AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
T. Mathivanan, J.—Invoking the inherent jurisdiction of this Court underSection 482 Cr.P.C.,the Petitioner has preferred thispetition to set aside the order dated 12.10.2010 and madein Crl.M.P. No. 244/2010 in S.C. No. 140/2007 on the file ofthe learned Additional District Judge, (Fast Track CourtNo.III), Tiruvallore and to direct the learned trial Judgeto reopen the trial of the case and to accord permission tosummon the witnesses cited in the Petitioner in Crl.M.P. No. 244/2010 so as to enable the Petitioner to examine the saidwitnesses on his side.
The Petitioner along with 27 others has beenfacing charges u/s 120B, 148, 302, 341, 449 and 506(ii) I.P.C., in connection with the case inS.C. No. 140/2007 on the file of the learned AdditionalDistrict Judge, Tiruvallore.
During the course of the trial the prosecutionhas purposely withheld certain important materials andfactual issues to suppress the truth before the trialCourt. The entire episode in the background of the case in S.C. No. 140/2007 has been fabricated based on the casteissue and the officer who is actually involved in theinitiation of the case and in the investigation had somevested interest in the issue involved. Hence, adequategrounds are available to withhold the material facts andthe related evidences. The said suppression came to thePetitioner's knowledge only in the later stage. On thisbackground, the Petitioner had filed a petition inCrl.M.P. No. 244/2010 in S.C. No. 140/2007 on the file of thelearned Additional District Judge, (Fast Track CourtNo.III) Tiruvallore after invoking the proviso to Section 311 of Cr.P.C., to reopen the trial of the said case and tosummon the former Superintendent of Police of TiruvalloreDistrict Mr. S.P. Ayush Mani Tiwari to examine him as awitness on behalf of the defence.
Heard both sides.
(i) The learned Counsel appearing for thePetitioner has submitted that Mr. S.P. Ayush Mani Tiwari, thethen Superintendent of Police of Tiruvallore District hadappointed Mr. Paul Raj, the then Inspector of Police,Periyapalayam to investigate the case in Crime No. 47/2003 on the file of the Respondent police. The above saidSuperintendent of Police in his proceedings inC. No. 35/Camp/SP-TVLR/2003 dated 01.02.2003 stated that twovanniars were murdered in Thiruvur Village and it isobvious that the abovesaid Superintendent of Police hadsigned his proceedings relating to the nomination of theInvestigating Officer at 10.00 a.m., on 01.02.2003, andthat the Petitioner was able to secure the proceeding onlyrecently.
(ii) The learned Counsel has also submitted thatinsofar as the case in Crime No. 47/2003 in S.C. No. 140/2007is concerned the occurrence is said to have been takenplace at 10.15 a.m., on 01.02.2003. Hence, from theabovesaid details it is palpably clear that the prosecutingagency has wantonly burked the real time of occurrence. The learned Counsel has also added that Mr. S.P. Ayush ManiTiwari, the then Superintendent of Police, TiruvalloreDistrict must be summoned and brought before the trialCourt to be examined as a witness only for the purpose ofexplaining the circumstances under which he had nominatedthe Investigating Officer Mr. Paul Raj at 10.00 a.m., on01.02.2003. The learned Counsel for the Petitioner has also adverted to that virtually Mr. S.P. Ayush Mani Tiwari,the then Superintendent of Police should have receivedfirst information with regard to the occurrence prior to 10.00 a.m., on 01.02.2003 and it also appears only afterreceipt of the first information about the occurrence, hewas able to nominate the Investigating Officer-Mr. Paul Rajto investigate the case in Crime No. 47/2003 at 10.00 a.m. If the nomination of the Investigating Officer by the thenS.P. Ayush Mani Tiwari is true, the occurrence as certifiedby the prosecuting agency could not have been taken placeat 10.15 a.m., on the abovesaid date. Only to clarify thisposition and other material facts the Petitioner happenedto file a petition u/s 311 Cr.P.C, inCrl.M.P. No. 244/2010 before the trial Court. But the trialCourt without giving due consideration or withoutapplication of its mind has simply rejected even withoutgiving notice to the prosecuting agency to invite theirobjections. Being aggrieved with the impugned order of thelearned Additional District and Sessions Judge, Fast TrackCourt No. III, dated 12.10.2010, the Petitioner wasconstrained to file this petition to set aside theabovesaid order and also to direct the trial Judge toreopen the trial of the case in S.C. No. 140/2007 and to summon Mr. S.P. Ayush Mani Tiwari, then Superintendent ofPolice, Tiruvallure District and examine him as a witnesson the defence side.
