High CourtsSingle Bench(2012) 08 P&H CK 0048

Joginder Kumar vs Mukesh Kumar Shingala

Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · Decided on 24 August 2012

HON’BLE JUDGES
K. Kannan, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
C.R. No. 3670 of 1998

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

13 paragraphs · 500 words

K. Kannan, J.—The revision petition is at the instance of a tenant challenging the validity of the fair rent as fixed by the Rent Controller that

was affirmed by the Appellate Authority. Learned counsel began his argument by seeking to contend that rent had been fixed in October, 1992 @

Rs. 300/- per month and the petition had been filed within 5 years, which went against the interdict of Section 5 of the Act. I find this contention to be wrong and misleading, for the case itself was considered on a plea by the landlord that after the death of the father when he demanded Rs.

300/- as rent, the tenant, who originally accepted, did not pay the rent. He was, therefore, contending for fixation of fair rent on the basis that the rent had been changed to Rs. 190/- per month from the year 1978 when he was initiated as a tenant and that the fair rent has to be fixed on that

basis. In appeal, the tenant wanted to contend that there had been some receipts given by the father fixing the rent at Rs. 190/- in the year 1992

and therefore, the base year must be given as 1992. This contention was also found to be false, for the Court found that the documents sought to be produced as additional evidence were photocopies and there had been no reason given as to why the originals-were not filed. The Appellate

Authority further reasoned that these documents themselves had not been confronted to the witness landlord when he was examined and therefore,

there was no basis for reception of the secondary evidence. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner wants to contend that these documents must have been taken as additional evidence. The fundamental question arises as to why the person, who was trying to rely on photocopies, could not produce the originals. Secondary evidence could not be admitted unless there is a foundation laid down in the manner that law requires. No such basis for production of secondary evidence was given. The rejection of additional piece of evidence was, therefore, justified.

2.

The determination of fair rent has been by the application of the principle laid down u/s 4 of the Act when the Appellate Authority has found that

if the base rent was taken as Rs. 190/- per month in the year 1978, the increase had to be with reference to the whole sale price index of 825

points in the year 1995 which meant an increase of All India Wholesale Index at 650 points and 25% of the same came to 160% increase. The said percentage of the basic rent of Rs. 190/- came to Rs. 304. This was the permissible increase and the Rent Controller had fixed the rent to be

Rs. 190+304 = Rs. 494/- per month. The fixation of fair rent conforms to the formula laid down u/s 4 of the Act. There is no scope for

interference. The revision petition is, therefore, dismissed.