AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
The proceedings before the Land Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram in O.A No.16/2024, instituted at the instance of the respondents 2 to 5 are under challenge in this writ petition.
The facts of the case are summarised as follows:
An extent of 24 cents of land in Survey No.2065 of Vailoor Village which belonged to the grandfather of the petitioner, was mortgaged in the year 1908 M.E, and the above property subsequently came to the possession of one Velayudhan Chettiyar, the father of respondents 2 to 5 by way of assignment of mortgage. The petitioner’s father got the above property redeemed by the decree passed by the Munsiff’s Court, Attingal in O.S No.412/1968. When the decree was sought to be executed, the father of the respondents 2 to 5 claimed fixity of tenure and right as ‘kudikidappukaran’. But, the above contentions were rejected by the Executing Court, against which a revision was filed before this Court as C.R.P No.477/1990. The aforesaid revision was dismissed by this Court by the reported judgment in Ponnammal v. Gomez [1991 (1) KLT 901]. Thereafter, the mother and sister of respondents 2 to 5 instituted a suit before the Sub Court, Attingal as O.S No.79/1991 for an injunction against the execution of the decree in O.S No.412/1968. The aforesaid suit was dismissed by the Sub Court, Attingal and the petitioner’s father got delivery of the property with police protection. In the meanwhile, the petitioner’s father gifted the said property to her sister Moriz Gomez by virtue of a gift deed of the year 1992. Thereafter, the respondents 3 to 5 and their mother trespassed into that property and filed O.A No.148/1994 before the Land Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram claiming kudikidappu right over that property and obtained an order of injunction against the aforesaid Moriz Gomez. The above injunction order was challenged before this Court in O.P No.8491/1994, which was allowed on 31.10.1994 with the observation that the proceedings before the Land Tribunal in O.A No.148/1994 was vexatious and barred by res judicata. Accordingly, the Land Tribunal dismissed the above O.A on 19.01.1995. On the very next day, the respondents 3 to 5 and their mother filed O.S.No.47/1995 before the Munsiff’s Court, Attingal claiming possession over the said property. The above suit was challenged by Moriz Gomez in O.P No.3746/1995 before this Court. The order passed in favour of Moriz Gomez on O.P NO.3746/1995 was appealed by the respondents 3 to 5 and their mother in W.A No.211/1998. In the aforesaid appeal, a direction was given to the Civil Court to set aside the ex parte injunction passed against Moriz Gomez. When the aforesaid case came up for final hearing, the respondents 3 to 5 and their mother filed a memo stating that the suit was not pressed, and accordingly it was dismissed. Thereafter, the mother of respondents 3 to 5 filed another suit as O.S No.402/2003 before the Munsiff’s Court, Attingal in respect of the same property, which was challenged before this Court in W.P(C) No.39977/2003. This Court disposed of the above writ petition directing the Trial Court to consider the maintainability and to impose heavy costs, if the suit was found not maintainable. However, the aforesaid suit was also later on withdrawn. Thereafter, the mother of respondents 3 to 5 instituted O.S.No.293/2010 before the Munsiff’s Court, Attingal against her forceful eviction from the aforesaid property. The aforesaid suit was challenged by Moriz Gomez in O.P(C) No.534/2011 before this Court. As per the judgment rendered on 23.01.2012, this Court directed the Trial Court to consider the maintainability of the suit, as a preliminary issue.
The petitioner’s father’s sister Moriz Gomez had instituted O.S.No.187/2012 before the Sub Court, Attingal, for recovery of possession of the above property since the respondents 3 to 5 and their mother had virtually dispossessed her from that property otherwise than due process of law. During the pendency of the above suit, Moriz Gomez died, and thus the petitioner and her sisters Helen Mary and Ann Pius got impleaded as additional plaintiffs as the legal heirs of deceased Moriz Gomez. Though the respondents 3 to 5 and their mother filed counter claim in the said suit, they later on abandoned it. The suit was accordingly decreed in favour of the petitioner and her sisters by the Sub Court, Attingal, vide Ext.P6 judgment. Though the respondents 3 to 5 filed R.F.A.No.39/2023 against the aforesaid decree and judgment, the said appeal was dismissed by this Court on 25.01.2024 vide Ext.P7 judgment. Thereafter, the petitioner filed Execution Petition before the Sub Court, Attingal, in O.S.No.187/2012, and accordingly, the property was delivered over to the petitioner on 05.10.2024 vide Ext.P8 report of the Amin. Subsequently, the petitioner and her sisters effected mutation of the said property in their names and started remitting land revenue for it. It is at that stage that the respondents 2 to 5 instituted O.A.No.16/2024 before the Land Tribunal suppressing all the earlier proceedings, and putting forward a new case that they are the deemed tenants of the property which actually belonged to one Telma, daughter of Stephen Gomez. It is the proceedings in the aforesaid O.A. that the petitioner seeks to quash in this writ petition.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner, the learned Government Pleader representing the first respondent and the learned counsel for the respondents 3 to 5.
The learned counsel for the respondents 3 to 5 would contend that this writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is not maintainable against the proceedings pending before the Land Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram, and hence it is liable to be dismissed at the threshold. According to the learned counsel for the respondents 3 to 5, the petitioner could raise all contentions before the first respondent, so that the proceedings before the first respondent could reach a logical conclusion with the adjudication of the rival claims of the parties.
The argument advanced by the learned counsel for respondents 3 to 5 in the above regard, is prima facie unsustainable. It is to be noted that the matter in issue involved in the aforesaid case had already been decided finally by the Land Tribunal as well as the competent Civil Court as could be seen from the various proceedings narrated in paragraph No.2 above. On multiple occasions, this Court had upheld the verdicts of the Civil Courts which declared the right over the property in favour of the petitioner, her siblings and her father, and found that the contentions raised by the respondents 3 to 5 and their predecessor were false and frivolous. Ultimately, the property was delivered over to the petitioner in execution of the decree and judgment in O.S.No.187/2012 of the Sub Court, Attingal, which were upheld by this Court vide Ext.P7 judgment in R.F.A.No.39/2025. It is at that stage that the respondents 3 to 5 have embarked upon a new round of litigation by filing O.A.No.16/2024 before the Land Tribunal suppressing all the previous proceedings and taking up new contentions. The aforesaid course adopted by the respondents 3 to 5 is nothing but blatant abuse of process of law. It is true that Article 227 of the Constitution of India is the relevant provision of law which deals with the powers of this Court to have superintendence over the Courts and Tribunals within its territory, and to pass appropriate orders to ensure that those Courts and Tribunals are exercising jurisdiction within the limits prescribed by law. But, when it is revealed in a writ petition instituted under Article 226 of the Constitution of India that there is flagrant abuse of process of law in any proceedings pending before a Tribunal, the hands of this Court are not tied in passing appropriate orders to terminate such proceedings to meet the ends of justice. As far as the present case is concerned, the continuance of the proceedings in O.A.No.16/2024 before the Land Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram, is an affront to the cause of justice. Therefore, the aforesaid proceedings are liable to be quashed to secure the ends of justice.
In the result, the writ petition stands allowed as follows:
Ext.P11 proceedings pending before the Land Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram, in O.A.No.16/2024, are hereby quashed.