On the other hand, the learned Public Prosecutorhas vehemently objected to allow this petition. He hasalso submitted that the case in Crime No. 47/2003 wasregistered by the Respondent police in the year 2003. After following all the formalities the case was taken onfile by the Principal Sessions Judge, Tiruvallore inS.C. No. 140/2007 and subsequently, forwarded to the learnedAdditional District and Sessions Judge (Fast Track CourtNo.III) Tiruvallore for trial in the year 2007. Aftercommencement of trial, two similarly placed petitions werefiled already to recall and to examine the witnesses andthe petition in Crl.M.P. No. 244/2010 is the third of it''skind. The learned Public Prosecutor has also adverted tothat the case was originally posted to 01.11.2010 forpronouncement of judgment and since the Petitioner haspreferred this petition before this Court, the judgment wasnot able to be pronounced and thereafter the case standsposted to 06.12.2010.
This Court has carefully considered the submissions made on either side.
On a cursory perusal of the order dated12.10.2010 passed by the learned Additional District andSessions Judge (Fast Track Court No. III), Tiruvallore inCrl.M.P. No. 244/2010 it appears that after the completionof the trial the case stood posted for judgment. Onlyunder these circumstances, the Petitioner came forward withthis petition to summon the erstwhile Superintendent ofPolice, Tiruvallore for the purpose of examining him as adefence witness. It also appears from the order of thetrial Court that even without issuing notice to theprosecuting agency so as to invite their objections, thepetition seems to have been rejected in limine. Thelearned trial Judge has observed in the abovesaid orderthat the petition appeared to have been filed to prolongthe case and that a non-bailable warrant was also pendingagainst the accused. Hence, the abovesaid petition wasrejected on the ground on maintainability.
The power of the trial Court to summon material witnessess or to examine the persons present has been verywell defined in Section 311 of Code of Criminal Procedure Section 311 readsas follows:
S.311. Any Court may, at any stage ofany inquiry, trial or other proceeding under thisCode, summon any person as a witness, or examineany person in attendance, though not summoned asa witness, or recall and re-examine any personalready examined; and the Court shall summon andexamine or recall and re-examine any such personif his evidence appears to it to be essential tothe just decision of the case.
From the language coined in Section 311 of Cr.P.C., it isobvious that the scope of section is very wider and it neednot be taken into a narrow one. In order to enable theCourt to find out the real truth which is hidden orinvisible and to take a just decision the salutaryprovisions of Section 311 are enacted whereunder any Courtby exercising its discretionary authority at any stage ofenquiry, trial or other proceeding can summon any person aswitness or examine any person in attendance though notsummoned as a witness or recall or re-examine any personalready examined who are expected to be able to throw light upon the matter in dispute. It must be borne-in-mind that opportunity of rebuttal shall be given to other party.
On coming to the instant case on hand from thematerials available on record it is obvious to note herethat as nearly as 27 accused are involved in this case inS.C. No. 140/2007. It is also apparent that two persons weresaid to have been murdered in the alleged occurrence dated01.02.2003. It also appears that the case in CrimeNo. 47/2003 in S.C. No. 140/2007 is a sensational one andrevolving around communal problem. Therefore, this casehas to be dealt with due care and caution.
Page one of the typed set tagged along with thispetition is the proceedings of the Superintendent ofPolice, Tiruvallore District. These proceedings seems tohave been issued by Thiru S.P. Ayush Mani Tiwari, the thenSuperintendent of Police, Tiruvallore District on01.02.2003. From the face of the proceedings it appearsthat a communal clash was taken place between Adi-dravidarsand Vanniars of Thiruvur village on 01.02.2003 and in thesaid clash two vanniars were murdered. It also appears that in order to take up the investigation, one Mr. PaulRaj, Inspector of Police, Periyapalayam Circle wasnominated as the Investigating Officer. Besides thisexfacie it is also appeared that the Inspector of Police-Mr. Paul Raj was also informed telephonically by theSpecial Branch Office at 10.00 a.m., on 01.02.2003. Only onthis background, the learned Counsel for the Petitioner hassubmitted that as per the case of the prosecution, theoccurrence was said to have been taken place at 10.15 a.m.,on 01.02.2003 and when such being the case how Mr. Paul Raj,attached to Periyapalayam Police Station could have beeninformed at 10.00 a.m., on 01.02.2003.
The learned Counsel has also added that only toexplain this position and since there is confliction andcontradiction with regard to the time of occurrence thePetitioner was accelerated to file a petition u/s 311 Cr.P.C., to summon the then Superintendent of Police,S.P. Ayush Mani Tiwari to be examined as a witness on thedefence side.
