penalty upon the employer without affording him an opportunity of hearing, which is contrary to the provisions contained in Section 4-A(3)(b) of the Act of 1923. It is further submitted that even if the Commissioner decides to impose a penalty upon the employer, the employer is required to be afforded a reasonable opportunity of hearing to justify the reasons for non-payment of compensation within one month from the date of the accident. It is contended that the aforesaid procedure has not been duly followed by the learned Commissioner while passing the impugned order imposing penalty upon the employer.
Learned counsel places reliance upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Oriental Insurance Company Limited v. Siby George and Others, reported in (2012) 12 SCC 540.
He further submits that the substantial question of law deserves to be answered in the affirmative in favour of the appellant and the appeal deserves to be allowed by setting aside the impugned order to the extent of imposition of penalty upon the appellant/employer.
Per contra, learned counsel for respondent Nos. 1 to 3 submits that the employer was required to deposit the compensation within one month from the date of the accident, which he failed to do. It is further submitted that the employer had deposited only Rs.50,000/-, which was not supported by any documentary evidence. According to learned counsel, this aspect of the matter was duly considered by the learned Commissioner, who found that there was no justifiable reason for the appellant/employer not to deposit the compensation within the prescribed period. Therefore, the impugned award imposing penalty upon the employer is justified.
Learned counsel for respondent No. 4 submits that the insurance company has already satisfied the award and, therefore, the dispute presently survives only between the employer and the claimants.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the records.
In order to appreciate the controversy involved in the present appeal, it is apt to refer to the provisions contained in Section 4-A of the Act of 1923, which read as under:
“4A. Compensation to be paid when due and penalty for default :-
(1)Compensation under section 4 shall be paid as soon as it falls due.
(2)In cases where the employer does not accept the liability for compensation to the extent claimed, he shall be bound to make provisional payment based on the extent of liability which he accepts, and, such payment shall be deposited with the Commissioner or made to the employee, as the case may be, without prejudice to the right of the employee to make any further claim.
(3)Where any employer is in default in paying the compensation due under this Act within one month from the date it fell due, the Commissioner shall :-
(a)direct that the employer shall, in addition to the amount of the arrears, pay simple interest thereon at the rate of twelve per cent. per annum or at such higher rate not exceeding the maximum of the lending rates of any scheduled bank as may be specified by the Central Government, by notification in the Official Gazette, on the amount due; and
(b)if, in his opinion, there is no justification for the delay, direct that the employer shall, in addition to the amount of the arrears and interest thereon, pay a further sum not exceeding fifty per cent. of such amount by way of penalty:
Provided that an order for the payment of penalty shall not be passed under clause (b) without giving a reasonable opportunity to the employer to show cause why it should not be passed.
Explanation. :-For the purposes of this sub-section, "scheduled bank" means a bank for the time being included in the Second Schedule to the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934 (2 of 1934).
(3A) The interest and the penalty payable under sub-section (3) shall be paid to the employee or his dependant, as the case may be.”
A perusal of the aforesaid provisions makes it abundantly clear that the Commissioner is empowered to award interest as well as penalty in terms of clauses (a) and (b) of sub-section (3) of Section 4-A of the Act of 1923.
However, the provisions also make it clear that where the Commissioner is satisfied that the employer is liable to pay a penalty, a reasonable opportunity of hearing ought to have been afforded to the employer to justify the reasons for non-payment of compensation within one month from the date of the accident.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of Siby George (supra), had occasion to deal with the aforesaid provisions and held that before passing any order imposing penalty, a reasonable opportunity of hearing ought to have been granted to the employer. In paragraph 8 of the aforesaid judgment, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed as under:
“8.It is, thus, to be seen that sub-section (3) of Section 4-A is in two parts, separately dealing with interest and penalty in clauses (a) and (b) respectively. Clause (a) makes the levy of interest, with no option, in case of default in payment of compensation, without going into the question regarding the reasons for the default. Clause (b) provides for imposition off penalty in case, in the opinion of the Commissioner, there was no justification for the delay. Before imposing penalty, however, the Commissioner is required to give the employer a reasonable opportunity to show cause. On a plain reading of the provisions of sub-section (3) it becomes clear that payment of interest is a consequence of default in payment without going into the reasons for the delay and it is only in case where the delay is without justification, the employer might also be held liable to penalty after giving him a show cause. Therefore, a finding to the effect that the delay in payment of the amount due was unjustified is required to be recorded only in case of imposition of penalty and no such finding is required in case of interest which is to be levied on default per se.”
In the opinion of this Court, if the learned Commissioner had decided to impose a penalty upon the employer, he ought to have afforded a reasonable opportunity to the employer to justify the reasons for non-payment of compensation within one month from the date of the accident.
In view of the aforesaid, the substantial question of law deserves to be answered in the affirmative, in favour of the appellant.
This Court is inclined to remit the matter to the learned Commissioner with a direction to comply with the provisions contained in Section 4-A(3) (b) of the Act of 1923 by issuing notice to the appellant/employer and affording him a reasonable opportunity of hearing.
Thereafter, the learned Commissioner shall pass an appropriate order in respect of the imposition of penalty upon the employer, in accordance with law.
Accordingly, the appeal is allowed in part. The impugned award, insofar as it relates to the imposition of penalty upon the appellant/employer, is hereby set aside.
The parties shall appear before the learned Commissioner on 12.01.2027.
It is expected that the learned Commissioner shall make all endeavours to decide the matter expeditiously.
