High CourtsSINGLE BENCH(2017) 07 KL CK 0015

JOSE, vs THE EMPLOYEES STATE INSURANCE CORPORATION,

High Court Of Kerala · Decided on 14 July 2017

HON’BLE JUDGES
K.Vinod Chandran
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
23106 of 2017 (K)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

23 paragraphs · 1,018 words
1.

The petitioners are father and daughter, who claim benefit under Exhibit P2 as a "ward of insured person" for admission to the MBBS Course in the Medical College run by the Employees' State Insurance Corporation [for brevity "ESI Corporation"]. The benefit as per Exhibit P2 is for the wards of insured persons under the Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948 [for brevity "ESI Act"].

There is a criteria provided in Exhibit P2, which, according to the 1st respondent-Corporation, has not been satisfied by the 1st petitioner and hence there can be no certificate of "ward of insured person" issued.

2.

The claim has to be decided on the facts of the case.

The employer has issued Exhibit P1 showing the contributions made with respect to the employee. Even according to the petitioners, the 1st petitioner was working as a Receptionist in Hotel New Excellency at Karunagappally. There was a strike of the employees in the said hotel and there was no employment and, hence, no contribution paid under the ESI Act for the said period.

Later on, the 1st petitioner was transferred to Hotel New Indraprastha, Adoor; which was also under the same management. It is, hence, Hotel Indraprastha has issued Exhibit P1 showing the contribution from 01.10.2011 to 31.03.2017.

3.

The respondents have filed a counter affidavit, in which it is specifically indicated that there was no contributions made for the period between April, 2015 to March, 2016. As per the admission policy as seen from Exhibit P2, the contribution for the period specified in Groups I, II and II has to be made on or before

01.01.2017.

4.

The objection is insofar as the 1st petitioner having not satisfied the criteria of Group I, II and III preference, as is indicated in Clause 4.5 of Exhibit P4. The Group Classification is as follows:

"Group-I: IPs who have been in continuous insurable employment for a minimum period of five years as on 1st January of the year of admission and have paid at least 78 days of contribution in each Contribution Period (09), during this five year period.

Group-II: IPs who have been in continuous insurable employment for a minimum period of four years as on 1st January of the year of admission and have paid at least 78 days of contribution in each Contribution Period (06), during this four year period.

Group-III: IPs who have been in continuous insurable employment for a minimum period of three years as on 1st January of the year of admission and have paid at least 78 days of contribution in each Contribution Period (05), during this three year period".

It is submitted by the learned Counsel appearing for the petitioners that the condition is only that the employment should be continuous as on 01.01.2017.

5.

The mandate as per the ESI Act is for paying contributions at the end of every month, on payment of salary, from which the employee's contribution is also deducted. It is a mandate on the employer to make such contribution on the very same month in which the salary is paid. Hence, this Court is inclined to accept the contention of the Corporation that the contributions ought to be made immediately and not far later, to be in accordance with the ESI Act and Rules.

6.

In the present case, the 1st petitioner was out of employment between April, 2015 to March, 2016. No wages were paid to the 1st petitioner and he was transferred and appointed to the other establishment only in 2016. Even in such establishment the contributions were not made and the same has been made for the earlier period only on 06.06.2017, just prior to the filing of the writ

petition.

7.

It is the contention of the learned Standing Counsel appearing for the Corporation that if this is permitted, any employee whose contributions were not paid could make up the payments by himself at a later stage without the wages also being paid and thus come within the preference as available under the admission policy.

The contribution has to be during the period of employment when wages are received by the employees. In this context, the learned Standing Counsel also relies on a Division Bench judgment of this Court in W.A.No.1993 of 2016, dated 07.10.2016.

8.

In W.A.No.1993 of 2016, there was only one day's shortage in one of the contribution periods, for reason of absence from work and the Division Bench refused to grant the preference as available from the admission policy, finding that a strict interpretation has to be given to such preferences; otherwise it would go against the normal rule of equality. It was held so:

"If this Court shows leniency in favour of one person, it will have cascading effect all over the State as well as the country. Such guidelines will have to be strictly construed in order to streamline the system. It is no doubt, true that as is clear from certain orders, this Court has taken a lenient view in one or two matters. That does not mean that such leniency should continue in future also without following the guidelines which are being followed in the entire country. In view of the same, we do not find any ground to interfere with the judgment passed by the learned Single Judge".

9.

The prescription of at least 78 days of contribution, in a contribution period of 6 months is also very reasonable. There would be a total of about 180 days in a six month period with about 150 working days. The prescription for even a Group I preference is only payment of contribution or attendance for little more than half the total working days.

10.

In the present case, the absence is of about one year.

The contention of the ESI Corporation that even the wages has not been paid and therefore there is no question of payment of contribution, is also of significant import. For the above reasons, this Court does not find any reason to exercise discretion in favour of the petitioners in this case.

The writ petition would stand dismissed.