In order to substantiate his arguments, thelearned Counsel for the Petitioner has also placed reliance upon the following decisions:
(i) Godrej Pacific Tech. Ltd. Vs. Computer Joint India Ltd.,
(ii) Palacharla Rama Rao Vs. The State of A.P.,
(iii) Seethathipal Antony and 8 Ors. v. Inspector of police, Kumbakonam 2002 (5) CTC 133
(iv) R. Krishnamurthy Vs. The State by Inspector of Police,
(v) T.Stanes & Company Limited, Coimbatore, rep. by Mr.William Hobert, Assistant General Manager (operations),3/23-24, Race Course Road, Coimbatore v. M.G.Mohamediqbal, B. Sc., (AGRI), Agricultural Officer (Quality Control), O/O T. Stanes and Company Limited Vs. Thiru. M.G. Mohamed Iqbal, B.Sc., (Agri) Agricultural Officer (Quality Control) and The General Agencies,
(vi) M/s. Free Look International and two others Vs. Subikisha Spinners (P) Ltd.,
(vii) Iddar and Others Vs. Aabida and Another,
(viii) Ramalingam v. State by Inspector of Police, Naducauvery police station 2006 (1)CTC 705
In Iddar and Others Vs. Aabida and Another, a Division Bench of Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed that
"Section 311 is a supplementary provisionenabling and in certain circumstances imposing onthe Court the duty of examining a materialwitness who would not be otherwise brought beforeit. It is couched in the widest possible termsand calls for no limitation, either with regardto the stage at which the powers of the Courtshould be exercised, or with regard to the mannerin which it should be exercised. It is not onlythe prerogative but also the plain duty of aCourt to examine such of those witnesses as itconsiders absolutely necessary for doing justicebetween the State and the subject."
"The section is not limited only for the benefitof the accused, and it will not be an improperexercise of the powers of the Court to summon awitness under the Section merely because theevidence supports the case for the prosecution and not that of the accused.
"It is a cardinal rule in the law of evidence that the best available evidence should be brought before the Court. The Court is not empowered under the provisionsof the Code to compel either the prosecution orthe defence to examine any particular witness orwitnesses on their side. This must be left to the parties."
It is also observed that the Court will often have todepend on intercepted allegations made by the parties, oron inconclusive inference from facts elicited in theevidence. In such cases, the Court has to act under thesecond part of the section. Sometimes the examination ofwitnesses as directed by the Court may result in what isthought to be "filing of loopholes''. That is purely asubsidiary factor and cannot be taken into account. Whether the new evidence is essential or not, must ofcourse depend on the facts of each case, and has to bedetermined by the Presiding Judge.
As rightly observed by Dr. Arijit Pasayat,J. in Godrej Pacific Tech. Ltd. Vs. Computer Joint India Ltd., the proviso to Section 311 of Code of Criminal Procedure ismanifestly in two parts. Whereas the word used in the firstpart is "may", the second part uses "shall". Inconsequence, the first part gives purely discretionaryauthority to a criminal court and enables it at any stageof enquiry, trial or proceeding under the Code (a) tosummon anyone as a witness, or (b)to examine any personpresent in the court, or (c)to recall and re-examine anyperson who evidence has already been recorded. On theother hand, the second part is mandatory and compels thecourt to take any of the aforementioned steps if the newevidence appears to it essential to the just decision ofthe case. This is a supplementary provision enabling, andin certain circumstances imposing on the court the duty ofexamining a material witness who would not be otherwisebrought before it.
One more dimension of Section 311 Cr.P.C., hasbeen expo-sed in Seethathipal Antony and 8 Ors. V.inspector of Police, Kumbakonam 2002 (5) ctc 133. Inthis case the learned single Judge of this Court has heldthat non-examination of the witness u/s 161(3) Cr.P.C., cannot be a handicap to the exercise of power u/s 311 of Code of Criminal Procedure
In the case on hand, from the context of thepetition in Crl.M.P. No. 244/2010 on the file of the trialCourt, the evidence of Mr. S.P. Ayush Mani Tiwari, the thenSuperintendent of Police, Tiruvallore is very muchessential to take just decision in this case and thecircumstances narrated in this petition imposing the dutyon the trial court to examine the then Superintendent ofPolice, Tiruvallore as a material evidence on the part ofthe defence side so as to clarify the position asaforementioned. If the trial Court fails to summon andexamine him as a material witness he would not be otherwisebrought before this Court at any stage at the later pointof time.
Keeping in view of the above circumstances, thereason as adduced by the learned trial Judge in his orderdated 12.10.2010 that the petition was filed to prolong thecase and that the pendency of non-bailable warrant are allextraneous. Further this Court has convinced with thereasons projected by the learned Counsel for the Petitionerand since the former Superintendent of Police, Tiruvallore appears to be a material witness to clarify the position asstated above he shall be summoned and examined as witnesson the part of the defence.
Having regard to the circumstances narratedabove, this Court is of the considered view that the orderof the learned trial Judge dated 12.10.2010 and made inCrl.M.P. No. 244/2010 in S.C. No. 140/2007 is liable to be setaside because the above said petition seems to have beenrejected without even inviting the objections from theprosecuting agency.
Accordingly, the order dated 12.10.2010 and madein Crl.M.P. No. 244/2010 is set aside and the petition inCrl.M.P. No. 244/2010 is allowed. The learned AdditionalDistrict and Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court No. III,Tiruvallore is directed to summon the witnesses requestedin Crl.M.P. No. 244/2010 and examine him as a witness on theside of the defence and the opposite side shall also begiven an opportunity to confront by way of cross-examination. Accordingly, this petition is allowed. Consequently, connected M.P. No. 1/2010 is disposed of.
