High CourtsDivision Bench(2021) 12 KL CK 0165

Jephin.E.Eapen vs Nitha Anu Abraham

High Court Of Kerala · Decided on 22 December 2021

HON’BLE JUDGES
A.Muhamed Mustaque, J · Sophy Thomas, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
MAT.Appeal No. 129 Of 2020

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

31 paragraphs · 2,219 words

Sophy Thomas, J

1.

The appellant Sri.Jephin K Eapen is the father and the respondent Smt.Nitha Anu Abraham is the mother of the minor child Jeev Jephin. The appellant filed these appeals against the judgment and decree in O.P No.566 of 2017 and O.P No.826 of 2017 on the file of Family Court, Kottayam at Ettumanoor. He filed O.P No.826 of 2017 and the respondent filed O.P No.566 of 2017, both for getting permanent custody of the minor child. The Family Court allowed O.P No.566 of 2017 declaring the respondent-wife as the guardian of the minor child. She was given permanent custody of the child, with permission to take the child abroad with her, reserving visitation rights for the appellant-father. O.P No.826 of 2017 filed by the appellant-husband was dismissed. Assailing the impugned judgment and decree in O.P No.566 of 2017, he has preferred Mat.Appeal No.129 of 2020, and against the judgment and decree in O.P No.826 of 2017, he has preferred Mat.Appeal No.292 of 2020.

2.

The marriage between the appellant and respondent was solemnised on 27.08.2012 as per Christian rites and ceremonies. The minor Jeev Jephin was born in their wedlock on 17.05.2015. Due to marital discord, they got separated and the minor child was with the respondent-mother. Later, as per the judgment in O.P No.564 of 2017, their marriage was dissolved. Now, the respondent-wife is working in Germany, and since the appellant-husband filed Mat.Appeal and obtained stay order against operation of the judgment and decree in O.P No. 566 of 2017, the respondent-mother could not take the child to Germany, and now the child is residing with its maternal grandparents.

3.

The appellant is assailing the impugned judgments on three grounds;

(i) If  the  child  is  taken  to  Germany  by  the respondent-mother, the child will be deprived of the paternal love and care for ever.

(ii) The respondent-mother is having some mental depression and so, she is not capable of attending the welfare and well-being of the child.

(iii) The appellant is financially stable compared to the respondent, and he is capable of giving quality education to the child.

4.

The Family Court, Kottayam tried O.P No.566 of 2017 and O.P No.826 of 2017 jointly with O.P. No.564 of 2017 and O.P.No.565 of 2017, and a common judgment was delivered on 31.12.2019. PWs 1 to 7 were examined and Exts.A1 to A27 were marked from the side of the wife. RWs 1 to 3 were examined and Exts.B1 to B63 were marked from the side of the husband. Exts.C1 and C1(a) were marked as court exhibits.

5.

The grounds taken up by the appellant in these Mat.Appeals were seen agitated before the Family Court also. After evaluating the facts and evidence, the Family Court found that the minor child Jeev Jephin being a little child aged only five years, was eagerly waiting to join his mother abroad and he expressed his desire to be with his mother. After analysing the evidence, the Family Court found that, considering the welfare and well-being of the child, it was better for the child to be with his mother and accordingly, the mother was declared as the guardian of the child and permanent custody was also given to her, with permission to take the child abroad.

6.

Now let us scrutinise the impugned judgments in the light of the available evidence to find out whether there is any illegality or impropriety warranting interference by this Court.

7.

Admittedly, the marriage between the appellant and the respondent was dissolved by a decree of Family Court, Kottayam at Ettumanoor. The minor Jeev Jephin is the only child born in their wedlock, and now he is only six years old. The respondent-wife is working as a Staff Nurse in Germany and she is ready and willing to take the child to Germany with her where she could provide all facilities to the child including his education. According to her, German Government is providing so many amenities to working mothers, and free education and medical assistance is being given to children apart from other financial benefits. That aspect is not under challenge. The appellant has no dispute with regard to the employment of the respondent-wife in Germany, and her financial capacity to take care of the child. Since the child Jeev Jephin is only six years old, it is not fair to deny him the warmth of mother's love at this tender-age. It is true that, he has to get the love and affection of his father too, for which provision can be made for interaction with the child everyday and to get custody of the child during school vacation. Moreover, whenever the respondent-wife comes down to Kerala along with the child, the appellant can get custody of the child on taking orders from the Family Court. So, his contention that if the child is taken to Germany, the child will be deprived of its father's love and affection forever cannot be accepted.

8.

The second ground put forward by him is that the respondent-wife is having mental depression, for which she was taking treatment and so, she is not a fit person to be appointed as the guardian of the child, and she is not having mental capacity to attend the welfare and well-being of the child, especially in a foreign country. The Family Court analysed the testimony of RW2 Doctor and RW3, the Psychologist with Exts.B15(a) and B15(b) documents, to find that the respondent was having 'reactive depression' which can be caused owing to pressure of circumstances, as deposed by RW2. It can be due to mental, physical or sexual harassment. RW2 categorically stated that, apart from reactive depression, respondent was not having any other problem and the medicines prescribed was only for bringing down her anxiety. The testimony of RW3 and the document Ext.B15(b) were found not acceptable and it was rightly rejected by the Family Court.

9.

The divorce was granted on the ground of mental cruelties inflicted on the wife by the husband. According to the respondent, her mental strain was solely due to the harassment by the appellant, who was a suspicious character. The Family Court found that, looking on the wife with suspicion without any reasonable cause, alleging aspersions about her character etc. will amount to mental cruelty which could have forced her to a state of depression, and as stated by RW2 Doctor, the reactive depression of PW1 could have been caused, due to the pressure of the circumstances on account of mental, physical or sexual harassment. The decree of divorce granted by the Family Court on the ground of matrimonial cruelties inflicted by the appellant on the wife by the husband is not seen challenged. So, the mental cruelties alleged against the husband was proved and it stands confirmed, since the divorce decree has not been challenged.

10.

The fact being that the respondent suffered reactive depression due to mental harassment from the side of the appellant and she had taken treatment for bringing down her anxiety, now that fact is being projected by the appellant to disqualify her, from getting custody of the child. Now she is out of the zone of harassment and its trauma, and so, that stage of depression might not have been haunting her. There is nothing to show that the respondent is not capable of looking after the affairs of her child. Admittedly, she is working as a Staff Nurse in Germany earning salary to lead a decent life. So, she is capable of protecting the welfare and well-being of the child. The evidence adduced by the appellant is not sufficient enough to hold that the respondent-wife is not competent to be declared as the guardian of the child with its permanent custody.

11.

The third contention taken up by the appellant is that, he is financially sound and he is capable of looking after the affairs of the child and to give him giving quality education. But, the Family Court found that though earlier the appellant was working in Kuwait, now he has no job or income, and nothing has been produced to prove any bank balance in his name. He and his parents may be having assets, but at present, there is nothing to show that the appellant is having any job, income or bank balance to attend the needs of the child.

12.

According to the appellant, only to take care of his minor son, he came down from Kuwait and he is now staying in Kerala. That does not seems to be a genuine statement. In IA No.4 of 2021 filed by the appellant in Mat.Appeal No.129 of 2020, he has stated that his visa processing to Canada is going on. So, after getting visa, he may be immigrating to Canada.

13.

Now the child is under the care and custody of his maternal grandparents, and the mother of the child is taking all endeavours to take him abroad to join his mother. When the appellant got interim custody of the child, he got the child admitted in a school at his place even without getting permission of the court. His attempt seems to prevent the child being taken to Germany to live with his mother, for which he obtained stay order in the Mat.Appeal staying the operation of the judgment in O.P. No.566 of 2017. Even after dissolution of their marriage, the fight is being continued in the name of the little kid, by which the child is being denied of the precious love and care of his mother.

14.

The Family Court rightly allowed O.P No.566 of 2017 filed by the respondent and rejected O.P No.826 of 2017 filed by the appellant. We find no reason to interfere with the order of the Family Court appointing the respondent-mother as the guardian of the minor child Jeev Jephin, with permanent custody, permitting her to take the child to Germany to live with her. Of course, the child needs the love and affection from his father too, for which also sufficient opportunity has to be provided. So, with certain modifications in the visitation right ordered by the Family Court, both the appeals are liable to be dismissed.

In the result, these appeals are dismissed, confirming the impugned judgments and decree with certain guidelines and directions regarding transit of the child to Germany and the visitation rights to be exercised by the appellant-father before and after the transit, to be followed strictly by the parties as given below.

i) The respondent-mother has to take the child Jeev Jephin to Germany within three months from the date of this judgment.

ii) During annual school vacation in Germany (the period of which the respondent-mother will inform the appellant-father before one month of starting the vacation), the appellant can take custody of the child from the respondent on the next day of closing of the school at 10 a.m (German time) and he can take the child to Kerala, and the child has to be given back to the custody of the respondent-mother, in Germany at 5 p.m (German time) on the previous day of re-opening of the school.

iii)The appellant is permitted to get mirror orders from the jurisdictional court in Germany to make the exchange of custody of the child hassle-free, if he feels so.

iv)The venue of exchange of the child shall be a neutral place as suggested by the respondent, and if parties are not amenable for the same, it can be in the premises of the jurisdictional court in Germany.

v) At the time of exchange of custody of the child, the passport of the child has to be handed over by either party.

vi)Whenever the respondent comes down to Kerala along with the child, she has to inform the appellant/counsel sufficiently early so that he can have custody of the child for few days proportionate to the period of leave, after taking orders from the Family Court.

vii) When the child is in Germany, the appellant or his parents can interact with the child everyday between 7 p.m to 7.30 p.m (German time) and on every Saturday and Sunday between 11 a.m to 12 p.m (German time) on Skype/Whatsapp/Zoom meeting or through any other virtual mode convenient to the parties, and the respondent has to facilitate such arrangements, without giving room for any complaint.

viii) During Christmas vacation of 2021, the appellant can have custody of the child from 5 p.m on 24.12.2021 till 5 p.m on 02.01.2022 and I.A No.5 of 2021 stands allowed accordingly. The venue of exchange of custody is the premises of St.Mary's Jacobite Cyrian Cathedral Church, Manarcad, Kottayam, as it was done before.

ix)Till the child is taken to Germany, the appellant can have custody of the child every Saturday from 10 a.m to ensuing Sunday at 4 p.m. The venue of exchange shall be the same as in clause (viii).

x) If the respondent fails to take the child to Germany within three months from today and the appellant continues to stay in Kerala, he can approach the jurisdictional Family Court to get permanent custody of the child.

xi) Violation of the conditions above mentioned by either party will disentitle him/her in claiming custody of the child in future.

xii) The parties shall suffer their respective costs.